Resources

An object of mass m=8.00 kgm = 8.00\text{ kg} is supported on a flat horizontal surface and attached to an ideal linear spring of stiffness k=320 N/mk = 320\text{ N/m}. The surface exhibits static friction with coefficient μs=0.250\mu_s = 0.250. The spring is gradually pulled outward, increasing its extension xx. Taking g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2: (a) Identify the horizontal forces acting on the mass for extensions where x<xcx < x_c, at the threshold x=xcx = x_c, and in the limit x→∞x \to \infty (assuming the spring does not break). (b) Compute the critical threshold extension xcx_c where the static frictional force reaches its maximum possible value. (c) Analyze the asymptotic behavior: as xx becomes arbitrarily large (x≫xcx \gg x_c), explain how the relative contribution of the frictional force (fk/Fspring)(f_k / F_{\text{spring}}) approaches an extreme limit, given μk=0.200\mu_k = 0.200.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) For x<xcx < x_c: Elastic spring force F⃗spring\vec{F}_{\text{spring}} (in direction of stretch) balanced identically by static friction f⃗s\vec{f}_s (fs=kxf_s = kx). At x=xcx = x_c: F⃗spring\vec{F}_{\text{spring}} equals maximum static friction fs,max=μsmgf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s mg. In the limit x→∞x \to \infty: Elastic force grows unbounded (Fspring=kx→∞F_{\text{spring}} = kx \to \infty), while kinetic friction remains strictly bounded at its constant value fk=μkmg=15.7 Nf_k = \mu_k mg = 15.7\text{ N}. (b) xc=0.0613 mx_c = 0.0613\text{ m} (or 6.13 cm6.13\text{ cm}). (c) As x→∞x \to \infty, the ratio fkFspring=μkmgkx→0\frac{f_k}{F_{\text{spring}}} = \frac{\mu_k mg}{kx} \to 0, meaning the frictional resistance becomes completely negligible relative to the dominant elastic restoring force.

Steps

Part (a): Identifying Horizontal Forces Across Regimes

On a flat horizontal surface, the vertical forces acting on the mass are the downward gravitational force Fg=mgF_g = mg and the upward normal force FNF_N. Since there is no vertical acceleration: FN=mg=(8.00 kg)(9.80 m/s2)=78.4 NF_N = mg = (8.00\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2) = 78.4\text{ N}

The horizontal forces consist of:

  1. Elastic spring force: Given by Hooke's Law, Fspring=kxF_{\text{spring}} = kx, directed along the line of tension pulling the block.
  2. Friction force: Acting opposite to the direction of impending or actual motion.

Analyzing the three regimes:

  • For x<xcx < x_c (Static Equilibrium): The block remains stationary. Static friction is a responsive force that self-adjusts to balance the applied pulling force exactly: fs=Fspring=kxf_s = F_{\text{spring}} = kx The net horizontal force is zero (ΣFx=0\Sigma F_x = 0).
  • At the critical threshold x=xcx = x_c (Impending Motion): The static friction reaches its maximum limit: fs,max=μsFN=μsmgf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s F_N = \mu_s mg The spring force is exactly equal in magnitude to this maximum static friction: Fspring=fs,maxF_{\text{spring}} = f_{s,\text{max}}.
  • In the asymptotic limit x→∞x \to \infty (Motion/Slipping): Once x>xcx > x_c, the block slips, and the surface exerts a constant kinetic friction force: fk=μkmg=(0.200)(78.4 N)=15.68 N≈15.7 Nf_k = \mu_k mg = (0.200)(78.4\text{ N}) = 15.68\text{ N} \approx 15.7\text{ N} While fkf_k remains bounded at 15.7 N15.7\text{ N}, the elastic force Fspring=kxF_{\text{spring}} = kx grows without bound (Fspring→∞F_{\text{spring}} \to \infty).

Part (b): Computing the Critical Threshold Extension xcx_c

At the verge of slipping (x=xcx = x_c), the spring force equals the maximum static friction: kxc=μsmgk x_c = \mu_s mg

Solve for xcx_c: xc=μsmgk=0.250⋅78.4 N320 N/m=19.6 N320 N/m=0.06125 mx_c = \frac{\mu_s mg}{k} = \frac{0.250 \cdot 78.4\text{ N}}{320\text{ N/m}} = \frac{19.6\text{ N}}{320\text{ N/m}} = 0.06125\text{ m}

Rounding to three significant figures: xc≈0.0613 m(or 6.13 cm)x_c \approx 0.0613\text{ m} \quad (\text{or } 6.13\text{ cm})

Common Pitfall: Assuming static friction always equals μsmg\mu_s mg. The formula μsmg\mu_s mg only gives the upper threshold fs,maxf_{s,\text{max}}. For any extension x<xcx < x_c, the static friction is strictly equal to kxkx.


Part (c): Asymptotic Behavior as x→∞x \to \infty

When the block is moving (x>xcx > x_c), the opposing frictional force is kinetic friction fk=μkmgf_k = \mu_k mg, which is independent of the position xx.

The ratio of the frictional force to the spring force is: fkFspring=μkmgkx\frac{f_k}{F_{\text{spring}}} = \frac{\mu_k mg}{kx}

Taking the limit as xx becomes arbitrarily large (x→∞x \to \infty): lim⁡x→∞μkmgkx=0\lim_{x \to \infty} \frac{\mu_k mg}{kx} = 0

Physical interpretation: As the spring extension becomes very large, the restoring force of the spring completely dominates the system. The constant kinetic friction becomes negligible in comparison to the immense elastic force.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student treats static friction as always equal to its maximum value μ_s mg even before the threshold is reached.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    For x<xcx < x_c, friction is fs=μsmg=19.6 Nf_s = \mu_s mg = 19.6\text{ N}. At x=xcx = x_c, friction is fs,max=μsmg=19.6 Nf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s mg = 19.6\text{ N}. For x→∞x \to \infty, friction is kinetic friction fk=μkmgf_k = \mu_k mg.

    Correct

    For x<xcx < x_c: fs=Fspring=kxf_s = F_{\text{spring}} = kx (responsive static friction balancing the spring force). At x=xcx = x_c: fs,max=μsmg=19.6 Nf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s mg = 19.6\text{ N}. For x→∞x \to \infty: fk=μkmg=15.7 Nf_k = \mu_k mg = 15.7\text{ N} while Fspring=kx→∞F_{\text{spring}} = kx \to \infty.

    Before slipping occurs, static friction is a self-adjusting constraint force that matches the applied pulling force Fspring=kxF_{\text{spring}} = kx to keep the block in equilibrium. The expression μsmg\mu_s mg gives only the maximum upper limit of static friction, which is only reached at the critical threshold x=xcx = x_c.

  2. Step 2

    kxc=μsmg  ⟹  xc=0.250×8.00×9.80320=0.06125 mkx_c = \mu_s mg \implies x_c = \frac{0.250 \times 8.00 \times 9.80}{320} = 0.06125\text{ m}

  3. Step 3

    fkFspring=μkmgkx  ⟹  \frac{f_k}{F_{\text{spring}}} = \frac{\mu_k mg}{kx} \implies As x→∞x \to \infty, μkmgkx→0\frac{\mu_k mg}{kx} \to 0, so the ratio approaches 00.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the horizontal forces are the spring force and friction.

You correctly equated the spring force to maximum static friction at the threshold of motion to find xcx_c.

You correctly set up and evaluated the asymptotic limit of the ratio fk/Fspringf_k / F_{\text{spring}} as x→∞x \to \infty.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Static Friction Constant Assumption

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that static friction always equals its theoretical maximum μsN=μsmg\mu_s N = \mu_s mg at all times prior to motion, overlooking that static friction is an adjustable force satisfying fs≤μsNf_s \le \mu_s N and exactly equals the applied load kxkx during static equilibrium.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Static Friction as an Inequality
  • Static friction satisfies 0≤fs≤fs,max=μsFN0 \le f_s \le f_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s F_N. It only equals μsFN\mu_s F_N at the moment of impending slip.

  • Check whether the object is in equilibrium below the slipping threshold; if so, determine fsf_s from ΣF=0\Sigma F = 0, giving fs=Fappliedf_s = F_{\text{applied}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that for x<xcx < x_c, the mass remains at rest in static equilibrium: ΣFx=Fspring−fs=0\Sigma F_x = F_{\text{spring}} - f_s = 0.

  2. Substitute Fspring=kxF_{\text{spring}} = kx to find the responsive static friction: fs(x)=kxf_s(x) = kx.

  3. Note that fsf_s increases linearly with extension xx from 00 up to its maximum threshold fs,max=μsmg=19.6 Nf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s mg = 19.6\text{ N} at x=xcx = x_c.

Final answer

(a) For x<xcx < x_c: Fspring=kxF_{\text{spring}} = kx pulling outward, balanced by fs=kxf_s = kx opposing it. At x=xcx = x_c: Fspring=fs,max=μsmg=19.6 NF_{\text{spring}} = f_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s mg = 19.6\text{ N}. For x→∞x \to \infty: Fspring=kx→∞F_{\text{spring}} = kx \to \infty, opposing a constant kinetic friction fk=μkmg=15.7 Nf_k = \mu_k mg = 15.7\text{ N}. (b) xc=0.0613 mx_c = 0.0613\text{ m}. (c) fkFspring=μkmgkx→0\frac{f_k}{F_{\text{spring}}} = \frac{\mu_k mg}{kx} \to 0 as x→∞x \to \infty.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the difference between the actual static friction force fsf_s and its upper bound fs,max=μsNf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s N.

  • Practice sketching friction ff versus applied horizontal force FF to visually distinguish the static slope region (fs=Ff_s = F) from the kinetic plateau (fk=constantf_k = \text{constant}).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student mistakenly uses the kinetic friction coefficient instead of the static friction coefficient to determine the threshold extension.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    For x<xc, forces are Fs=kx and fs=kx  ⟹  At x=xc, fs=μsmg  ⟹  As x→∞, fk=μkmg\text{For } x < x_c\text{, forces are } F_s = kx \text{ and } f_s = kx \implies \text{At } x = x_c\text{, } f_s = \mu_s mg \implies \text{As } x \to \infty\text{, } f_k = \mu_k mg

  2. Step 2

    At threshold, \text{At threshold, } kx_c = μ\muk mg   ⟹  \implies x_c = 0.200×8.00×9.80320\frac{0.200 \times 8.00 \times 9.80}{320} = 15.68320\frac{15.68}{320} = 0.049 m\text{ m}

    Correct

    kx_c = μ\mus mg   ⟹  \implies x_c = 0.250×8.00×9.80320\frac{0.250 \times 8.00 \times 9.80}{320} = 19.6320\frac{19.6}{320} ≈\approx 0.0613 m\text{ m}

    At the threshold of motion (impending slip), the block is still at rest, so the opposing force is maximum static friction fs,max=μsmgf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s mg, not kinetic friction μkmg\mu_k mg.

  3. Step 3

    Ratio is \text{Ratio is } fkFspring\frac{f_k}{F_{\text{spring}}} = μkmgkx\frac{\mu_k mg}{kx}   ⟹  \implies As \text{As } x →\to \infty$$\text{, } fkFspring\frac{f_k}{F_{\text{spring}}} →\to 0 $\text{ because the denominator grows infinitely large.}$$

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified how static friction self-adjusts up to μsmg\mu_s mg and transitions to kinetic friction once slipping occurs.

You correctly evaluated the asymptotic ratio in part (c) by showing that the unbounded spring force dominates the constant kinetic friction.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Used kinetic friction coefficient for slipping threshold

In part (a) you correctly stated that maximum static friction is fs=μsmgf_s = \mu_s mg, but in part (b) you substituted μk=0.200\mu_k = 0.200 instead of μs=0.250\mu_s = 0.250.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the coefficient of impending motion (static friction, μs\mu_s) with the coefficient of active sliding (kinetic friction, μk\mu_k) when setting up the boundary equilibrium equation.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Motion State at the Boundary
  • Impending motion is the final boundary of static equilibrium; slipping has not yet begun, so static friction governs the threshold (fs,max=μsFNf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s F_N).

  • Whenever a question asks for the critical force or extension needed to initiate motion, always use μs\mu_s.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute the static coefficient μs=0.250\mu_s = 0.250: 320xc=0.250×(8.00 kg)(9.80 m/s2)320 x_c = 0.250 \times (8.00\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2)

  2. Calculate the maximum static friction: fs,max=19.6 Nf_{s,\text{max}} = 19.6\text{ N}

  3. Solve for xcx_c: xc=19.6 N320 N/m=0.06125 mx_c = \frac{19.6\text{ N}}{320\text{ N/m}} = 0.06125\text{ m}

Final answer

xc≈0.0613 mx_c \approx 0.0613\text{ m} (or 6.13 cm6.13\text{ cm})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Recheck every threshold/slipping problem to confirm that μs\mu_s is selected for initiating motion, reserving μk\mu_k solely for when the object is already sliding.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses the spring force with spring potential energy and erroneously squares the extension in Hooke's law.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Horizontal forces are the outward spring force and opposing friction. ⟹ For x<xcx < x_c, static friction opposes spring pull with fs=kxf_s = kx. ⟹ At x=xcx = x_c, static friction is at maximum fs=μsmgf_s = \mu_s mg. ⟹ As x→∞x \to \infty, kinetic friction fk=μkmgf_k = \mu_k mg opposes motion.

  2. Step 2

    fs,max⁡=0.250×8.00×9.80=19.6 Nf_{s,\max} = 0.250 \times 8.00 \times 9.80 = 19.6\text{ N} ⟹ kxc2=μsmgk x_c^2 = \mu_s mg ⟹ 320xc2=19.6320 x_c^2 = 19.6 ⟹ xc2=0.06125x_c^2 = 0.06125 ⟹ xc=0.06125=0.247 mx_c = \sqrt{0.06125} = 0.247\text{ m}

    Correct

    fs,max⁡=μsmg=19.6 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s mg = 19.6\text{ N} ⟹ kxc=μsmgk x_c = \mu_s mg ⟹ 320xc=19.6320 x_c = 19.6 ⟹ xc=19.6320=0.06125 m≈0.0613 mx_c = \frac{19.6}{320} = 0.06125\text{ m} \approx 0.0613\text{ m}

    You correctly calculated the maximum static friction force as 19.6 N19.6\text{ N}, but you equated it to kxc2k x_c^2 instead of Hooke's law, Fspring=kxcF_{\text{spring}} = k x_c. Squaring the extension gave 0.247 m0.247\text{ m} instead of 0.0613 m0.0613\text{ m}.

  3. Step 3

    fkFspring=μkmgkx\frac{f_k}{F_{\text{spring}}} = \frac{\mu_k mg}{kx} ⟹ As x→∞x \to \infty, the constant friction divided by increasing spring force approaches 00.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that static friction self-adjusts to balance the spring force until the threshold xcx_c.

You accurately calculated the maximum static friction force fs,max⁡=μsmg=19.6 Nf_{s,\max} = \mu_s mg = 19.6\text{ N}.

You correctly analyzed the asymptotic behavior of the force ratio in part (c).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula confusion between force and energy

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You wrote the spring force as F=kx2F = kx^2 in the equilibrium balance for part (b), mistakenly squaring the displacement instead of using the linear form F=kxF = kx from Hooke's law.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Hooke's Law vs. Elastic Potential Energy
  • Spring force has units of newtons and scales linearly with extension (F=kxF = kx), whereas elastic potential energy scales quadratically (U=12kx2U = \frac{1}{2}kx^2).

  • When balancing forces, always use F=kxF = kx. Check dimensions: N/m×m=N\text{N/m} \times \text{m} = \text{N}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Equate the linear spring force to maximum static friction: kxc=fs,max⁡k x_c = f_{s,\max}

  2. Substitute the values: 320xc=19.6320 x_c = 19.6

  3. Solve for xcx_c: xc=19.6 N320 N/m=0.06125 mx_c = \frac{19.6\text{ N}}{320\text{ N/m}} = 0.06125\text{ m}

Final answer

xc≈0.0613 mx_c \approx 0.0613\text{ m} (or 6.13 cm6.13\text{ cm})

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always perform a quick dimensional check on force expressions: multiplying stiffness (extN/m ext{N/m}) by displacement (extm ext{m}) yields force (extN ext{N}), whereas multiplying by displacement squared (extm2 ext{m}^2) yields energy (extJ ext{J}).

  • Verify that the spring force formula used in part (b) matches the formula Fspring=kxF_{\text{spring}} = kx that you correctly used in part (c).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 5.00 kg5.00\text{ kg} box rests on a horizontal floor with μs=0.300\mu_s = 0.300 and g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2. A horizontal cable pulls the box with a tension of T=8.00 NT = 8.00\text{ N}. Determine the magnitude of the static friction force acting on the box.

Answer

The maximum static friction is fs,max=μsmg=0.300⋅(5.00)(9.80)=14.7 Nf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s mg = 0.300 \cdot (5.00)(9.80) = 14.7\text{ N}. Since T=8.00 N<fs,maxT = 8.00\text{ N} < f_{s,\text{max}}, the box remains in equilibrium. Therefore, fs=T=8.00 Nf_s = T = 8.00\text{ N}.

02

A horizontal spring with k=150 N/mk = 150\text{ N/m} is attached to a 2.00 kg2.00\text{ kg} block on a table with μs=0.450\mu_s = 0.450 and μk=0.300\mu_k = 0.300. If the spring is stretched by x=0.0400 mx = 0.0400\text{ m}, find the friction force acting on the block. Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2.

Answer

The applied spring force is Fspring=kx=150⋅0.0400=6.00 NF_{\text{spring}} = kx = 150 \cdot 0.0400 = 6.00\text{ N}. The maximum static friction is fs,max=μsmg=0.450⋅(2.00)(9.80)=8.82 Nf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s mg = 0.450 \cdot (2.00)(9.80) = 8.82\text{ N}. Since Fspring<fs,maxF_{\text{spring}} < f_{s,\text{max}}, the block does not slip, and static friction balances the spring force: f=fs=6.00 Nf = f_s = 6.00\text{ N}.

03

A block of mass mm on a rough horizontal surface with static coefficient μs\mu_s and kinetic coefficient μk\mu_k is connected to a spring of stiffness kk. Express the friction force f(x)f(x) as a piecewise function of the spring extension xx from x=0x = 0 to x>xcx > x_c.

Answer

For 0≤x<xc=μsmgk0 \le x < x_c = \frac{\mu_s mg}{k}, the block is stationary and f(x)=kxf(x) = kx. At x=xcx = x_c, f(xc)=μsmgf(x_c) = \mu_s mg. For x>xcx > x_c, the block moves and kinetic friction applies: f(x)=μkmgf(x) = \mu_k mg.

Loading workspace…