Resources

An introductory physics student records the position xx of a cart on a straight horizontal air track at equal time intervals of Δt=0.50 s\Delta t = 0.50\text{ s} using a motion sensor. The recorded data table is given below:

Time t (s)t\text{ (s)}Position x (m)x\text{ (m)}
0.000.000.200.20
0.500.500.450.45
1.001.000.900.90
1.501.501.551.55
2.002.002.402.40

Assuming the cart experiences a constant net forward horizontal force, calculate the average acceleration aa of the cart over the entire 2.00 s2.00\text{ s} interval, and determine its instantaneous velocity vv at t=1.00 st = 1.00\text{ s} using central difference numerical estimation.

Answer and steps

Final answer

a=0.80 m/s2a = 0.80\text{ m/s}^2; v(1.00 s)=1.1 m/sv(1.00\text{ s}) = 1.1\text{ m/s}

Steps

01

Calculate the Acceleration (aa)

Because the cart experiences a constant net force on a frictionless horizontal air track, its acceleration aa is constant throughout the motion.

For equally spaced time measurements with interval Δt=0.50 s\Delta t = 0.50\text{ s}, the change in position between successive points gives the displacements:

  • From t=0.00 st = 0.00\text{ s} to t=0.50 st = 0.50\text{ s}: Δx1=0.45 m−0.20 m=0.25 m\Delta x_1 = 0.45\text{ m} - 0.20\text{ m} = 0.25\text{ m}
  • From t=0.50 st = 0.50\text{ s} to t=1.00 st = 1.00\text{ s}: Δx2=0.90 m−0.45 m=0.45 m\Delta x_2 = 0.90\text{ m} - 0.45\text{ m} = 0.45\text{ m}
  • From t=1.00 st = 1.00\text{ s} to t=1.50 st = 1.50\text{ s}: Δx3=1.55 m−0.90 m=0.65 m\Delta x_3 = 1.55\text{ m} - 0.90\text{ m} = 0.65\text{ m}
  • From t=1.50 st = 1.50\text{ s} to t=2.00 st = 2.00\text{ s}: Δx4=2.40 m−1.55 m=0.85 m\Delta x_4 = 2.40\text{ m} - 1.55\text{ m} = 0.85\text{ m}

The second difference of position represents the change in displacement per interval: Δ2x=Δx2−Δx1=0.45 m−0.25 m=0.20 m\Delta^2 x = \Delta x_2 - \Delta x_1 = 0.45\text{ m} - 0.25\text{ m} = 0.20\text{ m}

For uniform acceleration, the relationship between the second difference and acceleration is: Δ2x=a(Δt)2\Delta^2 x = a (\Delta t)^2

Solving for acceleration aa: a=Δ2x(Δt)2=0.20 m(0.50 s)2=0.20 m0.25 s2=0.80 m/s2a = \frac{\Delta^2 x}{(\Delta t)^2} = \frac{0.20\text{ m}}{(0.50\text{ s})^2} = \frac{0.20\text{ m}}{0.25\text{ s}^2} = 0.80\text{ m/s}^2


02

Estimate the Velocity at t=1.00 st = 1.00\text{ s} Using Central Difference

The central difference method estimates the instantaneous velocity at a given time tt by evaluating the average velocity over a symmetric interval centered at tt: v(t)≈x(t+Δt)−x(t−Δt)2Δtv(t) \approx \frac{x(t + \Delta t) - x(t - \Delta t)}{2\Delta t}

For t=1.00 st = 1.00\text{ s} with Δt=0.50 s\Delta t = 0.50\text{ s}:

  • t+Δt=1.50 s  ⟹  x(1.50 s)=1.55 mt + \Delta t = 1.50\text{ s} \implies x(1.50\text{ s}) = 1.55\text{ m}
  • t−Δt=0.50 s  ⟹  x(0.50 s)=0.45 mt - \Delta t = 0.50\text{ s} \implies x(0.50\text{ s}) = 0.45\text{ m}

Substitute the table values into the formula: v(1.00 s)=1.55 m−0.45 m1.50 s−0.50 s=1.10 m1.00 s=1.1 m/sv(1.00\text{ s}) = \frac{1.55\text{ m} - 0.45\text{ m}}{1.50\text{ s} - 0.50\text{ s}} = \frac{1.10\text{ m}}{1.00\text{ s}} = 1.1\text{ m/s}

(Pitfall to avoid: Do not use a one-sided difference such as x(1.00)−x(0.50)0.50\frac{x(1.00) - x(0.50)}{0.50}, as forward or backward differences introduce a first-order truncation error, whereas the central difference eliminates the linear error term and provides an exact value for motion under constant acceleration.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student mistakenly assumes the cart starts from rest at t = 0, applying Δx = (1/2) a t² without accounting for non-zero initial velocity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Δx=x(2.00)−x(0.00)=2.40−0.20=2.20 m\Delta x = x(2.00) - x(0.00) = 2.40 - 0.20 = 2.20\text{ m}

  2. Step 2

    Assuming \text{Assuming } v_0 = 0,\ Δ\Delta x = 12\frac{1}{2} a t^2   ⟹  \implies 2.20 = 12\frac{1}{2} a (2.00)^2 = 2.00 a   ⟹  \implies a = 2.202.00\frac{2.20}{2.00} = 1.10 m/s\text{ m/s}^2

    Correct

    Δ\Delta^2 x = Δ\Delta x_2 - Δ\Delta x_1 = (0.90 - 0.45) - (0.45 - 0.20) = 0.20 m\text{ m}   ⟹  \implies a = Δ2x(Δt)2\frac{\Delta^2 x}{(\Delta t)^2} = 0.20 m(0.50 s)2\frac{0.20\text{ m}}{(0.50\text{ s})^2} = 0.80 m/s\text{ m/s}^2

    You assumed without justification that v0=0 m/sv_0 = 0\text{ m/s}. The problem statement does not state that the cart started from rest at t=0.00 st = 0.00\text{ s}. Because the initial velocity was non-zero, using Δx=12at2\Delta x = \frac{1}{2}at^2 overestimated the acceleration.

  3. Step 3

    v(1.00) ≈\approx x(1.50)−x(0.50)1.50−0.50\frac{x(1.50) - x(0.50)}{1.50 - 0.50} ≈\approx 1.55−0.451.00\frac{1.55 - 0.45}{1.00} = 1.10 m/s\text{ m/s}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the overall displacement from the endpoint values in the data table.

You applied the central difference approximation accurately with correct symmetric time points and position values.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Kinematics Assumption Error

Assuming zero initial velocity (v0=0v_0 = 0) when the problem does not state the object starts from rest.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating constant acceleration with motion starting from rest, leading to the use of Δx=12at2\Delta x = \frac{1}{2}at^2 instead of determining acceleration from consecutive interval differences or fitting x(t)=x0+v0t+12at2x(t) = x_0 + v_0 t + \frac{1}{2}at^2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Initial Velocity Verification
  • Never assume v0=0v_0 = 0 unless explicitly stated ('starts from rest') or verified by zero displacement over an initial infinitesimal interval.

  • Check consecutive displacements Δx1=x1−x0\Delta x_1 = x_1 - x_0 to see if the initial average velocity matches zero.

Second-Difference Rule for Constant Acceleration
  • For uniformly accelerated motion sampled at equal intervals Δt\Delta t, the second difference of position is constant: Δ2x=a(Δt)2\Delta^2 x = a(\Delta t)^2.

  • Subtract consecutive position differences (Δx2−Δx1)(\Delta x_2 - \Delta x_1) and divide by (Δt)2(\Delta t)^2 to find aa independently of v0v_0.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate successive interval displacements: Δx1=0.45−0.20=0.25 m\Delta x_1 = 0.45 - 0.20 = 0.25\text{ m} and Δx2=0.90−0.45=0.45 m\Delta x_2 = 0.90 - 0.45 = 0.45\text{ m}.

  2. Find the constant change between successive displacements: Δ2x=Δx2−Δx1=0.45 m−0.25 m=0.20 m\Delta^2 x = \Delta x_2 - \Delta x_1 = 0.45\text{ m} - 0.25\text{ m} = 0.20\text{ m}.

  3. Solve for acceleration using Δ2x=a(Δt)2\Delta^2 x = a(\Delta t)^2: a=0.20 m(0.50 s)2=0.80 m/s2a = \frac{0.20\text{ m}}{(0.50\text{ s})^2} = 0.80\text{ m/s}^2.

Final answer

a=0.80 m/s2a = 0.80\text{ m/s}^2; v(1.00 s)=1.1 m/sv(1.00\text{ s}) = 1.1\text{ m/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When working with tabular kinematic data, calculate successive interval displacements Δxi\Delta x_i first to inspect whether velocity changes uniformly.

  • Practice finding initial velocity v0v_0 and acceleration aa simultaneously using two kinematic equations or second differences rather than assuming v0=0v_0 = 0.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student divides by Δt = 0.50 s instead of 2Δt = 1.00 s in the denominator when calculating the central difference velocity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    vavg1=0.45−0.200.50=0.50 m/s at t=0.25 s  ⟹  vavg2=2.40−1.550.50=1.70 m/s at t=1.75 s  ⟹  a=1.70−0.501.75−0.25=1.201.50=0.80 m/s2v_{\text{avg}_1} = \frac{0.45 - 0.20}{0.50} = 0.50\text{ m/s at } t = 0.25\text{ s} \implies v_{\text{avg}_2} = \frac{2.40 - 1.55}{0.50} = 1.70\text{ m/s at } t = 1.75\text{ s} \implies a = \frac{1.70 - 0.50}{1.75 - 0.25} = \frac{1.20}{1.50} = 0.80\text{ m/s}^2

  2. Step 2

    v(1.00)≈x(1.50)−x(0.50)Δt  ⟹  v(1.00)≈1.55−0.450.50v(1.00) \approx \frac{x(1.50) - x(0.50)}{\Delta t} \implies v(1.00) \approx \frac{1.55 - 0.45}{0.50}

    Correct

    v(1.00 s)≈x(1.50 s)−x(0.50 s)2Δt=1.55 m−0.45 m1.50 s−0.50 s=1.10 m1.00 sv(1.00\text{ s}) \approx \frac{x(1.50\text{ s}) - x(0.50\text{ s})}{2\Delta t} = \frac{1.55\text{ m} - 0.45\text{ m}}{1.50\text{ s} - 0.50\text{ s}} = \frac{1.10\text{ m}}{1.00\text{ s}}

    You used Δt=0.50 s\Delta t = 0.50\text{ s} in the denominator, but the time elapsed between t=0.50 st = 0.50\text{ s} and t=1.50 st = 1.50\text{ s} spans two full intervals (2Δt=1.00 s2\Delta t = 1.00\text{ s}).

  3. Step 3

    v(1.00)≈1.100.50=2.20 m/sv(1.00) \approx \frac{1.10}{0.50} = 2.20\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    v(1.00 s)=1.1 m/sv(1.00\text{ s}) = 1.1\text{ m/s}

    Because the denominator was halved, your resulting velocity is twice the correct value.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that average velocity over an interval with constant acceleration equals the instantaneous velocity at the midpoint of that interval.

You accurately calculated the acceleration as 0.80 m/s20.80\text{ m/s}^2.

You selected the correct symmetric surrounding position values x(1.50 s)x(1.50\text{ s}) and x(0.50 s)x(0.50\text{ s}) for the central difference estimation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Central Difference Denominator Error

You wrote Δt\Delta t instead of 2Δt2\Delta t (or ti+1−ti−1t_{i+1} - t_{i-1}) in the denominator of the central difference quotient.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the single step size Δt=ti+1−ti\Delta t = t_{i+1} - t_i with the total time width of the symmetric interval spanning from ti−1t_{i-1} to ti+1t_{i+1}, which equals (t+Δt)−(t−Δt)=2Δt(t + \Delta t) - (t - \Delta t) = 2\Delta t.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Total Elapsed Time in Difference Formulas
  • Average rate of change between two data points is always xb−xatb−ta\frac{x_b - x_a}{t_b - t_a}.

  • Always write the denominator explicitly as ti+1−ti−1t_{i+1} - t_{i-1} before simplifying to ensure the time span matches the numerator positions.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the total elapsed time between the sample times: Δttotal=1.50 s−0.50 s=1.00 s=2Δt\Delta t_{\text{total}} = 1.50\text{ s} - 0.50\text{ s} = 1.00\text{ s} = 2\Delta t.

  2. Substitute into the central difference formula: v(1.00 s)≈x(1.50 s)−x(0.50 s)2Δt=1.55 m−0.45 m1.00 sv(1.00\text{ s}) \approx \frac{x(1.50\text{ s}) - x(0.50\text{ s})}{2\Delta t} = \frac{1.55\text{ m} - 0.45\text{ m}}{1.00\text{ s}}.

  3. Divide to find the estimated velocity: v(1.00 s)=1.10 m1.00 s=1.1 m/sv(1.00\text{ s}) = \frac{1.10\text{ m}}{1.00\text{ s}} = 1.1\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

a=0.80 m/s2a = 0.80\text{ m/s}^2; v(1.00 s)=1.1 m/sv(1.00\text{ s}) = 1.1\text{ m/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between one-sided difference quotients (width Δt\Delta t) and central difference quotients (width 2Δt2\Delta t).

  • Practice checking units and time spans whenever calculating numerical derivatives from discrete experimental data tables.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses forward difference instead of central difference to estimate the instantaneous velocity at t = 1.00 s.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    v1=0.45−0.200.50=0.50 m/s  ⟹  v4=2.40−1.550.50=1.70 m/s  ⟹  a=1.70−0.501.75−0.25=0.80 m/s2v_1 = \frac{0.45 - 0.20}{0.50} = 0.50\text{ m/s} \implies v_4 = \frac{2.40 - 1.55}{0.50} = 1.70\text{ m/s} \implies a = \frac{1.70 - 0.50}{1.75 - 0.25} = 0.80\text{ m/s}^2

  2. Step 2

    v(1.00)≈x(1.50)−x(1.00)1.50−1.00  ⟹  v(1.00)≈1.55−0.900.50=1.30 m/sv(1.00) \approx \frac{x(1.50) - x(1.00)}{1.50 - 1.00} \implies v(1.00) \approx \frac{1.55 - 0.90}{0.50} = 1.30\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    v(1.00)≈x(1.50)−x(0.50)1.50−0.50=1.55−0.451.00=1.1 m/sv(1.00) \approx \frac{x(1.50) - x(0.50)}{1.50 - 0.50} = \frac{1.55 - 0.45}{1.00} = 1.1\text{ m/s}

    You used the forward difference x(t+Δt)−x(t)Δt\frac{x(t+\Delta t) - x(t)}{\Delta t} instead of the central difference x(t+Δt)−x(t−Δt)2Δt\frac{x(t+\Delta t) - x(t-\Delta t)}{2\Delta t}, which estimates the velocity at the interval midpoint t=1.25 st = 1.25\text{ s} rather than at t=1.00 st = 1.00\text{ s}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the average velocity across symmetric sub-intervals.

You correctly identified the corresponding time midpoints to compute the acceleration.

You accurately read values from the experimental data table.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Numerical differentiation difference scheme confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You selected a one-sided forward difference formula instead of a two-sided central difference formula, leading to an estimate centered on t=1.25 st = 1.25\text{ s} instead of t=1.00 st = 1.00\text{ s}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Central Difference Definition
  • v(t)≈x(t+Δt)−x(t−Δt)2Δtv(t) \approx \frac{x(t + \Delta t) - x(t - \Delta t)}{2\Delta t}

  • Always evaluate data points symmetrically one step forward and one step backward from the target time.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the neighboring times one step before and after t=1.00 st = 1.00\text{ s}: t−Δt=0.50 st - \Delta t = 0.50\text{ s} and t+Δt=1.50 st + \Delta t = 1.50\text{ s}.

  2. Read the positions from the table: x(0.50 s)=0.45 mx(0.50\text{ s}) = 0.45\text{ m} and x(1.50 s)=1.55 mx(1.50\text{ s}) = 1.55\text{ m}.

  3. Apply the central difference formula: v(1.00 s)≈1.55 m−0.45 m1.50 s−0.50 s=1.10 m1.00 s=1.1 m/sv(1.00\text{ s}) \approx \frac{1.55\text{ m} - 0.45\text{ m}}{1.50\text{ s} - 0.50\text{ s}} = \frac{1.10\text{ m}}{1.00\text{ s}} = 1.1\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

a=0.80 m/s2a = 0.80\text{ m/s}^2; v(1.00 s)=1.1 m/sv(1.00\text{ s}) = 1.1\text{ m/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice distinguishing between forward, backward, and central finite difference formulas.

  • Verify that your chosen time interval [t1,t2][t_1, t_2] is symmetric around the target time tt so that t1+t22=t\frac{t_1 + t_2}{2} = t.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A runner moves with constant acceleration. Her positions at equal intervals of Δt=1.0 s\Delta t = 1.0\text{ s} are x(0)=0 mx(0) = 0\text{ m}, x(1)=4 mx(1) = 4\text{ m}, and x(2)=11 mx(2) = 11\text{ m}. Determine her acceleration aa and her initial velocity v0v_0 at t=0 st = 0\text{ s}.

Answer

Δx1=4−0=4 m\Delta x_1 = 4 - 0 = 4\text{ m}, Δx2=11−4=7 m\Delta x_2 = 11 - 4 = 7\text{ m}. Second difference: Δ2x=7−4=3 m\Delta^2 x = 7 - 4 = 3\text{ m}. Acceleration: a=Δ2x(Δt)2=3 m(1.0 s)2=3.0 m/s2a = \frac{\Delta^2 x}{(\Delta t)^2} = \frac{3\text{ m}}{(1.0\text{ s})^2} = 3.0\text{ m/s}^2. From x(1)−x(0)=v0(1)+12a(1)2x(1) - x(0) = v_0(1) + \frac{1}{2}a(1)^2: 4=v0+1.5  ⟹  v0=2.5 m/s4 = v_0 + 1.5 \implies v_0 = 2.5\text{ m/s}.

02

A glider on an air track passes positions x(1.0 s)=1.20 mx(1.0\text{ s}) = 1.20\text{ m}, x(2.0 s)=2.60 mx(2.0\text{ s}) = 2.60\text{ m}, and x(3.0 s)=4.40 mx(3.0\text{ s}) = 4.40\text{ m} under constant acceleration. Use central differences to find the instantaneous velocity at t=2.0 st = 2.0\text{ s}, then find the acceleration aa.

Answer

Central difference for velocity: v(2.0 s)≈x(3.0)−x(1.0)2Δt=4.40−1.202(1.0)=1.60 m/sv(2.0\text{ s}) \approx \frac{x(3.0) - x(1.0)}{2\Delta t} = \frac{4.40 - 1.20}{2(1.0)} = 1.60\text{ m/s}. Displacements: Δx1=2.60−1.20=1.40 m\Delta x_1 = 2.60 - 1.20 = 1.40\text{ m}, Δx2=4.40−2.60=1.80 m\Delta x_2 = 4.40 - 2.60 = 1.80\text{ m}. Acceleration: a=Δx2−Δx1(Δt)2=1.80−1.401.02=0.40 m/s2a = \frac{\Delta x_2 - \Delta x_1}{(\Delta t)^2} = \frac{1.80 - 1.40}{1.0^2} = 0.40\text{ m/s}^2.

03

Data for a rolling sphere shows positions x=[0.10,0.35,0.80,1.45] mx = [0.10, 0.35, 0.80, 1.45]\text{ m} at times t=[0.0,0.2,0.4,0.6] st = [0.0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6]\text{ s} respectively. Determine whether the acceleration is constant, and if so, compute both aa and the instantaneous velocity at t=0.4 st = 0.4\text{ s} via central difference.

Answer

First differences: Δx=[0.25,0.45,0.65] m\Delta x = [0.25, 0.45, 0.65]\text{ m}. Second differences: 0.45−0.25=0.20 m0.45 - 0.25 = 0.20\text{ m} and 0.65−0.45=0.20 m0.65 - 0.45 = 0.20\text{ m}. Since Δ2x\Delta^2 x is constant, aa is constant: a=0.20(0.2)2=5.0 m/s2a = \frac{0.20}{(0.2)^2} = 5.0\text{ m/s}^2. Central difference at t=0.4 st = 0.4\text{ s}: v(0.4 s)=x(0.6)−x(0.2)2(0.2)=1.45−0.350.4=2.75 m/sv(0.4\text{ s}) = \frac{x(0.6) - x(0.2)}{2(0.2)} = \frac{1.45 - 0.35}{0.4} = 2.75\text{ m/s}.

Loading workspace…