Resources

Two autonomous rovers, Rover A and Rover B, move along identical parallel tracks along the xx-axis. Rover A maintains a constant forward velocity of vA=4.50 m/sv_A = 4.50\text{ m/s} starting from xA0=0 mx_{A0} = 0\text{ m} at t=0 st = 0\text{ s}. Rover B starts ahead at xB0=150 mx_{B0} = 150\text{ m} and moves in the same direction at a lower constant velocity vBv_B. Determine the critical threshold velocity vB,critv_{B,\text{crit}} for Rover B such that Rover A overtakes Rover B exactly at the boundary of a 600 m600\text{ m} operational corridor (x=600 mx = 600\text{ m}). State whether Rover A can overtake Rover B within the corridor if vB>vB,critv_B > v_{B,\text{crit}}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

vB,crit=3.38 m/sv_{B,\text{crit}} = 3.38\text{ m/s}; if vB>vB,critv_B > v_{B,\text{crit}}, Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the corridor.

Steps

01

Write the equations of motion for both rovers

Both rovers travel along the positive xx-axis at constant speeds. Using the uniform motion formula x(t)=x0+v⋅tx(t) = x_0 + v \cdot t:

  • For Rover A: xA(t)=xA0+vA⋅t=0+4.50t=4.50tx_A(t) = x_{A0} + v_A \cdot t = 0 + 4.50 t = 4.50 t
  • For Rover B: xB(t)=xB0+vB⋅t=150+vB⋅tx_B(t) = x_{B0} + v_B \cdot t = 150 + v_B \cdot t

02

Determine the time Rover A reaches the boundary

Rover A reaches the boundary of the operational corridor at x=600 mx = 600\text{ m}. We set xA(t)=600 mx_A(t) = 600\text{ m} to find the arrival time tendt_{\text{end}}:

4.50tend=6004.50 t_{\text{end}} = 600

tend=6004.50=4003 s≈133.33 st_{\text{end}} = \frac{600}{4.50} = \frac{400}{3}\text{ s} \approx 133.33\text{ s}


03

Calculate the critical velocity vB,critv_{B,\text{crit}}

For Rover A to overtake Rover B exactly at the corridor boundary, both rovers must occupy the same position x=600 mx = 600\text{ m} at time tend=4003 st_{\text{end}} = \frac{400}{3}\text{ s}:

xB(4003)=150+vB,crit⋅(4003)=600x_B\left(\frac{400}{3}\right) = 150 + v_{B,\text{crit}} \cdot \left(\frac{400}{3}\right) = 600

Subtract 150 m150\text{ m} (the displacement covered by Rover B):

vB,crit⋅(4003)=450v_{B,\text{crit}} \cdot \left(\frac{400}{3}\right) = 450

Solve for vB,critv_{B,\text{crit}}:

vB,crit=450⋅3400=1350400=3.375 m/s≈3.38 m/sv_{B,\text{crit}} = \frac{450 \cdot 3}{400} = \frac{1350}{400} = 3.375\text{ m/s} \approx 3.38\text{ m/s}


04

Analyze the condition when vB>vB,critv_B > v_{B,\text{crit}}

The relative position between Rover B and Rover A at any time tt is:

Δx(t)=xB(t)−xA(t)=150−(vA−vB)t\Delta x(t) = x_B(t) - x_A(t) = 150 - (v_A - v_B)t

  • The time of overtaking tovertaket_{\text{overtake}} occurs when Δx(t)=0\Delta x(t) = 0, giving tovertake=150vA−vBt_{\text{overtake}} = \frac{150}{v_A - v_B}.
  • If vB>vB,critv_B > v_{B,\text{crit}}, Rover B travels faster, so the relative closing speed (vA−vB)(v_A - v_B) decreases. Consequently, tovertake>tendt_{\text{overtake}} > t_{\text{end}}, which means the overtake position satisfies xovertake=vA⋅tovertake>600 mx_{\text{overtake}} = v_A \cdot t_{\text{overtake}} > 600\text{ m}.

Therefore, if vB>vB,critv_B > v_{B,\text{crit}}, Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the 600 m600\text{ m} corridor.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student ignores Rover B's initial position offset and uses the total corridor distance of 600 m to calculate Rover B's velocity, yielding an incorrect critical speed of 4.50 m/s.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    t=600/4.50=133.33 st = 600 / 4.50 = 133.33\text{ s}

  2. Step 2

    vB,crit=600/133.33=4.50 m/sv_{B, \text{crit}} = 600 / 133.33 = 4.50\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vB,crit=x−xB0t=600−150133.33=450133.33≈3.38 m/sv_{B, \text{crit}} = \frac{x - x_{B0}}{t} = \frac{600 - 150}{133.33} = \frac{450}{133.33} \approx 3.38\text{ m/s}

    You used the final position 600 m600\text{ m} as Rover B's travel distance, but Rover B started with a 150 m150\text{ m} head start at xB0=150 mx_{B0} = 150\text{ m}, meaning Rover B only traveled a displacement of ΔxB=600 m−150 m=450 m\Delta x_B = 600\text{ m} - 150\text{ m} = 450\text{ m}.

  3. Step 3

    No, Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the corridor if vB>4.50 m/s.\text{No, Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the corridor if } v_B > 4.50\text{ m/s}.

    Correct

    No, Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the corridor if vB>3.38 m/s.\text{No, Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the corridor if } v_B > 3.38\text{ m/s}.

    Your qualitative reasoning that Rover A cannot overtake Rover B if Rover B exceeds the critical threshold is correct, but your statement inherited the incorrect numerical threshold from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the time elapsed before Rover A arrives at the 600 m600\text{ m} corridor boundary.

You understood the qualitative condition that moving faster than the critical speed prevents an overtake within the boundary.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Initial position omitted from displacement calculation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated coordinate position xx with displacement Δx=x−x0\Delta x = x - x_0, assuming that Rover B traversed the entire 600 m600\text{ m} corridor rather than accounting for its initial position at xB0=150 mx_{B0} = 150\text{ m}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Displacement vs. Position
  • Average velocity is displacement over time: v=ΔxΔt=xf−x0Δtv = \frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t} = \frac{x_f - x_0}{\Delta t}, not xfΔt\frac{x_f}{\Delta t}.

  • Always write out Δx=xf−x0\Delta x = x_f - x_0 before dividing by time whenever an object starts at a non-zero coordinate.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find Rover B's displacement: ΔxB=xfinal−xB0=600 m−150 m=450 m\Delta x_B = x_{\text{final}} - x_{B0} = 600\text{ m} - 150\text{ m} = 450\text{ m}.

  2. Calculate the critical velocity: vB,crit=ΔxBtend=450 m133.33 s=3.375 m/s≈3.38 m/sv_{B,\text{crit}} = \frac{\Delta x_B}{t_{\text{end}}} = \frac{450\text{ m}}{133.33\text{ s}} = 3.375\text{ m/s} \approx 3.38\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

vB,crit=3.38 m/sv_{B,\text{crit}} = 3.38\text{ m/s}; Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the corridor if vB>3.38 m/sv_B > 3.38\text{ m/s}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch a 1D position line or label x0x_0 clearly on problem diagrams before writing equations.

  • Check each kinematic term to ensure displacement Δx\Delta x is used rather than coordinate xx.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student calculates the critical velocity correctly but mistakenly concludes that a higher velocity for Rover B allows Rover A to overtake sooner within the corridor.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    t=6004.50=133.33 st = \frac{600}{4.50} = 133.33\text{ s}

  2. Step 2

    ΔxB=600−150=450 m  ⟹  vB,crit=450133.33=3.375 m/s\Delta x_B = 600 - 150 = 450\text{ m} \implies v_{B,\text{crit}} = \frac{450}{133.33} = 3.375\text{ m/s}

  3. Step 3

    Yes, Rover A can overtake Rover B within the corridor if vB>3.375 m/s because both rovers move faster.\text{Yes, Rover A can overtake Rover B within the corridor if } v_B > 3.375\text{ m/s} \text{ because both rovers move faster.}

    Correct

    No, if vB>vB,crit, Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the corridor.\text{No, if } v_B > v_{B,\text{crit}}\text{, Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the corridor.}

    When Rover B travels faster (vB>vB,critv_B > v_{B,\text{crit}}), the closing relative speed vrel=vA−vBv_{\text{rel}} = v_A - v_B decreases. This means Rover A requires more time and greater distance to close the initial 150 m150\text{ m} gap, so overtaking occurs past the 600 m600\text{ m} mark.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the total time Rover A takes to reach the corridor limit.

You accurately determined Rover B's required displacement and corresponding critical velocity vB,critv_{B,\text{crit}}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Relative Motion Misconception

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated an increase in Rover B's speed as facilitating the overtaking process rather than considering how it reduces the relative closing velocity between the two rovers.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Relative Velocity in Overtaking
  • The time to close a leading gap Δx0\Delta x_0 is t=Δx0vA−vBt = \frac{\Delta x_0}{v_A - v_B}, which depends inversely on the relative speed vrel=vA−vBv_{\text{rel}} = v_A - v_B.

  • Always check how changing the target's speed affects the gap closure rate: if the target moves faster, the relative closing speed decreases, increasing both the overtake time and overtake position.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the condition for the overtake position: xovertake=vA⋅tovertake=vA⋅150vA−vBx_{\text{overtake}} = v_A \cdot t_{\text{overtake}} = v_A \cdot \frac{150}{v_A - v_B}.

  2. Observe that when vB>vB,critv_B > v_{B,\text{crit}}, the denominator (vA−vB)(v_A - v_B) decreases, which makes tovertake>133.33 st_{\text{overtake}} > 133.33\text{ s}.

  3. Calculate the resulting position: xovertake=4.50⋅tovertake>4.50⋅133.33 s=600 mx_{\text{overtake}} = 4.50 \cdot t_{\text{overtake}} > 4.50 \cdot 133.33\text{ s} = 600\text{ m}.

Final answer

vB,crit=3.38 m/sv_{B,\text{crit}} = 3.38\text{ m/s}; Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the corridor if vB>vB,critv_B > v_{B,\text{crit}}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Express overtaking problems using the frame of relative velocity: vrel=vchaser−vleadv_{\text{rel}} = v_{\text{chaser}} - v_{\text{lead}}.

  • Perform an extreme-case test: imagine vBv_B is just below vAv_A (e.g., 4.49 m/s4.49\text{ m/s}); Rover A would barely close the gap and would need thousands of meters to catch up.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates the time using Rover B's initial position instead of the corridor length, finding t = 150 / 4.50 = 33.33 s and leading to an incorrect velocity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    t=1504.50=33.33 st = \frac{150}{4.50} = 33.33\text{ s}

    Correct

    t=6004.50=133.33 st = \frac{600}{4.50} = 133.33\text{ s}

    You calculated the time it takes Rover A to reach Rover B's starting location (x=150 mx = 150\text{ m}). To find the critical velocity where overtaking occurs at the corridor boundary, Rover A must reach x=600 mx = 600\text{ m} from x=0 mx = 0\text{ m}, which requires t=600 m4.50 m/s=4003 s≈133.33 st = \frac{600\text{ m}}{4.50\text{ m/s}} = \frac{400}{3}\text{ s} \approx 133.33\text{ s}.

  2. Step 2

    vB,crit=600−15033.33=13.5 m/sv_{B,\text{crit}} = \frac{600 - 150}{33.33} = 13.5\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vB,crit=600−150133.33≈3.38 m/sv_{B,\text{crit}} = \frac{600 - 150}{133.33} \approx 3.38\text{ m/s}

    Your formula for Rover B's required velocity ΔxBt=600−150t\frac{\Delta x_B}{t} = \frac{600 - 150}{t} is conceptually sound, but substituting the incorrect time of 33.33 s33.33\text{ s} propagated the error to yield 13.5 m/s13.5\text{ m/s} instead of 3.38 m/s3.38\text{ m/s}.

  3. Step 3

    No, Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the corridor if vB>13.5 m/s.\text{No, Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the corridor if } v_B > 13.5\text{ m/s}.

    Correct

    No, Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the corridor if vB>3.38 m/s.\text{No, Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the corridor if } v_B > 3.38\text{ m/s}.

    Your qualitative reasoning is completely correct: if Rover B travels faster than the critical velocity, the overtake point shifts beyond the boundary. However, the numerical threshold reflects the earlier calculation error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the net displacement required for Rover B: ΔxB=600 m−150 m=450 m\Delta x_B = 600\text{ m} - 150\text{ m} = 450\text{ m}.

You correctly related Rover B's velocity to displacement and time using v=ΔxΔtv = \frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t}.

You correctly deduced that a velocity higher than critical prevents Rover A from overtaking within the corridor.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect Reference Position in Time Calculation

No

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the initial position of Rover B (x=150 mx = 150\text{ m}) with the event boundary (x=600 mx = 600\text{ m}) when determining the available time for Rover A. The elapsed time until overtaking at the boundary is governed by Rover A moving all the way from x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} to x=600 mx = 600\text{ m}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the Event Location
  • The total transit time tt is determined by the vehicle whose motion is fully known reaching the specified meeting coordinate xmeetx_{\text{meet}}: t=xmeet−x0vt = \frac{x_{\text{meet}} - x_{0}}{v}.

  • Always identify the target coordinate where the meeting occurs (x=600 mx = 600\text{ m}) and divide the full distance covered by Rover A (600 m−0 m600\text{ m} - 0\text{ m}) by its speed.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the total transit time for Rover A to reach the boundary: t=600 m−0 m4.50 m/s=4003 s≈133.33 st = \frac{600\text{ m} - 0\text{ m}}{4.50\text{ m/s}} = \frac{400}{3}\text{ s} \approx 133.33\text{ s}.

  2. Determine the displacement of Rover B over this duration: ΔxB=600 m−150 m=450 m\Delta x_B = 600\text{ m} - 150\text{ m} = 450\text{ m}.

  3. Divide Rover B's displacement by the transit time: vB,crit=450 m4003 s=1350400=3.375 m/s≈3.38 m/sv_{B,\text{crit}} = \frac{450\text{ m}}{\frac{400}{3}\text{ s}} = \frac{1350}{400} = 3.375\text{ m/s} \approx 3.38\text{ m/s}.

  4. Conclude the qualitative check: if vB>3.38 m/sv_B > 3.38\text{ m/s}, Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the 600 m600\text{ m} corridor.

Final answer

vB,crit=3.38 m/sv_{B,\text{crit}} = 3.38\text{ m/s}; if vB>3.38 m/sv_B > 3.38\text{ m/s}, Rover A cannot overtake Rover B within the corridor.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • When solving multi-object catch-up problems, sketch a single position axis (xx-axis) and clearly mark the starting positions and the target meeting location.

  • Double-check that the distance in t=Δxvt = \frac{\Delta x}{v} matches the full displacement between the object's start and the meeting point, not the initial gap between the two objects.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

Car 1 starts at x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} moving at 20 m/s20\text{ m/s}. Car 2 starts at x=100 mx = 100\text{ m} moving in the same direction at constant velocity v2v_2. If Car 1 catches Car 2 at x=500 mx = 500\text{ m}, find v2v_2.

Answer

v2=16 m/sv_2 = 16\text{ m/s}. Car 1 takes t=50020=25 st = \frac{500}{20} = 25\text{ s}. Car 2 travels Δx2=500−100=400 m\Delta x_2 = 500 - 100 = 400\text{ m}. Thus, v2=400 m25 s=16 m/sv_2 = \frac{400\text{ m}}{25\text{ s}} = 16\text{ m/s}.

02

Drone A flies from x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} at 12 m/s12\text{ m/s}. Drone B starts at x=180 mx = 180\text{ m} at t=0 st = 0\text{ s} and flies forward at a constant speed vBv_B. Determine the maximum speed Drone B can have if Drone A must overtake Drone B before or at a safety boundary located at x=720 mx = 720\text{ m}.

Answer

vB≤9.0 m/sv_B \le 9.0\text{ m/s}. Drone A reaches x=720 mx = 720\text{ m} at t=72012=60 st = \frac{720}{12} = 60\text{ s}. In that time, Drone B's displacement must be at most ΔxB=720−180=540 m\Delta x_B = 720 - 180 = 540\text{ m}. Therefore, vB≤54060=9.0 m/sv_B \le \frac{540}{60} = 9.0\text{ m/s}.

03

Sprinter A starts from x=0 mx = 0\text{ m} with speed 8.0 m/s8.0\text{ m/s}. Sprinter B starts 24 m24\text{ m} ahead at x=24 mx = 24\text{ m} with constant speed vBv_B. If Sprinter A overtakes Sprinter B exactly at the finish line at x=120 mx = 120\text{ m}, find vBv_B. If Sprinter B runs at 7.0 m/s7.0\text{ m/s}, does Sprinter A overtake Sprinter B before the finish line?

Answer

vB,crit=6.4 m/sv_{B,\text{crit}} = 6.4\text{ m/s}; No overtake before the finish line if vB=7.0 m/sv_B = 7.0\text{ m/s}. The race duration is t=1208.0=15 st = \frac{120}{8.0} = 15\text{ s}. Sprinter B covers Δx=120−24=96 m\Delta x = 120 - 24 = 96\text{ m}, yielding vB,crit=9615=6.4 m/sv_{B,\text{crit}} = \frac{96}{15} = 6.4\text{ m/s}. Since 7.0 m/s>6.4 m/s7.0\text{ m/s} > 6.4\text{ m/s}, Sprinter B finishes ahead, so Sprinter A cannot overtake Sprinter B within the race.

Loading workspace…