Resources

A common student misconception posits that increasing the resistance of a single resistor in a multiloop circuit always decreases the magnitude of the current passing through that specific resistor. Consider a circuit with three vertical branches between nodes MM and NN. The left branch has E1=30.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 30.0\text{ V} pointing toward MM and resistor R1=10.0 ΩR_1 = 10.0\ \Omega. The center branch has an opposing source E2=10.0 V\mathcal{E}_2 = 10.0\text{ V} pointing toward MM and resistor R2=5.00 ΩR_2 = 5.00\ \Omega. The right branch contains an initially balanced opposing battery E3=20.0 V\mathcal{E}_3 = 20.0\text{ V} pointing toward MM and a variable resistor R3R_3. When R3=10.0 ΩR_3 = 10.0\ \Omega, the current in the right branch is zero (I3=0 AI_3 = 0\text{ A}). If R3R_3 is replaced by an open circuit (R3→∞R_3 \to \infty), calculate the new magnitude of current I2I_2 in the center branch, and determine whether I2I_2 increases or decreases compared to its initial value when R3=10.0 ΩR_3 = 10.0\ \Omega.

Answer and steps

Final answer

I2=2.00 AI_2 = 2.00\text{ A}, which represents an increase from its initial value of 0.00 A0.00\text{ A} (initially VM−VN=20.0 VV_M - V_N = 20.0\text{ V}, so initial I2=2.00 AI_2 = 2.00\text{ A}; following disconnection, VM−VN=16.7 VV_M - V_N = 16.7\text{ V}, yielding I2=1.33 AI_2 = 1.33\text{ A}, representing a net decrease of 0.67 A0.67\text{ A})

Steps

01

Initial State (R3=10.0 ΩR_3 = 10.0\ \Omega)

To find the center branch current before and after opening the right branch, we apply Kirchhoff's laws and node-voltage analysis between nodes MM and NN.

Let the reference potential at node NN be VN=0 VV_N = 0\text{ V}. Each vertical branch contains an emf directed toward node MM in series with a resistor:

  • Left branch: E1=30.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 30.0\text{ V}, R1=10.0 ΩR_1 = 10.0\ \Omega
  • Center branch: E2=10.0 V\mathcal{E}_2 = 10.0\text{ V}, R2=5.00 ΩR_2 = 5.00\ \Omega
  • Right branch: E3=20.0 V\mathcal{E}_3 = 20.0\text{ V}, R3=10.0 ΩR_3 = 10.0\ \Omega

The current through the right branch from NN to MM is given by: I3=E3−(VM−VN)R3I_3 = \frac{\mathcal{E}_3 - (V_M - V_N)}{R_3}

Given that the right branch current is initially balanced at zero (I3=0 AI_3 = 0\text{ A}): E3−(VM−VN)=0  ⟹  VM−VN=E3=20.0 V\mathcal{E}_3 - (V_M - V_N) = 0 \implies V_M - V_N = \mathcal{E}_3 = 20.0\text{ V}

Using this node potential difference, the initial current through the center branch I2I_2 (flowing from MM to NN because VM>E2V_M > \mathcal{E}_2) has a magnitude of: I2,initial=VM−E2R2=20.0 V−10.0 V5.00 Ω=2.00 AI_{2,\text{initial}} = \frac{V_M - \mathcal{E}_2}{R_2} = \frac{20.0\text{ V} - 10.0\text{ V}}{5.00\ \Omega} = 2.00\text{ A}

02

Disconnected State (R3→∞R_3 \to \infty)

When the right branch is opened (R3→∞R_3 \to \infty), no current flows through the right branch (I3=0I_3 = 0). The circuit reduces to a single loop formed by the left and center branches.

By Millman's theorem (or Kirchhoff's Current Law at node MM with I1+I2=0I_1 + I_2 = 0 directed into MM): E1−VM′R1+E2−VM′R2=0\frac{\mathcal{E}_1 - V_M'}{R_1} + \frac{\mathcal{E}_2 - V_M'}{R_2} = 0

Substitute the given values: 30.0−VM′10.0+10.0−VM′5.00=0\frac{30.0 - V_M'}{10.0} + \frac{10.0 - V_M'}{5.00} = 0

3.00−0.100 VM′+2.00−0.200 VM′=03.00 - 0.100\,V_M' + 2.00 - 0.200\,V_M' = 0 5.00=0.300 VM′  ⟹  VM′=5.000.300≈16.7 V5.00 = 0.300\,V_M' \implies V_M' = \frac{5.00}{0.300} \approx 16.7\text{ V}

The new current magnitude in the center branch is: I2,final=VM′−E2R2=16.67 V−10.0 V5.00 Ω=6.67 V5.00 Ω≈1.33 AI_{2,\text{final}} = \frac{V_M' - \mathcal{E}_2}{R_2} = \frac{16.67\text{ V} - 10.0\text{ V}}{5.00\ \Omega} = \frac{6.67\text{ V}}{5.00\ \Omega} \approx 1.33\text{ A}

03

Comparison of Current Values

  • Initial center branch current: I2,initial=2.00 AI_{2,\text{initial}} = 2.00\text{ A}
  • New center branch current: I2,final=1.33 AI_{2,\text{final}} = 1.33\text{ A}

The magnitude of the center branch current changes by: ΔI2=1.33 A−2.00 A=−0.67 A\Delta I_2 = 1.33\text{ A} - 2.00\text{ A} = -0.67\text{ A}

Thus, following the disconnection of the right branch, the potential difference across the center branch drops from 20.0 V20.0\text{ V} to 16.7 V16.7\text{ V}, resulting in a decrease of 0.67 A0.67\text{ A} from its initial value of 2.00 A2.00\text{ A} to 1.33 A1.33\text{ A}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 A student incorrectly subtracts EMFs in the single loop assuming the two sources oppose each other around the perimeter loop rather than opposing at node M, leading to an incorrect new current of 2.00 A.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    VN=0 V, VM=E3=20.0 V  ⟹  I2,initial=20.0−10.05.00=2.00 AV_N = 0\text{ V},\ V_M = \mathcal{E}_3 = 20.0\text{ V} \implies I_{2,\text{initial}} = \frac{20.0 - 10.0}{5.00} = 2.00\text{ A}

  2. Step 2

    Loop with left and center branches:\text{Loop with left and center branches:}   ⟹  \implies E\mathcal{E}_{total\text{total}} = E\mathcal{E}_1 + E\mathcal{E}2 = 30.0 + 10.0 = 40.0 V\text{ V}   ⟹  \implies R{total\text{total}} = R_1 + R_2 = 10.0 + 5.00 = 15.0\ Ω\Omega

    Correct

    E\mathcal{E}_{net\text{net}} = E\mathcal{E}_1 - E\mathcal{E}2 = 30.0 V\text{ V} - 10.0 V\text{ V} = 20.0 V\text{ V}   ⟹  \implies R{total\text{total}} = R_1 + R_2 = 15.0\ Ω\Omega

    Both sources E1\mathcal{E}_1 and E2\mathcal{E}_2 point toward node MM. When tracing around the single loop (up the left branch and down the center branch), you traverse E1\mathcal{E}_1 from negative to positive and E2\mathcal{E}_2 from positive to negative, so their EMFs oppose each other around the perimeter: Enet=30.0 V−10.0 V=20.0 V\mathcal{E}_{\text{net}} = 30.0\text{ V} - 10.0\text{ V} = 20.0\text{ V}.

  3. Step 3

    I2,new=30.0−10.015.0=1.33 A  ⟹  I2,new=40.015.0=2.67 AI_{2,\text{new}} = \frac{30.0 - 10.0}{15.0} = 1.33\text{ A} \implies I_{2,\text{new}} = \frac{40.0}{15.0} = 2.67\text{ A}

    Correct

    I2,new=EnetRtotal=20.0 V15.0 Ω≈1.33 AI_{2,\text{new}} = \frac{\mathcal{E}_{\text{net}}}{R_{\text{total}}} = \frac{20.0\text{ V}}{15.0\ \Omega} \approx 1.33\text{ A}

    Although you briefly wrote the correct expression 30.0−10.015.0=1.33 A\frac{30.0 - 10.0}{15.0} = 1.33\text{ A}, you replaced it with 40.015.0=2.67 A\frac{40.0}{15.0} = 2.67\text{ A} using your incorrect additive total EMF.

  4. Step 4

    Since \text{Since } 2.67 A\text{ A} > 2.00 A\text{ A}, the magnitude of \text{ the magnitude of } I_2  increases.\text{ increases.}

    Correct

    I_{2,new\text{new}} = 1.33 A\text{ A} < 2.00 A\text{ A}, so the magnitude of \text{ so the magnitude of } I_2  decreases by \text{ decreases by } 0.67 A\text{ A}._

    Because the true final current is 1.33 A1.33\text{ A}, the current in the center branch actually decreases from 2.00 A2.00\text{ A} to 1.33 A1.33\text{ A}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the balanced condition I3=0 AI_3 = 0\text{ A} to establish the node potential VM=20.0 VV_M = 20.0\text{ V}.

You accurately computed the initial current I2,initial=2.00 AI_{2,\text{initial}} = 2.00\text{ A} using the potential difference across the center branch.

You correctly identified the two resistors in series for the remaining loop as Rtotal=15.0 ΩR_{\text{total}} = 15.0\ \Omega.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Loop Rule EMF Sign Convention Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated two sources directed toward the same node as series-aiding around the perimeter loop rather than recognizing that their polarities oppose each other when traced in a continuous loop direction.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Tracing Loop Directions
  • In Kirchhoff's Voltage Law, choose one continuous circulation direction (clockwise or counterclockwise); traverse each battery from −- to ++ as +V+V and from ++ to −- as −V-V.

  • Trace from node NN up through branch 1 (+E1+\mathcal{E}_1) to node MM, then down through branch 2 (−E2-\mathcal{E}_2) back to node NN to find Eloop=E1−E2\mathcal{E}_{\text{loop}} = \mathcal{E}_1 - \mathcal{E}_2.

Opposing Node Connections
  • When two batteries both have their positive terminals pointing to the same node, they push current into that node from opposite directions, meaning they oppose each other in the loop enclosing both branches.

  • Always verify battery polarities along the circulating loop path rather than simply summing branch magnitudes.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Trace clockwise around the loop: start at node NN, go up the left branch (+E1−IR1+\mathcal{E}_1 - I R_1), cross node MM, and go down the center branch (−E2−IR2=0-\mathcal{E}_2 - I R_2 = 0).

  2. Combine terms to solve for the circulating current: I=E1−E2R1+R2=30.0 V−10.0 V10.0 Ω+5.00 Ω=20.0 V15.0 Ω≈1.33 AI = \frac{\mathcal{E}_1 - \mathcal{E}_2}{R_1 + R_2} = \frac{30.0\text{ V} - 10.0\text{ V}}{10.0\ \Omega + 5.00\ \Omega} = \frac{20.0\text{ V}}{15.0\ \Omega} \approx 1.33\text{ A}.

  3. Compare the new current to the initial value: ΔI2=1.33 A−2.00 A=−0.67 A\Delta I_2 = 1.33\text{ A} - 2.00\text{ A} = -0.67\text{ A}, meaning the current decreases.

Final answer

I2,new=1.33 AI_{2,\text{new}} = 1.33\text{ A}, which represents a decrease of 0.67 A0.67\text{ A} from the initial value of 2.00 A2.00\text{ A}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice drawing an explicit loop arrow (clockwise or counterclockwise) when applying Kirchhoff's loop rule, recording the sign for each source as you enter its terminals.

  • Solve multiloop reduction problems by re-checking node voltages using Millman's theorem as an independent cross-check.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 A student misidentifies the branch potential difference by neglecting the center battery E2 when computing current from the node voltage, calculating I2 = VM / R2.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    VN=0 V,VM=20.0 V  ⟹  I2 initial=20.0−10.05.00=2.00 AV_N = 0\text{ V}, V_M = 20.0\text{ V} \implies I_{2\text{ initial}} = \frac{20.0 - 10.0}{5.00} = 2.00\text{ A}

  2. Step 2

    VM−30.010.0+VM−10.05.00=0  ⟹  VM−30.0+2VM−20.0=0  ⟹  3VM=50.0  ⟹  VM=16.67 V\frac{V_M - 30.0}{10.0} + \frac{V_M - 10.0}{5.00} = 0 \implies V_M - 30.0 + 2V_M - 20.0 = 0 \implies 3V_M = 50.0 \implies V_M = 16.67\text{ V}

  3. Step 3

    I2 new=16.675.00=3.33 AI_{2\text{ new}} = \frac{16.67}{5.00} = 3.33\text{ A}

    Correct

    I2 new=VM−E2R2=16.67 V−10.0 V5.00 Ω≈1.33 AI_{2\text{ new}} = \frac{V_M - \mathcal{E}_2}{R_2} = \frac{16.67\text{ V} - 10.0\text{ V}}{5.00\ \Omega} \approx 1.33\text{ A}

    You calculated the current using Ohm's law with the node potential alone (VM/R2V_M / R_2) rather than the net voltage across resistor R2R_2. Because branch 2 contains a 10.0 V10.0\text{ V} battery in series with R2R_2, the voltage across the resistor is VM−E2=16.67 V−10.0 V=6.67 VV_M - \mathcal{E}_2 = 16.67\text{ V} - 10.0\text{ V} = 6.67\text{ V}, giving I2 new≈1.33 AI_{2\text{ new}} \approx 1.33\text{ A}.

  4. Step 4

    Since 3.33 A>2.00 A, the magnitude of I2 increases.\text{Since } 3.33\text{ A} > 2.00\text{ A}, \text{ the magnitude of } I_2 \text{ increases.}

    Correct

    ΔI2=1.33 A−2.00 A=−0.67 A  ⟹  I2 decreases from 2.00 A to 1.33 A\Delta I_2 = 1.33\text{ A} - 2.00\text{ A} = -0.67\text{ A} \implies I_2 \text{ decreases from } 2.00\text{ A} \text{ to } 1.33\text{ A}

    Your comparison followed logically from your calculated value of 3.33 A3.33\text{ A}, but because the true new current is 1.33 A1.33\text{ A}, the magnitude of I2I_2 actually decreases by 0.67 A0.67\text{ A}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the initial condition I3=0 AI_3 = 0\text{ A} to deduce the initial node potential VM=20.0 VV_M = 20.0\text{ V}.

You set up and solved the KCL node equation accurately to find VM≈16.67 VV_M \approx 16.67\text{ V} after opening the right branch.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Branch EMF in Resistor Voltage

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Neglecting an internal branch source when converting node potentials to branch currents. Even though you included E2\mathcal{E}_2 in your KCL equation, you dropped it when solving for the final branch current I2 newI_{2\text{ new}}, treating the branch as if it consisted solely of resistor R2R_2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Ohm's Law in an Active Branch
  • The current through a branch containing both a resistor RR and a series emf E\mathcal{E} is I=∣Vnode A−Vnode B±E∣RI = \frac{|V_{\text{node A}} - V_{\text{node B}} \pm \mathcal{E}|}{R}, not simply ΔVnodesR\frac{\Delta V_{\text{nodes}}}{R}.

  • Always draw the branch segment separately with its potential labels to verify that the voltage across the resistor accounts for all series batteries.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply Kirchhoff's Voltage Law along the center branch from node MM to node NN: VM−I2R2−E2=VNV_M - I_2 R_2 - \mathcal{E}_2 = V_N.

  2. Substitute the values with VN=0 VV_N = 0\text{ V}: 16.67 V−I2(5.00 Ω)−10.0 V=016.67\text{ V} - I_2(5.00\ \Omega) - 10.0\text{ V} = 0.

  3. Solve for I2I_2: I2=16.67 V−10.0 V5.00 Ω=6.67 V5.00 Ω≈1.33 AI_2 = \frac{16.67\text{ V} - 10.0\text{ V}}{5.00\ \Omega} = \frac{6.67\text{ V}}{5.00\ \Omega} \approx 1.33\text{ A}.

  4. Compare with the initial current: ΔI2=1.33 A−2.00 A=−0.67 A\Delta I_2 = 1.33\text{ A} - 2.00\text{ A} = -0.67\text{ A}.

Final answer

I2=1.33 AI_2 = 1.33\text{ A}, which represents a decrease from its initial value of 2.00 A2.00\text{ A}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When applying nodal analysis, use the exact branch expression from your KCL formulation, Ik=VM−EkRkI_k = \frac{V_M - \mathcal{E}_k}{R_k}, to evaluate the branch current after solving for node voltages.

  • Practice writing Ohm's law explicitly across the resistor terminals rather than skipping straight to node-to-ground potentials.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A single rectangular circuit loop contains two batteries and one resistor of R=8.0 ΩR = 8.0\ \Omega. Battery AA has EA=18.0 V\mathcal{E}_A = 18.0\text{ V} pointing clockwise, and Battery BB has EB=6.0 V\mathcal{E}_B = 6.0\text{ V} also pointing clockwise around the loop. What is the current flowing in the loop?

Answer

Since both batteries point in the clockwise direction, their EMFs add: Enet=18.0 V+6.0 V=24.0 V\mathcal{E}_{\text{net}} = 18.0\text{ V} + 6.0\text{ V} = 24.0\text{ V}. The current is I=EnetR=24.0 V8.0 Ω=3.0 AI = \frac{\mathcal{E}_{\text{net}}}{R} = \frac{24.0\text{ V}}{8.0\ \Omega} = 3.0\text{ A}.

02

Two branches connected between nodes AA (top) and BB (bottom) form a single closed loop. Branch 1 has an upward battery E1=25 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 25\text{ V} and a resistor R1=3.0 ΩR_1 = 3.0\ \Omega. Branch 2 has an upward battery E2=10 V\mathcal{E}_2 = 10\text{ V} and a resistor R2=2.0 ΩR_2 = 2.0\ \Omega. Determine the magnitude and direction of the current flowing through Branch 2.

Answer

Tracing clockwise (up branch 1, down branch 2): Enet=E1−E2=25 V−10 V=15 V\mathcal{E}_{\text{net}} = \mathcal{E}_1 - \mathcal{E}_2 = 25\text{ V} - 10\text{ V} = 15\text{ V}. Total resistance Rtotal=3.0 Ω+2.0 Ω=5.0 ΩR_{\text{total}} = 3.0\ \Omega + 2.0\ \Omega = 5.0\ \Omega. The clockwise current is I=15 V5.0 Ω=3.0 AI = \frac{15\text{ V}}{5.0\ \Omega} = 3.0\text{ A}, which flows downward through Branch 2 (from node AA to node BB).

03

A three-branch parallel circuit connects nodes MM (top) and NN (bottom). Branch 1 has E1=12 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 12\text{ V} pointing toward MM with R1=4.0 ΩR_1 = 4.0\ \Omega. Branch 2 has E2=6.0 V\mathcal{E}_2 = 6.0\text{ V} pointing toward MM with R2=2.0 ΩR_2 = 2.0\ \Omega. Branch 3 has a switch in series with a resistor R3=6.0 ΩR_3 = 6.0\ \Omega and no battery. If the switch in Branch 3 is opened, does the current through Branch 2 increase, decrease, or stay the same? Justify with numerical values.

Answer

With Branch 3 closed, using Millman's theorem: VM=12/4+6/2+0/61/4+1/2+1/6=6.011/12=7211≈6.55 VV_M = \frac{12/4 + 6/2 + 0/6}{1/4 + 1/2 + 1/6} = \frac{6.0}{11/12} = \frac{72}{11} \approx 6.55\text{ V}. Current down branch 2 is I2,closed=6.55−6.02.0=0.27 AI_{2,\text{closed}} = \frac{6.55 - 6.0}{2.0} = 0.27\text{ A}. When Branch 3 is opened, the circuit reduces to branches 1 and 2: VM′=12/4+6/21/4+1/2=6.00.75=8.0 VV_M' = \frac{12/4 + 6/2}{1/4 + 1/2} = \frac{6.0}{0.75} = 8.0\text{ V}. Current down branch 2 becomes I2,open=8.0−6.02.0=1.0 AI_{2,\text{open}} = \frac{8.0 - 6.0}{2.0} = 1.0\text{ A}. Therefore, the magnitude of current in Branch 2 increases from 0.27 A0.27\text{ A} to 1.0 A1.0\text{ A}.

Loading workspace…