Resources
Consider a conical pendulum consisting of a small bob of mass suspended from a cord of fixed length . As the angular velocity of rotation increases, the angle between the cord and the vertical approaches (the cord approaching a purely horizontal plane). (a) Derive an expression for the required angular velocity as a function of the angle , string length , and gravitational acceleration . (b) Using this expression, evaluate and describe the asymptotic behavior of the cord tension as , explaining the physical reason why a strictly horizontal rotation cannot be sustained in a uniform gravitational field.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) and . A strictly horizontal orientation () requires an infinite tension and infinite angular velocity because the cord's vertical tension component must balance the downward gravitational force , which is mathematically impossible if for any finite tension.
Steps
Part (a): Deriving the Angular Velocity
-
Identify the Geometry and Forces:
- The bob moves in a horizontal circle of radius , where is the angle between the cord of length and the downward vertical axis.
- Two forces act on the bob:
- The tension directed along the cord toward the suspension point.
- The gravitational force directed vertically downward.
-
Apply Newton's Second Law:
- Vertical Direction (-axis): Since the bob moves in a horizontal plane, there is no vertical acceleration (). Solving for tension :
- Horizontal Direction (-axis): The horizontal component of tension provides the necessary centripetal force directed toward the center of the circular path: Substitute :
-
Solve for :
- Assuming (so ), divide both sides by :
- Substitute :
- Divide by and take the square root:
Part (b): Asymptotic Behavior as
-
Evaluate the Limits:
- As , .
- For angular velocity:
- For tension:
-
Physical Explanation:
- In a uniform downward gravitational field, the bob experiences a constant downward force .
- The only upward force capable of supporting the weight of the bob is the vertical component of the cord tension, .
- If the cord were strictly horizontal (), the angle gives , meaning the vertical component of tension would be zero () for any finite tension .
- Consequently, the downward gravitational force cannot be balanced, making horizontal rotation impossible with finite tension and finite rotational speed.
Typical errors
01 The student misidentifies the horizontal and vertical trigonometric components of tension with respect to the vertical angle θ, leading to an incorrect angular velocity formula.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You recognized that the vertical component of tension balances the downward gravitational force . However, because is measured from the vertical axis, the vertical side is adjacent to , meaning the vertical component is , not .
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
Your algebraic manipulation and substitution were logically consistent, but the centripetal equation inherited the swapped trigonometric component ( is the horizontal component providing centripetal force, while is vertical).
- Step 4Correct
Your limit evaluation followed correctly from your derived formula, but because the formula had in the numerator rather than the denominator, it yielded instead of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the bob moves with zero vertical acceleration, requiring vertical forces to balance.
You accurately identified the horizontal radius of the circular orbit as .
You correctly related the net horizontal force to centripetal acceleration using .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeSwapping sine and cosine when resolving the tension vector along the vertical and radial directions.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou associated the vertical component with and the horizontal component with by default (as is customary when an angle is measured from the horizontal), rather than referencing the specific geometry where is defined with respect to the vertical axis.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Reference Axis for Angle
If an angle is measured from the vertical, the adjacent side is vertical () and the opposite side is horizontal ().
Always sketch a right triangle with the force vector as the hypotenuse, locate explicitly, and label adjacent vs. opposite before writing force equations.
- Sanity Check Extreme Angles
As (hanging almost straight down), the cord must support the full weight (), and spinning faster should lift the bob higher (increasing ).
Check whether your formula gives a larger for a larger ; if higher speeds yield smaller angles, the trigonometric terms are likely inverted.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationResolve tension components with respect to the vertical angle : and .
Set up vertical equilibrium: .
Set up the horizontal radial equation: .
Divide both sides by : .
Substitute : .
Evaluate the limits as : since , both and .
(a) ; (b) and . A horizontal rotation requires infinite tension and angular velocity because must balance , which is impossible when for any finite tension.
02 The student uses the total string length L instead of the circular orbital radius r = L sin θ in the centripetal force equation, resulting in an erroneous factor of sin θ.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Vertical equilibrium:
- Step 2Correct
The radius of the horizontal circular path is , not the total cord length . Because , the term cancels on both sides of .
- Step 3
As , , so . . A strictly horizontal rotation cannot be sustained because it requires infinite angular velocity and infinite tension to pull the cord fully horizontal against gravity.
Correctand . A horizontal orientation requires , so no finite tension can balance the downward force .
Your physical reasoning and limit values are correct, but your evaluation of relied on the erroneous expression from step 2 rather than .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly resolved the vertical component of the cord tension and set it equal to the downward weight .
You correctly recognized that the cord tension diverges to infinity as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou substituted the string length directly for the radius of rotation instead of projecting onto the horizontal plane.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the total length of a tether with the radius of the circular orbit in conical or 3D circular motion.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Orbital Radius vs. Cord Length
For a conical pendulum of length suspended at an angle from the vertical, the radius of horizontal circular motion is .
Always draw the right-angled triangle formed by the vertical axis, the horizontal radius, and the string before writing .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDivide both sides by (for ):
Substitute :
Solve for :
(a) ; (b) and . A strictly horizontal orientation is impossible because , meaning the cord cannot supply any upward force to balance the weight .
Lock it in
When resolving a vector whose angle is measured from the vertical axis, what are its vertical and horizontal components?
(adjacent to vertical) and (opposite to vertical). Do not assume vertical is always sine.
Similar question
A conical pendulum of cord length rotates such that the cord makes an angle of with the vertical. Taking , find the angular speed of the bob in .
Answer
. Using : .
A bead of mass slides without friction on a smooth circular hoop of radius rotating about its vertical diameter with angular velocity . If the bead stays at an angle measured from the lowest point (the vertical downward axis), derive an expression for in terms of , , and (for ).
Answer
. The normal force points inward toward the center of the hoop, making angle with the vertical. Vertical balance gives , and horizontal centripetal force gives . Thus , and substituting into the vertical equation gives .
A car travels on a frictionless banked curve of radius inclined at an angle above the horizontal. Derive the ideal speed such that the car does not slide up or down the bank, paying careful attention to how the normal force is resolved.
Answer
. The angle of the incline is above horizontal, so the normal force makes angle with the vertical. Vertical equilibrium requires . The horizontal component provides centripetal force: . Substituting yields .