Resources

A student claims that because a heat pump delivers thermal energy QHQ_H to a home that is strictly greater than the electrical work input WW consumed (QH>WQ_H > W), its coefficient of performance COPHP=QHW>1\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{Q_H}{W} > 1 represents an apparent efficiency greater than 100%100\% and thus violates the First Law of Thermodynamics. Consider a Carnot heat pump warming an indoor space held at TH=21.0∘CT_H = 21.0^\circ\text{C} while drawing ambient heat from outside air at TC=−5.00∘CT_C = -5.00^\circ\text{C}. Calculate the theoretical maximum COPHP\text{COP}_{\text{HP}}, the ratio QCW\frac{Q_C}{W} of free heat absorbed from the outside air per unit of electrical work input, and explain why energy conservation is fully preserved.

Answer and steps

Final answer

COPHP=11.3\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = 11.3; QCW=10.3\frac{Q_C}{W} = 10.3; energy is conserved because QH=QC+WQ_H = Q_C + W, meaning the heat pump does not create energy but moves environmental thermal energy (QCQ_C) alongside electrical work (WW).

Steps

01

Absolute Temperature Conversion

Thermodynamic formulas require temperatures expressed in Kelvin:

TH=21.0+273.15=294.15 KT_H = 21.0 + 273.15 = 294.15\text{ K}

TC=−5.00+273.15=268.15 KT_C = -5.00 + 273.15 = 268.15\text{ K}

The difference between reservoirs is:

ΔT=TH−TC=294.15 K−268.15 K=26.0 K\Delta T = T_H - T_C = 294.15\text{ K} - 268.15\text{ K} = 26.0\text{ K}


02

Theoretical Maximum Coefficient of Performance (COPHP\text{COP}_{\text{HP}})

For an ideal Carnot heat pump, the ratio of heat delivered to work input is determined directly by absolute reservoir temperatures:

COPHP=QHW=THTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{Q_H}{W} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C}

Substituting the Kelvin temperatures:

COPHP=294.15 K26.0 K≈11.3\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{294.15\text{ K}}{26.0\text{ K}} \approx 11.3


03

Ratio of Heat Absorbed to Work Input (QCW\frac{Q_C}{W})

By the First Law of Thermodynamics applied to a complete cyclic process, the net change in internal energy is zero (ΔU=0\Delta U = 0). Therefore, the energy leaving the system must equal the total energy entering:

QH=QC+WQ_H = Q_C + W

Dividing both sides by the electrical work input WW:

QHW=QCW+1  ⟹  COPHP=QCW+1\frac{Q_H}{W} = \frac{Q_C}{W} + 1 \implies \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{Q_C}{W} + 1

Rearranging to solve for the ratio of absorbed ambient heat:

QCW=COPHP−1=11.313−1≈10.3\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1 = 11.313 - 1 \approx 10.3

Alternatively, calculating directly from temperatures gives:

QCW=TCTH−TC=268.15 K26.0 K≈10.3\frac{Q_C}{W} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C} = \frac{268.15\text{ K}}{26.0\text{ K}} \approx 10.3

For every 1 J1\text{ J} of electrical work consumed, 10.3 J10.3\text{ J} of free ambient thermal energy is absorbed from the outside air, delivering a total of 11.3 J11.3\text{ J} indoors.


04

Preservation of Energy Conservation (The First Law)

  • Source of the Misconception: The student conflates a thermal coefficient of performance (COP) with thermodynamic conversion efficiency (η\eta). Efficiency compares output energy to all energy consumed, whereas COP compares the desired output (QHQ_H) strictly to the costly input (WW), ignoring the free environmental heat input (QCQ_C).
  • Conservation Law Validation: The heat pump does not synthesize thermal energy from nothing. Instead, it acts as an energy conveyor, taking QCQ_C from the cold reservoir and combining it with input work WW to deliver QH=QC+WQ_H = Q_C + W to the warmer space. Because the total energy entering the system (QC+WQ_C + W) strictly equals the energy exiting the system (QHQ_H), the First Law of Thermodynamics is fully satisfied.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the Carnot coefficient of performance using temperatures in Celsius instead of converting to Kelvin, yielding an incorrect COP.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    COPHP=THTH−TC  ⟹  COPHP=21.021.0−(−5.00)  ⟹  COPHP=21.026.0=0.808\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C} \implies \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{21.0}{21.0 - (-5.00)} \implies \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{21.0}{26.0} = 0.808

    Correct

    COPHP=THTH−TC=21.0+273.1521.0−(−5.00)=294.15 K26.0 K≈11.3\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C} = \frac{21.0 + 273.15}{21.0 - (-5.00)} = \frac{294.15\text{ K}}{26.0\text{ K}} \approx 11.3

    You correctly selected the Carnot COP formula, but thermodynamic formulas involving ratios of temperatures require absolute temperatures in Kelvin. While ΔT=26.0 K\Delta T = 26.0\text{ K} is unchanged, the numerator must be converted to Kelvin: TH=21.0+273.15=294.15 KT_H = 21.0 + 273.15 = 294.15\text{ K}.

  2. Step 2

    QCW=COPHP−1  ⟹  QCW=0.808−1=−0.192\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1 \implies \frac{Q_C}{W} = 0.808 - 1 = -0.192

    Correct

    QCW=COPHP−1=11.313−1≈10.3\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1 = 11.313 - 1 \approx 10.3

    Your relationship QCW=COPHP−1\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1 is completely correct. The negative result occurred solely because the incorrect COPHP\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} from part (a) was substituted.

  3. Step 3

    Energy is conserved because QH=QC+WQ_H = Q_C + W, so the work done transfers heat from the cold outside air rather than generating energy from nothing.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled and applied the Carnot heat pump formula COPHP=THTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C}.

You correctly derived the relationship QCW=COPHP−1\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1 from the First Law.

You clearly explained why energy conservation is preserved using QH=QC+WQ_H = Q_C + W.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Celsius instead of Kelvin

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You substituted temperatures in degrees Celsius (∘C^\circ\text{C}) into a thermodynamic formula that requires absolute temperature in Kelvin (K\text{K}). Temperature differences (ΔT\Delta T) have the same numerical value in Celsius and Kelvin, but single temperatures and ratios must always be expressed in Kelvin.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Temperature Scale Check
  • Thermodynamic efficiency and COP formulas require absolute temperature (T [K]=T [∘C]+273.15T\text{ [K]} = T\text{ [}^\circ\text{C]} + 273.15).

  • Always convert temperatures to Kelvin before substituting them into thermodynamic ratios.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert reservoir temperatures to Kelvin: TH=21.0+273.15=294.15 KT_H = 21.0 + 273.15 = 294.15\text{ K} and TC=−5.00+273.15=268.15 KT_C = -5.00 + 273.15 = 268.15\text{ K}.

  2. Compute the temperature difference: ΔT=TH−TC=294.15−268.15=26.0 K\Delta T = T_H - T_C = 294.15 - 268.15 = 26.0\text{ K}.

  3. Calculate the theoretical maximum COP: COPHP=THΔT=294.15 K26.0 K≈11.3\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{T_H}{\Delta T} = \frac{294.15\text{ K}}{26.0\text{ K}} \approx 11.3.

  4. Compute the ambient heat ratio: QCW=COPHP−1=11.313−1≈10.3\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1 = 11.313 - 1 \approx 10.3.

Final answer

COPHP≈11.3\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} \approx 11.3, QCW≈10.3\frac{Q_C}{W} \approx 10.3

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write down the Kelvin conversion step before plugging values into thermodynamic formulas.

  • Use sanity checks: a heat pump's heating COP is always strictly greater than 11 ( COPHP=COPref+1>1 \,\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \text{COP}_{\text{ref}} + 1 > 1\,); getting a COP below 11 is a clear warning sign of a temperature scale error.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses a heat pump with a heat engine and calculates the Carnot efficiency formula (T_H - T_C) / T_H instead of COP_HP.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    TH=21.0+273.15=294.15 K  ⟹  TC=−5.00+273.15=268.15 KT_H = 21.0 + 273.15 = 294.15\text{ K} \implies T_C = -5.00 + 273.15 = 268.15\text{ K}

  2. Step 2

    COPHP=TH−TCTH  ⟹  COPHP=26.00294.15=0.0884\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{T_H - T_C}{T_H} \implies \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{26.00}{294.15} = 0.0884

    Correct

    COPHP=THTH−TC=294.15 K26.00 K≈11.3\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C} = \frac{294.15\text{ K}}{26.00\text{ K}} \approx 11.3

    You used the formula for the thermal efficiency of a Carnot heat engine (η=WQH=TH−TCTH\eta = \frac{W}{Q_H} = \frac{T_H - T_C}{T_H}) instead of the coefficient of performance of a heat pump, which is the reciprocal ratio of desired heat output to work input: COPHP=QHW=THTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{Q_H}{W} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C}.

  3. Step 3

    QCW=COPHP−1  ⟹  QCW=0.0884−1=−0.912\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1 \implies \frac{Q_C}{W} = 0.0884 - 1 = -0.912

    Correct

    QCW=COPHP−1=11.313−1≈10.3\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1 = 11.313 - 1 \approx 10.3

    Your relationship QCW=COPHP−1\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1 is derived correctly from QH=QC+WQ_H = Q_C + W, but substituting the incorrect COPHP\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} gave an unphysical negative ratio.

  4. Step 4

    The First Law is satisfied because total energy delivered QHQ_H equals work input WW plus ambient heat absorbed QCQ_C.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately converted all temperatures from Celsius to Kelvin before computing thermodynamic ratios.

You correctly identified that conservation of energy requires QH=QC+WQ_H = Q_C + W, leading to QCW=COPHP−1\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1.

You provided an accurate physical explanation for why a heat pump does not violate the First Law of Thermodynamics.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Conflating Heat Engine Efficiency with Heat Pump COP

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused a heat engine with a heat pump. A heat engine produces work from heat (η=WQH=TH−TCTH<1\eta = \frac{W}{Q_H} = \frac{T_H - T_C}{T_H} < 1), whereas a heat pump uses input work to pump heat into a warm space (COPHP=QHW=THTH−TC>1\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{Q_H}{W} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C} > 1).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Desired Output vs. Consumed Input
  • COP=BenefitCost\text{COP} = \frac{\text{Benefit}}{\text{Cost}}. For a heat pump warming a room, the benefit is heat delivered (QHQ_H) and the cost is work input (WW).

  • Always set up COPHP=QHW=THTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{Q_H}{W} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C}. Because TH>TH−TCT_H > T_H - T_C, an ideal heat pump's COP is always strictly greater than 11.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. COPHP=THTH−TC=294.15 K294.15 K−268.15 K=294.15 K26.00 K≈11.3\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C} = \frac{294.15\text{ K}}{294.15\text{ K} - 268.15\text{ K}} = \frac{294.15\text{ K}}{26.00\text{ K}} \approx 11.3

  2. QCW=COPHP−1=11.313−1≈10.3\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1 = 11.313 - 1 \approx 10.3

Final answer

COPHP≈11.3\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} \approx 11.3, QCW≈10.3\frac{Q_C}{W} \approx 10.3, and energy is conserved because QH=QC+WQ_H = Q_C + W.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the fundamental distinction between heat engines (which produce work, with η=WQH<1\eta = \frac{W}{Q_H} < 1) and heat pumps/refrigerators (which consume work to move thermal energy, with COP>1\text{COP} > 1).

  • Whenever you calculate a heat pump's COP, run a quick sanity check: since delivering heat requires less work than the heat delivered (QH>WQ_H > W), COPHP\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} must always exceed 11.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses the heat pump COP formula with the refrigerator COP formula by calculating T_C / (T_H - T_C) for COP_HP.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    TH=21.0+273.15=294.15 K  ⟹  TC=−5.00+273.15=268.15 KT_H = 21.0 + 273.15 = 294.15\text{ K} \implies T_C = -5.00 + 273.15 = 268.15\text{ K}

  2. Step 2

    COPHP=TCTH−TC=268.1526.00=10.3\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C} = \frac{268.15}{26.00} = 10.3

    Correct

    COPHP=THTH−TC=294.15 K26.0 K≈11.3\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C} = \frac{294.15\text{ K}}{26.0\text{ K}} \approx 11.3

    You used the coefficient of performance formula for a refrigerator or air conditioner (TCΔT\frac{T_C}{\Delta T}) instead of a heat pump. For heating, the desired thermal output is QHQ_H delivered at the high temperature THT_H, so COPHP=THTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C}.

  3. Step 3

    QCW=COPHP−1=10.3−1=9.3\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1 = 10.3 - 1 = 9.3

    Correct

    QCW=COPHP−1=11.313−1≈10.3\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1 = 11.313 - 1 \approx 10.3

    Your relationship QCW=COPHP−1\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1 is algebraically and conceptually sound, but substituting your earlier value of 10.310.3 resulted in an incorrect numerical answer of 9.39.3.

  4. Step 4

    Energy conservation is preserved because QH=QC+WQ_H = Q_C + W, meaning the heat delivered comes from both work input and heat extracted from outdoors.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You converted both Celsius temperatures to absolute Kelvin temperatures accurately.

You recognized the algebraic relationship between the heat pump coefficient of performance and the absorbed heat ratio, QCW=COPHP−1\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1.

You clearly explained the physical basis of energy conservation using the First Law equation QH=QC+WQ_H = Q_C + W.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula confusion between heat pump and refrigerator COP

You accidentally placed the cold reservoir temperature TCT_C in the numerator rather than the warm reservoir temperature THT_H.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the cooling coefficient of performance (COPref=QCW=TCTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{ref}} = \frac{Q_C}{W} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C}), where the goal is heat extraction from a cold space, with the heating coefficient of performance (COPHP=QHW=THTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{Q_H}{W} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C}), where the goal is heat delivery to a warm space.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the Desired Output
  • The coefficient of performance is defined as COP=Desired OutputWork Input\text{COP} = \frac{\text{Desired Output}}{\text{Work Input}}. For heating, the desired output is heat delivered indoors (QHQ_H); for cooling, it is heat extracted from the cold space (QCQ_C).

  • Always write down COPHP=QHW=THTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{Q_H}{W} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C} before substituting numerical values.

Use the COP Relation Check
  • For identical operating reservoir temperatures, COPHP=COPref+1\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \text{COP}_{\text{ref}} + 1. Because QH=QC+WQ_H = Q_C + W, a heat pump must always have a COP strictly greater than 11, and exactly 11 greater than an equivalent refrigerator.

  • Verify that your heat pump COP exceeds your absorbed heat ratio QCW\frac{Q_C}{W} by exactly 11.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the ideal Carnot heating COP formula based on heat delivered to the warm reservoir: COPHP=THTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{T_H}{T_H - T_C}.

  2. Substitute the absolute temperatures: COPHP=294.15 K294.15 K−268.15 K=294.15 K26.0 K≈11.313\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{294.15\text{ K}}{294.15\text{ K} - 268.15\text{ K}} = \frac{294.15\text{ K}}{26.0\text{ K}} \approx 11.313.

  3. Apply the First Law energy balance QCW=COPHP−1\frac{Q_C}{W} = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} - 1 to find the free ambient heat absorbed: QCW=11.313−1≈10.3\frac{Q_C}{W} = 11.313 - 1 \approx 10.3.

Final answer

COPHP≈11.3\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} \approx 11.3, QCW≈10.3\frac{Q_C}{W} \approx 10.3, and energy conservation is satisfied via QH=QC+WQ_H = Q_C + W.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice identifying the objective (QHQ_H vs. QCQ_C) in reversed Carnot cycles before selecting your COP expression.

  • Remember the identity COPHP=COPref+1\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \text{COP}_{\text{ref}} + 1 as a quick mental consistency check.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A Carnot refrigerator maintains an interior temperature of TC=4.0∘CT_C = 4.0^\circ\text{C} in a room at TH=24.0∘CT_H = 24.0^\circ\text{C}. Calculate its theoretical coefficient of performance COPref=TCTH−TC\text{COP}_{\text{ref}} = \frac{T_C}{T_H - T_C}.

Answer

COPref≈13.9\text{COP}_{\text{ref}} \approx 13.9. Key steps: convert to Kelvin: TC=4.0+273.15=277.15 KT_C = 4.0 + 273.15 = 277.15\text{ K} and TH=24.0+273.15=297.15 KT_H = 24.0 + 273.15 = 297.15\text{ K}; compute ΔT=20.0 K\Delta T = 20.0\text{ K}; then COPref=277.1520.0=13.86\text{COP}_{\text{ref}} = \frac{277.15}{20.0} = 13.86.

02

An industrial heat pump supplies heat to a drying kiln at TH=65.0∘CT_H = 65.0^\circ\text{C} by extracting heat from ground water at TC=15.0∘CT_C = 15.0^\circ\text{C}. Find the ideal COPHP\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} and determine how much thermal energy QHQ_H is delivered per 1.00 kJ1.00\text{ kJ} of work input.

Answer

COPHP≈6.76\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} \approx 6.76; QH=6.76 kJQ_H = 6.76\text{ kJ}. Key steps: TH=338.15 KT_H = 338.15\text{ K}, TC=288.15 KT_C = 288.15\text{ K}, ΔT=50.0 K\Delta T = 50.0\text{ K}; COPHP=338.1550.0=6.763\text{COP}_{\text{HP}} = \frac{338.15}{50.0} = 6.763; QH=COPHP×W=6.763×1.00 kJ≈6.76 kJQ_H = \text{COP}_{\text{HP}} \times W = 6.763 \times 1.00\text{ kJ} \approx 6.76\text{ kJ}.

03

A home requires 12.0 kW12.0\text{ kW} of heat when outside air is −10.0∘C-10.0^\circ\text{C} and inside air is 20.0∘C20.0^\circ\text{C}. If a real heat pump achieves 45.0%45.0\% of its maximum theoretical Carnot COP, what electrical power input WinW_{\text{in}} is required, and how much heat QCQ_C is drawn from outside per second?

Answer

Win≈2.73 kWW_{\text{in}} \approx 2.73\text{ kW}; QC≈9.27 kWQ_C \approx 9.27\text{ kW}. Key steps: TH=293.15 KT_H = 293.15\text{ K}, TC=263.15 KT_C = 263.15\text{ K}, ΔT=30.0 K\Delta T = 30.0\text{ K}; COPCarnot=293.1530.0≈9.77\text{COP}_{\text{Carnot}} = \frac{293.15}{30.0} \approx 9.77; COPreal=0.450×9.7717≈4.397\text{COP}_{\text{real}} = 0.450 \times 9.7717 \approx 4.397; Win=QHCOPreal=12.0 kW4.397≈2.73 kWW_{\text{in}} = \frac{Q_H}{\text{COP}_{\text{real}}} = \frac{12.0\text{ kW}}{4.397} \approx 2.73\text{ kW}; QC=QH−Win=12.0−2.73=9.27 kWQ_C = Q_H - W_{\text{in}} = 12.0 - 2.73 = 9.27\text{ kW}.

Loading workspace…