Resources
A heat engine absorbs heat from a thermal reservoir maintained at constant temperature and discharges heat into a low-temperature sink at during each complete thermodynamic cycle. Rather than finding work output, determine: (a) the thermal efficiency of this engine compared to the theoretical Carnot efficiency between the same reservoirs, (b) the net entropy change of the universe per cycle , and (c) the ratio to demonstrate why net entropy generation characterizes irreversible cyclic operation.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) (), whereas (); (b) ; (c) Because for any complete cycle of a state function, the ratio is undefined (division by zero), confirming entropy generated lies entirely in the surroundings/universe.
Steps
Part (a): Thermal Efficiency vs. Carnot Efficiency
- Calculate the actual thermal efficiency ():
The thermal efficiency of any heat engine is the ratio of net work produced to the heat absorbed from the hot reservoir: Substituting and : -
Calculate the maximum theoretical Carnot efficiency ():
A Carnot engine operating reversibly between reservoirs at absolute temperatures and has an efficiency given by: Substituting and :Because , this engine is irreversible.
Part (b): Net Entropy Change of the Universe Per Cycle
The universe consists of the heat engine and the two thermal reservoirs (surroundings):
- Entropy change of the engine ():
Entropy is a state variable. At the end of every complete thermodynamic cycle, the working substance returns to its initial thermodynamic state: -
Entropy changes of the reservoirs:
Because the reservoirs are sufficiently large to remain at constant temperature, their entropy changes are calculated using reversible heat transfer:- Hot reservoir: Loses heat :
- Cold sink: Gains heat :
-
Total entropy change:
The positive value () confirms that the cycle is irreversible, in accordance with the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
Part (c): The Ratio and Irreversible Cyclic Operation
- Evaluating the proposed ratio gives:
- Physical Significance:
Because division by zero is undefined, this ratio highlights an essential principle: an engine cannot accumulate entropy over a complete cycle. Instead, all entropy generated by internal and external irreversibilities is continuously expelled into the surroundings. Consequently, net entropy generation () manifests entirely in the universe, serving as the definitive signature of irreversible cyclic operation.
Typical errors
01 The student confuses the net entropy change of the engine over a complete cycle with the heat absorbed divided by temperature, treating ΔS_engine as Q_H/T_H instead of recognizing it is zero for a cycle.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
S_H = - = -4 S_C = = +5.6 S_{} = -4 + 5.6 = +1.6_
- Step 3
S_{} = = = 4_
CorrectBecause entropy is a thermodynamic state variable, the working substance returns to its initial state at the end of every complete cycle, meaning rather than .
- Step 4
= = 0.40
CorrectBecause your value for was incorrect, this ratio calculation was affected. Dividing by zero gives an undefined ratio, confirming that an engine cannot accumulate entropy over a cycle and that all generated entropy is expelled into the universe.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the thermal efficiency and Carnot efficiency using the heat and temperature values.
You correctly determined the entropy changes of the hot and cold reservoirs with appropriate signs.
You correctly found the net entropy change of the universe to be .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou evaluated as the entropy entering from the hot reservoir () rather than evaluating the net change of the working substance over a complete thermodynamic cycle. Because entropy is a state variable, any closed cycle satisfies , so for any complete cycle.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- State Variable in a Closed Cycle
For any cyclic process returning to its initial state, the net change of any state function (, , , etc.) is identically zero: .
Always set for the working fluid or engine over one or more full cycles.
- Entropy Generation vs. Accumulation
A cyclic heat engine cannot continuously store or accumulate entropy; all entropy generated by internal or external irreversibilities must be rejected to the surroundings.
Attribute any positive net entropy change entirely to the surrounding reservoirs.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecognize that entropy is a state function: for any closed thermodynamic cycle, .
Substitute and into the required ratio: .
Conclude that the ratio is undefined (division by zero), demonstrating that entropy generation occurs entirely in the universe/surroundings.
(a) (), (); (b) ; (c) Undefined (division by zero, since for a complete cycle)
02 The student misassigns the algebraic signs of entropy change for the thermal reservoirs, treating the hot reservoir as gaining entropy and the cold reservoir as losing entropy.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
You reversed the thermodynamic sign convention for the reservoirs. The hot reservoir releases heat (), so its entropy decreases (). The cold sink absorbs heat (), so its entropy increases ().
- Step 3Correct
Because of the reversed signs in the reservoir entropy changes, your sum resulted in instead of .
- Step 4Correct
, confirming that generated entropy cannot accumulate in the cyclic engine and is entirely transferred to the universe.
You correctly identified that for a complete cycle, making the ratio undefined due to division by zero. However, your conclusion that the process violates the Second Law was caused by the propagated sign error from Step 2.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly calculated the actual thermal efficiency and the theoretical Carnot efficiency .
You correctly stated that entropy is a state function so over a complete thermodynamic cycle.
You recognized that division by zero makes the ratio undefined.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou assigned a positive sign to the entropy change of the hot reservoir and a negative sign to the cold reservoir.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou tracked heat transfer from the perspective of the engine rather than from the perspective of each individual reservoir when computing .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Reservoir Perspective Sign Convention
For any thermal reservoir at temperature , . Heat leaving a reservoir is negative (); heat entering a reservoir is positive ().
Always determine whether heat flows into or out of the reservoir itself before writing .
- Second Law Plausibility Check
For any real (irreversible) engine cycle, the Clausius inequality requires .
If your calculation yields for an engine operating below Carnot efficiency, immediately re-check your sign assignments.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDetermine : Since the hot reservoir expels , its entropy change is .
Determine : Since the cold reservoir absorbs , its entropy change is .
Calculate total universe entropy: .
Evaluate the ratio: , which is undefined, showing entropy generation resides entirely in the surroundings.
(a) (), (); (b) ; (c) (undefined).
03 The student incorrectly assumes the Carnot efficiency formula applies to the real irreversible engine, calculating its thermal efficiency directly from reservoir temperatures.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You applied the theoretical Carnot formula to find the actual efficiency of the engine. For any real or arbitrary engine, thermal efficiency is defined by the actual energy exchanged: .
- Step 2Correct
You calculated the Carnot efficiency correctly as , but your conclusion that was thrown off by the incorrect actual efficiency calculated in Step 1. Because the actual efficiency is , , which proves the engine is irreversible.
- Step 3
- Step 4
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that entropy is a state function and equals zero for a cyclic working fluid.
You calculated the net entropy change of the universe accurately from the thermal reservoir transfers.
You correctly evaluated the theoretical Carnot efficiency using absolute reservoir temperatures.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo slip occurred; you made a conceptual choice to use temperature ratios instead of heat ratios for the actual efficiency.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated the universal definition of actual thermal efficiency (, applicable to all engines) with the Carnot efficiency limit (, applicable only to ideal reversible engines).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Actual Efficiency vs. Maximum Possible Efficiency
For any heat engine, . The formula is strictly reserved for an ideal reversible (Carnot) engine.
Always compute actual efficiency from the given heats and , and use reservoir temperatures and only when computing the Carnot benchmark.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationUse the actual heat quantities absorbed and rejected to determine actual thermal efficiency: .
Compare this actual efficiency to the theoretical Carnot efficiency: .
(a) () compared to (); (b) ; (c) Because over a complete cycle, the ratio is undefined, demonstrating that generated entropy is entirely expelled to the universe.
Lock it in
What is the net change in entropy of the working substance of a heat engine over one complete cycle?
. Entropy is a state function, and the working substance returns to its initial thermodynamic state.
Similar question
A heat engine absorbs from a reservoir at and discharges to a reservoir at in one cycle. Calculate (a) the entropy change of the engine over one complete cycle and (b) the net entropy change of the universe per cycle.
Answer
(a) because entropy is a state variable and the cycle is complete. (b) .
An inventor claims an engine absorbs of heat from a source at , produces of net work, and rejects to a sink at per cycle. Determine whether this cycle is reversible, irreversible, or impossible by evaluating .
Answer
. For the reservoirs: . Since , the cycle is irreversible (and physically possible).
A cyclic heat pump operates between an outdoor environment at and an indoor room at . Over one full cycle, it absorbs from outdoors and delivers to the room. Find the entropy change of the heat pump's refrigerant over one cycle, and the total entropy generated in the universe .
Answer
because the refrigerant undergoes a complete cycle. The entropy generation in the universe is .