Resources

An electric circuit connected to a vacuum photocell uses an adjustable direct-current power supply to establish a potential difference Vanode−VcathodeV_{\text{anode}} - V_{\text{cathode}} between the collector anode and the photoemissive cathode (work function Φ=2.10 eV\Phi = 2.10\text{ eV}). Monochromatic light with photon energy E=3.60 eVE = 3.60\text{ eV} continuously illuminates the cathode. (a) By applying the standard work-energy theorem Wext=ΔKW_{\text{ext}} = \Delta K and preserving electrostatic sign conventions, determine the exact electric potential Vext=Vanode−VcathodeV_{\text{ext}} = V_{\text{anode}} - V_{\text{cathode}} in volts needed to establish the stopping threshold. (b) Identify the common sign trap: explain whether the collector anode must be held at a positive or negative electric potential relative to the cathode to extinguish the photocurrent.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Vext=−1.50 VV_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ V}; (b) The anode must be held at a negative potential relative to the cathode (−1.50 V-1.50\text{ V}) so that the electrostatic force on negative electrons opposes their forward velocity, performing negative work W=qΔV=(−e)(−V0)=−Kmax⁡W = q\Delta V = (-e)(-V_0) = -K_{\max} to decelerate them to rest.

Steps

Part (a): Determining the Stopping Potential Difference

  1. Calculate the Maximum Kinetic Energy (Kmax⁡K_{\max}) of Emitted Photoelectrons According to Einstein's photoelectric equation, when a photon of energy EE strikes the cathode, the maximum kinetic energy with which an electron can be ejected is: Kmax⁡=E−ΦK_{\max} = E - \Phi Substituting the given values: Kmax⁡=3.60 eV−2.10 eV=1.50 eVK_{\max} = 3.60\text{ eV} - 2.10\text{ eV} = 1.50\text{ eV}
  2. Apply the Work-Energy Theorem Consider an electron (charge q=−eq = -e, where e=1.602×10−19 Ce = 1.602 \times 10^{-19}\text{ C}) emitted with kinetic energy Ki=Kmax⁡K_i = K_{\max} traveling toward the anode. At the stopping threshold, this most energetic electron is brought to rest just as it reaches the anode, so Kf=0K_f = 0.

    The change in kinetic energy is: ΔK=Kf−Ki=0−1.50 eV=−1.50 eV\Delta K = K_f - K_i = 0 - 1.50\text{ eV} = -1.50\text{ eV}

    By the work-energy theorem, the work done on the electron by the retarding electric field must equal this change in kinetic energy: W=ΔK=−1.50 eVW = \Delta K = -1.50\text{ eV}

  3. Relate Electric Work to Potential Difference The work done by a conservative electric field on a charge qq moving through a potential difference ΔV=Vanode−Vcathode=Vext\Delta V = V_{\text{anode}} - V_{\text{cathode}} = V_{\text{ext}} is: W=−qΔV=−(−e)Vext=eVextW = -q \Delta V = -(-e) V_{\text{ext}} = e V_{\text{ext}} Setting WW equal to ΔK\Delta K: eVext=−1.50 eVe V_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ eV} Dividing both sides by the elementary charge ee: Vext=−1.50 VV_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ V}

Part (b): Common Sign Trap and Electrostatic Direction

  • Pitfall to Avoid: The term stopping potential is often quoted as a positive magnitude (V0=1.50 VV_0 = 1.50\text{ V}), which leads to the mistaken belief that the collector anode is maintained at a positive voltage.
  • Physical Reality: Electrons carry negative charge. If the anode were at a positive potential (Vanode>VcathodeV_{\text{anode}} > V_{\text{cathode}}), the electric field would accelerate electrons toward the anode, increasing the photocurrent.

    To extinguish the photocurrent, the anode must be at a negative potential relative to the cathode: Vext=Vanode−Vcathode=−1.50 VV_{\text{ext}} = V_{\text{anode}} - V_{\text{cathode}} = -1.50\text{ V} In this configuration, the electric field points from cathode to anode, exerting an electrostatic force F⃗=qE⃗=−eE⃗\vec{F} = q\vec{E} = -e\vec{E} directed back toward the cathode. This opposing force performs negative work on the forward-moving electrons, decelerating even the fastest electrons to zero speed before they reach the collector.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats stopping potential as an inherently positive scalar potential difference rather than preserving the signed electrostatic potential difference V_anode - V_cathode, yielding +1.50 V.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Kmax⁡=E−Φ=3.60 eV−2.10 eV=1.50 eVK_{\max} = E - \Phi = 3.60\text{ eV} - 2.10\text{ eV} = 1.50\text{ eV}

  2. Step 2

    e⋅Vext=Kmax⁡=1.50 eV  ⟹  Vext=1.50 Ve \cdot V_{\text{ext}} = K_{\max} = 1.50\text{ eV} \implies V_{\text{ext}} = 1.50\text{ V}

    Correct

    Wext=ΔK  ⟹  qVext=0−Kmax⁡  ⟹  (−e)Vext=−1.50 eV  ⟹  Vext=−1.50 VW_{\text{ext}} = \Delta K \implies q V_{\text{ext}} = 0 - K_{\max} \implies (-e) V_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ eV} \implies V_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ V}

    You treated the stopping potential as an unsigned magnitude. Because the electron has negative charge (q=−eq = -e) and decelerates from Ki=1.50 eVK_i = 1.50\text{ eV} to Kf=0K_f = 0, the work-energy theorem gives (−e)Vext=−1.50 eV(-e)V_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ eV}, which yields Vext=−1.50 VV_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ V}.

  3. Step 3

    The anode must be held at a negative electric potential relative to the cathode. A negative potential is required to create a retarding electric field that pushes back the emitted electrons.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used Einstein's photoelectric equation to find the maximum kinetic energy of the photoelectrons.

You correctly explained the qualitative physics in Part (b), recognizing that the anode must be negative relative to the cathode to retard electrons.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign convention omission in electric potential difference

You equated e⋅Vext=Kmax⁡e \cdot V_{\text{ext}} = K_{\max} as positive magnitudes instead of tracking the algebraic signs of charge q=−eq = -e and ΔK=−Kmax⁡\Delta K = -K_{\max}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the stopping potential as a scalar magnitude rather than a signed electrostatic potential difference Vext=Vanode−VcathodeV_{\text{ext}} = V_{\text{anode}} - V_{\text{cathode}}, creating an algebraic discrepancy with your correct conceptual answer in Part (b).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Work-Energy Theorem with Electrostatic Signs
  • W=qΔV=ΔK=Kf−KiW = q \Delta V = \Delta K = K_f - K_i

  • Always substitute q=−eq = -e for electrons and ΔK=0−Kmax⁡=−Kmax⁡\Delta K = 0 - K_{\max} = -K_{\max} when calculating stopping potential differences.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the work-energy relation: W=ΔK=Kf−Ki=0−1.50 eV=−1.50 eVW = \Delta K = K_f - K_i = 0 - 1.50\text{ eV} = -1.50\text{ eV}.

  2. Express the electrostatic work on the electron: W=qΔV=(−e)VextW = q \Delta V = (-e) V_{\text{ext}}.

  3. Equate work to kinetic energy change: (−e)Vext=−1.50 eV(-e) V_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ eV}.

  4. Solve for the potential difference: Vext=−1.50 eV−e=−1.50 VV_{\text{ext}} = \frac{-1.50\text{ eV}}{-e} = -1.50\text{ V}.

Final answer

Vext=−1.50 VV_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ V}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between stopping potential magnitude V0V_0 (always positive, 1.50 V1.50\text{ V}) and stopping potential difference Vanode−VcathodeV_{\text{anode}} - V_{\text{cathode}} (signed, −1.50 V-1.50\text{ V}).

  • Practice writing out the signs of qq and ΔK\Delta K explicitly whenever applying W=qΔV=ΔKW = q \Delta V = \Delta K.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the sign of electron charge or the direction of the electrostatic force, concluding that a positive anode potential is required to stop the photocurrent.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Kmax⁡=E−Φ=3.60 eV−2.10 eV=1.50 eVK_{\max} = E - \Phi = 3.60\text{ eV} - 2.10\text{ eV} = 1.50\text{ eV}

  2. Step 2

    Wext=q∗Vext=ΔK=−1.50 eV  ⟹  With q=e, Vext=−1.50 V/1=−1.50 VW_{\text{ext}} = q * V_{\text{ext}} = \Delta K = -1.50\text{ eV} \implies \text{With } q = e,\, V_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ V}/1 = -1.50\text{ V}

    Correct

    W=−qΔV=−(−e)Vext=eVext=ΔK=−1.50 eV  ⟹  Vext=−1.50 VW = -q\Delta V = -(-e)V_{\text{ext}} = e V_{\text{ext}} = \Delta K = -1.50\text{ eV} \implies V_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ V}

    While your final numerical voltage is correct, electrons carry negative charge (q=−eq = -e). The electrostatic work done by the electric field on a charge moving across a potential difference is W=−qΔV=−(−e)Vext=eVextW = -q\Delta V = -(-e)V_{\text{ext}} = eV_{\text{ext}}. Setting W=ΔK=−1.50 eVW = \Delta K = -1.50\text{ eV} yields Vext=−1.50 VV_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ V}.

  3. Step 3

    The anode must be held at a positive potential relative to the cathode. A positive potential attracts electrons to collect them and quickly exhaust the current.

    Correct

    The anode must be held at a negative potential relative to the cathode (Vext=−1.50 VV_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ V}). A negative anode repels negative electrons, doing negative work to decelerate them to rest before they reach the collector.

    Extinguishing or stopping the photocurrent means reducing the current to zero, not collecting electrons quickly. Because electrons are negatively charged, a positive anode attracts them and increases the current, whereas a negative anode repels them and brings them to rest.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You calculated the maximum kinetic energy of the emitted photoelectrons accurately using the photoelectric effect formula.

You recognized that bringing the fastest photoelectrons to rest corresponds to a kinetic energy change of ΔK=−1.50 eV\Delta K = -1.50\text{ eV}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Electrostatic sign convention and retarding potential concept

You initially wrote 'negative' for the anode potential, which was correct, but then crossed it out in favor of 'positive'.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated extinguishing a photocurrent (retarding and stopping emitted electrons from reaching the anode) with collecting charge carriers, and you treated the electron charge as positive q=eq = e in the work-energy relation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Electron Charge Sign
  • An electron carries negative elementary charge: q=−e=−1.602×10−19 Cq = -e = -1.602 \times 10^{-19}\text{ C}.

  • Always explicitly write q=−eq = -e when setting up electrostatic work equations for electrons.

Retarding Potential Condition
  • To decelerate a moving negative charge, the electric force must oppose its velocity, requiring an electric field pointing in the direction of motion (Vanode<VcathodeV_{\text{anode}} < V_{\text{cathode}}).

  • Verify that the collector anode is at a lower (negative) potential than the emitter cathode so that F⃗=−eE⃗\vec{F} = -e\vec{E} pushes electrons backward.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the work-energy theorem: Wfield=ΔK=Kf−Ki=0−1.50 eV=−1.50 eVW_{\text{field}} = \Delta K = K_f - K_i = 0 - 1.50\text{ eV} = -1.50\text{ eV}.

  2. Express the work done by the electric field on an electron: Wfield=−qΔV=−(−e)(Vanode−Vcathode)=eVextW_{\text{field}} = -q \Delta V = -(-e)(V_{\text{anode}} - V_{\text{cathode}}) = e V_{\text{ext}}.

  3. Equate work to kinetic energy change: eVext=−1.50 eV  ⟹  Vext=−1.50 Ve V_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ eV} \implies V_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ V}.

  4. Interpret the physical meaning: because Vanode−Vcathode<0V_{\text{anode}} - V_{\text{cathode}} < 0, the anode is held at a negative potential relative to the cathode, creating a retarding force that stops the electrons.

Final answer

(a) Vext=−1.50 VV_{\text{ext}} = -1.50\text{ V}; (b) The collector anode must be held at a negative potential relative to the cathode so that the electrostatic force opposes electron motion and reduces the photocurrent to zero.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice distinguishing between the work done BY the electric field (W=−qΔVW = -q\Delta V) and the external agent work (Wext=qΔVW_{\text{ext}} = q\Delta V).

  • Review how electrostatic forces act on negative charges compared to positive charges in uniform electric fields.

  • Solve stopping potential problems by drawing a quick schematic showing the direction of E⃗\vec{E} and F⃗=qE⃗\vec{F} = q\vec{E}.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A photocathode with work function Φ=2.30 eV\Phi = 2.30\text{ eV} is illuminated by light with photon energy 4.80 eV4.80\text{ eV}. Calculate the exact potential difference Vcollector−VemitterV_{\text{collector}} - V_{\text{emitter}} required to stop all photoelectrons.

Answer

Vcollector−Vemitter=−2.50 VV_{\text{collector}} - V_{\text{emitter}} = -2.50\text{ V}. First find Kmax⁡=E−Φ=4.80 eV−2.30 eV=2.50 eVK_{\max} = E - \Phi = 4.80\text{ eV} - 2.30\text{ eV} = 2.50\text{ eV}. Applying qΔV=ΔKq \Delta V = \Delta K gives (−e)(Vcollector−Vemitter)=0−2.50 eV=−2.50 eV(-e)(V_{\text{collector}} - V_{\text{emitter}}) = 0 - 2.50\text{ eV} = -2.50\text{ eV}, so ΔV=−2.50 V\Delta V = -2.50\text{ V}.

02

In a photoelectric experiment, photoelectrons are ejected with maximum speed vmax⁡=6.00×105 m/sv_{\max} = 6.00 \times 10^5\text{ m/s}. Find: (a) Kmax⁡K_{\max} in electron-volts, and (b) the collector potential relative to the cathode Vext=Vanode−VcathodeV_{\text{ext}} = V_{\text{anode}} - V_{\text{cathode}} needed to extinguish the current. (Take me=9.11×10−31 kgm_e = 9.11 \times 10^{-31}\text{ kg} and e=1.602×10−19 Ce = 1.602 \times 10^{-19}\text{ C}.)

Answer

(a) Kmax⁡=12mevmax⁡2=12(9.11×10−31 kg)(6.00×105 m/s)2=1.64×10−19 J=1.02 eVK_{\max} = \frac{1}{2} m_e v_{\max}^2 = \frac{1}{2}(9.11 \times 10^{-31}\text{ kg})(6.00 \times 10^5\text{ m/s})^2 = 1.64 \times 10^{-19}\text{ J} = 1.02\text{ eV}. (b) Using (−e)Vext=−Kmax⁡(-e) V_{\text{ext}} = -K_{\max}, we find Vext=−1.02 VV_{\text{ext}} = -1.02\text{ V}.

03

An alpha particle (q=+2eq = +2e) is emitted from a metal plate with kinetic energy K=5.0 eVK = 5.0\text{ eV} toward an opposing plate. Using W=qΔV=ΔKW = q \Delta V = \Delta K, determine the potential difference ΔV=Vopposing−Vemitter\Delta V = V_{\text{opposing}} - V_{\text{emitter}} needed to bring the alpha particle to rest.

Answer

ΔV=+2.5 V\Delta V = +2.5\text{ V}. For the alpha particle, q=+2eq = +2e and ΔK=0−5.0 eV=−5.0 eV\Delta K = 0 - 5.0\text{ eV} = -5.0\text{ eV}. Applying W=qΔV=ΔKW = q \Delta V = \Delta K gives (+2e)ΔV=−5.0 eV(+2e)\Delta V = -5.0\text{ eV}, so ΔV=−5.0/2 V=−2.5 V\Delta V = -5.0/2\text{ V} = -2.5\text{ V} would accelerate it; to decelerate a positive particle, the opposing plate must be at higher potential: (+2e)(Vopposing−Vemitter)=−5.0 eV(+2e)(V_{\text{opposing}} - V_{\text{emitter}}) = -5.0\text{ eV} yields ΔV=+2.5 V\Delta V = +2.5\text{ V} because work must be negative (W=−5.0 eVW = -5.0\text{ eV}, so qΔV=−5.0 eV  ⟹  (2e)ΔV=−5.0 eVq\Delta V = -5.0\text{ eV} \implies (2e)\Delta V = -5.0\text{ eV}, giving ΔV=+2.5 V\Delta V = +2.5\text{ V} with electric force opposing forward motion).

Loading workspace…