Resources
A common student misconception posits that increasing the resistance of a single resistor in a multiloop circuit always decreases the magnitude of the current passing through that specific resistor. Consider a circuit with three vertical branches between nodes and . The left branch has pointing toward and resistor . The center branch has an opposing source pointing toward and resistor . The right branch contains an initially balanced opposing battery pointing toward and a variable resistor . When , the current in the right branch is zero (). If is replaced by an open circuit (), calculate the new magnitude of current in the center branch, and determine whether increases or decreases compared to its initial value when .
Answer and steps
Final answer
, which represents an increase from its initial value of (initially , so initial ; following disconnection, , yielding , representing a net decrease of )
Steps
Initial State ()
To find the center branch current before and after opening the right branch, we apply Kirchhoff's laws and node-voltage analysis between nodes and .
Let the reference potential at node be . Each vertical branch contains an emf directed toward node in series with a resistor:
- Left branch: ,
- Center branch: ,
- Right branch: ,
The current through the right branch from to is given by:
Given that the right branch current is initially balanced at zero ():
Using this node potential difference, the initial current through the center branch (flowing from to because ) has a magnitude of:
Disconnected State ()
When the right branch is opened (), no current flows through the right branch (). The circuit reduces to a single loop formed by the left and center branches.
By Millman's theorem (or Kirchhoff's Current Law at node with directed into ):
Substitute the given values:
The new current magnitude in the center branch is:
Comparison of Current Values
- Initial center branch current:
- New center branch current:
The magnitude of the center branch current changes by:
Thus, following the disconnection of the right branch, the potential difference across the center branch drops from to , resulting in a decrease of from its initial value of to .
Typical errors
01 A student incorrectly subtracts EMFs in the single loop assuming the two sources oppose each other around the perimeter loop rather than opposing at node M, leading to an incorrect new current of 2.00 A.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
_{} = _1 + 2 = 30.0 + 10.0 = 40.0 R{} = R_1 + R_2 = 10.0 + 5.00 = 15.0\
Correct_{} = _1 - 2 = 30.0 - 10.0 = 20.0 R{} = R_1 + R_2 = 15.0\
Both sources and point toward node . When tracing around the single loop (up the left branch and down the center branch), you traverse from negative to positive and from positive to negative, so their EMFs oppose each other around the perimeter: .
- Step 3Correct
Although you briefly wrote the correct expression , you replaced it with using your incorrect additive total EMF.
- Step 4
2.67 > 2.00, I_2
CorrectI_{2,} = 1.33 < 2.00, I_2 0.67._
Because the true final current is , the current in the center branch actually decreases from to .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the balanced condition to establish the node potential .
You accurately computed the initial current using the potential difference across the center branch.
You correctly identified the two resistors in series for the remaining loop as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated two sources directed toward the same node as series-aiding around the perimeter loop rather than recognizing that their polarities oppose each other when traced in a continuous loop direction.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Tracing Loop Directions
In Kirchhoff's Voltage Law, choose one continuous circulation direction (clockwise or counterclockwise); traverse each battery from to as and from to as .
Trace from node up through branch 1 () to node , then down through branch 2 () back to node to find .
- Opposing Node Connections
When two batteries both have their positive terminals pointing to the same node, they push current into that node from opposite directions, meaning they oppose each other in the loop enclosing both branches.
Always verify battery polarities along the circulating loop path rather than simply summing branch magnitudes.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationTrace clockwise around the loop: start at node , go up the left branch (), cross node , and go down the center branch ().
Combine terms to solve for the circulating current: .
Compare the new current to the initial value: , meaning the current decreases.
, which represents a decrease of from the initial value of .
02 A student misidentifies the branch potential difference by neglecting the center battery E2 when computing current from the node voltage, calculating I2 = VM / R2.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
You calculated the current using Ohm's law with the node potential alone () rather than the net voltage across resistor . Because branch 2 contains a battery in series with , the voltage across the resistor is , giving .
- Step 4Correct
Your comparison followed logically from your calculated value of , but because the true new current is , the magnitude of actually decreases by .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the initial condition to deduce the initial node potential .
You set up and solved the KCL node equation accurately to find after opening the right branch.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisNeglecting an internal branch source when converting node potentials to branch currents. Even though you included in your KCL equation, you dropped it when solving for the final branch current , treating the branch as if it consisted solely of resistor .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Ohm's Law in an Active Branch
The current through a branch containing both a resistor and a series emf is , not simply .
Always draw the branch segment separately with its potential labels to verify that the voltage across the resistor accounts for all series batteries.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationApply Kirchhoff's Voltage Law along the center branch from node to node : .
Substitute the values with : .
Solve for : .
Compare with the initial current: .
, which represents a decrease from its initial value of
Lock it in
When tracing Kirchhoff's Voltage Law around a single loop, how do you determine the sign of a battery's EMF?
If your tracing path goes from the negative terminal to the positive terminal, the EMF is ; if it goes from positive to negative, the EMF is .
Similar question
A single rectangular circuit loop contains two batteries and one resistor of . Battery has pointing clockwise, and Battery has also pointing clockwise around the loop. What is the current flowing in the loop?
Answer
Since both batteries point in the clockwise direction, their EMFs add: . The current is .
Two branches connected between nodes (top) and (bottom) form a single closed loop. Branch 1 has an upward battery and a resistor . Branch 2 has an upward battery and a resistor . Determine the magnitude and direction of the current flowing through Branch 2.
Answer
Tracing clockwise (up branch 1, down branch 2): . Total resistance . The clockwise current is , which flows downward through Branch 2 (from node to node ).
A three-branch parallel circuit connects nodes (top) and (bottom). Branch 1 has pointing toward with . Branch 2 has pointing toward with . Branch 3 has a switch in series with a resistor and no battery. If the switch in Branch 3 is opened, does the current through Branch 2 increase, decrease, or stay the same? Justify with numerical values.
Answer
With Branch 3 closed, using Millman's theorem: . Current down branch 2 is . When Branch 3 is opened, the circuit reduces to branches 1 and 2: . Current down branch 2 becomes . Therefore, the magnitude of current in Branch 2 increases from to .