Resources

In a cyclic heat engine, the heat transferred to the working substance from the heat source is QH=+4500 JQ_H = +4500\text{ J}, and the net work performed by the gas on the surroundings is Wby=+1350 JW_{\text{by}} = +1350\text{ J}. By thermodynamic sign conventions where QQ and WW represent net transfers into the system (such that ΔU=Qnet+Won=0\Delta U = Q_{\text{net}} + W_{\text{on}} = 0 over a closed cycle), determine the signed value of the heat exchanged with the cold sink QCQ_C, and calculate the thermal efficiency η\eta.

Answer and steps

Final answer

QC=−3150 JQ_C = -3150\text{ J}, η=30.0%\eta = 30.0\%

Steps

01

Apply the First Law of Thermodynamics to a Complete Cycle

In any complete thermodynamic cycle, the working substance starts and ends in the exact same thermodynamic state. Because internal energy UU is a state function, the net change in internal energy over one full cycle is zero:

ΔU=0\Delta U = 0

According to the First Law of Thermodynamics, the change in internal energy is related to the net heat added to the system QnetQ_{\text{net}} and the work done on the system WonW_{\text{on}}:

ΔU=Qnet+Won=0\Delta U = Q_{\text{net}} + W_{\text{on}} = 0

Work performed by the gas on its surroundings relates to work performed on the gas by Won=−WbyW_{\text{on}} = -W_{\text{by}}. The net heat transfer to the system consists of the heat entering from the hot reservoir (QHQ_H) and the heat exchanged with the cold sink (QCQ_C):

Qnet=QH+QCQ_{\text{net}} = Q_H + Q_C

Substitute these relations into the first-law equation:

(QH+QC)−Wby=0(Q_H + Q_C) - W_{\text{by}} = 0

02

Solve for the Heat Exchanged with the Cold Sink (QCQ_C)

Rearranging the energy balance gives:

QC=Wby−QHQ_C = W_{\text{by}} - Q_H

Substitute the given values (QH=+4500 JQ_H = +4500\text{ J} and Wby=+1350 JW_{\text{by}} = +1350\text{ J}):

QC=1350 J−4500 J=−3150 JQ_C = 1350\text{ J} - 4500\text{ J} = -3150\text{ J}

Sign convention note: The negative sign confirms that heat leaves the working substance and is discharged into the cold sink.

03

Calculate the Thermal Efficiency (η\eta)

The thermal efficiency η\eta of a heat engine is defined as the fraction of the heat absorbed from the high-temperature reservoir that is successfully converted into useful work:

η=WbyQH\eta = \frac{W_{\text{by}}}{Q_H}

Substitute the values:

η=1350 J4500 J=0.300=30.0%\eta = \frac{1350\text{ J}}{4500\text{ J}} = 0.300 = 30.0\%

Alternatively, expressing efficiency in terms of heat transfers gives η=1−∣QC∣QH=1−3150 J4500 J=1−0.700=30.0%\eta = 1 - \frac{|Q_C|}{Q_H} = 1 - \frac{3150\text{ J}}{4500\text{ J}} = 1 - 0.700 = 30.0\%.

Common Pitfall: Always use the heat absorbed from the hot reservoir (QHQ_H), not the net heat or rejected heat, as the denominator when calculating efficiency.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student ignores the thermodynamic sign convention that heat released to the cold sink must be negative, stating Q_C as a positive magnitude.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Δ\Delta U = Q_H - Q_C - W_{by\text{by}} = 0   ⟹  \implies Q_C = Q_H - W_{by\text{by}} = 4500 - 1350   ⟹  \implies Q_C = 3150 J\text{ J}

    Correct

    Δ\Delta U = Q_H + Q_C - W_{by\text{by}} = 0   ⟹  \implies Q_C = W_{by\text{by}} - Q_H = 1350 J\text{ J} - 4500 J\text{ J} = -3150 J\text{ J}

    You embedded an explicit minus sign into the first law equation before solving for QCQ_C, which yielded an unsigned magnitude. Under standard thermodynamic sign conventions where all QQ terms represent energy entering the system, the net heat is Qnet=QH+QCQ_{\text{net}} = Q_H + Q_C, giving a negative signed value for heat leaving the engine.

  2. Step 2

    η=WbyQH=13504500=0.30\eta = \frac{W_{\text{by}}}{Q_H} = \frac{1350}{4500} = 0.30

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that internal energy change ΔU=0\Delta U = 0 over a complete thermodynamic cycle.

You correctly defined and calculated thermal efficiency as η=WbyQH=0.30\eta = \frac{W_{\text{by}}}{Q_H} = 0.30.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign convention confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You pre-assigned a subtraction sign to QCQ_C in the energy balance equation instead of writing the algebraic sum Qnet=QH+QCQ_{\text{net}} = Q_H + Q_C, causing you to report the magnitude ∣QC∣|Q_C| instead of the requested signed value.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Thermodynamic Sign Convention for Heat
  • Q>0Q > 0 means heat is added to the system; Q<0Q < 0 means heat is released from the system into the surroundings.

  • Keep all heat exchanges as additive terms (Qnet=∑QiQ_{\text{net}} = \sum Q_i) in your first-law equation and let the algebraic solution determine the sign.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express the net heat added to the system over one cycle: Qnet=QH+QCQ_{\text{net}} = Q_H + Q_C.

  2. Apply the First Law of Thermodynamics for a complete cycle: ΔU=Qnet−Wby=0\Delta U = Q_{\text{net}} - W_{\text{by}} = 0.

  3. Substitute QnetQ_{\text{net}} and solve for QCQ_C: QC=Wby−QH=1350 J−4500 J=−3150 JQ_C = W_{\text{by}} - Q_H = 1350\text{ J} - 4500\text{ J} = -3150\text{ J}.

Final answer

QC=−3150 JQ_C = -3150\text{ J}, η=30.0%\eta = 30.0\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When a problem explicitly requests a signed thermodynamic quantity, express energy balances as sums (Qnet=QH+QCQ_{\text{net}} = Q_H + Q_C) rather than inserting negative signs manually.

  • Practice distinguishing between absolute magnitudes (e.g., ∣QC∣|Q_C|) used in efficiency definitions and signed transfer quantities used in first-law balances.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the definition of thermal efficiency by dividing net work by the heat discharged to the cold sink instead of the heat absorbed from the hot source.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Qnet=Wby  ⟹  QH+QC=1350  ⟹  4500+QC=1350  ⟹  QC=−3150 JQ_{\text{net}} = W_{\text{by}} \implies Q_H + Q_C = 1350 \implies 4500 + Q_C = 1350 \implies Q_C = -3150\text{ J}

  2. Step 2

    η=Wby∣QC∣  ⟹  η=13503150=0.43\eta = \frac{W_{\text{by}}}{|Q_C|} \implies \eta = \frac{1350}{3150} = 0.43

    Correct

    η=WbyQH=1350 J4500 J=0.300=30.0%\eta = \frac{W_{\text{by}}}{Q_H} = \frac{1350\text{ J}}{4500\text{ J}} = 0.300 = 30.0\%

    Thermal efficiency is defined as the ratio of useful work output to total heat input from the hot source (QHQ_H), not the heat rejected to the cold sink (∣QC∣|Q_C|).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that internal energy change is zero over a complete thermodynamic cycle.

You properly computed the heat exchanged with the cold sink as QC=−3150 JQ_C = -3150\text{ J} with the correct negative sign.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect denominator in efficiency definition

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You placed the rejected heat ∣QC∣|Q_C| in the denominator of the efficiency formula instead of the heat absorbed from the high-temperature reservoir QHQ_H.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Thermal Efficiency Formula
  • Thermal efficiency represents useful benefit divided by energy paid for: η=WnetQin=WbyQH=1−∣QC∣QH\eta = \frac{W_{\text{net}}}{Q_{\text{in}}} = \frac{W_{\text{by}}}{Q_H} = 1 - \frac{|Q_C|}{Q_H}.

  • Always place the heat absorbed from the hot source (QHQ_H) in the denominator.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the definition of thermal efficiency: η=WbyQH\eta = \frac{W_{\text{by}}}{Q_H}.

  2. Substitute the given values Wby=1350 JW_{\text{by}} = 1350\text{ J} and QH=4500 JQ_H = 4500\text{ J}: η=13504500=0.300\eta = \frac{1350}{4500} = 0.300.

  3. Express the efficiency as a percentage: η=30.0%\eta = 30.0\%.

Final answer

QC=−3150 JQ_C = -3150\text{ J}, η=30.0%\eta = 30.0\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Anchor efficiency to the intuitive phrase 'benefit divided by cost', where heat absorbed from fuel/source (QHQ_H) is always the cost in the denominator.

  • Practice drawing an energy flow diagram showing QHQ_H splitting into WnetW_{\text{net}} and QCQ_C to keep the terms clearly separated.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student incorrectly adds work and heat absorbed to find Q_C, treating the first law as Q_C = Q_H + W_by.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    QC=−(QH+Wby)  ⟹  QC=−(4500+1350)  ⟹  QC=−5850 JQ_C = -(Q_H + W_{\text{by}}) \implies Q_C = -(4500 + 1350) \implies Q_C = -5850\text{ J}

    Correct

    QC=Wby−QH=1350 J−4500 J=−3150 JQ_C = W_{\text{by}} - Q_H = 1350\text{ J} - 4500\text{ J} = -3150\text{ J}

    Over a full cycle, ΔU=Qnet+Won=0\Delta U = Q_{\text{net}} + W_{\text{on}} = 0. Since work done on the gas relates to work done by the gas by Won=−WbyW_{\text{on}} = -W_{\text{by}}, the balance is (QH+QC)−Wby=0(Q_H + Q_C) - W_{\text{by}} = 0, which gives QC=Wby−QHQ_C = W_{\text{by}} - Q_H rather than −(QH+Wby)-(Q_H + W_{\text{by}}).

  2. Step 2

    η=WbyQH  ⟹  η=13504500=0.30\eta = \frac{W_{\text{by}}}{Q_H} \implies \eta = \frac{1350}{4500} = 0.30

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled the definition of thermal efficiency η=WbyQH\eta = \frac{W_{\text{by}}}{Q_H}.

You substituted the given values accurately to calculate η=0.30\eta = 0.30.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in thermodynamic first-law energy balance

You added work done by the engine and heat absorbed from the hot reservoir when writing the expression for heat rejected, instead of subtracting.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated work output and heat input when setting up the cyclic energy conservation equation. Because energy absorbed (QHQ_H) splits into useful work done (WbyW_{\text{by}}) and waste heat expelled (∣QC∣|Q_C|), the magnitude of rejected heat must satisfy ∣QC∣=QH−Wby|Q_C| = Q_H - W_{\text{by}}, meaning QC=Wby−QHQ_C = W_{\text{by}} - Q_H.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Cyclic Energy Conservation
  • For any closed cycle, total energy in equals total energy out: QH=Wby+∣QC∣Q_H = W_{\text{by}} + |Q_C|.

  • Always check that ∣QC∣<QH|Q_C| < Q_H for a positive work output engine before assigning the negative sign to QCQ_C.

First Law Sign Conventions
  • When ΔU=Qnet+Won=0\Delta U = Q_{\text{net}} + W_{\text{on}} = 0, substitute Won=−WbyW_{\text{on}} = -W_{\text{by}} and Qnet=QH+QCQ_{\text{net}} = Q_H + Q_C.

  • Write the fundamental equation (QH+QC)−Wby=0(Q_H + Q_C) - W_{\text{by}} = 0 and isolate QC=Wby−QHQ_C = W_{\text{by}} - Q_H step-by-step.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the first law for a complete cycle: ΔU=QH+QC−Wby=0\Delta U = Q_H + Q_C - W_{\text{by}} = 0.

  2. Isolate QCQ_C: QC=Wby−QHQ_C = W_{\text{by}} - Q_H.

  3. Substitute the given numbers: QC=1350 J−4500 J=−3150 JQ_C = 1350\text{ J} - 4500\text{ J} = -3150\text{ J}.

Final answer

QC=−3150 JQ_C = -3150\text{ J}, η=30.0%\eta = 30.0\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice setting up energy flow diagrams (energy in = energy out) to verify sign consistency before writing algebraic equations.

  • Solve heat engine problems by finding the magnitude ∣QC∣|Q_C| first, then applying the appropriate sign convention.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A cyclic heat engine absorbs QH=+6200 JQ_H = +6200\text{ J} from a hot reservoir and exhausts heat into a cold reservoir with an efficiency of η=25.0%\eta = 25.0\%. Determine the net work done by the engine WbyW_{\text{by}} and the signed value of the heat transferred to the cold reservoir QCQ_C.

Answer

Wby=ηQH=0.25×6200 J=+1550 JW_{\text{by}} = \eta Q_H = 0.25 \times 6200\text{ J} = +1550\text{ J}. Over a full cycle, ΔU=QH+QC−Wby=0\Delta U = Q_H + Q_C - W_{\text{by}} = 0, so QC=Wby−QH=1550 J−6200 J=−4650 JQ_C = W_{\text{by}} - Q_H = 1550\text{ J} - 6200\text{ J} = -4650\text{ J}.

02

In a refrigeration cycle operating in reverse of a heat engine, the working fluid absorbs QC=+2400 JQ_C = +2400\text{ J} from the cold refrigerated space while net work Won=+800 JW_{\text{on}} = +800\text{ J} is performed on the fluid by a compressor. Using the convention ΔU=QH+QC+Won=0\Delta U = Q_H + Q_C + W_{\text{on}} = 0, find the signed heat transfer to the high-temperature room QHQ_H, and calculate the coefficient of performance COP=QCWin\text{COP} = \frac{Q_C}{W_{\text{in}}}.

Answer

From ΔU=QH+QC+Won=0\Delta U = Q_H + Q_C + W_{\text{on}} = 0, QH=−QC−Won=−2400 J−800 J=−3200 JQ_H = -Q_C - W_{\text{on}} = -2400\text{ J} - 800\text{ J} = -3200\text{ J}. The coefficient of performance is COP=2400 J800 J=3.0\text{COP} = \frac{2400\text{ J}}{800\text{ J}} = 3.0.

03

An experimental gas engine operates through a closed cycle where heat Q1=+5000 JQ_1 = +5000\text{ J} enters at state 1→21 \to 2, Q2=−1200 JQ_2 = -1200\text{ J} leaves at 2→32 \to 3, and Q3=−2300 JQ_3 = -2300\text{ J} leaves at 3→13 \to 1. Calculate the total net work done by the gas WbyW_{\text{by}}, the total heat absorbed QinQ_{\text{in}}, and the thermal efficiency η\eta of the cycle.

Answer

The net work is Wby=Qnet=Q1+Q2+Q3=5000−1200−2300=+1500 JW_{\text{by}} = Q_{\text{net}} = Q_1 + Q_2 + Q_3 = 5000 - 1200 - 2300 = +1500\text{ J}. Total heat absorbed is Qin=Q1=5000 JQ_{\text{in}} = Q_1 = 5000\text{ J}. The thermal efficiency is η=WbyQin=1500 J5000 J=0.300=30.0%\eta = \frac{W_{\text{by}}}{Q_{\text{in}}} = \frac{1500\text{ J}}{5000\text{ J}} = 0.300 = 30.0\%.

Loading workspace…