Resources

A box of mass m=15.0 kgm = 15.0\text{ kg} rests on a horizontal floor where μs=0.400\mu_s = 0.400. A student applies a horizontal pushing force of P=40.0 NP = 40.0\text{ N}. A common student misconception assumes that the static friction force must always equal the maximum threshold μsFN=(0.400)(15.0)(9.80)=58.8 N\mu_s F_N = (0.400)(15.0)(9.80) = 58.8\text{ N}, concluding that a net backward force exists. Resolve this conceptual trap by determining the actual static friction force fsf_s acting on the box and whether the system is in an equilibrium or non-equilibrium state. Then determine the minimum force PslipP_{\text{slip}} needed to initiate non-equilibrium motion. Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2.

Answer and steps

Final answer

fs=40.0 Nf_s = 40.0\text{ N} opposing the push; the box is in static equilibrium with net acceleration a=0 m/s2a = 0\text{ m/s}^2; Pslip=58.8 NP_{\text{slip}} = 58.8\text{ N}

Steps

01

Calculate the Maximum Available Static Friction

First, analyze the vertical forces acting on the box. Since there is no vertical motion, the normal force FNF_N balances gravity:

FN=mg=(15.0 kg)(9.80 m/s2)=147 NF_N = mg = (15.0\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2) = 147\text{ N}

The static friction coefficient μs\mu_s determines the maximum possible static friction fs,max⁡f_{s,\max} before sliding starts:

fs,max⁡=μsFN=(0.400)(147 N)=58.8 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = (0.400)(147\text{ N}) = 58.8\text{ N}


02

Conceptual Pitfall: Static Friction Is a Self-Adjusting Force

A common misconception is treating the static friction formula as an equality: fs=μsFNf_s = \mu_s F_N. In reality, the law of static friction is an inequality:

fs≤μsFNf_s \le \mu_s F_N

Static friction is a responsive force. It matches the applied force in magnitude and opposes it in direction up to its threshold fs,max⁡f_{s,\max}. If static friction were always 58.8 N58.8\text{ N}, pushing the box forward with 40.0 N40.0\text{ N} would create a backward net force of 18.8 N18.8\text{ N}, causing the box to accelerate backward into the pusher—a physical impossibility for a passive resistive force.


03

Determine the Actual Friction Force and System State

Compare the applied horizontal force P=40.0 NP = 40.0\text{ N} with fs,max⁡f_{s,\max}:

P=40.0 N<58.8 NP = 40.0\text{ N} < 58.8\text{ N}

Because the applied force does not exceed the threshold:

  • The actual static friction force adjusts to balance the push exactly: fs=P=40.0 N(opposing the push)f_s = P = 40.0\text{ N}\quad \text{(opposing the push)}
  • The net horizontal force is: ΣFx=P−fs=40.0 N−40.0 N=0 N\Sigma F_x = P - f_s = 40.0\text{ N} - 40.0\text{ N} = 0\text{ N}
  • According to Newton's first law, the system is in static equilibrium with acceleration: a=0 m/s2a = 0\text{ m/s}^2

04

Determine the Force Needed to Initiate Motion

To transition the box from static equilibrium into a non-equilibrium state (where it begins to accelerate and slide), the applied force must overcome the maximum threshold of static friction:

Pslip=fs,max⁡=58.8 NP_{\text{slip}} = f_{s,\max} = 58.8\text{ N}

Any applied force strictly greater than 58.8 N58.8\text{ N} will cause non-zero net acceleration.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes static friction is always equal to its maximum value μ_s F_N, concluding that the actual friction is 58.8 N and the box accelerates backward in a non-equilibrium state.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    FN=mg=15.0×9.80=147 NF_N = mg = 15.0 \times 9.80 = 147\text{ N}

  2. Step 2

    fs=μsFN=0.400×147 N=58.8 Nf_s = \mu_s F_N = 0.400 \times 147\text{ N} = 58.8\text{ N}

    Correct

    fs,max⁡=μsFN=58.8 N  ⟹  fs=P=40.0 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = 58.8\text{ N} \implies f_s = P = 40.0\text{ N}

    The formula μsFN\mu_s F_N gives the maximum possible static friction force, not the actual friction force. Since the applied force P=40.0 NP = 40.0\text{ N} is less than fs,max⁡=58.8 Nf_{s,\max} = 58.8\text{ N}, static friction only opposes with fs=40.0 Nf_s = 40.0\text{ N}.

  3. Step 3

    Fnet=P−fs=40.0 N−58.8 N=−18.8 N  ⟹  F_{\text{net}} = P - f_s = 40.0\text{ N} - 58.8\text{ N} = -18.8\text{ N} \implies The system is in a non-equilibrium state accelerating backward.

    Correct

    ΣFx=P−fs=40.0 N−40.0 N=0 N  ⟹  \Sigma F_x = P - f_s = 40.0\text{ N} - 40.0\text{ N} = 0\text{ N} \implies Static equilibrium with a=0 m/s2a = 0\text{ m/s}^2

    Because static friction matches the applied push, the net horizontal force is zero. Static friction cannot cause an object at rest to accelerate backward.

  4. Step 4

    Pslip=fs=58.8 NP_{\text{slip}} = f_s = 58.8\text{ N}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the normal force FN=147 NF_N = 147\text{ N}.

You correctly evaluated the threshold value 58.8 N58.8\text{ N} needed to cause slipping.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Static friction treated as fixed value

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating static friction as an active fixed force given by fs=μsFNf_s = \mu_s F_N instead of an inequality constraint fs≤μsFNf_s \le \mu_s F_N where the actual force self-adjusts to balance applied forces up to the maximum threshold.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Static Friction as an Inequality
  • Static friction is a responsive, passive force that satisfies 0≤fs≤μsFN0 \le f_s \le \mu_s F_N.

  • Always compute fs,max⁡=μsFNf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N as an upper limit first, then check whether the applied force exceeds this limit.

Equilibrium Condition
  • If the total applied parallel force P≤fs,max⁡P \le f_{s,\max}, the object does not move, so fs=Pf_s = P and a=0 m/s2a = 0\text{ m/s}^2.

  • Set fs=Pf_s = P to maintain equilibrium whenever P≤fs,max⁡P \le f_{s,\max}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the maximum available static friction: fs,max⁡=μsFN=0.400×147 N=58.8 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = 0.400 \times 147\text{ N} = 58.8\text{ N}.

  2. Compare the applied push P=40.0 NP = 40.0\text{ N} to fs,max⁡f_{s,\max}: since 40.0 N≤58.8 N40.0\text{ N} \le 58.8\text{ N}, static friction adjusts to match PP.

  3. Conclude the actual static friction is fs=40.0 Nf_s = 40.0\text{ N} directed opposite to the push.

  4. Determine the state: ΣFx=P−fs=0 N\Sigma F_x = P - f_s = 0\text{ N}, so the box is in static equilibrium with acceleration a=0 m/s2a = 0\text{ m/s}^2.

  5. The minimum threshold force to initiate slipping is Pslip=fs,max⁡=58.8 NP_{\text{slip}} = f_{s,\max} = 58.8\text{ N}.

Final answer

fs=40.0 Nf_s = 40.0\text{ N} opposing the push; the box is in static equilibrium with net acceleration a=0 m/s2a = 0\text{ m/s}^2; Pslip=58.8 NP_{\text{slip}} = 58.8\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When working with static friction, label the quantity μsFN\mu_s F_N as fs,max⁡f_{s,\max} to remind yourself it is an upper bound, not necessarily the active force.

  • Verify that passive friction never creates spontaneous motion or accelerates an object in the direction opposing a small push.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to multiply mass by gravitational acceleration g when finding normal force, setting F_N = m = 15.0 N.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    FN=m=15.0 NF_N = m = 15.0\text{ N}

    Correct

    FN=mg=(15.0 kg)(9.80 m/s2)=147 NF_N = mg = (15.0\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2) = 147\text{ N}

    Normal force balances gravity in the vertical direction, so it must equal weight mgmg, not just mass mm. Setting FN=15.0 NF_N = 15.0\text{ N} misses the gravitational acceleration g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 and conflates kilograms with newtons.

  2. Step 2

    fs,max⁡=μsFN=0.400×15.0 N=6.00 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = 0.400 \times 15.0\text{ N} = 6.00\text{ N}

    Correct

    fs,max⁡=μsFN=(0.400)(147 N)=58.8 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = (0.400)(147\text{ N}) = 58.8\text{ N}

    Your formula for maximum static friction is correct, but evaluating it with FN=15.0 NF_N = 15.0\text{ N} instead of 147 N147\text{ N} produced an incorrect threshold.

  3. Step 3

    Since P=40.0 N>6.00 N, the box slips.  ⟹  fs=6.00 N  ⟹  The system is in a non-equilibrium state.\text{Since } P = 40.0\text{ N} > 6.00\text{ N}, \text{ the box slips.} \implies f_s = 6.00\text{ N} \implies \text{The system is in a non-equilibrium state.}

    Correct

    Since P=40.0 N<58.8 N,fs=P=40.0 N (opposing the push),ΣFx=0 N, so the system is in static equilibrium.\text{Since } P = 40.0\text{ N} < 58.8\text{ N}, f_s = P = 40.0\text{ N} \text{ (opposing the push)}, \Sigma F_x = 0\text{ N}, \text{ so the system is in static equilibrium.}

    Because your calculated fs,max⁡f_{s,\max} was too small, you concluded the box would slip. With the correct threshold of 58.8 N58.8\text{ N}, the applied force of 40.0 N40.0\text{ N} does not exceed the limit, meaning static friction self-adjusts to balance the push at 40.0 N40.0\text{ N} in static equilibrium.

  4. Step 4

    Pslip=fs,max⁡=6.00 NP_{\text{slip}} = f_{s,\max} = 6.00\text{ N}

    Correct

    Pslip=fs,max⁡=58.8 NP_{\text{slip}} = f_{s,\max} = 58.8\text{ N}

    You correctly recognized that the slip threshold requires matching fs,max⁡f_{s,\max}, but the numerical value inherits the initial normal force error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the formula fs,max⁡=μsFNf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N to relate normal force to maximum static friction.

You correctly identified that the threshold force needed to cause slipping equals fs,max⁡f_{s,\max}.

You compared the applied horizontal push to the calculated friction threshold to determine whether motion occurs.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating mass and weight

You wrote FN=m=15.0 NF_N = m = 15.0\text{ N} instead of multiplying mass by gg.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating mass (measured in kilograms) with gravitational force or normal force (measured in newtons). A horizontal surface supporting an object without vertical acceleration provides a normal force equal to the object's weight W=mgW = mg, not its mass mm.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Mass vs. Weight Check
  • FN=mgF_N = mg on a level surface without vertical acceleration.

  • Always multiply mass in kilograms by g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 to find the force of gravity before equating it to the normal force.

Self-Adjusting Static Friction
  • fs≤μsFNf_s \le \mu_s F_N; when P≤fs,max⁡P \le f_{s,\max}, static friction matches the push: fs=Pf_s = P.

  • Check whether the applied force exceeds fs,max⁡f_{s,\max}. If it does not, the actual friction is equal and opposite to the applied force, maintaining equilibrium.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. FN=mg=(15.0 kg)(9.80 m/s2)=147 NF_N = mg = (15.0\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2) = 147\text{ N}

  2. fs,max⁡=μsFN=(0.400)(147 N)=58.8 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = (0.400)(147\text{ N}) = 58.8\text{ N}

  3. Compare PP to fs,max⁡f_{s,\max}: P=40.0 N<58.8 NP = 40.0\text{ N} < 58.8\text{ N}, so static friction matches the push: fs=40.0 Nf_s = 40.0\text{ N} opposing PP

  4. Because ΣFx=P−fs=0 N\Sigma F_x = P - f_s = 0\text{ N}, the system is in static equilibrium with a=0 m/s2a = 0\text{ m/s}^2

  5. The minimum force to initiate non-equilibrium motion is Pslip=fs,max⁡=58.8 NP_{\text{slip}} = f_{s,\max} = 58.8\text{ N}

Final answer

fs=40.0 Nf_s = 40.0\text{ N} opposing the push; the box is in static equilibrium with net acceleration a=0 m/s2a = 0\text{ m/s}^2; Pslip=58.8 NP_{\text{slip}} = 58.8\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When finding contact forces, always draw a vertical free-body diagram and solve ΣFy=0\Sigma F_y = 0 to ensure FN=mgF_N = mg.

  • Verify units at each step: mass is in kg\text{kg} and cannot be directly set equal to a force in N\text{N} without multiplying by an acceleration.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates the net force between the threshold friction and applied force and mistakes this difference for the actual static friction force.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    FN=mg=15.0×9.80=147 N  ⟹  fs,max⁡=μsFN=0.400×147=58.8 NF_N = mg = 15.0 \times 9.80 = 147\text{ N} \implies f_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = 0.400 \times 147 = 58.8\text{ N}

  2. Step 2

    fs=fs,max⁡−P=58.8 N−40.0 N=18.8 Nf_s = f_{s,\max} - P = 58.8\text{ N} - 40.0\text{ N} = 18.8\text{ N}

    Correct

    Since P=40.0 N≤fs,max⁡=58.8 NP = 40.0\text{ N} \le f_{s,\max} = 58.8\text{ N}, fs=P=40.0 Nf_s = P = 40.0\text{ N}

    You calculated the remaining margin before slipping (fs,max⁡−Pf_{s,\max} - P) and labeled it as the friction force. Because the applied push is less than the threshold, static friction self-adjusts to balance the push directly, so fs=40.0 Nf_s = 40.0\text{ N} directed opposite to the push.

  3. Step 3

    The system is in an equilibrium state.

  4. Step 4

    Pslip=fs,max⁡=58.8 NP_{\text{slip}} = f_{s,\max} = 58.8\text{ N}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You calculated the normal force and maximum static friction threshold accurately.

You correctly recognized that the box is in an equilibrium state.

You correctly established that the force required to initiate sliding equals fs,max⁡f_{s,\max}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Static friction self-adjustment vs. friction capacity margin

You subtracted the applied force from the maximum static friction (58.8 N−40.0 N58.8\text{ N} - 40.0\text{ N}) and treated that difference as the friction force.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated static friction as a quantity where the applied force consumes part of the threshold, leaving the remainder as the acting force, instead of applying Newton's first law where static friction is a responsive constraint force that exactly opposes and cancels the applied force until the threshold is exceeded.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Static Friction Inequality
  • Static friction satisfies 0≤fs≤μsFN0 \le f_s \le \mu_s F_N. The formula fs,max⁡=μsFNf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N gives the upper limit, not an automatic value.

  • Check whether the applied force exceeds fs,max⁡f_{s,\max}. If P≤fs,max⁡P \le f_{s,\max}, the object stays at rest and fs=Pf_s = P.

Equilibrium Force Balance
  • For a stationary object in horizontal equilibrium, ΣFx=P−fs=0\Sigma F_x = P - f_s = 0.

  • Set fsf_s equal in magnitude to the applied horizontal force PP rather than subtracting PP from fs,max⁡f_{s,\max}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the applied push P=40.0 NP = 40.0\text{ N} with the threshold fs,max⁡=58.8 Nf_{s,\max} = 58.8\text{ N}.

  2. Since P≤fs,max⁡P \le f_{s,\max}, the box remains stationary, so ΣFx=P−fs=0 N\Sigma F_x = P - f_s = 0\text{ N}.

  3. Solve for the actual static friction: fs=P=40.0 Nf_s = P = 40.0\text{ N} (pointing opposite to the push).

Final answer

fs=40.0 Nf_s = 40.0\text{ N} opposing the push; the box is in static equilibrium with net acceleration a=0 m/s2a = 0\text{ m/s}^2; Pslip=58.8 NP_{\text{slip}} = 58.8\text{ N}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Remember that static friction is self-adjusting: it provides only as much force as needed to maintain balance, up to its maximum ceiling.

  • Practice checking ΣFx=0\Sigma F_x = 0 on stationary objects to find fsf_s directly from force balance rather than using subtraction formulas.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 10.0 kg10.0\text{ kg} crate rests on a horizontal floor with μs=0.500\mu_s = 0.500. You pull horizontally with a force of 30.0 N30.0\text{ N}. Determine the friction force acting on the crate and its acceleration. Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2.

Answer

fs=30.0 Nf_s = 30.0\text{ N} opposing the pull, and a=0 m/s2a = 0\text{ m/s}^2. Key steps: FN=mg=98.0 NF_N = mg = 98.0\text{ N}; fs,max⁡=μsFN=0.500(98.0 N)=49.0 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = 0.500(98.0\text{ N}) = 49.0\text{ N}. Since the applied pull 30.0 N<49.0 N30.0\text{ N} < 49.0\text{ N}, the crate remains in static equilibrium, so fs=30.0 Nf_s = 30.0\text{ N} and ΣF=0 N\Sigma F = 0\text{ N}.

02

A 25.0 kg25.0\text{ kg} block sits on a horizontal surface (μs=0.350\mu_s = 0.350, μk=0.250\mu_k = 0.250). A horizontal force of 70.0 N70.0\text{ N} pushes the block to the right. State whether the block moves, and find the magnitude and direction of the friction force. Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2.

Answer

The block does not move; fs=70.0 Nf_s = 70.0\text{ N} directed to the left. Key steps: FN=(25.0)(9.80)=245 NF_N = (25.0)(9.80) = 245\text{ N}. The maximum static friction is fs,max⁡=0.350×245 N=85.75 Nf_{s,\max} = 0.350 \times 245\text{ N} = 85.75\text{ N}. Since 70.0 N<85.75 N70.0\text{ N} < 85.75\text{ N}, the block stays at rest in static equilibrium, and friction exactly balances the push.

03

A 5.00 kg5.00\text{ kg} box rests on a horizontal surface where μs=0.600\mu_s = 0.600. A person pushes downward and to the right on the box with force components Px=20.0 NP_x = 20.0\text{ N} (horizontal) and Py=15.0 NP_y = 15.0\text{ N} (downward). Determine whether the box slips, the actual friction force, and the acceleration. Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2.

Answer

The box does not slip; fs=20.0 Nf_s = 20.0\text{ N} opposing PxP_x, and a=0 m/s2a = 0\text{ m/s}^2. Key steps: Normal force includes the downward push component: FN=mg+Py=(5.00)(9.80)+15.0=64.0 NF_N = mg + P_y = (5.00)(9.80) + 15.0 = 64.0\text{ N}. Maximum static friction is fs,max⁡=μsFN=0.600(64.0 N)=38.4 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s F_N = 0.600(64.0\text{ N}) = 38.4\text{ N}. Because Px=20.0 N<38.4 NP_x = 20.0\text{ N} < 38.4\text{ N}, static friction matches PxP_x exactly, maintaining equilibrium with a=0 m/s2a = 0\text{ m/s}^2.

Loading workspace…