Resources
A horizontal, unpolarized electromagnetic beam (consisting of coupled, transverse time-varying electric field and magnetic field ) propagates along the -direction in air with an initial intensity of . Simultaneously, a longitudinal ultrasonic sound wave with frequency propagates along the same -direction through the air column. (a) Explain why the electromagnetic wave can be polarized by passing it through an ideal linear polarizer, whereas the acoustic wave cannot be polarized under any physical condition. (b) The electromagnetic beam passes through two successive ideal linear polarizers: the transmission axis of the first polarizer is oriented vertically along the -axis, and the transmission axis of the second polarizer is oriented at an angle of relative to the vertical -axis. Calculate the final transmitted intensity of the electromagnetic wave.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Only transverse waves can exhibit polarization because their field oscillations occur in directions perpendicular to the propagation vector, allowing asymmetry about the axis of travel; longitudinal waves oscillate exclusively along the direction of propagation, possessing cylindrical symmetry along the wave vector and lacking independent transverse degrees of freedom; (b) .
Steps
Transmission Through the First Polarizer (One-Half Rule)
Part (a): Physical Basis of Polarization
Polarization is a geometric property describing the orientation of wave oscillations in the space perpendicular to the direction of travel.
- Electromagnetic Waves (Transverse Waves):
- An electromagnetic wave propagating along the -direction consists of electric () and magnetic () fields oscillating in the -plane, perpendicular to the propagation vector .
- Because the plane normal to the direction of propagation is two-dimensional, there are two mutually orthogonal transverse degrees of freedom (for example, along the - and -axes).
- A wave can have oscillations restricted to a single axis or plane within this transverse space (breaking rotational symmetry around the propagation axis). An ideal linear polarizer selectively transmits field components aligned with its transmission axis, thus polarizing the light.
- Sound Waves in Air (Longitudinal Waves):
- A sound wave propagating in a fluid medium such as air consists of alternating compressions and rarefactions. The displacement of air molecules and the pressure variations occur exclusively along the direction of wave propagation (the -axis).
- Because the oscillation vector is parallel to the propagation vector , there are no transverse degrees of freedom. The motion is intrinsically symmetric about the propagation axis under all physical conditions, making polarization impossible.
Part (b): Calculation of the Transmitted Intensity
The incident electromagnetic wave is unpolarized with initial intensity:
An unpolarized wave consists of equal intensities distributed randomly across all transverse directions. When it passes through the first ideal linear polarizer, the time-averaged transmitted component equals half the incident intensity:
The light emerging from this polarizer is vertically polarized along the -axis.
Transmission Through the Second Polarizer (Malus's Law)
The linearly polarized beam from the first filter now encounters a second polarizer whose transmission axis makes an angle with respect to the vertical -axis.
According to Malus's Law:
Substitute the values:
Evaluating the trigonometric term:
Now compute the final intensity:
Common Pitfall: Do not apply Malus's law directly to the unpolarized beam using . Malus's law applies only when already polarized light encounters a polarizer. The transition from unpolarized light to linearly polarized light must always use the factor of .
Typical errors
01 The student forgets that unpolarized light passing through the first polarizer is reduced by half, instead applying Malus's law directly to the full initial intensity I₀.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
EM waves are transverse with oscillations perpendicular to propagation, allowing polarization. Sound waves in air are longitudinal with oscillations parallel to propagation, so they have no transverse directions to polarize.
- Step 2Correct
The incident electromagnetic wave is completely unpolarized. An ideal linear polarizer transmits only the component aligned with its axis, which reduces the time-averaged intensity by half ().
- Step 3Correct
Your formulation of Malus's Law and arithmetic were correct, but substituting your unattenuated carried the error through to the final answer.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly articulated the geometric reason why transverse waves can be polarized while longitudinal waves cannot.
You set up Malus's Law correctly for the second polarizer using the relative angle .
You calculated the trigonometric square accurately.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated the beam entering the first polarizer as if it were already polarized parallel to the transmission axis rather than unpolarized.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating unpolarized incident light with polarized incident light leads to skipping the initial intensity factor before applying Malus's Law.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify Initial Polarization State
Unpolarized light contains randomly oriented electric field vectors in the transverse plane; passing through an ideal linear polarizer always yields .
Check whether the incident beam is unpolarized before writing down the intensity after the first filter.
- Apply Malus's Law Only Between Polarizers
Malus's Law () applies exclusively when the light incident on a polarizer is already linearly polarized.
Use for the first filter, then apply for the second filter.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecognize that the initial light with is unpolarized.
Apply the one-half rule for the first polarizer: .
Apply Malus's Law across the second polarizer: .
02 The student misremembers Malus's law as depending on cos(θ) to the first power rather than cos²(θ).
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Electromagnetic waves are transverse, so oscillations are perpendicular to the direction of propagation and can be polarized. Acoustic waves in air are longitudinal, oscillating parallel to the direction of propagation, and therefore cannot be polarized.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
You wrote instead of Malus's law, . While the electric field amplitude scales with , wave intensity is proportional to the square of the amplitude, leading to the squared cosine factor.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly articulated the structural difference in oscillation directions between transverse and longitudinal waves.
You accurately identified that acoustic waves in air cannot be polarized due to their longitudinal nature.
You correctly applied the one-half reduction rule to calculate the intensity emerging from the first polarizer.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou omitted the exponent of 2 on the cosine term when writing Malus's law, evaluating rather than .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou confused the transmission factor for electric field amplitude () with the transmission law for wave intensity (, which yields ).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Amplitude vs. Intensity
The transmitted electric field amplitude is , but electromagnetic intensity is proportional to the time-averaged electric field squared: .
Whenever calculating intensity through a polarizer oriented at angle to linearly polarized light, square the geometric projection factor: .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationApply Malus's law with the squared cosine factor: .
Evaluate , so .
Multiply by the incident polarized intensity: .
(a) Transverse waves oscillate perpendicular to the direction of propagation and exhibit polarization, while longitudinal waves oscillate parallel to propagation and cannot be polarized; (b) .
03 The student mistakenly applies the one-half reduction factor twice, treating the second polarizer as if it also receives unpolarized light instead of using Malus's law.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
EM waves are transverse waves with field vibrations perpendicular to the propagation axis, so a polarizer can filter them. Sound waves in air are longitudinal with vibrations along the propagation axis, so they cannot be polarized.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
The light emerging from the first polarizer is already linearly polarized along the -axis. When linearly polarized light encounters a second polarizer at an angle , its transmitted intensity is governed by Malus's law (), not the one-half rule for unpolarized light.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly distinguished transverse waves from longitudinal waves and explained why only transverse waves can be polarized.
You accurately calculated the transmitted intensity after the first polarizer using the one-half rule for unpolarized light.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the beam entering the second polarizer as if it were still unpolarized light, overlooking that the first polarizer transformed the beam into linearly polarized light whose transmission through subsequent filters depends on angle via Malus's law ().
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- State of Polarization Check
Unpolarized light transmitted through an ideal linear polarizer loses half its intensity: . Linearly polarized light transmitted through an ideal polarizer with relative axis angle follows Malus's law: .
Before calculating transmitted intensity, identify whether the incoming light is unpolarized or already linearly polarized.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the angle between the polarization direction of the beam and the transmission axis of the second polarizer: .
Apply Malus's law: .
Substitute the values: .
(a) Only transverse waves possess oscillations perpendicular to the direction of propagation that can be selectively filtered; longitudinal waves oscillate purely along the direction of propagation and lack transverse degrees of freedom. (b)
Lock it in
What happens to the intensity of completely unpolarized light when it passes through a single ideal linear polarizer?
Its intensity is halved: . The emerging light is linearly polarized along the polarizer's transmission axis.
Similar question
An unpolarized laser beam of intensity passes through two polarizers. The first has its transmission axis oriented horizontally, and the second has its transmission axis oriented at to the horizontal. Calculate the final transmitted intensity.
Answer
. Key steps: After the first polarizer, . After the second polarizer, .
Unpolarized light of intensity is incident on a system of three successive polarizers. The first is vertical (), the second is oriented at relative to the vertical, and the third is oriented at relative to the vertical (horizontal). Find the final transmitted intensity.
Answer
. Key steps: . Angle between 1st and 2nd is , so . Angle between 2nd and 3rd is , so .
A beam of unpolarized light passes through a sequence of two linear polarizers. If the final measured intensity is and the initial unpolarized intensity was , determine the acute angle between the transmission axes of the two polarizers.
Answer
. Key steps: After the first filter, . By Malus's Law, .