Resources

In a resonance tube experiment conducted at 20.0∘C20.0^\circ\text{C} where the speed of sound is v=343 m/sv = 343\text{ m/s}, an acoustic speaker driven by a function generator is placed near the open top end of a vertical cylinder filled with water. A calibrated microphone connected to an oscilloscope is moved along the column, generating an acoustic standing wave profile of sound pressure amplitude ΔP\Delta P versus vertical probe position zz measured from the top open rim (z=0z = 0). The open end acts as a pressure node (ΔP=0\Delta P = 0), while the water surface acts as a pressure antinode. As the water level is slowly lowered, the oscilloscope trace registers the first two consecutive resonance maxima in tube acoustic energy at water surface depths of z1=17.2 cmz_1 = 17.2\text{ cm} and z2=52.6 cmz_2 = 52.6\text{ cm}. Accounting for the acoustic end correction ee at the tube rim: (a) determine the operational acoustic wavelength λ\lambda from the spatial separation of the resonance nodes, (b) calculate the frequency ff emitted by the speaker, and (c) calculate the empirical end correction ee of the resonance tube.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) λ=0.708 m\lambda = 0.708\text{ m}, (b) f=484 Hzf = 484\text{ Hz}, (c) e=0.500 cm=5.00×10−3 me = 0.500\text{ cm} = 5.00 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}

Steps

Part (a): Determine the Wavelength λ\lambda

A vertical cylinder closed by water at the bottom and open to the atmosphere at the top forms a pipe open at one end and closed at the other:

  • At the open top rim (z=0z = 0), the acoustic wave reflects slightly outside the physical boundary at an effective distance ee, known as the end correction. The effective pressure node is located at z=−ez = -e.
  • At the water surface, the boundary is rigid, forming a pressure antinode (or displacement node).

For a pipe with one open end and one closed end, resonant standing waves form when the effective length of the vibrating air column matches an odd multiple of a quarter-wavelength: Leff=(2n−1)λ4,n=1,2,3,…L_{\text{eff}} = (2n - 1)\frac{\lambda}{4}, \quad n = 1, 2, 3, \dots

For the first two consecutive resonant states (n=1n = 1 and n=2n = 2):

  1. First resonance at depth z1z_1: z1+e=λ4z_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4}
  2. Second resonance at depth z2z_2: z2+e=3λ4z_2 + e = \frac{3\lambda}{4}

Subtracting the first equation from the second eliminates the unknown end correction ee: (z2+e)−(z1+e)=3λ4−λ4(z_2 + e) - (z_1 + e) = \frac{3\lambda}{4} - \frac{\lambda}{4} z2−z1=λ2z_2 - z_1 = \frac{\lambda}{2}

Solving for the wavelength λ\lambda: λ=2(z2−z1)\lambda = 2(z_2 - z_1)

Substitute the given depths z1=17.2 cm=0.172 mz_1 = 17.2\text{ cm} = 0.172\text{ m} and z2=52.6 cm=0.526 mz_2 = 52.6\text{ cm} = 0.526\text{ m}: λ=2(52.6 cm−17.2 cm)=2(35.4 cm)=70.8 cm=0.708 m\lambda = 2(52.6\text{ cm} - 17.2\text{ cm}) = 2(35.4\text{ cm}) = 70.8\text{ cm} = 0.708\text{ m}


Part (b): Calculate the Emitted Frequency ff

Using the fundamental wave relationship v=fλv = f\lambda, where v=343 m/sv = 343\text{ m/s}: f=vλf = \frac{v}{\lambda}

Substitute the values: f=343 m/s0.708 m≈484.46 Hz≈484 Hzf = \frac{343\text{ m/s}}{0.708\text{ m}} \approx 484.46\text{ Hz} \approx 484\text{ Hz}


Part (c): Calculate the Empirical End Correction ee

Using the resonance condition for the first harmonic: z1+e=λ4z_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4}

Rearranging for the end correction ee: e=λ4−z1e = \frac{\lambda}{4} - z_1

Substitute λ=70.8 cm\lambda = 70.8\text{ cm} and z1=17.2 cmz_1 = 17.2\text{ cm}: e=70.8 cm4−17.2 cm=17.7 cm−17.2 cm=0.500 cme = \frac{70.8\text{ cm}}{4} - 17.2\text{ cm} = 17.7\text{ cm} - 17.2\text{ cm} = 0.500\text{ cm}

In SI units: e=5.00×10−3 me = 5.00 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}

(Verification using the second resonance: e=3λ4−z2=3(70.8 cm)4−52.6 cm=53.1 cm−52.6 cm=0.500 cme = \frac{3\lambda}{4} - z_2 = \frac{3(70.8\text{ cm})}{4} - 52.6\text{ cm} = 53.1\text{ cm} - 52.6\text{ cm} = 0.500\text{ cm}, which confirms consistency.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the distance between consecutive resonances with a full wavelength rather than half a wavelength, leading to halving the wavelength and doubling the calculated frequency.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    λ=z2−z1=52.6 cm−17.2 cm=35.4 cm=0.354 m\lambda = z_2 - z_1 = 52.6\text{ cm} - 17.2\text{ cm} = 35.4\text{ cm} = 0.354\text{ m}

    Correct

    λ2=z2−z1  ⟹  λ=2(52.6 cm−17.2 cm)=70.8 cm=0.708 m\frac{\lambda}{2} = z_2 - z_1 \implies \lambda = 2(52.6\text{ cm} - 17.2\text{ cm}) = 70.8\text{ cm} = 0.708\text{ m}

    Consecutive resonance levels in a pipe closed at one end differ by an added pressure node-to-node (or antinode-to-antinode) segment, which spans λ2\frac{\lambda}{2}, not a full wavelength λ\lambda.

  2. Step 2

    f=vλ=3430.354=968.9 Hzf = \frac{v}{\lambda} = \frac{343}{0.354} = 968.9\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f=vλ=343 m/s0.708 m≈484 Hzf = \frac{v}{\lambda} = \frac{343\text{ m/s}}{0.708\text{ m}} \approx 484\text{ Hz}

    Your formula f=vλf = \frac{v}{\lambda} and substitution method are correct, but your result is doubled because it used the halved wavelength from Part (a).

  3. Step 3

    z1+e=λ4  ⟹  e=35.44−17.2=8.85−17.2=−8.35 cmz_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4} \implies e = \frac{35.4}{4} - 17.2 = 8.85 - 17.2 = -8.35\text{ cm}

    Correct

    z1+e=λ4  ⟹  e=70.8 cm4−17.2 cm=17.7 cm−17.2 cm=0.500 cm=5.00×10−3 mz_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4} \implies e = \frac{70.8\text{ cm}}{4} - 17.2\text{ cm} = 17.7\text{ cm} - 17.2\text{ cm} = 0.500\text{ cm} = 5.00 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}

    You correctly set up the effective tube length for the first resonance, but substituting λ=35.4 cm\lambda = 35.4\text{ cm} yielded an unphysical negative end correction.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the first harmonic resonance formula z1+e=λ4z_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4}.

You used the fundamental wave speed equation v=fλv = f\lambda correctly to relate speed, frequency, and wavelength.

You correctly subtracted the two given water levels to find their spatial difference.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Node-to-Node Distance Misinterpreted as Full Wavelength

You set λ=z2−z1\lambda = z_2 - z_1 instead of λ2=z2−z1\frac{\lambda}{2} = z_2 - z_1.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In standing waves, adjacent nodes or adjacent antinodes are spaced by half a wavelength (λ2\frac{\lambda}{2}). When consecutive resonances are observed by changing the column length, each successive resonance corresponds to adding one additional half-wave loop between the open top and the water surface.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Standing Wave Node Spacing
  • The spatial distance between any two consecutive nodes (or consecutive antinodes) is Δz=λ2\Delta z = \frac{\lambda}{2}.

  • Always write Δz=zn+1−zn=λ2\Delta z = z_{n+1} - z_n = \frac{\lambda}{2} when subtracting consecutive resonance lengths.

Sanity Check on End Correction
  • For an open circular pipe of radius rr, the acoustic end correction is positive and approximately e≈0.6re \approx 0.6r.

  • If your calculated end correction ee is negative or extraordinarily large, verify whether your wavelength was accidentally halved or calculated incorrectly.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the distance between consecutive resonance depths equal to half a wavelength: z2−z1=λ2z_2 - z_1 = \frac{\lambda}{2}.

  2. Calculate the true wavelength: λ=2(52.6 cm−17.2 cm)=2(35.4 cm)=70.8 cm=0.708 m\lambda = 2(52.6\text{ cm} - 17.2\text{ cm}) = 2(35.4\text{ cm}) = 70.8\text{ cm} = 0.708\text{ m}.

  3. Compute the frequency using v=343 m/sv = 343\text{ m/s}: f=vλ=343 m/s0.708 m≈484 Hzf = \frac{v}{\lambda} = \frac{343\text{ m/s}}{0.708\text{ m}} \approx 484\text{ Hz}.

  4. Substitute λ\lambda into the first resonance equation: e=λ4−z1=70.8 cm4−17.2 cm=17.7 cm−17.2 cm=0.500 cme = \frac{\lambda}{4} - z_1 = \frac{70.8\text{ cm}}{4} - 17.2\text{ cm} = 17.7\text{ cm} - 17.2\text{ cm} = 0.500\text{ cm}.

Final answer

(a) λ=0.708 m\lambda = 0.708\text{ m}, (b) f=484 Hzf = 484\text{ Hz}, (c) e=0.500 cm=5.00×10−3 me = 0.500\text{ cm} = 5.00 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch standing wave pressure profiles for n=1n = 1 and n=2n = 2 in a closed-open pipe to visualize why the length difference adds exactly one loop (λ2\frac{\lambda}{2}).

  • Practice resonance tube problems by verifying that both e=λ4−z1e = \frac{\lambda}{4} - z_1 and e=3λ4−z2e = \frac{3\lambda}{4} - z_2 produce identical positive values.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student ignores the end correction when setting up the first resonance length, assuming z₁ is directly λ / 4, which yields an incorrect wavelength and frequency.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    λ=4z1=4(17.2 cm)=68.8 cm=0.688 m\lambda = 4z_1 = 4(17.2\text{ cm}) = 68.8\text{ cm} = 0.688\text{ m}

    Correct

    λ=2(z2−z1)=2(52.6 cm−17.2 cm)=70.8 cm=0.708 m\lambda = 2(z_2 - z_1) = 2(52.6\text{ cm} - 17.2\text{ cm}) = 70.8\text{ cm} = 0.708\text{ m}

    You assumed the first resonance depth z1z_1 equals λ4\frac{\lambda}{4} without including the end correction ee. The effective length is z1+e=λ4z_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4} and z2+e=3λ4z_2 + e = \frac{3\lambda}{4}, so subtracting them gives z2−z1=λ2z_2 - z_1 = \frac{\lambda}{2}, which yields λ=2(z2−z1)=70.8 cm\lambda = 2(z_2 - z_1) = 70.8\text{ cm}.

  2. Step 2

    f=vλ=3430.688=498.5 Hzf = \frac{v}{\lambda} = \frac{343}{0.688} = 498.5\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f=vλ=343 m/s0.708 m≈484 Hzf = \frac{v}{\lambda} = \frac{343\text{ m/s}}{0.708\text{ m}} \approx 484\text{ Hz}

    You correctly applied the wave speed formula f=vλf = \frac{v}{\lambda}, but your calculated value was affected by the incorrect wavelength from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    e=z2−3z1=52.6−3(17.2)=52.6−51.6=1.0 cme = z_2 - 3z_1 = 52.6 - 3(17.2) = 52.6 - 51.6 = 1.0\text{ cm}

    Correct

    e=λ4−z1=17.7 cm−17.2 cm=0.500 cme = \frac{\lambda}{4} - z_1 = 17.7\text{ cm} - 17.2\text{ cm} = 0.500\text{ cm}

    You subtracted 3(z1+e)=3λ43(z_1 + e) = \frac{3\lambda}{4} and z2+e=3λ4z_2 + e = \frac{3\lambda}{4}, which yields z2+e=3z1+3e  ⟹  2e=z2−3z1z_2 + e = 3z_1 + 3e \implies 2e = z_2 - 3z_1, so e=z2−3z12=0.500 cme = \frac{z_2 - 3z_1}{2} = 0.500\text{ cm}. You missed the factor of 22 in the denominator.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the wave speed relationship f=vλf = \frac{v}{\lambda} to connect frequency, speed, and wavelength.

You recognized that the first and second resonances correspond to fundamental and third-harmonic quarter-wavelength ratios.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ignoring Acoustic End Correction

You omitted the factor of 22 when relating ee to z2−3z1z_2 - 3z_1.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed the open tube boundary occurs exactly at the physical rim (z1=λ4z_1 = \frac{\lambda}{4}) rather than accounting for the acoustic antinode extending beyond the rim by an end correction ee, which requires using the difference between consecutive resonances Δz=λ2\Delta z = \frac{\lambda}{2} to find λ\lambda.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Eliminating End Correction
  • For consecutive resonances in a closed-open tube, (zn+1+e)−(zn+e)=zn+1−zn=λ2(z_{n+1} + e) - (z_n + e) = z_{n+1} - z_n = \frac{\lambda}{2}.

  • Always compute λ\lambda from the difference between consecutive resonance positions Δz=λ2\Delta z = \frac{\lambda}{2} rather than from a single measured length.

Solving for End Correction
  • Once λ\lambda is known, e=λ4−z1e = \frac{\lambda}{4} - z_1 or e=z2−3z12e = \frac{z_2 - 3z_1}{2}.

  • Substitute the corrected λ\lambda back into the first resonance condition z1+e=λ4z_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4} to solve directly for ee.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. λ=2(z2−z1)=2(52.6 cm−17.2 cm)=2(35.4 cm)=70.8 cm=0.708 m\lambda = 2(z_2 - z_1) = 2(52.6\text{ cm} - 17.2\text{ cm}) = 2(35.4\text{ cm}) = 70.8\text{ cm} = 0.708\text{ m}

  2. f=vλ=343 m/s0.708 m≈484 Hzf = \frac{v}{\lambda} = \frac{343\text{ m/s}}{0.708\text{ m}} \approx 484\text{ Hz}

  3. e=λ4−z1=70.8 cm4−17.2 cm=17.7 cm−17.2 cm=0.500 cme = \frac{\lambda}{4} - z_1 = \frac{70.8\text{ cm}}{4} - 17.2\text{ cm} = 17.7\text{ cm} - 17.2\text{ cm} = 0.500\text{ cm}

Final answer

(a) λ=0.708 m\lambda = 0.708\text{ m}, (b) f=484 Hzf = 484\text{ Hz}, (c) $e = 0.500 cm\text{ cm} = 5.00 ×\times 10^{-3} m\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice finding λ\lambda by taking the difference between consecutive resonance lengths ΔL=λ2\Delta L = \frac{\lambda}{2}.

  • Double-check algebraic linear combinations when eliminating variables from two simultaneous resonance equations.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misplaces the sign of the end correction by writing z₁ - e = λ / 4 instead of z₁ + e = λ / 4, resulting in a negative end correction.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    λ=2(z2−z1)=2(52.6−17.2)=70.8 cm=0.708 m\lambda = 2(z_2 - z_1) = 2(52.6 - 17.2) = 70.8\text{ cm} = 0.708\text{ m}

  2. Step 2

    f=vλ=3430.708=484.5 Hzf = \frac{v}{\lambda} = \frac{343}{0.708} = 484.5\text{ Hz}

  3. Step 3

    z1−e=λ4z_1 - e = \frac{\lambda}{4}

    Correct

    z1+e=λ4z_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4}

    The effective air column extends slightly outside the physical tube rim to the pressure node located at a distance ee above the rim. Therefore, the effective quarter-wave length is the sum of the physical depth and the end correction, Leff=z1+eL_{\text{eff}} = z_1 + e.

  4. Step 4

    e=z1−λ4=17.2−70.84=17.2−17.7=−0.5 cme = z_1 - \frac{\lambda}{4} = 17.2 - \frac{70.8}{4} = 17.2 - 17.7 = -0.5\text{ cm}

    Correct

    e=λ4−z1=17.7 cm−17.2 cm=0.500 cme = \frac{\lambda}{4} - z_1 = 17.7\text{ cm} - 17.2\text{ cm} = 0.500\text{ cm}

    This step carries forward the sign error from the previous step, resulting in a negative end correction.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the spatial difference between consecutive resonance positions to eliminate the end correction and determine the wavelength.

You applied the wave speed equation v=fλv = f\lambda accurately to compute the frequency.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in boundary end correction

You wrote z1−e=λ4z_1 - e = \frac{\lambda}{4} instead of z1+e=λ4z_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4}, which made the physical column appear longer than the acoustic quarter-wavelength.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Misinterpreting how the acoustic end correction modifies physical tube length: the effective pressure node forms slightly outside the open rim, meaning the acoustic standing wave is longer than the physical air column (Leff=z+eL_{\text{eff}} = z + e).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Acoustic End Correction Position
  • For an open pipe rim, the antinode in displacement (or node in pressure) is located slightly outside the tube at an effective distance ee beyond the rim.

  • Always add the end correction to the measured physical tube length: Leff=Lphys+eL_{\text{eff}} = L_{\text{phys}} + e.

Physical Sanity Check on End Correction
  • An end correction ee represents an extra length of vibrating air and must be a positive quantity (e>0e > 0).

  • If your calculation produces a negative end correction, check whether you swapped the order of subtraction or wrote L−eL - e instead of L+eL + e.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute the known values: 17.2 cm+e=70.8 cm4=17.7 cm17.2\text{ cm} + e = \frac{70.8\text{ cm}}{4} = 17.7\text{ cm}

  2. Solve for ee: e=17.7 cm−17.2 cm=0.500 cm=5.00×10−3 me = 17.7\text{ cm} - 17.2\text{ cm} = 0.500\text{ cm} = 5.00 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}

Final answer

(a) λ=0.708 m\lambda = 0.708\text{ m}, (b) f=484 Hzf = 484\text{ Hz}, (c) e=0.500 cm=5.00×10−3 me = 0.500\text{ cm} = 5.00 \times 10^{-3}\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the geometry of open ends in standing acoustic waves to visualize why the acoustic boundary lies outside the physical boundary.

  • Practice setting up effective length equations for both one-open-end and two-open-ends tubes with end corrections.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A tuning fork of frequency f=512 Hzf = 512\text{ Hz} is held over a resonance tube. The first two resonances occur at water levels L1=16.0 cmL_1 = 16.0\text{ cm} and L2=49.5 cmL_2 = 49.5\text{ cm}. Calculate the speed of sound vv in the tube.

Answer

v=343 m/sv = 343\text{ m/s}. The wavelength is λ=2(L2−L1)=2(49.5 cm−16.0 cm)=2(33.5 cm)=67.0 cm=0.670 m\lambda = 2(L_2 - L_1) = 2(49.5\text{ cm} - 16.0\text{ cm}) = 2(33.5\text{ cm}) = 67.0\text{ cm} = 0.670\text{ m}. Then v=fλ=(512 s−1)(0.670 m)≈343.04 m/sv = f\lambda = (512\text{ s}^{-1})(0.670\text{ m}) \approx 343.04\text{ m/s}.

02

A vertical tube open at the top has consecutive resonances at air column lengths of 22.0 cm22.0\text{ cm} and 68.0 cm68.0\text{ cm}. (a) Find the acoustic wavelength λ\lambda. (b) Determine the end correction ee of the tube.

Answer

(a) λ=92.0 cm=0.920 m\lambda = 92.0\text{ cm} = 0.920\text{ m}; (b) e=1.00 cme = 1.00\text{ cm}. Key steps: λ2=68.0 cm−22.0 cm=46.0 cm  ⟹  λ=92.0 cm\frac{\lambda}{2} = 68.0\text{ cm} - 22.0\text{ cm} = 46.0\text{ cm} \implies \lambda = 92.0\text{ cm}. For the first harmonic, L1+e=λ4=23.0 cm  ⟹  e=23.0 cm−22.0 cm=1.00 cmL_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4} = 23.0\text{ cm} \implies e = 23.0\text{ cm} - 22.0\text{ cm} = 1.00\text{ cm}.

03

A sound wave of frequency f=686 Hzf = 686\text{ Hz} resonates in an open-topped water column where sound speed is v=343 m/sv = 343\text{ m/s}. The inner radius of the tube is r=2.50 cmr = 2.50\text{ cm}, with an empirical end correction e=0.60re = 0.60r. Determine the water depths z1z_1 and z2z_2 from the top rim for the first two resonance modes.

Answer

z1=11.0 cmz_1 = 11.0\text{ cm} and z2=36.0 cmz_2 = 36.0\text{ cm}. Key steps: λ=vf=343686=0.500 m=50.0 cm\lambda = \frac{v}{f} = \frac{343}{686} = 0.500\text{ m} = 50.0\text{ cm}. The end correction is e=0.60(2.50 cm)=1.50 cme = 0.60(2.50\text{ cm}) = 1.50\text{ cm}. First resonance: z1+e=λ4=12.5 cm  ⟹  z1=12.5−1.5=11.0 cmz_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4} = 12.5\text{ cm} \implies z_1 = 12.5 - 1.5 = 11.0\text{ cm}. Second resonance: z2=z1+λ2=11.0+25.0=36.0 cmz_2 = z_1 + \frac{\lambda}{2} = 11.0 + 25.0 = 36.0\text{ cm}.

Loading workspace…