Resources
Consider an ideal Atwood machine consisting of two masses and connected by a light string over a frictionless pulley. In Setup 1, mass hangs freely on the right and hangs freely on the left, so the system accelerates under gravity (). In Setup 2, mass is removed, and a constant downward external tension force is applied directly to the left end of the string. A student hypothesizes that both setups produce identical accelerations for mass . Calculate: (a) the magnitude of acceleration of mass in Setup 1, (b) the magnitude of acceleration of mass in Setup 2, and (c) identify which setup produces a strictly greater acceleration.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) ; (c) Setup 2 produces a strictly greater acceleration because the applied force accelerates only the inertia of , whereas in Setup 1 the net gravitational force accelerates the combined inertia .
Steps
Part (a): Acceleration of the System in Setup 1
In Setup 1, both blocks are connected by an ideal (massless, inextensible) string passing over a frictionless, massless pulley. Because the string is inextensible, both blocks have the same magnitude of acceleration, .
-
Free-body equations for each block:
- For the heavier block moving downward:
- For the lighter block moving upward:
- Solve for acceleration : Adding the two equations eliminates the internal tension :
- Substitute the given values:
Part (b): Acceleration of Mass in Setup 2
In Setup 2, the block is replaced by an external force pulling straight down on the left side of the string.
- Tension in the string: Since the string is massless, the tension throughout the string is equal to the applied force:
- Equation of motion for mass : Mass moves downward with acceleration :
- Solve for :
Part (c): Comparison and Physical Explanation
- Result: Setup 2 produces a strictly greater acceleration ().
- Physical Reason:
In both setups, the net external driving force accelerating the system is identical:
However, by Newton's second law ():
- In Setup 1, this net force accelerates the combined inertia of both masses, .
- In Setup 2, the force accelerates only the inertia of block , , because the applied force itself adds no mass to the system.
Common Pitfall: A frequent misconception is assuming that replacing a hanging mass with its equivalent weight produces the same acceleration. While the downward pull on the string appears identical, replacing a mass with a pure force eliminates that mass's inertia, resulting in a strictly higher acceleration.
Typical errors
01 The student assumes replacing the hanging mass with an equivalent gravitational force does not change the system's inertia, incorrectly dividing by the combined mass in Setup 2.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
In Setup 2, block has been completely removed and replaced by an external force . Because a force has no mass, the total inertia being accelerated is only , not .
- Step 3
Neither, both setups produce identical accelerations of .
CorrectSetup 2 produces a strictly greater acceleration ().
This comparison followed directly from your previous calculation of . Since and , Setup 2 produces the strictly greater acceleration.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the net accelerating force in both setups.
You correctly calculated the system acceleration for the two-body system in Setup 1.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated an applied external force as if it brought its own inertia to the system, dividing by the original total mass rather than only the remaining physical mass .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identifying System Mass
Newton's second law is , where is the sum of actual physical masses that move.
When a hanging object is replaced by a pulling force of equal magnitude, remove that object's mass from .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the physical objects that are moving in Setup 2: only block is present, so .
Apply Newton's second law to block : .
Substitute the numerical values: .
Compare the accelerations: , meaning Setup 2 produces a strictly greater acceleration.
(a) ; (b) ; (c) Setup 2 produces a strictly greater acceleration.
02 The student adds rather than subtracts the opposing forces when determining the net force acting on the system in Setup 1.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Because the two masses hang on opposite sides of the pulley, their gravitational forces pull the string in opposite directions. The net driving force accelerating the system along the string is the difference between their weights, , not their sum.
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
.
Your comparison logically followed your calculated values (), but because the true acceleration is , Setup 2 actually produces the strictly greater acceleration.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified the total system mass in Setup 1 as .
You correctly calculated the net force and acceleration for Setup 2.
You recognized that Setup 2 only accelerates mass rather than both masses.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated the two gravitational forces in Setup 1 as acting in the same direction along the line of motion, adding them instead of subtracting them.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisFailing to define a single consistent coordinate direction along the path of the connecting string. When wrapped over a pulley, downward motion on one side corresponds to upward motion on the other, meaning gravity on the two sides opposes rather than reinforces.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Define a Curvilinear Coordinate Along the String
For masses connected over a pulley, assign one direction along the string as positive (for example, clockwise: downward for the right mass and upward for the left mass).
Project every external force onto this single coordinate line: forces aiding clockwise motion are positive, while forces opposing it are negative.
- Net Unbalanced Force for an Atwood Machine
In an ideal vertical Atwood machine, the net force accelerating the system is , not .
Always subtract the smaller weight from the larger weight to find the net driving force along the string.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet the clockwise direction along the pulley as positive, so that the downward motion of and upward motion of are both positive: .
Apply Newton's second law to the total connected mass: .
Compare the two accelerations: since and , Setup 2 produces the strictly greater acceleration.
(a) ; (b) ; (c) Setup 2 produces a strictly greater acceleration.
03 The student forgets to account for the opposing upward tension force in Setup 2, assuming mass B falls freely under gravity.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You omitted the upward tension force exerted on mass by the string. Because the external force pulls downward on the left end, an equal tension of pulls upward on , giving a net force of rather than .
- Step 3Correct
Your final qualitative conclusion is correct, but it was reached using the incorrect acceleration value from Step 2.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the net driving force and total mass for the two-body system in Setup 1.
You correctly recognized that Setup 2 involves only mass accelerating.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou set the net force on in Setup 2 equal to its full gravitational weight, overlooking the upward pull of the string.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisTreating a connected object as isolated and in free fall when an external pulling force maintains tension throughout the connecting string.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Draw a Complete Free-Body Diagram
For an object attached to a taut string, tension always acts away from the object along the string.
Always draw every force acting on the body—both gravity downward and tension upward—before applying .
- Ideal String Force Transmission
In an ideal string over a frictionless pulley, the tension magnitude is uniform everywhere and equals any external force applied directly to the end: .
Set the upward tension on the hanging mass directly equal to the external pulling force applied on the opposite side.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the forces acting on mass : downward gravity and upward string tension .
Write Newton's second law for : .
Substitute the forces: .
Solve for the acceleration: .
(a) ; (b) ; (c) Setup 2 produces a strictly greater acceleration.
Lock it in
Does replacing a hanging weight with a hand pulling downward with an external force change the system's acceleration?
Yes, acceleration increases. The net force remains the same, but the hand adds zero inertia, reducing the total mass .
Similar question
A block of mass rests on a frictionless horizontal table and is connected via a light string over a frictionless pulley to a hanging mass . In Case 1, the mass accelerates the system under gravity (). In Case 2, mass is removed and the string is pulled downward with a constant force . Find the acceleration of mass in both cases.
Answer
Case 1: . Case 2: .
An Atwood machine has masses and (). If is replaced by an upward pulling force on equal to , by what factor does the acceleration of increase compared to the original setup?
Answer
Original acceleration: . New acceleration: . The factor is .
A cart of mass on a frictionless ramp inclined at angle is connected over a pulley at the top of the incline to a hanging mass . Derive the condition on an applied downward force (replacing mass ) such that the cart experiences the exact same acceleration as it did when mass was hanging.
Answer
With hanging mass , . With applied force , . Setting them equal gives .