Resources
A courier must drive along a straight highway connecting City P and City Q separated by a distance . Due to heavy morning traffic, the courier drives the first half of the total distance () at an average speed of . The courier needs the average speed for the complete one-way trip to reach a target threshold of . (a) Determine the constant speed required over the second half of the distance to achieve this overall average speed. (b) Explain the physical boundary/limiting condition that occurs if the target average speed was instead set to .
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) It is physically impossible to achieve an overall average speed of ; (b) The courier spends on the first half alone, which equals the total allowable time for the entire trip (), requiring an infinite speed () over the second half.
Steps
Part (a): Setting up the Average Speed Equation
By definition, the average speed for a journey is the total distance traveled divided by the total elapsed time:
The trip consists of two equal segments of distance :
- The time spent on the first half is:
- Let be the speed during the second half. The time taken for this segment is:
- The total time for the entire journey of is:
Substitute these values into the average speed formula with the target speed :
Multiply both sides by :
Subtracting from both sides gives:
Because no finite non-zero value of satisfies this equation, it is physically impossible to achieve an overall average speed of .
Part (b): Physical Limiting Condition
To understand why this is impossible physically, consider the time budget allowed for the entire trip:
- To cover the full distance at an average speed of , the total allowed travel time is:
- However, traveling the first at takes:
The courier has already consumed the entire time budget of just completing the first half. Therefore, the remaining time available for the second half is:
Covering a non-zero distance () in zero time () requires an infinite speed (). Since instantaneous teleportation or infinite speed is physically impossible, the target threshold cannot be met.
Common Pitfall: A common mistake is simply taking the arithmetic mean of the speeds, , which gives . The arithmetic mean is only valid when equal times are spent at each speed. For equal distances, average speed is governed by the harmonic mean: Because must always be strictly less than for any finite , the limit as is precisely .
Typical errors
01 The student treats average speed over equal distances as the simple arithmetic mean of the two speeds rather than accounting for time elapsed, obtaining an impossible finite speed.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You applied the arithmetic mean of speeds. The arithmetic mean only applies when equal times are spent at each speed. For segments of equal distance, you must determine total time elapsed, leading to the harmonic mean: .
- Step 2Correct
Your algebraic rearrangement is correct for the equation you set up, but it inherits the invalid arithmetic-mean formula from Step 1.
- Step 3Correct
You concluded that average speed scales without an asymptote. In reality, because time depends inversely on speed, spending on the first half exhausts the entire time budget for an overall trip, creating a hard physical asymptote at as .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly isolated using sound linear algebra.
You explicitly articulated the conceptual model underlying your calculation.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo; this is a conceptual misunderstanding of the definition of average speed when segments have equal distance rather than equal duration.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating time-weighted and distance-weighted averages. When distance is split equally, the slower speed consumes a disproportionately larger fraction of the total travel time, so the average speed is strongly biased toward the lower speed and governed by the harmonic mean, not the arithmetic mean.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Definition of Average Speed
Average speed is strictly defined as total distance divided by total time: .
Always compute the elapsed time of each individual segment before calculating the average speed.
- Equal Distances vs. Equal Times
For two equal distance intervals, . The arithmetic mean is valid only if the travel times are equal.
Check whether the problem splits the journey by distance or by time before selecting an average-speed shortcut.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the time spent on the first half: .
Calculate the total time permitted for the entire journey at : .
Determine the remaining time for the second half: .
Express the speed required for the second half: .
(a) It is physically impossible to achieve an overall average speed of with any finite speed; (b) The courier consumes the entire trip time budget during the first half alone, requiring and thus .
02 The student incorrectly subtracts the two speeds directly to find the required speed over the remaining distance.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
No finite real solution (impossible)
Speeds over different segments cannot be added or subtracted directly to find an average. You must compute the travel time for each segment using and apply the definition .
- Step 2
The boundary is reached when the two speeds are equal at . The courier only needs to maintain to make up the difference.
CorrectThe total allowed time is . The courier spends on the first half alone, leaving , which requires an infinite speed .
The physical boundary occurs because all available time () is already used up during the first half of the trip, leaving zero time to cover the remaining .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly identified the given numerical values for the first segment speed and target average speed.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that the overall average speed equals the sum of the speeds on the two legs (), rather than using the fundamental definition .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Definition of Average Speed
Always set up a time budget () for each individual leg instead of adding, subtracting, or averaging speeds directly.
- Equal Distance Segments Formula
For two equal distance halves,
Recognize that the overall average speed can never reach or exceed twice the speed of the first half () for any finite second-half speed.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the allowable time budget for the complete trip: .
Calculate the time elapsed during the first half: .
Determine the remaining time for the second half: .
Calculate the required speed: .
(a) It is physically impossible to achieve an overall average speed of ; (b) The entire time budget of is exhausted on the first half alone, requiring infinite speed () to cover the second half in zero time.
Lock it in
A car travels distance at speed and another equal distance at speed . What formula gives the average speed?
(the harmonic mean), because average speed is total distance divided by total time: .
Similar question
A motorist drives at and the next at . Calculate the motorist's average speed for the entire trip.
Answer
. Key steps: , . Total time . .
A cyclist completes the first half of a race at . What constant speed must the cyclist maintain over the second half of the distance to achieve an overall average speed of ?
Answer
. Key steps: Total allowed time . First half time . Remaining time . Required speed .
A train travels between two stations separated by distance . It covers the first of the distance at and the remaining of the distance at . Determine the train's average speed for the full journey.
Answer
. Key steps: , . Total time . Average speed .