Resources

A student sets up a double-slit experiment in air using light of wavelength λ0=600 nm\lambda_0 = 600\text{ nm} and slit separation d=0.200 mmd = 0.200\text{ mm}, observing an adjacent bright-fringe spacing of Δy=4.50 mm\Delta y = 4.50\text{ mm} on a screen at distance LL. The entire apparatus is then submerged in a transparent liquid of refractive index n=1.33n = 1.33. Counter to the student's initial intuition that adding a medium with a higher optical density will cause the fringes to spread farther apart, calculate the new fringe spacing Δy′\Delta y' (in millimeters) in the liquid and state whether the pattern compressed or expanded.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Δy′=3.38 mm\Delta y' = 3.38\text{ mm} (the fringe pattern compresses)

Steps

01

Relate Fringe Spacing to Wavelength

In Young's double-slit experiment, the distance between adjacent bright fringes on a distant screen is given by the small-angle approximation:

Δy=λLd\Delta y = \frac{\lambda L}{d}

where:

  • λ\lambda is the wavelength of light in the surrounding medium,
  • LL is the distance from the slits to the screen,
  • dd is the separation between the two slits.

Initially, in air (where n≈1n \approx 1), the fringe spacing is:

Δy=λ0Ld=4.50 mm\Delta y = \frac{\lambda_0 L}{d} = 4.50\text{ mm}


02

Determine the Wavelength in the Liquid

When light travels from air into a medium with refractive index nn, its frequency ff remains unchanged because the oscillations are driven by the source. However, the speed of light decreases to v=cnv = \frac{c}{n}. Consequently, the wavelength in the liquid, λ′\lambda', shortens according to the wave relation v=fλ′v = f\lambda':

λ′=λ0n\lambda' = \frac{\lambda_0}{n}

For n=1.33n = 1.33:

λ′=600 nm1.33≈451.1 nm\lambda' = \frac{600\text{ nm}}{1.33} \approx 451.1\text{ nm}


03

Calculate the New Fringe Spacing

Because the physical geometry of the apparatus (LL and dd) does not change when submerged, the new fringe spacing Δy′\Delta y' is:

Δy′=λ′Ld=(λ0/n)Ld=1n(λ0Ld)=Δyn\Delta y' = \frac{\lambda' L}{d} = \frac{(\lambda_0 / n) L}{d} = \frac{1}{n} \left(\frac{\lambda_0 L}{d}\right) = \frac{\Delta y}{n}

Substitute the given values:

Δy′=4.50 mm1.33≈3.38 mm\Delta y' = \frac{4.50\text{ mm}}{1.33} \approx 3.38\text{ mm}


04

Qualitative Behavior: Compression vs. Expansion

Because the refractive index of the liquid is greater than that of air (n>1n > 1), the wavelength decreases (λ′<λ0\lambda' < \lambda_0). Since fringe spacing is directly proportional to wavelength (Δy∝λ\Delta y \propto \lambda), the distance between adjacent fringes decreases:

Δy′=3.38 mm<4.50 mm\Delta y' = 3.38\text{ mm} < 4.50\text{ mm}

Therefore, the interference pattern compresses (the fringes move closer together).

Common Pitfall: A higher refractive index means a denser optical medium, which students sometimes intuitively associate with "spreading" or scattering waves. In reality, the wave speed slows down while the frequency remains constant, forcing the wavefronts closer together (smaller wavelength) and reducing the diffraction/interference spread on the screen.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes that wavelength increases in an optically denser medium by multiplying by the index of refraction, leading to an expanded fringe spacing.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    λ′=n⋅λ0\lambda' = n \cdot \lambda_0

    Correct

    λ′=λ0n\lambda' = \frac{\lambda_0}{n}

    Light slows down upon entering an optically denser medium (v=c/nv = c/n) while frequency ff remains constant, which causes the wavelength to shorten to λ′=λ0/n\lambda' = \lambda_0 / n rather than increase.

  2. Step 2

    Δy′=n⋅Δy  ⟹  Δy′=1.33⋅4.50 mm=5.99 mm\Delta y' = n \cdot \Delta y \implies \Delta y' = 1.33 \cdot 4.50\text{ mm} = 5.99\text{ mm}

    Correct

    Δy′=Δyn=4.50 mm1.33≈3.38 mm\Delta y' = \frac{\Delta y}{n} = \frac{4.50\text{ mm}}{1.33} \approx 3.38\text{ mm}

    Because fringe spacing is directly proportional to wavelength (Δy∝λ\Delta y \propto \lambda), dividing λ\lambda by nn requires dividing the fringe spacing by nn.

  3. Step 3

    The fringe pattern expanded.

    Correct

    The fringe pattern compressed.

    Because the new fringe spacing Δy′=3.38 mm\Delta y' = 3.38\text{ mm} is smaller than the original Δy=4.50 mm\Delta y = 4.50\text{ mm}, the fringes move closer together, meaning the pattern compresses.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the change in fringe spacing depends directly on the change in wavelength.

You correctly substituted the numerical values into your chosen formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverse proportionality vs direct multiplication with refractive index

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the index of refraction as an expansion factor rather than a slowing and wave-compressing factor, multiplying λ0\lambda_0 and Δy\Delta y by nn instead of dividing by nn.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Wave speed and wavelength in a medium
  • v=cnv = \frac{c}{n} and v=fλ  ⟹  λ′=λ0nv = f\lambda \implies \lambda' = \frac{\lambda_0}{n}

  • Always remember that in an optically denser medium (n>1n > 1), light slows down while frequency remains constant, so the wavelength must decrease.

Double-slit fringe spacing scaling
  • Δy=λLd\Delta y = \frac{\lambda L}{d}

  • When the surrounding medium changes without altering geometry (LL and dd), scale the fringe spacing inversely with nn: Δy′=Δyn\Delta y' = \frac{\Delta y}{n}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use the wavelength relation for a medium with refractive index nn: λ′=λ0n\lambda' = \frac{\lambda_0}{n}.

  2. Substitute into the fringe-spacing formula: Δy′=λ′Ld=Δyn=4.50 mm1.33≈3.38 mm\Delta y' = \frac{\lambda' L}{d} = \frac{\Delta y}{n} = \frac{4.50\text{ mm}}{1.33} \approx 3.38\text{ mm}.

  3. Compare Δy′\Delta y' with Δy\Delta y: since 3.38 mm<4.50 mm3.38\text{ mm} < 4.50\text{ mm}, the fringe spacing is smaller.

Final answer

Δy′=3.38 mm\Delta y' = 3.38\text{ mm} (the fringe pattern compressed)

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how wave speed v=c/nv = c/n links to wavelength shortening λ′=λ0/n\lambda' = \lambda_0/n via constant frequency.

  • Practice checking whether physical fringe patterns compress or spread out when submerged in liquids of different indices.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misremembers the fringe spacing formula with wavelength in the denominator, concluding that a shorter wavelength causes fringes to spread farther apart.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    λ′=λ0n=600 nm1.33=451.1 nm\lambda' = \frac{\lambda_0}{n} = \frac{600\text{ nm}}{1.33} = 451.1\text{ nm}

  2. Step 2

    Δy=L⋅dλ\Delta y = \frac{L \cdot d}{\lambda}

    Correct

    Δy=λLd\Delta y = \frac{\lambda L}{d}

    In double-slit interference, the path difference between adjacent bright fringes satisfies dsin⁡θ≈dΔyL=λd \sin\theta \approx d \frac{\Delta y}{L} = \lambda, which gives Δy=λLd\Delta y = \frac{\lambda L}{d}. Placing λ\lambda in the denominator inverted the direct proportionality between fringe width and wavelength.

  3. Step 3

    Δy′=Δy⋅n=4.50 mm⋅1.33=5.99 mm\Delta y' = \Delta y \cdot n = 4.50\text{ mm} \cdot 1.33 = 5.99\text{ mm}

    Correct

    Δy′=Δyn=4.50 mm1.33≈3.38 mm\Delta y' = \frac{\Delta y}{n} = \frac{4.50\text{ mm}}{1.33} \approx 3.38\text{ mm}

    Because of the inverted formula in Step 2, you multiplied by the refractive index instead of dividing by it.

  4. Step 4

    The fringe pattern expanded.

    Correct

    The fringe pattern compressed.

    Because your calculated spacing was larger than the initial spacing, you concluded the pattern expanded. With the correct value Δy′=3.38 mm<4.50 mm\Delta y' = 3.38\text{ mm} < 4.50\text{ mm}, the pattern compresses.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the relationship λ′=λ0n\lambda' = \frac{\lambda_0}{n} to find the shortened wavelength in the liquid medium.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted formula

No, this is a conceptual error involving the geometric derivation and proportionality of fringe spacing in wave interference.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You misremembered the Young's double-slit fringe spacing formula by placing the slit separation dd in the numerator and wavelength λ\lambda in the denominator. Remembering that diffraction and interference spreading scale directly with wavelength ("longerwavesbendandspreadmore""longer waves bend and spread more") prevents this inversion.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Derive from path difference
  • Constructive interference requires dsin⁡θ=mλd \sin\theta = m\lambda. For small angles, sin⁡θ≈yL\sin\theta \approx \frac{y}{L}, leading directly to ym=mλLdy_m = \frac{m\lambda L}{d}.

  • Always verify the position of variables by checking that increasing λ\lambda must increase the diffraction and fringe spread.

Dimensional and physical sanity check
  • Fringe spacing Δy\Delta y has units of length (meters). In λLd\frac{\lambda L}{d}, units are m⋅mm=m\frac{\text{m} \cdot \text{m}}{\text{m}} = \text{m}. In Ldλ\frac{L d}{\lambda}, units are also meters, but physically, zero wavelength (ray optics limit) must yield zero fringe separation, not infinite separation.

  • Check the limiting case: as λ→0\lambda \to 0, wave effects vanish, so fringe spacing must approach 00, requiring λ\lambda to be in the numerator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the standard fringe spacing formula: Δy=λLd\Delta y = \frac{\lambda L}{d}.

  2. Relate the submerged spacing to the air spacing: Δy′=λ′Ld=(λ0/n)Ld=Δyn\Delta y' = \frac{\lambda' L}{d} = \frac{(\lambda_0 / n) L}{d} = \frac{\Delta y}{n}.

  3. Substitute the given values: Δy′=4.50 mm1.33≈3.38 mm\Delta y' = \frac{4.50\text{ mm}}{1.33} \approx 3.38\text{ mm}.

  4. Compare spacings: since Δy′=3.38 mm<4.50 mm\Delta y' = 3.38\text{ mm} < 4.50\text{ mm}, the fringes move closer together.

Final answer

Δy′=3.38 mm\Delta y' = 3.38\text{ mm}; the fringe pattern compressed.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Re-derive Δy=λLd\Delta y = \frac{\lambda L}{d} starting from the double-slit geometry to anchor the position of each variable.

  • Practice scaling problems where you determine whether an interference pattern expands or compresses when switching media or changing slit parameters.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student correctly calculates the compressed fringe spacing but misinterprets smaller spacing as an expansion of the fringe pattern.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Δy′=Δyn  ⟹  Δy′=4.50 mm1.33=3.38 mm\Delta y' = \frac{\Delta y}{n} \implies \Delta y' = \frac{4.50\text{ mm}}{1.33} = 3.38\text{ mm}

  2. Step 2

    Because the fringes are closer together, the pattern expanded.

    Correct

    Because the fringe spacing decreased from 4.50 mm4.50\text{ mm} to 3.38 mm3.38\text{ mm}, the fringes are closer together, so the pattern compressed.

    When adjacent fringes move closer together, the overall spacing across the screen shrinks, which corresponds to compression, not expansion.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the wavelength reduction relation λ′=λ0n\lambda' = \frac{\lambda_0}{n} to express the new fringe spacing as Δy′=Δyn\Delta y' = \frac{\Delta y}{n}.

You accurately calculated Δy′=3.38 mm\Delta y' = 3.38\text{ mm}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Qualitative interpretation contradiction

You correctly noted that the fringes are closer together, but wrote that the pattern expanded instead of compressed.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the spatial extent of the interference pattern with fringe count: packing more fringes into a given space makes each fringe interval smaller, which means the physical pattern has compressed or squeezed together.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Fringe Spacing vs. Pattern Size
  • An interference pattern expands when fringe spacing Δy\Delta y increases, and compresses when Δy\Delta y decreases.

  • Check the sign of change: if Δy′<Δy\Delta y' < \Delta y, the pattern shrinks toward the central maximum (compresses).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the initial and final fringe spacings: Δy′=3.38 mm<Δy=4.50 mm\Delta y' = 3.38\text{ mm} < \Delta y = 4.50\text{ mm}.

  2. Because the distance between neighboring bright maxima decreased, the interference fringes cluster closer to the central axis, which means the pattern compressed.

Final answer

Δy′=3.38 mm\Delta y' = 3.38\text{ mm}, compressed

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the physical meaning of pattern compression versus expansion in interference and diffraction.

  • Practice interpreting qualitative changes in fringe spacing when experimental parameters like λ\lambda, dd, LL, or nn vary.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A double-slit experiment uses light of wavelength 540 nm540\text{ nm} in air, producing bright fringes spaced by 3.60 mm3.60\text{ mm}. What is the fringe spacing if the entire setup is submerged in a liquid with index of refraction n=1.50n = 1.50?

Answer

Δy′=Δyn=3.60 mm1.50=2.40 mm\Delta y' = \frac{\Delta y}{n} = \frac{3.60\text{ mm}}{1.50} = 2.40\text{ mm}. The fringe pattern compresses.

02

In a double-slit setup immersed in an unknown oil, the fringe spacing is measured to be 2.50 mm2.50\text{ mm}. When the setup is cleaned and operated in air with the same light source and geometry, the fringe spacing is 4.00 mm4.00\text{ mm}. Determine the refractive index of the oil.

Answer

Since Δyoil=Δyairn\Delta y_{\text{oil}} = \frac{\Delta y_{\text{air}}}{n}, we have n=ΔyairΔyoil=4.00 mm2.50 mm=1.60n = \frac{\Delta y_{\text{air}}}{\Delta y_{\text{oil}}} = \frac{4.00\text{ mm}}{2.50\text{ mm}} = 1.60.

03

A double-slit apparatus submerged in water (n=1.33n = 1.33) produces fringes separated by Δy1=3.00 mm\Delta y_1 = 3.00\text{ mm}. By what factor must the slit separation dd be changed so that the fringe spacing returns to the original air value Δy0\Delta y_0 without removing the apparatus from water?

Answer

To restore Δy=λ0Lnd′=λ0Ld\Delta y = \frac{\lambda_0 L}{n d'} = \frac{\lambda_0 L}{d}, we require nd′=dn d' = d, so d′=dn=d1.33≈0.752dd' = \frac{d}{n} = \frac{d}{1.33} \approx 0.752 d. Thus, the slit separation must be reduced by a factor of 1.331.33 (multiplied by 1/1.33≈0.7521/1.33 \approx 0.752).

Loading workspace…