Resources

Consider a helium-filled weather balloon with a total payload mass mload=1.20 kgm_{\text{load}} = 1.20\text{ kg} and an expandable envelope containing helium gas. At sea level, atmospheric air density is ρ0=1.225 kg/m3\rho_0 = 1.225\text{ kg/m}^3. In the isothermal limit, atmospheric density varies with altitude zz according to ρair(z)=ρ0e−z/H0\rho_{\text{air}}(z) = \rho_0 e^{-z / H_0}, where the scale height is H0=8.50×103 mH_0 = 8.50 \times 10^3\text{ m}. As the balloon rises, it expands to maintain a fixed total displacement volume V0=4.50 m3V_0 = 4.50\text{ m}^3, and the helium inside maintains a constant mass mHe=0.800 kgm_{\text{He}} = 0.800\text{ kg}. Find the theoretical asymptotic equilibrium altitude zmaxz_{\text{max}} where the buoyant force equals the total weight. Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2.

Answer and steps

Final answer

zmax=8.62×103 mz_{\text{max}} = 8.62 \times 10^3\text{ m}

Steps

01

Determine the Total Weight of the Balloon System

The total mass MtotalM_{\text{total}} of the rising system consists of the payload and the helium gas inside the envelope: Mtotal=mload+mHe=1.20 kg+0.800 kg=2.00 kgM_{\text{total}} = m_{\text{load}} + m_{\text{He}} = 1.20\text{ kg} + 0.800\text{ kg} = 2.00\text{ kg}

The total downward gravitational force (weight) is: W=MtotalgW = M_{\text{total}} g


02

Apply Archimedes' Principle for the Buoyant Force

By Archimedes' principle, the upward buoyant force FBF_B equals the weight of the ambient air displaced by the balloon: FB=ρair(z)V0gF_B = \rho_{\text{air}}(z) V_0 g

Substituting the isothermal atmospheric density profile ρair(z)=ρ0e−z/H0\rho_{\text{air}}(z) = \rho_0 e^{-z / H_0}: FB=ρ0e−z/H0V0gF_B = \rho_0 e^{-z / H_0} V_0 g


03

Establish the Equilibrium Condition

At the asymptotic maximum altitude zmaxz_{\text{max}}, the balloon reaches static equilibrium where the upward buoyant force equals the downward weight: FB=W  ⟹  ρ0e−zmax/H0V0g=MtotalgF_B = W \implies \rho_0 e^{-z_{\text{max}} / H_0} V_0 g = M_{\text{total}} g

Dividing both sides by gg: ρ0V0e−zmax/H0=Mtotal\rho_0 V_0 e^{-z_{\text{max}} / H_0} = M_{\text{total}}

Pitfall to Avoid: Remember to include the mass of the gas itself (mHem_{\text{He}}) in the total mass. The buoyant force must support both the structural payload and the internal lifting gas.


04

Solve for the Altitude zmaxz_{\text{max}}

Rearrange the equation to isolate the exponential term: e−zmax/H0=Mtotalρ0V0e^{-z_{\text{max}} / H_0} = \frac{M_{\text{total}}}{\rho_0 V_0}

Take the natural logarithm of both sides: −zmaxH0=ln⁡(Mtotalρ0V0)  ⟹  zmax=H0ln⁡(ρ0V0Mtotal)-\frac{z_{\text{max}}}{H_0} = \ln\left(\frac{M_{\text{total}}}{\rho_0 V_0}\right) \implies z_{\text{max}} = H_0 \ln\left(\frac{\rho_0 V_0}{M_{\text{total}}}\right)

Calculate the mass of the air displaced at sea level: ρ0V0=(1.225 kg/m3)(4.50 m3)=5.5125 kg\rho_0 V_0 = (1.225\text{ kg/m}^3)(4.50\text{ m}^3) = 5.5125\text{ kg}

Substitute the values into the formula for zmaxz_{\text{max}}: zmax=(8.50×103 m)ln⁡(5.5125 kg2.00 kg)z_{\text{max}} = (8.50 \times 10^3\text{ m}) \ln\left(\frac{5.5125\text{ kg}}{2.00\text{ kg}}\right) zmax=(8.50×103 m)ln⁡(2.75625)≈(8.50×103 m)(1.0139)≈8.62×103 mz_{\text{max}} = (8.50 \times 10^3\text{ m}) \ln(2.75625) \approx (8.50 \times 10^3\text{ m})(1.0139) \approx 8.62 \times 10^3\text{ m}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to include the mass of the helium inside the envelope when calculating the total gravitational weight.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Fb=Wtotal  ⟹  ρair(z)⋅V0⋅g=mload⋅g  ⟹  ρair(z)=1.204.50=0.2667 kg/m3F_b = W_{\text{total}} \implies \rho_{\text{air}}(z) \cdot V_0 \cdot g = m_{\text{load}} \cdot g \implies \rho_{\text{air}}(z) = \frac{1.20}{4.50} = 0.2667\text{ kg/m}^3

    Correct

    ρair(z)V0g=(mload+mHe)g  ⟹  ρair(z)=1.20 kg+0.800 kg4.50 m3≈0.4444 kg/m3\rho_{\text{air}}(z) V_0 g = (m_{\text{load}} + m_{\text{He}}) g \implies \rho_{\text{air}}(z) = \frac{1.20\text{ kg} + 0.800\text{ kg}}{4.50\text{ m}^3} \approx 0.4444\text{ kg/m}^3

    You equated the upward buoyant force to the weight of the payload alone, forgetting that the balloon envelope contains 0.800 kg0.800\text{ kg} of helium gas that also contributes to the total downward gravitational force.

  2. Step 2

    ρ\rho0 ⋅\cdot e^{-z/H_0} = 0.2667   ⟹  \implies e^{-z/H_0} = 0.26671.225\frac{0.2667}{1.225} = 0.2177

    Correct

    e^{-z/H_0} = 0.44441.225\frac{0.4444}{1.225} ≈\approx 0.3628

    You substituted the exponential barometric formula and isolated the exponential term correctly, but the result is affected by the omitted helium mass.

  3. Step 3

    z_{max\text{max}} = 8500 ⋅\cdot \ln(10.2177)\left(\frac{1}{0.2177}\right) = 12959 m\text{ m}_

    Correct

    z_{max\text{max}} = 8500 m\text{ m} ⋅\cdot \ln(10.3628)\left(\frac{1}{0.3628}\right) ≈\approx 8.62 ×\times 10^3 m\text{ m}_

    You correctly took the natural logarithm and inverted the exponential relationship, but the numerical answer is significantly higher than the true equilibrium altitude because the system was treated as lighter than it actually is.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the equilibrium condition where buoyant force equals total weight.

You accurately modeled Archimedes' principle using the ambient density profile.

You applied natural logarithms accurately to solve for altitude from the exponential density model.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted lifting gas mass in total weight

You used only the payload mass mloadm_{\text{load}} instead of the total system mass mload+mHem_{\text{load}} + m_{\text{He}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating lifting gas as 'weightless' or neglecting its gravitational mass because it provides positive net lift. Although the gas is less dense than the surrounding air, gravity still pulls downward on every kilogram of helium inside the envelope.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Account for All Masses in Free-Body Diagrams
  • The total gravitational force on any flying vehicle is Wtotal=(mstructure+mpayload+mgas)gW_{\text{total}} = (m_{\text{structure}} + m_{\text{payload}} + m_{\text{gas}})g.

  • Always list every physical component inside the system boundary before writing ∑Fy=0\sum F_y = 0.

Distinguish Net Lift from Gross Buoyant Force
  • The gross buoyant force is FB=ρfluidVgF_B = \rho_{\text{fluid}} V g, while net upward force is FB−Wtotal=(ρair−ρgas)Vg−mloadgF_B - W_{\text{total}} = (\rho_{\text{air}} - \rho_{\text{gas}}) V g - m_{\text{load}} g.

  • Do not treat the buoyant force as already accounting for the weight of the internal gas.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Sum the total system mass: Mtotal=mload+mHe=1.20 kg+0.800 kg=2.00 kgM_{\text{total}} = m_{\text{load}} + m_{\text{He}} = 1.20\text{ kg} + 0.800\text{ kg} = 2.00\text{ kg}.

  2. Set up the equilibrium condition at zmaxz_{\text{max}}: ρair(zmax)V0g=Mtotalg  ⟹  ρair(zmax)=2.00 kg4.50 m3≈0.4444 kg/m3\rho_{\text{air}}(z_{\text{max}}) V_0 g = M_{\text{total}} g \implies \rho_{\text{air}}(z_{\text{max}}) = \frac{2.00\text{ kg}}{4.50\text{ m}^3} \approx 0.4444\text{ kg/m}^3.

  3. Equate to the exponential density model: ρ0e−zmax/H0=0.4444 kg/m3  ⟹  e−zmax/H0=0.44441.225≈0.3628\rho_0 e^{-z_{\text{max}}/H_0} = 0.4444\text{ kg/m}^3 \implies e^{-z_{\text{max}}/H_0} = \frac{0.4444}{1.225} \approx 0.3628.

  4. Solve for zmaxz_{\text{max}}: zmax=H0ln⁡(1.2250.4444)=(8.50×103 m)ln⁡(2.75625)≈8.62×103 mz_{\text{max}} = H_0 \ln\left(\frac{1.225}{0.4444}\right) = (8.50 \times 10^3\text{ m}) \ln(2.75625) \approx 8.62 \times 10^3\text{ m}.

Final answer

zmax≈8.62×103 mz_{\text{max}} \approx 8.62 \times 10^3\text{ m} (or 8620 m8620\text{ m})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review free-body diagrams for aerostats to ensure internal gas mass is included in the downward gravity vector.

  • Practice problems that isolate the difference between gross buoyant force and net lifting force.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student solves for the exponential decay algebraically with a sign error, writing z_max = -H_0 * ln(ρ_0 / ρ_air) and obtaining a negative altitude.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mtotal=1.20+0.800=2.00 kgm_{\text{total}} = 1.20 + 0.800 = 2.00\text{ kg}

  2. Step 2

    ρair(z)=2.004.50=0.4444 kg/m3\rho_{\text{air}}(z) = \frac{2.00}{4.50} = 0.4444\text{ kg/m}^3

  3. Step 3

    1.225∗e(−z/H0)=0.44441.225 * e^{(-z/H_0)} = 0.4444

  4. Step 4

    −z/H0=ln⁡(1.2250.4444)-z/H_0 = \ln\left(\frac{1.225}{0.4444}\right)

    Correct

    −zmaxH0=ln⁡(0.44441.225)=−ln⁡(1.2250.4444)-\frac{z_{\text{max}}}{H_0} = \ln\left(\frac{0.4444}{1.225}\right) = -\ln\left(\frac{1.225}{0.4444}\right)

    When dividing both sides of 1.225e−z/H0=0.44441.225 e^{-z/H_0} = 0.4444 by 1.2251.225, you get e−z/H0=0.44441.225e^{-z/H_0} = \frac{0.4444}{1.225}. Taking the logarithm of both sides gives −zH0=ln⁡(0.44441.225)-\frac{z}{H_0} = \ln\left(\frac{0.4444}{1.225}\right). You inverted the argument inside the logarithm while keeping the negative sign on −zH0-\frac{z}{H_0}, which reversed the sign of the altitude.

  5. Step 5

    zmax=−8500∗ln⁡(2.756)=−8618 mz_{\text{max}} = -8500 * \ln(2.756) = -8618\text{ m}

    Correct

    zmax=8500 m×ln⁡(2.75625)≈8.62×103 mz_{\text{max}} = 8500\text{ m} \times \ln(2.75625) \approx 8.62 \times 10^3\text{ m}

    Your final calculation evaluated the expression from Step 4 correctly, but inherited the sign error, producing a negative altitude below sea level.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly included both the payload and the lifting helium gas to find the total mass.

You correctly applied Archimedes' principle to find the required air density at float equilibrium.

You correctly substituted the numerical constants into the isothermal atmospheric density formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Logarithmic inversion sign error

Inverting the fraction inside the natural logarithm while keeping the negative exponent sign, resulting in a negative altitude.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

When solving equations of the form Ae−x=BA e^{-x} = B, isolating the exponential yields e−x=BAe^{-x} = \frac{B}{A}. Taking the natural logarithm gives −x=ln⁡(B/A)=−ln⁡(A/B)-x = \ln(B/A) = -\ln(A/B), which means x=ln⁡(A/B)x = \ln(A/B). You wrote −x=ln⁡(A/B)-x = \ln(A/B), which effectively introduced an extra factor of −1-1.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isolate before taking logarithms
  • For Ae−kz=BA e^{-k z} = B, first write e−kz=BAe^{-k z} = \frac{B}{A}, then take ln⁡\ln of both sides to get −kz=ln⁡(BA)-k z = \ln\left(\frac{B}{A}\right).

  • Keep the numerator and denominator in their direct positions (BB divided by AA) before applying logarithmic identities.

Physical reality check on altitude
  • An ascending balloon in an atmosphere where density decreases with height (z>0z > 0) must reach equilibrium at a positive altitude (zmax>0z_{\text{max}} > 0).

  • If you obtain a negative altitude when solving for equilibrium above sea level, check whether an algebraic sign was dropped or inverted during log simplification.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Isolate the exponential term: e−zmax/H0=0.4444 kg/m31.225 kg/m3=0.3628e^{-z_{\text{max}}/H_0} = \frac{0.4444\text{ kg/m}^3}{1.225\text{ kg/m}^3} = 0.3628

  2. Take the natural logarithm of both sides: −zmaxH0=ln⁡(0.3628)≈−1.014-\frac{z_{\text{max}}}{H_0} = \ln(0.3628) \approx -1.014

  3. Multiply by −H0-H_0: zmax=−(8.50×103 m)×(−1.014)≈8.62×103 mz_{\text{max}} = - (8.50 \times 10^3\text{ m}) \times (-1.014) \approx 8.62 \times 10^3\text{ m}

Final answer

zmax≈8.62×103 mz_{\text{max}} \approx 8.62 \times 10^3\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how negative exponents interact with fractions inside logarithms: −x=ln⁡(y)  ⟺  x=ln⁡(1/y)-x = \ln(y) \iff x = \ln(1/y).

  • Practice isolating exponential decay variables algebraically before plugging in numbers.

  • Always perform a sign and magnitude sanity check on calculated physical altitudes.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student mistakenly subtracts the mass of the helium from the payload mass instead of adding it, confusing net upward buoyant force with total gravitational mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    mnet=mload−mHe=1.20−0.800=0.400 kgm_{\text{net}} = m_{\text{load}} - m_{\text{He}} = 1.20 - 0.800 = 0.400\text{ kg}

    Correct

    Mtotal=mload+mHe=1.20 kg+0.800 kg=2.00 kgM_{\text{total}} = m_{\text{load}} + m_{\text{He}} = 1.20\text{ kg} + 0.800\text{ kg} = 2.00\text{ kg}

    You subtracted the helium mass from the payload mass. Both the payload and the helium gas inside the envelope have mass and are pulled downward by gravity, so their masses must be added to find the total downward weight.

  2. Step 2

    ρair(z)⋅V0=0.400  ⟹  ρair(z)=0.4004.50=0.0889 kg/m3\rho_{\text{air}}(z) \cdot V_0 = 0.400 \implies \rho_{\text{air}}(z) = \frac{0.400}{4.50} = 0.0889\text{ kg/m}^3

    Correct

    ρair(z)V0=Mtotal  ⟹  ρair(z)=2.00 kg4.50 m3≈0.444 kg/m3\rho_{\text{air}}(z) V_0 = M_{\text{total}} \implies \rho_{\text{air}}(z) = \frac{2.00\text{ kg}}{4.50\text{ m}^3} \approx 0.444\text{ kg/m}^3

    You correctly balanced the displaced air mass against the system mass, but this step inherited the incorrect mass value of 0.400 kg0.400\text{ kg} from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    e−(z/H0)=0.08891.225=0.0726  ⟹  zmax=8500⋅ln⁡(10.0726)=22295 me^{-(z / H_0)} = \frac{0.0889}{1.225} = 0.0726 \implies z_{\text{max}} = 8500 \cdot \ln\left(\frac{1}{0.0726}\right) = 22295\text{ m}

    Correct

    e−zmax/H0=0.44441.225≈0.3628  ⟹  zmax=8500 m⋅ln⁡(1.2250.4444)≈8.62×103 me^{-z_{\text{max}} / H_0} = \frac{0.4444}{1.225} \approx 0.3628 \implies z_{\text{max}} = 8500\text{ m} \cdot \ln\left(\frac{1.225}{0.4444}\right) \approx 8.62 \times 10^3\text{ m}

    You solved the exponential equation and natural logarithm correctly, but the final altitude is skewed because of the initial mass error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that equilibrium occurs when the buoyant force equals the total weight.

You applied the exponential barometric density model correctly to isolate altitude.

You handled the logarithmic inversion and algebraic steps accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Mass Accounting in Buoyant Systems

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the helium gas as if it reduces the total mass or acts as an inherent upward force, rather than recognizing that all matter inside the balloon system contributes to the downward gravitational force.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Total System Weight
  • Wtotal=(mstructure+mpayload+mgas)gW_{\text{total}} = (m_{\text{structure}} + m_{\text{payload}} + m_{\text{gas}})g

  • Always sum every component of mass inside the system boundary when calculating the total downward force.

Equilibrium Criterion
  • FB=Wtotal  ⟹  ρfluidVdispg=MtotalgF_B = W_{\text{total}} \implies \rho_{\text{fluid}} V_{\text{disp}} g = M_{\text{total}} g

  • Equate the displaced external fluid mass directly to the total enclosed system mass.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the total mass of the system: Mtotal=mload+mHe=1.20 kg+0.800 kg=2.00 kgM_{\text{total}} = m_{\text{load}} + m_{\text{He}} = 1.20\text{ kg} + 0.800\text{ kg} = 2.00\text{ kg}.

  2. Equate the buoyant force to total weight at equilibrium: ρair(zmax)V0=Mtotal  ⟹  ρair(zmax)=2.00 kg4.50 m3≈0.4444 kg/m3\rho_{\text{air}}(z_{\text{max}}) V_0 = M_{\text{total}} \implies \rho_{\text{air}}(z_{\text{max}}) = \frac{2.00\text{ kg}}{4.50\text{ m}^3} \approx 0.4444\text{ kg/m}^3.

  3. Substitute into the atmospheric density relation: ρ0e−zmax/H0=0.4444 kg/m3  ⟹  e−zmax/H0=0.44441.225≈0.3628\rho_0 e^{-z_{\text{max}} / H_0} = 0.4444\text{ kg/m}^3 \implies e^{-z_{\text{max}} / H_0} = \frac{0.4444}{1.225} \approx 0.3628.

  4. Solve for zmaxz_{\text{max}}: zmax=−H0ln⁡(0.3628)=8500 m⋅ln⁡(2.75625)≈8.62×103 mz_{\text{max}} = -H_0 \ln(0.3628) = 8500\text{ m} \cdot \ln(2.75625) \approx 8.62 \times 10^3\text{ m}.

Final answer

zmax=8.62×103 mz_{\text{max}} = 8.62 \times 10^3\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Draw a free-body diagram before writing equations, identifying the buoyant force as the sole upward force and all physical masses as downward forces.

  • Practice distinguishing between 'net lift capacity' and 'total gravitational mass' in aerostat problems.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A rigid research balloon has an envelope mass of 3.00 kg3.00\text{ kg}, carries an instrument package of 5.00 kg5.00\text{ kg}, and is filled with 2.00 kg2.00\text{ kg} of helium. It displaces a constant volume of 12.0 m312.0\text{ m}^3. At what atmospheric air density ρair\rho_{\text{air}} will the balloon float in static equilibrium?

Answer

ρair=0.833 kg/m3\rho_{\text{air}} = 0.833\text{ kg/m}^3. Key steps: Total mass M=3.00+5.00+2.00=10.0 kgM = 3.00 + 5.00 + 2.00 = 10.0\text{ kg}. Equilibrium requires FB=Mg  ⟹  ρairVg=Mg  ⟹  ρair=10.0 kg12.0 m3≈0.833 kg/m3F_B = M g \implies \rho_{\text{air}} V g = M g \implies \rho_{\text{air}} = \frac{10.0\text{ kg}}{12.0\text{ m}^3} \approx 0.833\text{ kg/m}^3.

02

A weather balloon has total structural plus payload mass m0=1.50 kgm_0 = 1.50\text{ kg} and holds mgas=0.900 kgm_{\text{gas}} = 0.900\text{ kg} of hydrogen gas inside a fixed volume V=5.00 m3V = 5.00\text{ m}^3. Sea-level air density is ρ0=1.20 kg/m3\rho_0 = 1.20\text{ kg/m}^3 and the scale height is H=8000 mH = 8000\text{ m} (with ρ(z)=ρ0e−z/H\rho(z) = \rho_0 e^{-z/H}). Find its float altitude zz.

Answer

z≈7320 mz \approx 7320\text{ m}. Key steps: Total mass M=1.50+0.900=2.40 kgM = 1.50 + 0.900 = 2.40\text{ kg}. Required air density ρ(z)=2.40 kg5.00 m3=0.480 kg/m3\rho(z) = \frac{2.40\text{ kg}}{5.00\text{ m}^3} = 0.480\text{ kg/m}^3. Solve ρ0e−z/H=0.480  ⟹  e−z/8000=0.4801.20=0.400  ⟹  z=−8000ln⁡(0.400)≈7330 m\rho_0 e^{-z/H} = 0.480 \implies e^{-z/8000} = \frac{0.480}{1.20} = 0.400 \implies z = -8000 \ln(0.400) \approx 7330\text{ m} (or 7.33 km7.33\text{ km}).

03

An expandable sounding balloon starts at sea level with volume Vi=2.00 m3V_i = 2.00\text{ m}^3 containing 0.360 kg0.360\text{ kg} of helium and a 0.640 kg0.640\text{ kg} payload. As it ascends to altitude z1z_1, the envelope expands to maintain internal pressure equal to ambient pressure. If the atmosphere is isothermal, does the buoyant force FBF_B change as the balloon ascends prior to reaching maximum stretch? Explain why or why not.

Answer

FBF_B remains constant. Key steps: In an isothermal atmosphere, ideal gas law gives ρair∝P\rho_{\text{air}} \propto P and ρHe∝P\rho_{\text{He}} \propto P. The balloon volume expands as V(z)=ViP0P(z)V(z) = V_i \frac{P_0}{P(z)}. The displaced mass of air is mdisp=ρair(z)V(z)=ρ0Vi=constantm_{\text{disp}} = \rho_{\text{air}}(z) V(z) = \rho_0 V_i = \text{constant}. Therefore, FB=mdispgF_B = m_{\text{disp}} g remains invariant with altitude until the envelope reaches its maximum physical expansion limit.

Loading workspace…