Resources

While total energy release per event is greater in heavy-element fission, fusion yields substantially more energy per unit fuel mass. Using the nuclear reactions from baseline analysis—yielding Qfission=173.3 MeVQ_{\text{fission}} = 173.3\text{ MeV} per reaction of 92235U^{235}_{92}\text{U} (reactant fuel mass 235.04 u235.04\text{ u}) and Qfusion=17.59 MeVQ_{\text{fusion}} = 17.59\text{ MeV} per reaction of 12H+13H^{2}_{1}\text{H} + ^{3}_{1}\text{H} (total reactant fuel mass 5.030 u5.030\text{ u})—solve for the specific energy yield (energy released per unit mass of reactant fuel) in units of TJ/kg\text{TJ}/\text{kg} for both processes, and determine the ratio of specific energy of D-T fusion to that of 92235U^{235}_{92}\text{U} fission.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Specific energy of fission: 7.11×101 TJ/kg7.11 \times 10^1\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}; Specific energy of fusion: 3.37×102 TJ/kg3.37 \times 10^2\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}; Ratio Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=4.74\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = 4.74.

Steps

01

Understanding Specific Energy

The specific energy (or energy density by mass) of a nuclear reaction is the total energy released divided by the total mass of the reacting fuel:

Specific Energy=Qmfuel\text{Specific Energy} = \frac{Q}{m_{\text{fuel}}}

To express the result in terajoules per kilogram (TJ/kg\text{TJ}/\text{kg}), we use the standard conversion factors:

  • 1 MeV=1.6022×10−13 J=1.6022×10−25 TJ1\text{ MeV} = 1.6022 \times 10^{-13}\text{ J} = 1.6022 \times 10^{-25}\text{ TJ}
  • 1 u=1.6605×10−27 kg1\text{ u} = 1.6605 \times 10^{-27}\text{ kg}

Combining these gives the conversion factor from MeV/u\text{MeV}/\text{u} to TJ/kg\text{TJ}/\text{kg}:

1 MeV/u=1.6022×10−13 J1.6605×10−27 kg=9.6485×1013 J/kg=96.485 TJ/kg1\text{ MeV}/\text{u} = \frac{1.6022 \times 10^{-13}\text{ J}}{1.6605 \times 10^{-27}\text{ kg}} = 9.6485 \times 10^{13}\text{ J}/\text{kg} = 96.485\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}


02

Specific Energy of 92235U^{235}_{92}\ce{U} Fission

For the fission reaction:

  • Qfission=173.3 MeVQ_{\text{fission}} = 173.3\text{ MeV}
  • mfission=235.04 um_{\text{fission}} = 235.04\text{ u}

First, calculate the energy release per atomic mass unit:

(Qm)fission=173.3 MeV235.04 u≈0.73732 MeV/u\left(\frac{Q}{m}\right)_{\text{fission}} = \frac{173.3\text{ MeV}}{235.04\text{ u}} \approx 0.73732\text{ MeV}/\text{u}

Now, convert this into TJ/kg\text{TJ}/\text{kg}:

Specific Energyfission=0.73732 MeV/u×96.485 TJ/(kg⋅(MeV/u))≈71.1 TJ/kg=7.11×101 TJ/kg\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}} = 0.73732\text{ MeV}/\text{u} \times 96.485\text{ TJ}/(\text{kg}\cdot(\text{MeV}/\text{u})) \approx 71.1\text{ TJ}/\text{kg} = 7.11 \times 10^1\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}


03

Specific Energy of D−T\ce{D-T} Fusion

For the deuterium-tritium (X12X2122H+X13X2123H\ce{^{2}_{1}H + ^{3}_{1}H}) fusion reaction:

  • Qfusion=17.59 MeVQ_{\text{fusion}} = 17.59\text{ MeV}
  • mfusion=5.030 um_{\text{fusion}} = 5.030\text{ u}

First, calculate the energy release per atomic mass unit:

(Qm)fusion=17.59 MeV5.030 u≈3.4970 MeV/u\left(\frac{Q}{m}\right)_{\text{fusion}} = \frac{17.59\text{ MeV}}{5.030\text{ u}} \approx 3.4970\text{ MeV}/\text{u}

Convert this into TJ/kg\text{TJ}/\text{kg}:

Specific Energyfusion=3.4970 MeV/u×96.485 TJ/(kg⋅(MeV/u))≈337 TJ/kg=3.37×102 TJ/kg\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}} = 3.4970\text{ MeV}/\text{u} \times 96.485\text{ TJ}/(\text{kg}\cdot(\text{MeV}/\text{u})) \approx 337\text{ TJ}/\text{kg} = 3.37 \times 10^2\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}


04

Ratio of Fusion to Fission Specific Energy

To find how much more concentrated the energy release of fusion is compared to fission per unit mass, take the ratio:

Ratio=Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=3.4970 MeV/u0.73732 MeV/u≈4.74\text{Ratio} = \frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = \frac{3.4970\text{ MeV}/\text{u}}{0.73732\text{ MeV}/\text{u}} \approx 4.74

Key Takeaway: Although a single heavy-nucleus fission event releases about 10 times more total energy (173.3 MeV173.3\text{ MeV}) than a single light-nucleus fusion event (17.59 MeV17.59\text{ MeV}), the reactant mass of fusion is vastly smaller (5.030 u5.030\text{ u} vs. 235.04 u235.04\text{ u}). As a result, fusion yields approximately 4.744.74 times more energy per kilogram of fuel.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student calculates the ratio of specific energies by directly taking the ratio of the reaction Q-values rather than accounting for reactant mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Efission=173.3 MeV×1.602×10−13 J/MeV235.04 u×1.661×10−27 kg/u=2.776×10−11 J3.904×10−25 kg=7.11×1013 J/kg=71.1 TJ/kgE_{\text{fission}} = \frac{173.3\text{ MeV} \times 1.602 \times 10^{-13}\text{ J/MeV}}{235.04\text{ u} \times 1.661 \times 10^{-27}\text{ kg/u}} = \frac{2.776 \times 10^{-11}\text{ J}}{3.904 \times 10^{-25}\text{ kg}} = 7.11 \times 10^{13}\text{ J/kg} = 71.1\text{ TJ/kg}

  2. Step 2

    Efusion=17.59 MeV×1.602×10−13 J/MeV5.030 u×1.661×10−27 kg/u=2.818×10−12 J8.355×10−27 kg=3.37×1014 J/kg=337.3 TJ/kgE_{\text{fusion}} = \frac{17.59\text{ MeV} \times 1.602 \times 10^{-13}\text{ J/MeV}}{5.030\text{ u} \times 1.661 \times 10^{-27}\text{ kg/u}} = \frac{2.818 \times 10^{-12}\text{ J}}{8.355 \times 10^{-27}\text{ kg}} = 3.37 \times 10^{14}\text{ J/kg} = 337.3\text{ TJ/kg}

  3. Step 3

    Ratio=QfusionQfission=17.59 MeV173.3 MeV=0.101\text{Ratio} = \frac{Q_{\text{fusion}}}{Q_{\text{fission}}} = \frac{17.59\text{ MeV}}{173.3\text{ MeV}} = 0.101

    Correct

    Ratio=Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=337.3 TJ/kg71.1 TJ/kg≈4.74\text{Ratio} = \frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = \frac{337.3\text{ TJ/kg}}{71.1\text{ TJ/kg}} \approx 4.74

    The question asked for the ratio of the specific energies (energy per unit mass), not the ratio of single-event QQ-values.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used standard unit conversion factors to convert megaelectronvolts to joules and atomic mass units to kilograms.

You accurately found the specific energy for both fission and fusion in units of TJ/kg\text{TJ/kg}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Quantity confusion: single-event energy vs. specific energy

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You reverted to comparing raw reaction QQ-values per event rather than using the two specific energy values you had just computed.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Differentiating Single-Event Energy from Specific Energy
  • The reaction energy QQ measures energy per individual nuclear reaction, whereas specific energy Qm\frac{Q}{m} measures energy per unit fuel mass.

  • Always verify which quantity the final prompt asks you to compare before computing ratios.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Divide the specific energy of fusion by the specific energy of fission: Ratio=337.3 TJ/kg71.1 TJ/kg\text{Ratio} = \frac{337.3\text{ TJ/kg}}{71.1\text{ TJ/kg}}.

  2. Calculate the numerical quotient: 337.371.1≈4.74\frac{337.3}{71.1} \approx 4.74.

Final answer

Ratio Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=4.74\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = 4.74

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Take the ratio of the two mass-normalized values you solved for rather than the original event QQ-values.

  • Remember that fusion has a much higher specific energy because its reacting nuclei are vastly lighter than heavy fission nuclei.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student divides the fusion energy by the mass of only deuteron rather than the total mass of the reacting fuel pair.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    1 MeV/u=1.602×10−13 J1.661×10−27 kg=96.45 TJ/kg1\text{ MeV}/\text{u} = \frac{1.602 \times 10^{-13}\text{ J}}{1.661 \times 10^{-27}\text{ kg}} = 96.45\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}

  2. Step 2

    Efission=(173.3235.04)×96.45 TJ/kg  ⟹  Efission=71.1 TJ/kgE_{\text{fission}} = \left(\frac{173.3}{235.04}\right) \times 96.45\text{ TJ}/\text{kg} \implies E_{\text{fission}} = 71.1\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}

  3. Step 3

    Efusion=(17.592.014)×96.45 TJ/kg  ⟹  Efusion=8.734×96.45 TJ/kg=842.4 TJ/kgE_{\text{fusion}} = \left(\frac{17.59}{2.014}\right) \times 96.45\text{ TJ}/\text{kg} \implies E_{\text{fusion}} = 8.734 \times 96.45\text{ TJ}/\text{kg} = 842.4\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}

    Correct

    Specific Energyfusion=(17.59 MeV5.030 u)×96.485 TJ/kg≈3.37×102 TJ/kg\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}} = \left(\frac{17.59\text{ MeV}}{5.030\text{ u}}\right) \times 96.485\text{ TJ}/\text{kg} \approx 3.37 \times 10^2\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}

    You divided by 2.014 u2.014\text{ u} (the mass of only the deuterium reactant) instead of the total reactant mass m(2H+3H)=5.030 um(^{2}\text{H} + {^{3}\text{H}}) = 5.030\text{ u} provided in the problem.

  4. Step 4

    Ratio=EfusionEfission  ⟹  Ratio=842.471.1=11.85\text{Ratio} = \frac{E_{\text{fusion}}}{E_{\text{fission}}} \implies \text{Ratio} = \frac{842.4}{71.1} = 11.85

    Correct

    Ratio=337 TJ/kg71.1 TJ/kg≈4.74\text{Ratio} = \frac{337\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}}{71.1\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}} \approx 4.74

    You set up the ratio correctly, but the numerical answer is incorrect due to the propagated error from your fusion specific energy calculation.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You derived an accurate conversion factor between MeV/u\text{MeV}/\text{u} and TJ/kg\text{TJ}/\text{kg}.

You correctly calculated the specific energy of 235U^{235}\text{U} fission.

You used the correct ratio formula Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Co-Reactant Mass in Specific Energy

You substituted the mass of only deuterium (2.014 u2.014\text{ u}) instead of the combined reactant mass (5.030 u5.030\text{ u}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked that specific energy (energy per unit mass of fuel) requires the total mass of all input fuel components consumed in the reaction, not just one of the colliding nuclei.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Define Total Fuel Mass
  • Specific energy is Q∑mreactants\frac{Q}{\sum m_{\text{reactants}}}, accounting for all consumable fuel particles in the input channel.

  • Always sum the masses of both reactants (m1+m2m_1 + m_2) when calculating fuel energy density for a binary collision/fusion reaction.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Specific Energyfusion=17.59 MeV5.030 u×96.485 TJ/kg≈337.4 TJ/kg=3.37×102 TJ/kg\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}} = \frac{17.59\text{ MeV}}{5.030\text{ u}} \times 96.485\text{ TJ}/\text{kg} \approx 337.4\text{ TJ}/\text{kg} = 3.37 \times 10^2\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}

  2. Ratio=337.4 TJ/kg71.13 TJ/kg≈4.74\text{Ratio} = \frac{337.4\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}}{71.13\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}} \approx 4.74

Final answer

Specific energy of fission: 7.11×101 TJ/kg7.11 \times 10^1\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}; Specific energy of fusion: 3.37×102 TJ/kg3.37 \times 10^2\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}; Ratio: 4.744.74

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review multi-reactant reactions to ensure the denominator always contains the sum of all reacting masses.

  • Re-read the question carefully to identify given total reactant quantities before looking up individual isotopic masses.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the ratio by dividing fission specific energy by fusion specific energy instead of fusion by fission.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Efission=(173.3235.04)×96.485 TJ/kg=71.14 TJ/kgE_{\text{fission}} = \left(\frac{173.3}{235.04}\right) \times 96.485\text{ TJ}/\text{kg} = 71.14\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}

  2. Step 2

    Efusion=(17.595.030)×96.485 TJ/kg=337.41 TJ/kgE_{\text{fusion}} = \left(\frac{17.59}{5.030}\right) \times 96.485\text{ TJ}/\text{kg} = 337.41\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}

  3. Step 3

    Ratio=EfissionEfusion=71.14337.41=0.211\text{Ratio} = \frac{E_{\text{fission}}}{E_{\text{fusion}}} = \frac{71.14}{337.41} = 0.211

    Correct

    Ratio=Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=337.4171.14≈4.74\text{Ratio} = \frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = \frac{337.41}{71.14} \approx 4.74

    The prompt asked for the ratio of fusion to fission specific energy (fusion:fission\text{fusion} : \text{fission}), which requires placing fusion in the numerator and fission in the denominator.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly set up the specific energy formula as total reaction energy divided by reactant mass for both processes.

You accurately converted MeV/u\text{MeV}/\text{u} to TJ/kg\text{TJ}/\text{kg} using the correct conversion factor.

You calculated both specific energy values with high numerical accuracy.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Ratio

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You reversed the order of terms in the ratio comparison, placing fission in the numerator even though the question asked for the ratio of fusion to fission.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Phrasing of Ratios
  • The phrase 'ratio of AA to BB' mathematically translates to AB\frac{A}{B}.

  • Always write out the target ratio symbolically (e.g., Ratio=FusionFission\text{Ratio} = \frac{\text{Fusion}}{\text{Fission}}) directly from the wording before plugging in numerical values.

Sanity Check with Physical Context
  • Fusion yields significantly more energy per unit mass than fission, so the ratio of fusion to fission specific energy must be greater than 11.

  • Compare your calculated ratio against the qualitative premise of the problem: if fusion has higher specific energy, the ratio of fusion to fission cannot be less than 11.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the requested ratio: Ratio=Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission\text{Ratio} = \frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}}.

  2. Substitute your calculated values: Ratio=337.41 TJ/kg71.14 TJ/kg\text{Ratio} = \frac{337.41\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}}{71.14\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}}.

  3. Evaluate the quotient: Ratio≈4.74\text{Ratio} \approx 4.74.

Final answer

Specific energy of fission: 7.11×101 TJ/kg7.11 \times 10^1\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}; Specific energy of fusion: 3.37×102 TJ/kg3.37 \times 10^2\text{ TJ}/\text{kg}; Ratio Specific EnergyfusionSpecific Energyfission=4.74\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fusion}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}} = 4.74.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check that the quantity named first in 'ratio of AA to BB' is placed in the numerator.

  • Perform a physical sanity check to ensure the resulting ratio reflects which quantity is larger.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A fusion reaction releases Q=4.03 MeVQ = 4.03\text{ MeV} from reactants with total mass 4.03 u4.03\text{ u}, while a fission reaction releases Q=200 MeVQ = 200\text{ MeV} from reactants with total mass 236 u236\text{ u}. Find the ratio of specific energy of this fusion reaction to this fission reaction.

Answer

Specific energy of fusion: 4.03 MeV4.03 u=1.00 MeV/u\frac{4.03\text{ MeV}}{4.03\text{ u}} = 1.00\text{ MeV/u}. Specific energy of fission: 200 MeV236 u≈0.847 MeV/u\frac{200\text{ MeV}}{236\text{ u}} \approx 0.847\text{ MeV/u}. Ratio =1.000.847≈1.18= \frac{1.00}{0.847} \approx 1.18.

02

A deuterium-helium-3 reaction releases 18.35 MeV18.35\text{ MeV} from reactants totaling 5.015 u5.015\text{ u}. Compare this with 235U^{235}\text{U} fission releasing 173.3 MeV173.3\text{ MeV} from 235.04 u235.04\text{ u}. Calculate the specific energy ratio Specific EnergyD-He3Specific Energyfission\frac{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{D-He3}}}{\text{Specific Energy}_{\text{fission}}}.

Answer

(Qm)D-He3=18.35 MeV5.015 u≈3.659 MeV/u\left(\frac{Q}{m}\right)_{\text{D-He3}} = \frac{18.35\text{ MeV}}{5.015\text{ u}} \approx 3.659\text{ MeV/u}. (Qm)fission=173.3 MeV235.04 u≈0.7373 MeV/u\left(\frac{Q}{m}\right)_{\text{fission}} = \frac{173.3\text{ MeV}}{235.04\text{ u}} \approx 0.7373\text{ MeV/u}. Ratio =3.6590.7373≈4.96= \frac{3.659}{0.7373} \approx 4.96.

03

Suppose fuel A yields 10.0 MeV10.0\text{ MeV} per reaction with reactant mass 4.0 u4.0\text{ u}, and fuel B yields 80.0 MeV80.0\text{ MeV} with reactant mass 60.0 u60.0\text{ u}. (a) Which fuel releases more energy per reaction? (b) Which fuel has the higher specific energy, and by what factor?

Answer

(a) Fuel B releases more energy per event (80.0 MeV>10.0 MeV80.0\text{ MeV} > 10.0\text{ MeV}). (b) Specific energies: fuel A is 10.04.0=2.50 MeV/u\frac{10.0}{4.0} = 2.50\text{ MeV/u}; fuel B is 80.060.0=1.33 MeV/u\frac{80.0}{60.0} = 1.33\text{ MeV/u}. Fuel A has the higher specific energy by a factor of 2.501.33≈1.88\frac{2.50}{1.33} \approx 1.88.

Loading workspace…