Resources
A crate of mass rests on a rough horizontal floor where the coefficient of static friction is and the coefficient of kinetic friction is . A student pulls the crate with a horizontal rope under a tension of . Taking : (a) Identify every force acting on the crate, explicitly stating its type (gravitational, normal, frictional, tension, or elastic), its source/agent, and its direction. (b) Calculate the magnitude of each identified force. (c) Determine whether the crate remains at rest or begins to accelerate.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Gravitational force (Earth, downward); Normal force (floor surface, upward); Tension force (rope, horizontal along the pull); Static frictional force (floor surface, horizontal opposing the pull). (b) , , , . (c) The crate remains at rest because .
Steps
Vertical Forces
Part (a): Identifying the Forces
To identify the forces acting on the crate, we distinguish between non-contact forces (field forces) and contact forces:
- Gravitational force ( or ):
- Type: Gravitational force
- Agent/Source: Earth
- Direction: Vertically downward toward the center of the Earth.
- Normal force ( or ):
- Type: Normal (contact) force
- Agent/Source: The horizontal floor
- Direction: Vertically upward, perpendicular to the floor surface.
- Tension force ():
- Type: Tension force
- Agent/Source: The rope attached to the crate
- Direction: Horizontally in the direction of the pull (e.g., to the right).
- Frictional force ():
- Type: Static frictional force
- Agent/Source: The rough floor surface
- Direction: Horizontally opposing the direction of the pull (e.g., to the left).
Part (b) & (c): Calculating Magnitudes and Determining Motion
Because the crate rests on a horizontal surface and there is no vertical acceleration (), Newton's second law in the vertical direction gives:
Calculate the gravitational force:
Therefore, the normal force is:
Determining Motion and Friction
To determine whether the crate moves, compare the applied horizontal pulling force () to the maximum possible static friction force ():
- Motion state: Since the applied tension is less than the threshold , the static friction holds, and the crate remains at rest ().
Common Pitfall: A frequent mistake is calculating friction using or directly. The formula gives only the maximum possible static friction. As long as the object does not slip, static friction acts as a self-adjusting reaction force that exactly matches the applied horizontal load: .
Since the crate remains in static equilibrium along the horizontal axis ():
Summary of Magnitudes:
- Gravitational force:
- Normal force:
- Tension force:
- Static frictional force:
Typical errors
01 The student calculates friction using the kinetic friction coefficient or assumes static friction always equals its maximum value, obtaining an incorrect friction force magnitude.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Forces acting on the crate: Gravity: gravitational force, exerted by Earth, directed downward Normal force: normal force, exerted by floor, directed upward Tension: tension force, exerted by rope, directed rightward Friction: frictional force, exerted by floor, directed leftward
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
. Since , static friction holds and .
You applied kinetic friction directly instead of checking the maximum static friction threshold first. Because the crate starts from rest, it only begins moving if the applied tension exceeds . Since , the crate does not slip, and static friction self-adjusts to balance the tension: .
- Step 4Correct
This conclusion resulted from using kinetic friction in the previous step. Because static friction balances the tension completely, the net horizontal force is zero and the crate remains at rest.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou identified every contact and non-contact force along with its correct physical agent and direction.
You accurately determined the vertical equilibrium condition and calculated the normal force correctly.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed the object was already moving and calculated kinetic friction immediately, bypassing the static friction threshold check .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Static vs. Kinetic State Check
For an object initially at rest, friction is static unless the net driving force strictly exceeds .
Always compute first and compare it to the applied horizontal load before choosing between static and kinetic friction.
- Self-Adjusting Static Friction
When an object stays at rest, static friction is not equal to ; it adjusts to match the applied force: .
Set equal to the applied load required to maintain equilibrium whenever .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the threshold for slipping: .
Compare the pulling force to : because , the crate does not move.
Apply horizontal equilibrium to find the actual friction: .
(b) , , , ; (c) The crate remains at rest.
02 The student equates the actual static friction force to the maximum possible static friction force rather than the applied tension.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Gravity: gravitational, Earth, downward ⟹ Normal force: normal, floor, upward ⟹ Tension: tension, rope, horizontal to the right ⟹ Static friction: frictional, floor, horizontal to the left
- Step 2
⟹ ⟹
- Step 3
⟹ Friction force magnitude is
Correct; because , static equilibrium along the horizontal axis requires .
You calculated the maximum available static friction threshold () and set the actual static friction force equal to that upper limit. Because the crate does not move, static friction is an adjustable response force that only matches the applied tension, so .
- Step 4
Since the maximum static friction is and , . ⟹ The crate remains at rest.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified every force acting on the crate along with its type, agent, and direction.
You correctly calculated the weight and normal force using Newton's second law in the vertical direction.
You correctly determined that the crate remains stationary by comparing the pulling tension to the maximum static friction threshold.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the formula as the actual value of static friction rather than its maximum possible threshold (). Static friction is an inequality () that self-adjusts to balance external horizontal forces until slipping begins.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Static Friction as an Inequality
Static friction satisfies . It only equals at the verge of slipping.
First calculate to test whether motion occurs. If , set from equilibrium .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the threshold for impending motion: .
Compare the applied pull to the threshold: because , the crate does not slip.
Apply horizontal equilibrium : .
(a) (Earth, downward), (floor, upward), (rope, horizontal along pull), (floor, horizontal opposing pull). (b) , , , . (c) The crate remains at rest.
Lock it in
What does the formula represent for an object resting on a surface?
It gives the maximum possible static friction force (), not the actual friction force for any applied load below that threshold.
Similar question
A box rests on a horizontal floor with and . A horizontal force of is applied. Taking , determine the friction force acting on the box and whether it moves.
Answer
, at rest. Normal force . Maximum static friction . Since , static friction balances the pull: .
A sled rests on packed snow (, ). A rope pulls horizontally with tension . (a) What minimum tension starts the sled moving? (b) If , find the acceleration of the sled. (Use ).
Answer
(a) ; (b) . Vertical forces give . (a) Slipping begins when . (b) Since , the sled slips and kinetic friction acts: . Net force , so .
A block is pushed against a rough horizontal floor by a force of directed at an angle of below the horizontal. The surface has and . Taking , determine if the block moves and find the magnitude of the friction force.
Answer
, block remains at rest. Normal force . Maximum static friction . Horizontal pushing component . Since , the block does not move, and .