Resources

A cart of mass M=3.00 kgM = 3.00\text{ kg} rests on a frictionless horizontal floor. Mounted on top of the cart is a flat horizontal tray with a coefficient of static friction μs=0.400\mu_s = 0.400. A small block of mass m=1.00 kgm = 1.00\text{ kg} rests on the tray. A horizontal projectile of mass mp=0.0500 kgm_p = 0.0500\text{ kg} strikes the cart horizontally from the left and embeds in the cart body over an impact duration of Δt=2.50 ms\Delta t = 2.50\text{ ms}. Taking g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2, find the maximum initial speed vp,maxv_{p,\text{max}} of the projectile such that the small block does not slip relative to the cart during the collision.

Answer and steps

Final answer

vp,max=0.608 m/sv_{p,\text{max}} = 0.608\text{ m/s}

Steps

01

Maximum Acceleration Without Slipping

Consider the small block of mass mm resting on the cart tray. The only horizontal force acting on the block is the static friction force fsf_s exerted by the tray:

fs=maf_s = m a

The maximum static friction force the surface can provide before slipping occurs is:

fs,max=μsN=μsmgf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s N = \mu_s m g

Therefore, the maximum horizontal acceleration the block can experience without slipping is independent of its mass:

amax=fs,maxm=μsga_{\text{max}} = \frac{f_{s,\text{max}}}{m} = \mu_s g

For the block to remain stationary relative to the cart throughout the impact, the horizontal acceleration aa of the cart must satisfy:

a≤amax=μsga \le a_{\text{max}} = \mu_s g


02

Force and Acceleration During the Impact

During the collision of duration Δt\Delta t, the projectile of mass mpm_p embeds into the cart.

Assuming uniform acceleration aa during the impact interval Δt\Delta t, the common forward speed acquired by the cart and embedded projectile by the end of the collision is:

vf=aΔtv_f = a \Delta t

Over this same time interval Δt\Delta t, the projectile decelerates from its initial speed vpv_p to the final speed vfv_f. The average horizontal decelerating force acting on the projectile is:

Fˉ=mpvp−vfΔt=mp(vp−aΔt)Δt=mpvpΔt−mpa\bar{F} = m_p \frac{v_p - v_f}{\Delta t} = \frac{m_p (v_p - a \Delta t)}{\Delta t} = \frac{m_p v_p}{\Delta t} - m_p a

By Newton's third law, the projectile exerts an equal and opposite forward impact force Fˉ\bar{F} on the cart. This force accelerates the combined mass of the cart and embedded projectile (M+mp)(M + m_p) at acceleration aa:

Fˉ=(M+mp)a\bar{F} = (M + m_p) a


03

Relation Between Initial Speed and Acceleration

Equating the two expressions for the average impact force Fˉ\bar{F}:

mpvpΔt−mpa=(M+mp)a\frac{m_p v_p}{\Delta t} - m_p a = (M + m_p) a

Rearranging gives:

mpvpΔt=(M+2mp)a\frac{m_p v_p}{\Delta t} = (M + 2m_p) a

vp=M+2mpmpaΔtv_p = \frac{M + 2m_p}{m_p} a \Delta t


04

Calculating the Maximum Projectile Speed

To find the maximum projectile speed vp,maxv_{p,\text{max}} that prevents slipping, substitute the threshold acceleration a=amax=μsga = a_{\text{max}} = \mu_s g:

vp,max=M+2mpmpμsgΔtv_{p,\text{max}} = \frac{M + 2m_p}{m_p} \mu_s g \Delta t

Substitute the given numerical values:

  • M=3.00 kgM = 3.00\text{ kg}
  • mp=0.0500 kg  ⟹  M+2mp=3.00+2(0.0500)=3.10 kgm_p = 0.0500\text{ kg} \implies M + 2m_p = 3.00 + 2(0.0500) = 3.10\text{ kg}
  • μs=0.400\mu_s = 0.400
  • g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2
  • Δt=2.50 ms=2.50×10−3 s\Delta t = 2.50\text{ ms} = 2.50 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}

vp,max=(3.10 kg0.0500 kg)⋅(0.400)⋅(9.80 m/s2)⋅(2.50×10−3 s)v_{p,\text{max}} = \left(\frac{3.10\text{ kg}}{0.0500\text{ kg}}\right) \cdot (0.400) \cdot (9.80\text{ m/s}^2) \cdot (2.50 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s})

3.100.0500=62\frac{3.10}{0.0500} = 62

vp,max=62⋅0.00980 m/s=0.6076 m/s≈0.608 m/sv_{p,\text{max}} = 62 \cdot 0.00980\text{ m/s} = 0.6076\text{ m/s} \approx 0.608\text{ m/s}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets that the projectile embeds into the cart, omitting the projectile mass from the total accelerated mass during the impact.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    amax=μsg=0.400×9.80=3.92 m/s2a_{\text{max}} = \mu_s g = 0.400 \times 9.80 = 3.92\text{ m/s}^2

  2. Step 2

    mpvp=(M+m)amaxΔtm_p v_p = (M + m) a_{\text{max}} \Delta t

    Correct

    Fˉ=mp(vp−aΔt)Δt=(M+mp)a  ⟹  vp=M+2mpmpaΔt\bar{F} = \frac{m_p(v_p - a \Delta t)}{\Delta t} = (M + m_p) a \implies v_p = \frac{M + 2m_p}{m_p} a \Delta t

    During the collision interval Δt\Delta t, the projectile decelerates to the cart's final speed vf=aΔtv_f = a \Delta t rather than coming to rest, and embeds into the cart body. Equating the decelerating force on the projectile to the accelerating force on the cart and embedded projectile yields mp(vp−aΔt)Δt=(M+mp)a\frac{m_p(v_p - a \Delta t)}{\Delta t} = (M + m_p) a.

  3. Step 3

    vp=(3.00+1.00)×3.92×0.002500.0500  ⟹  vp=0.784 m/sv_p = \frac{(3.00 + 1.00) \times 3.92 \times 0.00250}{0.0500} \implies v_p = 0.784\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vp,max=3.00+2(0.0500)0.0500×3.92×2.50×10−3=0.608 m/sv_{p,\text{max}} = \frac{3.00 + 2(0.0500)}{0.0500} \times 3.92 \times 2.50 \times 10^{-3} = 0.608\text{ m/s}

    Your calculation followed logically from your equation in Step 2, but the numerical result is inaccurate due to the setup error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the static friction coefficient to find the maximum acceleration of the block without slipping: amax=μsg=3.92 m/s2a_{\text{max}} = \mu_s g = 3.92\text{ m/s}^2.

You correctly converted the time duration to standard units (2.50 ms=0.00250 s2.50\text{ ms} = 0.00250\text{ s}).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Collision Dynamics & Inelastic Embedding Formulation

You assumed the projectile transfers its entire initial momentum to the cart and block via mpvp=(M+m)aΔtm_p v_p = (M + m) a \Delta t, rather than accounting for the projectile embedding into the cart and sharing the final speed.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When an object embeds into a target over a finite duration Δt\Delta t, its change in velocity is Δvp=vp−vf\Delta v_p = v_p - v_f, not vp−0v_p - 0. Setting up Newton's second law on each colliding component (or tracking internal forces during the collision) is necessary rather than assuming instantaneous momentum conservation with external impulse approximations.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Calculate Projectile Deceleration
  • Over duration Δt\Delta t, the projectile slows from vpv_p to vf=aΔtv_f = a \Delta t, exerting average force Fˉ=mpvp−aΔtΔt\bar{F} = m_p \frac{v_p - a \Delta t}{\Delta t}.

  • Express the impact force using the net velocity change of the projectile relative to the ground.

Account for Embedded Mass
  • The impact force Fˉ\bar{F} accelerates the cart and the embedded projectile of combined mass (M+mp)(M + m_p) at acceleration aa.

  • Equate Fˉ=(M+mp)a\bar{F} = (M + m_p) a to link initial speed vpv_p directly with acceleration aa and collision time Δt\Delta t.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Equate the average horizontal force decelerating the projectile to the force accelerating the cart and embedded projectile: Fˉ=mpvp−vfΔt=(M+mp)a\bar{F} = m_p \frac{v_p - v_f}{\Delta t} = (M + m_p) a.

  2. Substitute vf=aΔtv_f = a \Delta t into the force balance: mp(vp−aΔt)Δt=(M+mp)a\frac{m_p(v_p - a \Delta t)}{\Delta t} = (M + m_p) a.

  3. Rearrange for initial speed: vp=M+2mpmpaΔtv_p = \frac{M + 2m_p}{m_p} a \Delta t.

  4. Substitute a=amax=3.92 m/s2a = a_{\text{max}} = 3.92\text{ m/s}^2, M=3.00 kgM = 3.00\text{ kg}, mp=0.0500 kgm_p = 0.0500\text{ kg}, and Δt=0.00250 s\Delta t = 0.00250\text{ s}: vp,max=3.100.0500×3.92×0.00250v_{p,\text{max}} = \frac{3.10}{0.0500} \times 3.92 \times 0.00250.

Final answer

vp,max=0.608 m/sv_{p,\text{max}} = 0.608\text{ m/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how to relate average impact force Fˉ\bar{F} to the velocity change Δv\Delta v over a non-zero collision time Δt\Delta t.

  • Practice writing Newton's third law force pairs separately for the bullet and the target during an embedding collision.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student ignores the inertia of the resting block on top of the cart and only accounts for the cart and projectile mass in the impulse balance.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    amax=μsg=0.400×9.80=3.92 m/s2a_{\text{max}} = \mu_s g = 0.400 \times 9.80 = 3.92\text{ m/s}^2

  2. Step 2

    mpvp=(M+mp)amaxΔtm_p v_p = (M + m_p) a_{\text{max}} \Delta t

    Correct

    vp=M+2mpmpamaxΔtv_p = \frac{M + 2m_p}{m_p} a_{\text{max}} \Delta t

    During the impact time Δt\Delta t, the average force accelerating the cart assembly is Fˉ=(M+mp)a\bar{F} = (M + m_p) a, while the force decelerating the projectile is Fˉ=mpvp−vfΔt=mpvpΔt−mpa\bar{F} = m_p \frac{v_p - v_f}{\Delta t} = \frac{m_p v_p}{\Delta t} - m_p a. Equating these forces yields mpvpΔt=(M+2mp)a\frac{m_p v_p}{\Delta t} = (M + 2m_p) a, which introduces an additional mpm_p term compared to your formulation.

  3. Step 3

    vp=(3.00+0.0500)×3.92×0.002500.0500  ⟹  vp=0.598 m/sv_p = \frac{(3.00 + 0.0500) \times 3.92 \times 0.00250}{0.0500} \implies v_p = 0.598\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vp,max=3.100.0500×3.92×0.00250≈0.608 m/sv_{p,\text{max}} = \frac{3.10}{0.0500} \times 3.92 \times 0.00250 \approx 0.608\text{ m/s}

    Your arithmetic was executed cleanly following your formula, but the result is affected by the missing mass term in Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the threshold acceleration is determined solely by static friction: amax=μsga_{\text{max}} = \mu_s g.

You substituted the numerical values for mass, friction, and impact duration into your equation with consistent units.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Collision impulse force balance mismatch

You equated the initial projectile momentum directly to (M+mp)aΔt(M + m_p) a \Delta t rather than equating the average mutual impact force between the projectile and cart body.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing an instant-after post-collision momentum state (mpvp=mtotvfm_p v_p = m_{\text{tot}} v_f) with the ongoing force balance during the non-negligible impact interval Δt\Delta t, where the projectile's deceleration force must match the cart's accelerating force.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Deceleration force on the projectile
  • Over impact duration Δt\Delta t with final speed vf=aΔtv_f = a \Delta t, the average impact force is Fˉ=mpvp−vfΔt=mpvpΔt−mpa\bar{F} = m_p \frac{v_p - v_f}{\Delta t} = \frac{m_p v_p}{\Delta t} - m_p a.

  • Express the contact force using the projectile's actual change in velocity rather than neglecting its final speed.

Internal force matching
  • By Newton's third law, the forward force on the cart assembly equals the backward force on the projectile: (M+mp)a=Fˉ(M + m_p) a = \bar{F}.

  • Equate the two expressions for Fˉ\bar{F} to relate vpv_p to aa.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the impact force accelerating the cart assembly equal to the decelerating force on the projectile: (M+mp)a=mp(vp−aΔt)Δt(M + m_p) a = \frac{m_p(v_p - a \Delta t)}{\Delta t}.

  2. Rearrange to isolate the initial projectile speed: vp=M+2mpmpaΔtv_p = \frac{M + 2m_p}{m_p} a \Delta t.

  3. Substitute a=3.92 m/s2a = 3.92\text{ m/s}^2, M=3.00 kgM = 3.00\text{ kg}, mp=0.0500 kgm_p = 0.0500\text{ kg}, and Δt=0.00250 s\Delta t = 0.00250\text{ s}.

Final answer

vp,max=0.608 m/sv_{p,\text{max}} = 0.608\text{ m/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how average impact forces are derived from change in momentum when collision duration Δt\Delta t is explicitly given.

  • Practice separating colliding bodies into free-body diagrams during the collision duration rather than assuming instantaneous momentum conservation.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misinterprets the condition as requiring the post-collision final velocity of the system rather than limiting the acceleration during the collision impact time Δt.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    amax⁡=μsg=0.400×9.80=3.92 m/s2a_{\max} = \mu_s g = 0.400 \times 9.80 = 3.92\text{ m/s}^2

  2. Step 2

    vfinal=amax⁡=3.92 m/sv_{\text{final}} = a_{\max} = 3.92\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vf=amax⁡Δt=(3.92 m/s2)(2.50×10−3 s)=0.00980 m/sv_f = a_{\max} \Delta t = (3.92\text{ m/s}^2)(2.50 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}) = 0.00980\text{ m/s}

    You equated velocity directly to acceleration. Velocity and acceleration have different dimensions; the velocity acquired during the impact is vf=aΔtv_f = a \Delta t.

  3. Step 3

    mpvp=(M+m+mp)vfinal  ⟹  vp=4.05×3.920.0500=318 m/sm_p v_p = (M + m + m_p) v_{\text{final}} \implies v_p = \frac{4.05 \times 3.92}{0.0500} = 318\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vp,max⁡=M+2mpmpμsgΔt=3.100.0500×0.00980=0.608 m/sv_{p,\max} = \frac{M + 2m_p}{m_p} \mu_s g \Delta t = \frac{3.10}{0.0500} \times 0.00980 = 0.608\text{ m/s}

    Because vfinalv_{\text{final}} was incorrect and the collision dynamics during the short impact time Δt\Delta t were not used, the resulting initial speed is incorrect.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified static friction as the limiting mechanism for the block.

You accurately evaluated amax⁡=μsg=3.92 m/s2a_{\max} = \mu_s g = 3.92\text{ m/s}^2.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equating acceleration directly to velocity / ignoring impact duration

You set vfinal=amax⁡v_{\text{final}} = a_{\max} numerically without multiplying by the collision time interval Δt\Delta t, creating a dimensional mismatch.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the non-slip condition as a constraint on the overall post-collision system velocity rather than limiting the peak cart acceleration during the brief impact duration Δt\Delta t.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Kinematic Relationship Across Collision Time
  • For uniform acceleration over time Δt\Delta t starting from rest, change in velocity is Δv=aΔt\Delta v = a \Delta t, never aa.

  • Multiply the acceleration limit by the impact duration Δt\Delta t to find the speed reached during the collision.

Impulsive Force vs. Momentum Conservation
  • When a collision duration Δt\Delta t is specified to limit acceleration, relate the impact force Fˉ=mpvp−vfΔt\bar{F} = m_p \frac{v_p - v_f}{\Delta t} directly to the accelerated body's mass and acceleration.

  • Set up Newton's second law for the cart and projectile during Δt\Delta t rather than assuming an unconstrained total momentum equation.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. The speed acquired by the cart and embedded projectile by the end of the collision is vf=aΔtv_f = a \Delta t.

  2. The average force exerted by the projectile as it decelerates from vpv_p to vfv_f is Fˉ=mpvp−vfΔt=mpvpΔt−mpa\bar{F} = m_p \frac{v_p - v_f}{\Delta t} = \frac{m_p v_p}{\Delta t} - m_p a.

  3. This average force accelerates the combined mass (M+mp)(M + m_p) at aa: Fˉ=(M+mp)a\bar{F} = (M + m_p)a.

  4. Equating these forces gives mpvpΔt=(M+2mp)a  ⟹  vp=M+2mpmpaΔt\frac{m_p v_p}{\Delta t} = (M + 2m_p)a \implies v_p = \frac{M + 2m_p}{m_p} a \Delta t.

  5. Substitute a=amax⁡=μsg=3.92 m/s2a = a_{\max} = \mu_s g = 3.92\text{ m/s}^2 and Δt=2.50×10−3 s\Delta t = 2.50 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}: vp,max⁡=3.100.0500×3.92×2.50×10−3=0.608 m/sv_{p,\max} = \frac{3.10}{0.0500} \times 3.92 \times 2.50 \times 10^{-3} = 0.608\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

vp,max⁡=0.608 m/sv_{p,\max} = 0.608\text{ m/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always verify that physical dimensions match before equating two quantities ([v]=m/s[v] = \text{m/s} while [a]=m/s2[a] = \text{m/s}^2).

  • When an impact duration Δt\Delta t is given, focus on the acceleration and average force during that interval rather than just post-collision momentum.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A block of mass m=2.00 kgm = 2.00\text{ kg} rests on a flat cart of mass M=8.00 kgM = 8.00\text{ kg}. The coefficient of static friction between the block and the cart is μs=0.300\mu_s = 0.300. What is the maximum horizontal force that can be applied to the cart without the block slipping? (Use g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2.)

Answer

Fmax=29.4 NF_{\text{max}} = 29.4\text{ N}. The maximum acceleration without slipping is amax=μsg=0.300×9.80=2.94 m/s2a_{\text{max}} = \mu_s g = 0.300 \times 9.80 = 2.94\text{ m/s}^2. The total mass accelerated is M+m=10.00 kgM + m = 10.00\text{ kg}, so Fmax=(M+m)amax=10.00×2.94=29.4 NF_{\text{max}} = (M + m) a_{\text{max}} = 10.00 \times 2.94 = 29.4\text{ N}.

02

A pellet of mass mp=0.020 kgm_p = 0.020\text{ kg} moving at speed vpv_p strikes a stationary target block of mass M=1.98 kgM = 1.98\text{ kg} on a frictionless surface and embeds in it over an impact duration of Δt=4.0 ms\Delta t = 4.0\text{ ms}. If the target experiences a constant acceleration of a=15 m/s2a = 15\text{ m/s}^2 during impact, find the initial speed vpv_p of the pellet.

Answer

vp=6.06 m/sv_p = 6.06\text{ m/s}. The force on the combined mass during impact is Fˉ=(M+mp)a=(1.98+0.020)(15)=30.0 N\bar{F} = (M + m_p) a = (1.98 + 0.020)(15) = 30.0\text{ N}. Newton's third law gives Fˉ=mpvp−aΔtΔt  ⟹  vp=FˉΔtmp+aΔt=30.0×0.00400.020+15(0.0040)=6.00+0.06=6.06 m/s\bar{F} = m_p \frac{v_p - a \Delta t}{\Delta t} \implies v_p = \frac{\bar{F} \Delta t}{m_p} + a \Delta t = \frac{30.0 \times 0.0040}{0.020} + 15(0.0040) = 6.00 + 0.06 = 6.06\text{ m/s}.

03

A small crate of mass m=0.50 kgm = 0.50\text{ kg} rests on a cart of mass M=4.50 kgM = 4.50\text{ kg} with static friction coefficient μs=0.250\mu_s = 0.250. A bullet of mass mb=0.010 kgm_b = 0.010\text{ kg} hits the cart horizontally and embeds in Δt=1.5 ms\Delta t = 1.5\text{ ms}. Taking g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2, find the maximum initial bullet speed vb,maxv_{b,\text{max}} so that the crate does not slip relative to the cart during the collision.

Answer

vb,max=1.66 m/sv_{b,\text{max}} = 1.66\text{ m/s}. The maximum cart acceleration is amax=μsg=0.250×9.80=2.45 m/s2a_{\text{max}} = \mu_s g = 0.250 \times 9.80 = 2.45\text{ m/s}^2. The impact force accelerates (M+mb)(M + m_b), giving Fˉ=(M+mb)amax\bar{F} = (M + m_b) a_{\text{max}}. Since Fˉ=mbvb−amaxΔtΔt\bar{F} = m_b \frac{v_b - a_{\text{max}} \Delta t}{\Delta t}, we obtain vb,max=M+2mbmbamaxΔt=4.520.010×2.45×(1.5×10−3)≈1.66 m/sv_{b,\text{max}} = \frac{M + 2m_b}{m_b} a_{\text{max}} \Delta t = \frac{4.52}{0.010} \times 2.45 \times (1.5 \times 10^{-3}) \approx 1.66\text{ m/s}.

Loading workspace…