Resources

Two spherical research probes of masses mA=450 kgm_A = 450\text{ kg} and mB=820 kgm_B = 820\text{ kg} are stationed in deep space. A third micro-probe of mass mC=15.0 kgm_C = 15.0\text{ kg} is placed along the straight line connecting the centers of mAm_A and mBm_B. The distance between the centers of mAm_A and mBm_B is L=120 mL = 120\text{ m}. Find the distance from the center of mass mAm_A at which the net gravitational force acting on probe mCm_C is exactly zero.

Answer and steps

Final answer

d=51.1 md = 51.1\text{ m}

Steps

01

Set Up the Gravitational Force Balance

According to Newton's law of universal gravitation, the magnitude of the gravitational attraction between two point masses (or spherical masses) m1m_1 and m2m_2 separated by a distance rr is:

F=Gm1m2r2F = \frac{G m_1 m_2}{r^2}

Let probe CC be placed at a distance dd from the center of probe AA along the straight line connecting probe AA and probe BB. Since the total distance between probes AA and BB is LL, the distance from probe CC to probe BB is:

rBC=L−dr_{BC} = L - d

For the net gravitational force on mCm_C to be zero, probe CC must lie strictly between AA and BB, where the attractive pull from probe AA (directed toward AA) is equal in magnitude and opposite in direction to the attractive pull from probe BB (directed toward BB):

FAC=FBCF_{AC} = F_{BC}

GmAmCd2=GmBmC(L−d)2\frac{G m_A m_C}{d^2} = \frac{G m_B m_C}{(L - d)^2}


02

Simplify and Solve for dd

Both the gravitational constant GG and the mass of probe CC (mCm_C) cancel out, showing that the position of zero net force is independent of mCm_C:

mAd2=mB(L−d)2\frac{m_A}{d^2} = \frac{m_B}{(L - d)^2}

Because distances dd and L−dL - d must be positive, take the positive square root on both sides:

mAd=mBL−d\frac{\sqrt{m_A}}{d} = \frac{\sqrt{m_B}}{L - d}

Cross-multiply to isolate dd:

mA(L−d)=mBd\sqrt{m_A}(L - d) = \sqrt{m_B} d

LmA−dmA=dmBL\sqrt{m_A} - d\sqrt{m_A} = d\sqrt{m_B}

d(mA+mB)=LmAd\left(\sqrt{m_A} + \sqrt{m_B}\right) = L\sqrt{m_A}

d=mAmA+mBLd = \frac{\sqrt{m_A}}{\sqrt{m_A} + \sqrt{m_B}} L


03

Calculate the Numerical Value

Substitute the given values (mA=450 kgm_A = 450\text{ kg}, mB=820 kgm_B = 820\text{ kg}, and L=120 mL = 120\text{ m}):

mA=450≈21.213 kg1/2\sqrt{m_A} = \sqrt{450} \approx 21.213\text{ kg}^{1/2}

mB=820≈28.636 kg1/2\sqrt{m_B} = \sqrt{820} \approx 28.636\text{ kg}^{1/2}

d=21.21321.213+28.636×120 m=21.21349.849×120 m≈51.1 md = \frac{21.213}{21.213 + 28.636} \times 120\text{ m} = \frac{21.213}{49.849} \times 120\text{ m} \approx 51.1\text{ m}

(Common Pitfall: Do not set the ratio of distances proportional to masses directly as mAmB\frac{m_A}{m_B}; gravitational force depends inversely on the square of distance, so the distance ratio depends on the square root of the masses.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets that the gravitational force obeys an inverse-square law and instead assumes force is inversely proportional to distance.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    FA=FB  ⟹  G∗mA∗mCd=G∗mB∗mC(L−d)F_A = F_B \implies \frac{G * m_A * m_C}{d} = \frac{G * m_B * m_C}{(L - d)}

    Correct

    FA=FB  ⟹  GmAmCd2=GmBmC(L−d)2F_A = F_B \implies \frac{G m_A m_C}{d^2} = \frac{G m_B m_C}{(L - d)^2}

    You set up the force balance condition correctly, but you divided by distance rr instead of r2r^2. Newton's law of universal gravitation states that gravitational force is inversely proportional to the square of the separation distance: F=Gm1m2r2F = \frac{G m_1 m_2}{r^2}.

  2. Step 2

    450d=820120−d  ⟹  450∗(120−d)=820∗d  ⟹  54000−450d=820d  ⟹  1270d=54000\frac{450}{d} = \frac{820}{120 - d} \implies 450 * (120 - d) = 820 * d \implies 54000 - 450d = 820d \implies 1270d = 54000

    Correct

    450d2=820(120−d)2  ⟹  450d=820120−d\frac{450}{d^2} = \frac{820}{(120 - d)^2} \implies \frac{\sqrt{450}}{d} = \frac{\sqrt{820}}{120 - d}

    Your algebraic manipulation was logically sound for the equation you wrote, but it was affected by the missing exponent on the distance terms.

  3. Step 3

    d=42.5 md = 42.5\text{ m}

    Correct

    d≈51.1 md \approx 51.1\text{ m}

    This numerical result is incorrect due to the initial formula error in Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the net force is zero when the two gravitational forces are equal in magnitude and opposite in direction.

You correctly identified the two separation distances as dd and L−dL - d.

You solved your resulting linear algebraic equation accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverse-Square Law Omission

You wrote rr instead of r2r^2 in the denominator of Newton's gravitational force formula.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated gravitational force as inversely proportional to distance (F∝1rF \propto \frac{1}{r}) rather than inversely proportional to the square of distance (F∝1r2F \propto \frac{1}{r^2}). Consequently, the balance condition yielded a linear ratio of masses to distances rather than a square-root dependence.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Newton's Universal Gravitation Formula
  • Fg=Gm1m2r2F_g = \frac{G m_1 m_2}{r^2}

  • Always verify that the separation distance in the denominator is squared whenever you calculate gravitational forces.

Equilibrium Distance Ratio
  • mAd2=mB(L−d)2  ⟹  dL−d=mAmB\frac{m_A}{d^2} = \frac{m_B}{(L - d)^2} \implies \frac{d}{L - d} = \sqrt{\frac{m_A}{m_B}}

  • Take the square root of both sides before cross-multiplying to keep the equation linear in dd.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the correct inverse-square force balance: GmAmCd2=GmBmC(L−d)2\frac{G m_A m_C}{d^2} = \frac{G m_B m_C}{(L - d)^2}.

  2. Cancel common factors GG and mCm_C: 450d2=820(120−d)2\frac{450}{d^2} = \frac{820}{(120 - d)^2}.

  3. Take the positive square root of both sides: 450d=820120−d  ⟹  21.213d≈28.636120−d\frac{\sqrt{450}}{d} = \frac{\sqrt{820}}{120 - d} \implies \frac{21.213}{d} \approx \frac{28.636}{120 - d}.

  4. Cross-multiply and isolate dd: 21.213(120−d)=28.636d  ⟹  2545.6=49.849d21.213(120 - d) = 28.636d \implies 2545.6 = 49.849d.

Final answer

d≈51.1 md \approx 51.1\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the algebraic form of inverse-square laws (such as Newton's gravitation and Coulomb's law).

  • Practice taking the square root of both sides when solving two-body balance problems to avoid solving full quadratic equations.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the positions of the two masses and sets the distance from m_B as d instead of the distance from m_A.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    G⋅mA⋅mC(120−d)2=G⋅mB⋅mCd2  ⟹  450(120−d)2=820d2\frac{G \cdot m_A \cdot m_C}{(120 - d)^2} = \frac{G \cdot m_B \cdot m_C}{d^2} \implies \frac{450}{(120 - d)^2} = \frac{820}{d^2}

    Correct

    GmAmCd2=GmBmC(120−d)2  ⟹  450d2=820(120−d)2\frac{G m_A m_C}{d^2} = \frac{G m_B m_C}{(120 - d)^2} \implies \frac{450}{d^2} = \frac{820}{(120 - d)^2}

    You defined dd as the distance from probe BB and (120−d)(120 - d) as the distance from probe AA. Because the question asked for the distance measured from probe AA, the distance term under mAm_A should be d2d^2 and the distance term under mBm_B should be (120−d)2(120 - d)^2.

  2. Step 2

    450120−d=820d  ⟹  21.21120−d=28.64d\frac{\sqrt{450}}{120 - d} = \frac{\sqrt{820}}{d} \implies \frac{21.21}{120 - d} = \frac{28.64}{d}

    Correct

    450d=820120−d  ⟹  21.21d=28.64120−d\frac{\sqrt{450}}{d} = \frac{\sqrt{820}}{120 - d} \implies \frac{21.21}{d} = \frac{28.64}{120 - d}

    You correctly took the square root of both sides to simplify the quadratic relationship into a linear one, but the terms remained swapped from the previous step.

  3. Step 3

    21.21d=28.64⋅(120−d)  ⟹  21.21d=3436.8−28.64d  ⟹  49.85d=3436.821.21d = 28.64 \cdot (120 - d) \implies 21.21d = 3436.8 - 28.64d \implies 49.85d = 3436.8

    Correct

    28.64d=21.21⋅(120−d)  ⟹  28.64d=2545.2−21.21d  ⟹  49.85d=2545.228.64d = 21.21 \cdot (120 - d) \implies 28.64d = 2545.2 - 21.21d \implies 49.85d = 2545.2

    You executed the cross-multiplication and linear algebra correctly based on your equation.

  4. Step 4

    d=68.9 md = 68.9\text{ m}

    Correct

    d=51.1 md = 51.1\text{ m}

    Your calculated value of 68.9 m68.9\text{ m} is the distance from probe BB. Subtracting this from the total separation gives the distance from probe AA: 120 m−68.9 m=51.1 m120\text{ m} - 68.9\text{ m} = 51.1\text{ m}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the net force is zero where the two gravitational attraction forces balance: FAC=FBCF_{AC} = F_{BC}.

You correctly canceled the common factors GG and mCm_C.

You correctly applied the square root trick to avoid expanding a quadratic equation.

You solved the resulting linear equation with accurate arithmetic.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
swapped reference position

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You swapped which distance variable belonged to which mass, placing dd beneath mBm_B and (L−d)(L - d) beneath mAm_A. Since gravitational force decreases with distance squared, the zero-force point must always be closer to the smaller mass (mA=450 kgm_A = 450\text{ kg} is lighter than mB=820 kgm_B = 820\text{ kg}, so dA<60 md_A < 60\text{ m}). A quick physical sanity check reveals that 68.9 m68.9\text{ m} is closer to the heavier mass, signaling that the references were inverted.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Anchor your reference frame
  • Assign dd directly to the distance from the object specified in the question before writing the equation.

  • Draw a labeled line diagram showing AA at 00, probe CC at dd, and probe BB at LL, then write rA=dr_A = d and rB=L−dr_B = L - d directly beneath their respective masses.

Check proximity against mass magnitude
  • For two attractive inverse-square forces to balance, the equilibrium point must always lie closer to the smaller source mass.

  • Compare mAm_A and mBm_B: because mA<mBm_A < m_B, your final distance from AA must satisfy d<L2=60 md < \frac{L}{2} = 60\text{ m}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. GmAmCd2=GmBmC(120−d)2\frac{G m_A m_C}{d^2} = \frac{G m_B m_C}{(120 - d)^2}

  2. 450d2=820(120−d)2\frac{450}{d^2} = \frac{820}{(120 - d)^2}

  3. 21.21d=28.64120−d\frac{21.21}{d} = \frac{28.64}{120 - d}

  4. 28.64d=21.21(120−d)28.64d = 21.21(120 - d)

  5. 49.85d=2545.249.85d = 2545.2

Final answer

d=51.1 md = 51.1\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always sketch a one-dimensional coordinate axis and label each separation distance explicitly before setting up Newton's law.

  • Perform a physical reasonability check at the end: confirm that the neutral gravity point lies closer to the smaller mass.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student equates the ratio of the squared distances directly to the masses without taking the square root before solving for d.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    G⋅mA⋅mCd2=G⋅mB⋅mC(L−d)2  ⟹  (120−d)2d2=820450G \cdot \frac{m_A \cdot m_C}{d^2} = G \cdot \frac{m_B \cdot m_C}{(L-d)^2} \implies \frac{(120-d)^2}{d^2} = \frac{820}{450}

  2. Step 2

    120−dd=1.82\frac{120-d}{d} = 1.82

    Correct

    120−dd=820450≈1.350\frac{120-d}{d} = \sqrt{\frac{820}{450}} \approx 1.350

    You removed the square on the left side but evaluated 820450≈1.82\frac{820}{450} \approx 1.82 directly without taking its square root. You must take the square root of both sides: 820450=1.822≈1.350\sqrt{\frac{820}{450}} = \sqrt{1.822} \approx 1.350.

  3. Step 3

    120−d=1.82d  ⟹  2.82d=120120 - d = 1.82d \implies 2.82d = 120

    Correct

    120−d=1.350d  ⟹  2.350d=120120 - d = 1.350d \implies 2.350d = 120

    Your algebraic rearrangement was logically consistent with your previous step, but the coefficient was carried over from the missed square root.

  4. Step 4

    d=42.6 md = 42.6\text{ m}

    Correct

    d=51.1 md = 51.1\text{ m}

    Your final numerical answer is incorrect due to the propagated calculation error from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the net gravitational force is zero where the magnitudes of the forces from probes AA and BB are equal.

You accurately identified that the mass of probe CC and the universal gravitational constant GG cancel out.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Missed Square Root on Right-Hand Side

You computed the quotient 820450≈1.82\frac{820}{450} \approx 1.82 and equated it to 120−dd\frac{120-d}{d} without taking the square root of that quotient.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Applying an operation (taking the square root) to only one side of an equation when eliminating exponents.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Maintain Equality Across Both Sides
  • Whenever you take the square root of an equation (xy)2=C\left(\frac{x}{y}\right)^2 = C, both sides must be rooted: xy=C\frac{x}{y} = \sqrt{C}.

  • Circle both sides before simplifying, and write the radical explicitly as mBmA\sqrt{\frac{m_B}{m_A}} before converting to decimals.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Take the principal square root of both sides: 120−dd=8245≈1.3499\frac{120-d}{d} = \sqrt{\frac{82}{45}} \approx 1.3499

  2. Cross-multiply: 120−d=1.3499d120 - d = 1.3499d

  3. Combine like terms: 2.3499d=1202.3499d = 120

  4. Divide to find dd: d=1202.3499≈51.1 md = \frac{120}{2.3499} \approx 51.1\text{ m}

Final answer

d=51.1 md = 51.1\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice solving ratio-of-squares equations by explicitly writing …\sqrt{\dots} over both sides.

  • Perform a sanity check: since mB>mAm_B > m_A, the neutral point must be closer to mAm_A (d<60 md < 60\text{ m}), but since 820/450≈1.35\sqrt{820/450} \approx 1.35 is much smaller than 1.821.82, dd should be just under half the total distance, around 51 m51\text{ m} rather than 42 m42\text{ m}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Two asteroids of masses m1=100 kgm_1 = 100\text{ kg} and m2=400 kgm_2 = 400\text{ kg} are separated by a center-to-center distance of 90 m90\text{ m}. At what distance from m1m_1 along the line connecting their centers is the net gravitational force on a small space probe equal to zero?

Answer

d=30 md = 30\text{ m}. Key steps: Balance the gravitational forces Gm1m(d)2=Gm2m(90−d)2\frac{G m_1 m}{(d)^2} = \frac{G m_2 m}{(90 - d)^2}, simplify to 100d2=400(90−d)2\frac{100}{d^2} = \frac{400}{(90 - d)^2}, take the square root of both sides to get 10d=2090−d\frac{10}{d} = \frac{20}{90 - d}, which yields 2d=90−d  ⟹  3d=90  ⟹  d=30 m2d = 90 - d \implies 3d = 90 \implies d = 30\text{ m}.

02

A planet of mass MM and its moon of mass 0.04M0.04M are separated by center-to-center distance DD. Find the distance from the center of the planet to the point between them where a spacecraft experiences zero net gravitational pull.

Answer

d=56D≈0.833Dd = \frac{5}{6}D \approx 0.833D. Key steps: Set GMmd2=G(0.04M)m(D−d)2\frac{G M m}{d^2} = \frac{G (0.04M) m}{(D - d)^2}, cancel common factors to get 1d2=0.04(D−d)2\frac{1}{d^2} = \frac{0.04}{(D - d)^2}, take the square root to find 1d=0.2D−d\frac{1}{d} = \frac{0.2}{D - d}, and solve D−d=0.2d  ⟹  1.2d=D  ⟹  d=D1.2=56DD - d = 0.2d \implies 1.2d = D \implies d = \frac{D}{1.2} = \frac{5}{6}D.

03

Two fixed stars of masses M1=2.0×1030 kgM_1 = 2.0 \times 10^{30}\text{ kg} and M2=8.0×1030 kgM_2 = 8.0 \times 10^{30}\text{ kg} are separated by 6.0×108 m6.0 \times 10^8\text{ m}. An interstellar comet is located along the line joining them at a point where the gravitational attraction from M2M_2 is four times stronger than from M1M_1. Determine the distance from M1M_1 to the comet if the comet lies between the two stars.

Answer

d=3.0×108 md = 3.0 \times 10^8\text{ m}. Key steps: The condition is F2=4F1F_2 = 4 F_1, so GM2m(L−d)2=4GM1md2\frac{G M_2 m}{(L - d)^2} = 4 \frac{G M_1 m}{d^2}. Substitute masses: 8.0×1030(L−d)2=4(2.0×1030)d2  ⟹  8(L−d)2=8d2\frac{8.0 \times 10^{30}}{(L - d)^2} = \frac{4(2.0 \times 10^{30})}{d^2} \implies \frac{8}{(L - d)^2} = \frac{8}{d^2}. Therefore (L−d)2=d2  ⟹  L−d=d  ⟹  2d=L  ⟹  d=6.0×108 m2=3.0×108 m(L - d)^2 = d^2 \implies L - d = d \implies 2d = L \implies d = \frac{6.0 \times 10^8\text{ m}}{2} = 3.0 \times 10^8\text{ m}.

Loading workspace…