Resources

A student drops a small dense pebble from the edge of a tall cliff (v0=0v_0 = 0). One second later, the student drops a second identical pebble from the exact same point. Assuming both pebbles fall freely under constant acceleration g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 with negligible air resistance, evaluate whether the spatial distance between the two pebbles increases, decreases, or remains constant over time. Calculate the precise vertical separation between the two pebbles at t=3.00 st = 3.00\text{ s} after the first pebble was released.

Answer and steps

Final answer

The separation increases linearly with time; vertical separation Δy=24.5 m\Delta y = 24.5\text{ m}

Steps

01

Set Up the Kinematic Equations for Each Pebble

Choose the cliff edge as the origin (y=0y = 0) and define the downward direction as positive. Both pebbles fall from rest (v0=0v_0 = 0) with uniform downward acceleration a=g=9.80 m/s2a = g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2.

  • First pebble: Released at t=0 st = 0\text{ s}. Its vertical position for t≥0t \ge 0 is: y1(t)=12gt2y_1(t) = \frac{1}{2}gt^2
  • Second pebble: Released one second later at t=1.00 st = 1.00\text{ s}. Its fall time is t−1.00 st - 1.00\text{ s}, so for t≥1.00 st \ge 1.00\text{ s}, its vertical position is: y2(t)=12g(t−1.00)2y_2(t) = \frac{1}{2}g(t - 1.00)^2

02

Determine How the Spatial Distance Evolves Over Time

The vertical separation Δy(t)\Delta y(t) between the two pebbles while both are in the air (t≥1.00 st \ge 1.00\text{ s}) is:

Δy(t)=y1(t)−y2(t)=12gt2−12g(t−1.00)2\Delta y(t) = y_1(t) - y_2(t) = \frac{1}{2}g t^2 - \frac{1}{2}g(t - 1.00)^2

Expanding the binomial term:

(t−1.00)2=t2−2t+1(t - 1.00)^2 = t^2 - 2t + 1

Substitute this back into the expression for Δy(t)\Delta y(t):

Δy(t)=12g[t2−(t2−2t+1)]=12g(2t−1)=g(t−12)\Delta y(t) = \frac{1}{2}g\left[t^2 - (t^2 - 2t + 1)\right] = \frac{1}{2}g(2t - 1) = g\left(t - \frac{1}{2}\right)

Because g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 is a positive constant, the rate of change of separation with respect to time is:

d(Δy)dt=g=9.80 m/s\frac{d(\Delta y)}{dt} = g = 9.80\text{ m/s}

Since this derivative is positive and constant, the separation increases linearly with time.

Physical Intuition & Common Pitfall: A common misconception is that because both pebbles experience the exact same acceleration gg, the distance between them must stay constant. While their acceleration is identical, the first pebble had a 1 s1\text{ s} head start and therefore always travels faster than the second pebble at any shared clock time: v1(t)−v2(t)=gt−g(t−1.00)=g(1.00)=9.80 m/sv_1(t) - v_2(t) = gt - g(t - 1.00) = g(1.00) = 9.80\text{ m/s} Because the leading pebble constantly moves 9.80 m/s9.80\text{ m/s} faster than the trailing pebble, the spatial gap between them grows continuously at a constant rate of 9.80 m9.80\text{ m} every second.


03

Calculate the Separation at t=3.00 st = 3.00\text{ s}

At t=3.00 st = 3.00\text{ s}, the first pebble has been falling for t1=3.00 st_1 = 3.00\text{ s}, and the second pebble has been falling for t2=3.00 s−1.00 s=2.00 st_2 = 3.00\text{ s} - 1.00\text{ s} = 2.00\text{ s}.

Calculate each pebble's vertical displacement:

y1=12(9.80 m/s2)(3.00 s)2=0.5⋅9.80⋅9.00=44.1 my_1 = \frac{1}{2}(9.80\text{ m/s}^2)(3.00\text{ s})^2 = 0.5 \cdot 9.80 \cdot 9.00 = 44.1\text{ m}

y2=12(9.80 m/s2)(2.00 s)2=0.5⋅9.80⋅4.00=19.6 my_2 = \frac{1}{2}(9.80\text{ m/s}^2)(2.00\text{ s})^2 = 0.5 \cdot 9.80 \cdot 4.00 = 19.6\text{ m}

Find the vertical separation Δy\Delta y:

Δy=y1−y2=44.1 m−19.6 m=24.5 m\Delta y = y_1 - y_2 = 44.1\text{ m} - 19.6\text{ m} = 24.5\text{ m}

(Alternatively, evaluating the derived formula directly yields Δy(3.00)=9.80⋅(3.00−0.5)=9.80⋅2.50=24.5 m\Delta y(3.00) = 9.80 \cdot (3.00 - 0.5) = 9.80 \cdot 2.50 = 24.5\text{ m}.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses equal constant acceleration with constant separation, falsely assuming that identical acceleration maintains a fixed distance between the pebbles.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Both pebbles have the same acceleration g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2. Since both fall at the same rate, the distance between them remains constant.

    Correct

    Because the first pebble has a 1.00 s1.00\text{ s} head start, its speed at any shared time tt is v1=gtv_1 = gt, while v2=g(t−1.00 s)v_2 = g(t - 1.00\text{ s}). The relative velocity is v1−v2=9.80 m/s>0v_1 - v_2 = 9.80\text{ m/s} > 0, so their separation increases linearly with time: Δy(t)=g(t−0.50 s)\Delta y(t) = g(t - 0.50\text{ s}).

    You observed that both pebbles share the same acceleration g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2, but identical acceleration does not mean their distance stays fixed. The leading pebble has been falling for an extra second and is always traveling 9.80 m/s9.80\text{ m/s} faster than the trailing pebble, so the gap between them continuously grows.

  2. Step 2

    t1=3.00 s,  t2=2.00 s  ⟹  y1=0.5×9.80×3.002=44.1 m  ⟹  y2=0.5×9.80×2.002=19.6 m  ⟹  Δy=44.1−19.6=24.5 mt_1 = 3.00\text{ s},\; t_2 = 2.00\text{ s} \implies y_1 = 0.5 \times 9.80 \times 3.00^2 = 44.1\text{ m} \implies y_2 = 0.5 \times 9.80 \times 2.00^2 = 19.6\text{ m} \implies \Delta y = 44.1 - 19.6 = 24.5\text{ m}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the effective fall time for both pebbles at t=3.00 st = 3.00\text{ s}.

You correctly applied the kinematic equation y=12gt2y = \frac{1}{2}gt^2 to find each pebble's position.

You correctly calculated the exact vertical distance between the two pebbles at t=3.00 st = 3.00\text{ s}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equating identical acceleration with fixed spatial separation

You equated 'falling with the same acceleration' with 'maintaining a constant distance between objects.'

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You focused on the fact that both pebbles experience the same constant acceleration gg, overlooking that separation depends on their relative velocity (vrel=v1−v2v_{\text{rel}} = v_1 - v_2). Because the first pebble has a time head start, it continuously moves faster than the second pebble at every instant, which causes their separation to expand at a steady rate of 9.80 m/s9.80\text{ m/s}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Relative Velocity for Changing Separation
  • Two objects maintain a constant separation if and only if their relative velocity is zero (v1(t)−v2(t)=0v_1(t) - v_2(t) = 0).

  • Find the velocity of each object at the same clock time tt. If v1(t)≠v2(t)v_1(t) \neq v_2(t), the distance between them is changing.

Express Separation Algebraically as a Function of Time
  • Write Δy(t)=y1(t)−y2(t)\Delta y(t) = y_1(t) - y_2(t) and inspect how it depends on tt.

  • Subtract y2(t)=12g(t−Δt)2y_2(t) = \frac{1}{2}g(t - \Delta t)^2 from y1(t)=12gt2y_1(t) = \frac{1}{2}gt^2 to get Δy(t)=gΔt(t−Δt2)\Delta y(t) = g\Delta t\left(t - \frac{\Delta t}{2}\right), which shows Δy(t)\Delta y(t) grows as tt increases.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the position of pebble 1: y1(t)=12gt2y_1(t) = \frac{1}{2}gt^2.

  2. Write the position of pebble 2 for t≥1.00 st \ge 1.00\text{ s}: y2(t)=12g(t−1.00)2y_2(t) = \frac{1}{2}g(t - 1.00)^2.

  3. Subtract the two expressions: Δy(t)=12g[t2−(t−1.00)2]=g(t−0.50)\Delta y(t) = \frac{1}{2}g[t^2 - (t - 1.00)^2] = g(t - 0.50).

  4. Note that d(Δy)dt=g=9.80 m/s>0\frac{d(\Delta y)}{dt} = g = 9.80\text{ m/s} > 0, confirming that separation increases linearly with time.

Final answer

The separation increases linearly over time; the vertical separation at t=3.00 st = 3.00\text{ s} is 24.5 m24.5\text{ m}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review how relative velocity governs the rate of change of distance between two moving bodies.

  • Practice deriving general time-dependent separation equations Δy(t)\Delta y(t) instead of relying purely on intuition about acceleration.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes the separation between the pebbles is simply the distance the first pebble travels during the 1.00 s delay before the second pebble is released.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    v1=gt  ⟹  v2=g(t−1)  ⟹  v1>v2 at all times, so distance increases.v_1 = gt \implies v_2 = g(t-1) \implies v_1 > v_2\text{ at all times, so distance increases.}

  2. Step 2

    Δy=(12)g(1.00)2=0.5×9.80×1.00  ⟹  Δy=4.90 m\Delta y = \left(\frac{1}{2}\right)g(1.00)^2 = 0.5 \times 9.80 \times 1.00 \implies \Delta y = 4.90\text{ m}

    Correct

    y1(3.00)=12(9.80)(3.00)2=44.1 my_1(3.00) = \frac{1}{2}(9.80)(3.00)^2 = 44.1\text{ m}, y2(3.00)=12(9.80)(2.00)2=19.6 m  ⟹  Δy=44.1 m−19.6 m=24.5 my_2(3.00) = \frac{1}{2}(9.80)(2.00)^2 = 19.6\text{ m} \implies \Delta y = 44.1\text{ m} - 19.6\text{ m} = 24.5\text{ m}

    You calculated the distance fallen by the first pebble during the 1.00 s1.00\text{ s} delay before the second pebble was dropped. Because the gap continues to widen while both pebbles fall, you need to evaluate each pebble's position at t=3.00 st = 3.00\text{ s} and find the difference.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed the velocities of both pebbles as functions of time.

You correctly reasoned that because the leading pebble is always faster, the spatial separation between them must increase.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Initial head-start distance used for instantaneous separation

You substituted the 1.00 s1.00\text{ s} time delay into the position equation instead of finding each pebble's position at clock time t=3.00 st = 3.00\text{ s}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the separation between two accelerating bodies as a static displacement equal to the initial lead, overlooking that the distance keeps growing because the lead object continually travels faster.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Track individual elapsed times
  • For objects released at different times, evaluate each object's position using its own elapsed time: t1=tt_1 = t and t2=t−Δtt_2 = t - \Delta t.

  • At t=3.00 st = 3.00\text{ s}, use t1=3.00 st_1 = 3.00\text{ s} for the first pebble and t2=2.00 st_2 = 2.00\text{ s} for the second pebble.

Compute separation by subtracting positions
  • Spatial separation at any time tt is Δy(t)=y1(t)−y2(t)\Delta y(t) = y_1(t) - y_2(t), not 12g(Δt)2\frac{1}{2}g(\Delta t)^2.

  • Calculate y1(3.00)y_1(3.00) and y2(3.00)y_2(3.00) separately, then subtract them to find the true gap.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the elapsed time for each pebble at t=3.00 st = 3.00\text{ s}: Pebble 1 has fallen for t1=3.00 st_1 = 3.00\text{ s}, and Pebble 2 has fallen for t2=3.00 s−1.00 s=2.00 st_2 = 3.00\text{ s} - 1.00\text{ s} = 2.00\text{ s}.

  2. Compute Pebble 1's position: y1=12(9.80 m/s2)(3.00 s)2=44.1 my_1 = \frac{1}{2}(9.80\text{ m/s}^2)(3.00\text{ s})^2 = 44.1\text{ m}.

  3. Compute Pebble 2's position: y2=12(9.80 m/s2)(2.00 s)2=19.6 my_2 = \frac{1}{2}(9.80\text{ m/s}^2)(2.00\text{ s})^2 = 19.6\text{ m}.

  4. Subtract the two positions: Δy=y1−y2=44.1 m−19.6 m=24.5 m\Delta y = y_1 - y_2 = 44.1\text{ m} - 19.6\text{ m} = 24.5\text{ m}.

Final answer

Δy=24.5 m\Delta y = 24.5\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice setting up individual position equations y1(t)y_1(t) and y2(t)y_2(t) whenever multiple objects move with a time offset.

  • Remember that the initial displacement at the moment of release is only the starting separation, which grows continuously under uniform acceleration.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student squares the difference between the fall times instead of taking the difference of their squares when calculating the separation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Relative velocity is v1−v2=g(1.00 s)>0v_1 - v_2 = g(1.00\text{ s}) > 0. ⟹ Because the leading pebble is always faster, the distance increases over time.

  2. Step 2

    t1=3.00 st_1 = 3.00\text{ s}, t2=2.00 s  ⟹  Δt=3.00−2.00=1.00 st_2 = 2.00\text{ s} \implies \Delta t = 3.00 - 2.00 = 1.00\text{ s}

  3. Step 3

    Δy=12g(t1−t2)2\Delta y = \frac{1}{2}g(t_1 - t_2)^2

    Correct

    Δy=y1−y2=12gt12−12gt22=12g(t12−t22)\Delta y = y_1 - y_2 = \frac{1}{2}g t_1^2 - \frac{1}{2}g t_2^2 = \frac{1}{2}g\left(t_1^2 - t_2^2\right)

    Vertical position depends quadratically on each object's elapsed time, meaning Δy=y1−y2=12gt12−12gt22\Delta y = y_1 - y_2 = \frac{1}{2}gt_1^2 - \frac{1}{2}gt_2^2. In general, t12−t22≠(t1−t2)2t_1^2 - t_2^2 \neq (t_1 - t_2)^2.

  4. Step 4

    Δy=0.5×9.80×(1.00)2=4.90 m\Delta y = 0.5 \times 9.80 \times (1.00)^2 = 4.90\text{ m}

    Correct

    Δy=0.5×9.80×(3.002−2.002)=0.5×9.80×5.00=24.5 m\Delta y = 0.5 \times 9.80 \times \left(3.00^2 - 2.00^2\right) = 0.5 \times 9.80 \times 5.00 = 24.5\text{ m}

    Evaluating your formula produced 4.90 m4.90\text{ m}, which represents only the distance fallen during the very first second rather than the actual separation at t=3.00 st = 3.00\text{ s}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that a constant positive relative velocity causes the gap between the pebbles to expand over time.

You accurately identified the elapsed fall times for both pebbles at t=3.00 st = 3.00\text{ s}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Difference of squares vs. square of difference

You squared the time difference (t1−t2)(t_1 - t_2) rather than subtracting the squared times (t12−t22)(t_1^2 - t_2^2).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the separation of positions Δy=y(t1)−y(t2)\Delta y = y(t_1) - y(t_2) with applying the kinematic formula to the time interval Δt\Delta t. Because y(t)∝t2y(t) \propto t^2, displacement is nonlinear with time, so y1−y2≠12g(Δt)2y_1 - y_2 \ne \frac{1}{2}g(\Delta t)^2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Difference of Squares in Kinematics
  • Δy=y1−y2=12at12−12at22=12a(t12−t22)\Delta y = y_1 - y_2 = \frac{1}{2}a t_1^2 - \frac{1}{2}a t_2^2 = \frac{1}{2}a(t_1^2 - t_2^2)

  • Calculate the position of each object individually, or factor out the constant acceleration to take the difference between their squared times: t12−t22t_1^2 - t_2^2.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write each pebble's position from the release point: y1=12gt12y_1 = \frac{1}{2}gt_1^2 and y2=12gt22y_2 = \frac{1}{2}gt_2^2.

  2. Subtract the positions to find the separation: Δy=y1−y2=12g(t12−t22)\Delta y = y_1 - y_2 = \frac{1}{2}g\left(t_1^2 - t_2^2\right).

  3. Substitute t1=3.00 st_1 = 3.00\text{ s}, t2=2.00 st_2 = 2.00\text{ s}, and g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2: Δy=12(9.80)(3.002−2.002)=4.90×(9.00−4.00)=4.90×5.00=24.5 m\Delta y = \frac{1}{2}(9.80)(3.00^2 - 2.00^2) = 4.90 \times (9.00 - 4.00) = 4.90 \times 5.00 = 24.5\text{ m}.

Final answer

The separation increases linearly with time; vertical separation Δy=24.5 m\Delta y = 24.5\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always calculate individual positions y1(t)y_1(t) and y2(t)y_2(t) first before subtracting them to find spatial separation.

  • Remember that 12g(Δt)2\frac{1}{2}g(\Delta t)^2 only gives the distance an object falls from rest during a time span Δt\Delta t, not the distance between two objects moving at different speeds.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A stone is dropped from rest from a bridge. Exactly 2.0 s2.0\text{ s} later, a second stone is dropped from rest from the same spot. Taking g=9.8 m/s2g = 9.8\text{ m/s}^2, determine the vertical separation between the two stones at t=4.0 st = 4.0\text{ s} after the first stone was released.

Answer

At t=4.0 st = 4.0\text{ s}, stone 1 falls for t1=4.0 st_1 = 4.0\text{ s} giving y1=12(9.8)(4.0)2=78.4 my_1 = \frac{1}{2}(9.8)(4.0)^2 = 78.4\text{ m}. Stone 2 falls for t2=2.0 st_2 = 2.0\text{ s} giving y2=12(9.8)(2.0)2=19.6 my_2 = \frac{1}{2}(9.8)(2.0)^2 = 19.6\text{ m}. Vertical separation Δy=78.4 m−19.6 m=58.8 m\Delta y = 78.4\text{ m} - 19.6\text{ m} = 58.8\text{ m}.

02

Two balls are dropped from rest from the same point, one release occurring Δt\Delta t seconds after the other. Derive a formula for the rate of change of their vertical separation with respect to time, d(Δy)dt\frac{d(\Delta y)}{dt}, while both are in free fall under acceleration gg.

Answer

Separation is Δy(t)=12gt2−12g(t−Δt)2=gΔt(t−Δt2)\Delta y(t) = \frac{1}{2}gt^2 - \frac{1}{2}g(t - \Delta t)^2 = g\Delta t\left(t - \frac{\Delta t}{2}\right). Differentiating with respect to tt gives d(Δy)dt=gΔt\frac{d(\Delta y)}{dt} = g\Delta t, which is a constant rate.

03

Pebble 1 is dropped from rest from the top of a cliff. After it has fallen a vertical distance of 4.9 m4.9\text{ m}, pebble 2 is dropped from rest from the same cliff edge (g=9.8 m/s2g = 9.8\text{ m/s}^2). How far apart will the two pebbles be when pebble 1 has been falling for a total of 3.0 s3.0\text{ s}?

Answer

Pebble 1 falls 4.9 m4.9\text{ m} in time t0=2(4.9)9.8=1.0 st_0 = \sqrt{\frac{2(4.9)}{9.8}} = 1.0\text{ s}, meaning pebble 2 is released at t=1.0 st = 1.0\text{ s}. At t=3.0 st = 3.0\text{ s}, pebble 1 has fallen y1=12(9.8)(3.0)2=44.1 my_1 = \frac{1}{2}(9.8)(3.0)^2 = 44.1\text{ m}, and pebble 2 has fallen for 2.0 s2.0\text{ s} to y2=12(9.8)(2.0)2=19.6 my_2 = \frac{1}{2}(9.8)(2.0)^2 = 19.6\text{ m}. The separation is Δy=44.1 m−19.6 m=24.5 m\Delta y = 44.1\text{ m} - 19.6\text{ m} = 24.5\text{ m}.

Loading workspace…