Resources

During an introductory physics lab on internal resistance and non-ideal meters, a student calibrates a real DC voltage source using a voltmeter and an ammeter. The non-ideal voltmeter has an internal resistance of RV=20.0 kΩR_V = 20.0\text{ k}\Omega, and the non-ideal ammeter has an internal resistance of RA=0.500 ΩR_A = 0.500\,\Omega. The circuit is arranged such that the battery (with EMF E\mathcal{E} and internal resistance rr) is placed in series with a decade resistance box set to Rbox=19.5 ΩR_{\text{box}} = 19.5\,\Omega, the ammeter, and a switch. The voltmeter is connected directly across the terminals of the battery. When the switch is open, the voltmeter reads 12.00 V12.00\text{ V}. When the switch is closed, the ammeter reads 0.571 A0.571\text{ A} while the voltmeter reads 11.42 V11.42\text{ V}. Accounting for the finite internal resistance of both instruments, calculate (a) the true EMF E\mathcal{E} of the battery, and (b) the internal resistance rr of the battery.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) E=12.0 V\mathcal{E} = 12.0\text{ V}; (b) r=1.01 Ωr = 1.01\,\Omega

Steps

01

Terminal Voltage Relationship

A real battery of electromotive force E\mathcal{E} and internal resistance rr provides a terminal voltage VV given by: V=E−ItotalrV = \mathcal{E} - I_{\text{total}} r where ItotalI_{\text{total}} is the total current drawn from the battery.


02

State 1: Switch Open

When the switch is open, the branch with the resistance box and the ammeter is disconnected. The only load connected across the battery's terminals is the voltmeter of resistance RV=20.0 kΩ=2.00×104 ΩR_V = 20.0\text{ k}\Omega = 2.00 \times 10^4\,\Omega.

The current drawn by the voltmeter is: I1=ERV+rI_1 = \frac{\mathcal{E}}{R_V + r}

The terminal voltage measured by the voltmeter is V1=12.00 VV_1 = 12.00\text{ V}: V1=I1RV=E(RVRV+r)V_1 = I_1 R_V = \mathcal{E} \left(\frac{R_V}{R_V + r}\right)

Rearranging for E\mathcal{E}: E=V1(1+rRV)\mathcal{E} = V_1 \left(1 + \frac{r}{R_V}\right)

Because RV=20 000 ΩR_V = 20\,000\,\Omega is many orders of magnitude larger than a typical battery internal resistance (r∼1 Ωr \sim 1\,\Omega), the ratio rRV≈5×10−5≪1\frac{r}{R_V} \approx 5 \times 10^{-5} \ll 1. Thus, the voltage drop across the internal resistance with only the voltmeter connected is negligibly small (I1r≈0.0006 VI_1 r \approx 0.0006\text{ V}): E≈V1=12.0 V\mathcal{E} \approx V_1 = 12.0\text{ V}


03

State 2: Switch Closed

When the switch is closed, current flows through two parallel paths across the battery terminals:

  1. Voltmeter branch: The voltmeter reads V2=11.42 VV_2 = 11.42\text{ V}. IV=V2RV=11.42 V20 000 Ω=5.71×10−4 A=0.000571 AI_V = \frac{V_2}{R_V} = \frac{11.42\text{ V}}{20\,000\,\Omega} = 5.71 \times 10^{-4}\text{ A} = 0.000571\text{ A}
  2. Ammeter branch: The ammeter directly measures the current flowing through the series combination of RboxR_{\text{box}} and RAR_A: IA=0.571 AI_A = 0.571\text{ A}

The total current supplied by the battery is the sum of the currents in both branches: Itotal=IA+IV=0.571 A+0.000571 A=0.571571 AI_{\text{total}} = I_A + I_V = 0.571\text{ A} + 0.000571\text{ A} = 0.571571\text{ A}


04

Calculating the Internal Resistance rr

Using the terminal voltage equation for the closed state: V2=E−ItotalrV_2 = \mathcal{E} - I_{\text{total}} r

Rearranging for the internal resistance rr: r=E−V2Itotal=12.00 V−11.42 V0.571571 A=0.58 V0.571571 A≈1.0147 Ω≈1.01 Ωr = \frac{\mathcal{E} - V_2}{I_{\text{total}}} = \frac{12.00\text{ V} - 11.42\text{ V}}{0.571571\text{ A}} = \frac{0.58\text{ V}}{0.571571\text{ A}} \approx 1.0147\,\Omega \approx 1.01\,\Omega

(Note: Substituting this value of rr back into the expression for E\mathcal{E} gives E=12.00(1+1.0120000)=12.0006 V\mathcal{E} = 12.00\left(1 + \frac{1.01}{20000}\right) = 12.0006\text{ V}, which confirms E=12.0 V\mathcal{E} = 12.0\text{ V} to three significant figures.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes the open-circuit voltmeter reading directly equals the true EMF by neglecting voltmeter current, and takes the closed circuit current to simply be the ammeter reading without accounting for voltmeter current.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    When switch is open, no current flows, so E=Vopen  ⟹  E=12.00 V\text{When switch is open, no current flows, so } \mathcal{E} = V_{\text{open}} \implies \mathcal{E} = 12.00\text{ V}

    Correct

    I1=ERV+r  ⟹  V1=E(RVRV+r)≈E=12.0 VI_1 = \frac{\mathcal{E}}{R_V + r} \implies V_1 = \mathcal{E}\left(\frac{R_V}{R_V + r}\right) \approx \mathcal{E} = 12.0\text{ V}

    Because the non-ideal voltmeter has a finite resistance of RV=20.0 kΩR_V = 20.0\text{ k}\Omega, a small current still flows through the battery and voltmeter even when the switch is open. While E≈12.0 V\mathcal{E} \approx 12.0\text{ V} to three significant figures, stating that no current flows overlooks the meter's finite resistance.

  2. Step 2

    Vclosed=E−I⋅r  ⟹  11.42=12.00−0.571⋅r  ⟹  0.571⋅r=0.58  ⟹  r=0.580.571=1.016 ΩV_{\text{closed}} = \mathcal{E} - I \cdot r \implies 11.42 = 12.00 - 0.571 \cdot r \implies 0.571 \cdot r = 0.58 \implies r = \frac{0.58}{0.571} = 1.016\,\Omega

    Correct

    Itotal=IA+IV=0.571 A+11.42 V20 000 Ω=0.571571 A  ⟹  r=12.00 V−11.42 V0.571571 A≈1.01 ΩI_{\text{total}} = I_A + I_V = 0.571\text{ A} + \frac{11.42\text{ V}}{20\,000\,\Omega} = 0.571571\text{ A} \implies r = \frac{12.00\text{ V} - 11.42\text{ V}}{0.571571\text{ A}} \approx 1.01\,\Omega

    You used only the ammeter reading for the battery current. The voltmeter is connected in parallel across the battery terminals, so it also draws current (IV=V2RV=0.571 mAI_V = \frac{V_2}{R_V} = 0.571\text{ mA}). The total current leaving the battery is Itotal=IA+IV=0.571571 AI_{\text{total}} = I_A + I_V = 0.571571\text{ A}, yielding r≈1.01 Ωr \approx 1.01\,\Omega.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled the terminal voltage relationship V=E−IrV = \mathcal{E} - Ir for a real DC power source.

You correctly identified that the open-circuit terminal voltage closely approximates the battery EMF.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Neglecting voltmeter loading current in non-ideal meter analysis

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the voltmeter as an ideal open circuit (RV=∞R_V = \infty) rather than accounting for its finite internal resistance (RV=20.0 kΩR_V = 20.0\text{ k}\Omega) as specified by the problem, missing the parallel current IVI_V drawn by the voltmeter.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Acknowledge Non-Ideal Voltmeter Branch
  • A real voltmeter with resistance RVR_V connected in parallel across a voltage VV draws a finite current IV=VRVI_V = \frac{V}{R_V}.

  • Always draw the voltmeter as a resistor RVR_V in parallel with the terminals and sum branch currents at the terminal node.

Apply Junction Rule at Battery Terminals
  • By Kirchhoff's current law, the total current supplied by the battery is the sum of currents entering all connected parallel branches: Itotal=Iload+IVI_{\text{total}} = I_{\text{load}} + I_V.

  • Add the current through the voltmeter branch to the ammeter branch current before substituting into V=E−ItotalrV = \mathcal{E} - I_{\text{total}}r.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the voltmeter current during the closed-switch state: IV=V2RV=11.42 V20 000 Ω=0.000571 AI_V = \frac{V_2}{R_V} = \frac{11.42\text{ V}}{20\,000\,\Omega} = 0.000571\text{ A}.

  2. Determine total current supplied by the battery: Itotal=IA+IV=0.571 A+0.000571 A=0.571571 AI_{\text{total}} = I_A + I_V = 0.571\text{ A} + 0.000571\text{ A} = 0.571571\text{ A}.

  3. Solve for the internal resistance: r=E−V2Itotal=12.00 V−11.42 V0.571571 A=0.58 V0.571571 A≈1.01 Ωr = \frac{\mathcal{E} - V_2}{I_{\text{total}}} = \frac{12.00\text{ V} - 11.42\text{ V}}{0.571571\text{ A}} = \frac{0.58\text{ V}}{0.571571\text{ A}} \approx 1.01\,\Omega.

Final answer

(a) E=12.0 V\mathcal{E} = 12.0\text{ V}; (b) r=1.01 Ωr = 1.01\,\Omega

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Include non-ideal meters as explicit resistors in your circuit diagram before writing loop or node equations.

  • Check Kirchhoff's Current Law at nodes where voltmeters connect to confirm whether meter branch current is negligible or required by the problem.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student mistakenly includes the ammeter resistance R_A as part of the battery's internal resistance r by calculating equivalent circuit resistance instead of applying terminal voltage directly.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Iopen=12.0020000=0.0006 A  ⟹  E≈12.00 VI_{\text{open}} = \frac{12.00}{20000} = 0.0006\text{ A} \implies \mathcal{E} \approx 12.00\text{ V}

  2. Step 2

    Rtotal=EI=12.000.571=21.016 ΩR_{\text{total}} = \frac{\mathcal{E}}{I} = \frac{12.00}{0.571} = 21.016\,\Omega

    Correct

    Itotal=IA+IV=0.571 A+11.42 V20 000 Ω=0.571571 AI_{\text{total}} = I_A + I_V = 0.571\text{ A} + \frac{11.42\text{ V}}{20\,000\,\Omega} = 0.571571\text{ A}

    You assumed all battery current passes through the ammeter branch. Because the non-ideal voltmeter is connected in parallel across the battery terminals, it also draws current (IV=11.42 V20 000 Ω≈0.000571 AI_V = \frac{11.42\text{ V}}{20\,000\,\Omega} \approx 0.000571\text{ A}), which must be added to IAI_A to find the total battery current.

  3. Step 3

    Rtotal=Rbox+RA+r  ⟹  21.016=19.5+0.500+r  ⟹  r=1.016 ΩR_{\text{total}} = R_{\text{box}} + R_A + r \implies 21.016 = 19.5 + 0.500 + r \implies r = 1.016\,\Omega

    Correct

    r=E−V2Itotal=12.00 V−11.42 V0.571571 A≈1.01 Ωr = \frac{\mathcal{E} - V_2}{I_{\text{total}}} = \frac{12.00\text{ V} - 11.42\text{ V}}{0.571571\text{ A}} \approx 1.01\,\Omega

    Because your total current omitted the voltmeter's branch current, your calculation for internal resistance was slightly high and rounded to 1.02 Ω1.02\,\Omega instead of the exact 1.01 Ω1.01\,\Omega.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the high internal resistance of the voltmeter to find that the open-circuit terminal voltage gives E≈12.0 V\mathcal{E} \approx 12.0\text{ V}.

You accounted for the ammeter's internal resistance RA=0.500 ΩR_A = 0.500\,\Omega in the load branch.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted parallel voltmeter branch current

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating a multi-branch parallel circuit as a simple single-loop series circuit when accounting for non-ideal meters. A voltmeter connected directly across battery terminals forms a parallel branch that draws current whenever the circuit is active.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify All Branches Connected Across Terminals
  • When a real voltmeter is placed across the terminals of a power source, it acts as a parallel resistor RVR_V carrying current IV=VRVI_V = \frac{V}{R_V}.

  • Apply junction rule Itotal=Iload+IVI_{\text{total}} = I_{\text{load}} + I_V before computing internal resistance drops.

Use Terminal Voltage Directly
  • The terminal voltage equation V=E−ItotalrV = \mathcal{E} - I_{\text{total}}r isolates rr directly from the measured closed-switch terminal voltage V2=11.42 VV_2 = 11.42\text{ V}.

  • Compute r=E−V2Itotalr = \frac{\mathcal{E} - V_2}{I_{\text{total}}} instead of taking ratios of EMF to branch current.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the current drawn by the voltmeter branch in State 2: IV=V2RV=11.42 V20 000 Ω=0.000571 AI_V = \frac{V_2}{R_V} = \frac{11.42\text{ V}}{20\,000\,\Omega} = 0.000571\text{ A}.

  2. Determine the total current drawn from the battery: Itotal=IA+IV=0.571 A+0.000571 A=0.571571 AI_{\text{total}} = I_A + I_V = 0.571\text{ A} + 0.000571\text{ A} = 0.571571\text{ A}.

  3. Solve for the internal resistance using terminal voltage: r=E−V2Itotal=12.00 V−11.42 V0.571571 A=0.58 V0.571571 A≈1.01 Ωr = \frac{\mathcal{E} - V_2}{I_{\text{total}}} = \frac{12.00\text{ V} - 11.42\text{ V}}{0.571571\text{ A}} = \frac{0.58\text{ V}}{0.571571\text{ A}} \approx 1.01\,\Omega.

Final answer

(a) E=12.0 V\mathcal{E} = 12.0\text{ V}; (b) r=1.01 Ωr = 1.01\,\Omega

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Draw circuit diagrams showing meters as explicit resistors (RVR_V and RAR_A) to see junction splits clearly.

  • Practice using the terminal voltage equation V=E−IrV = \mathcal{E} - Ir directly whenever terminal voltage is measured.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A battery with EMF E=9.00 V\mathcal{E} = 9.00\text{ V} and internal resistance r=2.00 Ωr = 2.00\,\Omega is connected across a voltmeter of internal resistance RV=1.00 kΩR_V = 1.00\text{ k}\Omega. No other load is attached. Calculate the terminal voltage reading on the voltmeter.

Answer

V=8.98 VV = 8.98\text{ V}. By voltage division, V=E(RVRV+r)=9.00(10001002)≈8.982 VV = \mathcal{E}\left(\frac{R_V}{R_V + r}\right) = 9.00\left(\frac{1000}{1002}\right) \approx 8.982\text{ V}.

02

A real DC power supply is connected to a load branch and a parallel voltmeter. The voltmeter has internal resistance RV=5.00 kΩR_V = 5.00\text{ k}\Omega and reads 10.00 V10.00\text{ V}. An ammeter in the load branch measures 0.498 A0.498\text{ A}. If the open-circuit EMF is known to be 10.50 V10.50\text{ V}, find the power supply's internal resistance rr.

Answer

r=1.00 Ωr = 1.00\,\Omega. The voltmeter draws IV=10.00 V5000 Ω=0.002 AI_V = \frac{10.00\text{ V}}{5000\,\Omega} = 0.002\text{ A}. The total current is Itotal=Iload+IV=0.498 A+0.002 A=0.500 AI_{\text{total}} = I_{\text{load}} + I_V = 0.498\text{ A} + 0.002\text{ A} = 0.500\text{ A}. Then r=E−VItotal=10.50−10.000.500=1.00 Ωr = \frac{\mathcal{E} - V}{I_{\text{total}}} = \frac{10.50 - 10.00}{0.500} = 1.00\,\Omega.

03

A circuit contains a battery with unknown E\mathcal{E} and rr. A non-ideal voltmeter (RV=10.0 kΩR_V = 10.0\text{ k}\Omega) connected across the battery reads 6.00 V6.00\text{ V} with no load. When a resistor R=14.0 ΩR = 14.0\,\Omega is connected in parallel with the voltmeter, the reading drops to 5.60 V5.60\text{ V}. Calculate both the battery EMF E\mathcal{E} and internal resistance rr, accounting for meter loading.

Answer

E≈6.00 V\mathcal{E} \approx 6.00\text{ V}, r=1.00 Ωr = 1.00\,\Omega. With load connected, IR=5.6014.0=0.400 AI_R = \frac{5.60}{14.0} = 0.400\text{ A} and IV=5.6010 000=0.00056 AI_V = \frac{5.60}{10\,000} = 0.00056\text{ A}, so Itotal=0.40056 AI_{\text{total}} = 0.40056\text{ A}. Open-circuit gives E=6.00(1+r104)≈6.00 V\mathcal{E} = 6.00\left(1 + \frac{r}{10^4}\right) \approx 6.00\text{ V}. Then r=6.00−5.600.40056≈1.00 Ωr = \frac{6.00 - 5.60}{0.40056} \approx 1.00\,\Omega.

Loading workspace…