Resources

A commuter train moves along a straight horizontal track at 24.0 m/s24.0\text{ m/s}, sounding a horn of frequency 440 Hz440\text{ Hz}. A steady horizontal wind blows at 12.0 m/s12.0\text{ m/s} along the track in the direction from the train toward a stationary listener standing ahead on the track. The speed of sound in calm air is 344 m/s344\text{ m/s}. Taking the effective medium velocity into account, calculate the frequency heard by the stationary listener.

Answer and steps

Final answer

472 Hz472\text{ Hz}

Steps

Understanding the Effect of Wind on the Doppler Effect

The standard Doppler effect equation assumes that the medium (air) is stationary. When wind blows steadily along the line of wave propagation, it carries the medium along, shifting the effective speed of sound relative to the ground.

  1. Identify the Given Values and Directions:

    • Frequency emitted by the source: f0=440 Hzf_0 = 440\text{ Hz}
    • Speed of the train (source): vs=24.0 m/sv_{\text{s}} = 24.0\text{ m/s} toward the listener
    • Speed of the stationary listener: vL=0 m/sv_{\text{L}} = 0\text{ m/s}
    • Speed of sound in calm air: v=344 m/sv = 344\text{ m/s}
    • Wind speed: vw=12.0 m/sv_{\text{w}} = 12.0\text{ m/s} directed from the train toward the listener
  2. Determine the Effective Speed of Sound: Because the wind blows in the same direction that the sound travels (from the train toward the listener), the wind aids the sound waves. Relative to the ground, the effective speed of sound veffv_{\text{eff}} is: veff=v+vw=344 m/s+12.0 m/s=356 m/sv_{\text{eff}} = v + v_{\text{w}} = 344\text{ m/s} + 12.0\text{ m/s} = 356\text{ m/s}
  3. Apply the Doppler Formula: For a moving source approaching a stationary listener in a moving medium: fL=f0(veff−vLveff−vs)f_{\text{L}} = f_0 \left(\frac{v_{\text{eff}} - v_{\text{L}}}{v_{\text{eff}} - v_{\text{s}}}\right)

    Substitute vL=0v_{\text{L}} = 0, vs=24.0 m/sv_{\text{s}} = 24.0\text{ m/s}, and veff=356 m/sv_{\text{eff}} = 356\text{ m/s}: fL=440 Hz(356 m/s356 m/s−24.0 m/s)f_{\text{L}} = 440\text{ Hz} \left(\frac{356\text{ m/s}}{356\text{ m/s} - 24.0\text{ m/s}}\right) fL=440 Hz(356332)f_{\text{L}} = 440\text{ Hz} \left(\frac{356}{332}\right) fL≈471.8 Hz≈472 Hzf_{\text{L}} \approx 471.8\text{ Hz} \approx 472\text{ Hz}

Common Pitfall: Do not simply subtract the wind speed from the train's speed. The wind alters the propagation speed of the medium itself relative to the ground, so it directly modifies the speed of sound vv to v+vwv + v_{\text{w}}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student ignores the medium motion (wind velocity) entirely and uses the calm air sound speed in the standard Doppler formula.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    v=344 m/s, vs=24.0 m/s, f=440 Hzv = 344\text{ m/s},\, v_{\text{s}} = 24.0\text{ m/s},\, f = 440\text{ Hz}

  2. Step 2

    f′=f⋅vv−vsf' = f \cdot \frac{v}{v - v_{\text{s}}}

    Correct

    veff=v+vw=356 m/s  ⟹  f′=f(veffveff−vs)v_{\text{eff}} = v + v_{\text{w}} = 356\text{ m/s} \implies f' = f \left(\frac{v_{\text{eff}}}{v_{\text{eff}} - v_{\text{s}}}\right)

    Because wind moves the air medium toward the listener at 12.0 m/s12.0\text{ m/s}, the speed of sound relative to the ground is veff=v+vw=356 m/sv_{\text{eff}} = v + v_{\text{w}} = 356\text{ m/s} rather than calm-air speed vv.

  3. Step 3

    f′=440⋅344344−24.0f' = \frac{440 \cdot 344}{344 - 24.0}

    Correct

    f′=440⋅356356−24.0f' = 440 \cdot \frac{356}{356 - 24.0}

    You substituted your calm-air sound speed into the formula accurately, but this step inherits the unadjusted sound speed.

  4. Step 4

    f′=440⋅344320=473 Hzf' = \frac{440 \cdot 344}{320} = 473\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f′=440⋅356332≈472 Hzf' = 440 \cdot \frac{356}{332} \approx 472\text{ Hz}

    Your arithmetic evaluation was correct for your numbers, but the missing wind adjustment led to an incorrect observed frequency.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the source is approaching the listener and selected the Doppler form with a minus sign in the denominator.

You accurately substituted the extracted values and completed the arithmetic calculation.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Neglecting medium motion (wind velocity)

You solved the problem as if the air were completely calm, overlooking the steady wind speed given along the track.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

The Doppler effect formula describes wave propagation relative to a stationary reference frame (the ground). When the medium itself moves, the wave propagation speed relative to the ground becomes veff=v±vwindv_{\text{eff}} = v \pm v_{\text{wind}}, which replaces vv in every part of the Doppler formula.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check for medium motion
  • Sound waves propagate through air at speed vv relative to the air. If the air moves at vwv_{\text{w}} relative to the ground, the wave speed relative to the ground is veff=v+vwv_{\text{eff}} = v + v_{\text{w}} in the direction of the wind.

  • Always check whether the medium is moving; if wind is present along the line of sound propagation, replace vv with veffv_{\text{eff}} before applying Doppler ratios.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the effective speed of sound toward the listener: veff=v+vw=344 m/s+12.0 m/s=356 m/sv_{\text{eff}} = v + v_{\text{w}} = 344\text{ m/s} + 12.0\text{ m/s} = 356\text{ m/s}.

  2. Set up the Doppler formula using veffv_{\text{eff}}: f′=f(veffveff−vs)f' = f \left(\frac{v_{\text{eff}}}{v_{\text{eff}} - v_{\text{s}}}\right).

  3. Substitute the known values: f′=440 Hz(356 m/s356 m/s−24.0 m/s)=440⋅356332≈471.8 Hzf' = 440\text{ Hz} \left(\frac{356\text{ m/s}}{356\text{ m/s} - 24.0\text{ m/s}}\right) = 440 \cdot \frac{356}{332} \approx 471.8\text{ Hz}.

Final answer

472 Hz472\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write down all velocity vectors relative to the ground at the start of the problem, including the wind speed vwv_{\text{w}}.

  • Compute veff=v±vwv_{\text{eff}} = v \pm v_{\text{w}} along the line from source to detector before setting up the Doppler equation.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student subtracts the wind speed instead of adding it, mistakenly assuming the wind flowing from source to listener opposes the sound wave propagation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    v′=v−vwind=344−12.0=332 m/sv' = v - v_{\text{wind}} = 344 - 12.0 = 332\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    veff=v+vwind=344 m/s+12.0 m/s=356 m/sv_{\text{eff}} = v + v_{\text{wind}} = 344\text{ m/s} + 12.0\text{ m/s} = 356\text{ m/s}

    The sound waves travel from the train toward the listener. Since the wind blows in this exact same direction, the medium carries the sound forward, which increases the speed of sound relative to the ground to v+vwindv + v_{\text{wind}}.

  2. Step 2

    f′=f⋅v′v′−vsf' = f \cdot \frac{v'}{v' - v_{\text{s}}}

  3. Step 3

    f′=440⋅332332−24.0  ⟹  f′=440⋅332308≈474.3 Hzf' = \frac{440 \cdot 332}{332 - 24.0} \implies f' = \frac{440 \cdot 332}{308} \approx 474.3\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    fL=440 Hz(356 m/s356 m/s−24.0 m/s)=440(356332)≈472 Hzf_{\text{L}} = 440\text{ Hz} \left(\frac{356\text{ m/s}}{356\text{ m/s} - 24.0\text{ m/s}}\right) = 440\left(\frac{356}{332}\right) \approx 472\text{ Hz}

    Your algebra and evaluation were executed properly, but the result was shifted because of the incorrect value of v′v' carried over from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that wind alters the effective speed of sound relative to the ground.

You identified the correct Doppler shift expression for a source approaching a stationary observer.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in medium velocity

You subtracted the wind speed from the speed of sound instead of adding it.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the wind blowing from source to listener as opposing the wave propagation rather than aiding it. In a ground frame of reference, sound traveling with the wind acquires an increased speed equal to v+vwindv + v_{\text{wind}}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Direction of Wave Propagation vs. Wind
  • Sound travels along a vector pointing from the source to the observer. If the wind vector points in the same direction, the effective speed is veff=v+vwindv_{\text{eff}} = v + v_{\text{wind}}. If it points in the opposite direction, veff=v−vwindv_{\text{eff}} = v - v_{\text{wind}}.

  • Always draw an arrow from source to observer first. Compare the wind arrow to this wave propagation arrow to determine the sign before calculating.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Determine the effective sound speed with aiding wind: veff=344 m/s+12.0 m/s=356 m/sv_{\text{eff}} = 344\text{ m/s} + 12.0\text{ m/s} = 356\text{ m/s}.

  2. Substitute veff=356 m/sv_{\text{eff}} = 356\text{ m/s}, vs=24.0 m/sv_{\text{s}} = 24.0\text{ m/s}, and f0=440 Hzf_0 = 440\text{ Hz} into the Doppler formula: fL=440⋅356356−24.0f_{\text{L}} = 440 \cdot \frac{356}{356 - 24.0}.

  3. Compute the ratio: fL=440⋅356332≈471.8 Hzf_{\text{L}} = 440 \cdot \frac{356}{332} \approx 471.8\text{ Hz}.

Final answer

472 Hz472\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Draw a quick vector sketch showing the source, listener, sound direction, and wind direction whenever a moving medium is present.

  • Re-evaluate Doppler problems with wind blowing against the sound wave to practice choosing the negative sign appropriately.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses an incorrect sign for the source motion, adding the source speed in the denominator instead of subtracting it for a source moving toward the observer.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    v′=v+vwind=344+12.0=356 m/sv' = v + v_{\text{wind}} = 344 + 12.0 = 356\text{ m/s}

  2. Step 2

    f′=f⋅v′v′+vsf' = \frac{f \cdot v'}{v' + v_s}

    Correct

    fL=f0(veffveff−vs)f_{\text{L}} = f_0\left(\frac{v_{\text{eff}}}{v_{\text{eff}} - v_{\text{s}}}\right)

    Because the source is approaching the listener, the wavefronts are compressed in front of it, shortening the observed wavelength and increasing the observed frequency. This requires subtracting the source speed in the denominator: v′−vsv' - v_{\text{s}}.

  3. Step 3

    f′=440⋅356356+24.0=440⋅356380≈412.2 Hzf' = \frac{440 \cdot 356}{356 + 24.0} = \frac{440 \cdot 356}{380} \approx 412.2\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    fL=440 Hz(356 m/s356 m/s−24.0 m/s)=440(356332)≈472 Hzf_{\text{L}} = 440\text{ Hz}\left(\frac{356\text{ m/s}}{356\text{ m/s} - 24.0\text{ m/s}}\right) = 440\left(\frac{356}{332}\right) \approx 472\text{ Hz}

    Your arithmetic was accurate based on your formula, but the calculation propagated the incorrect plus sign from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that wind traveling from the source to the listener increases the effective propagation speed of the sound waves.

You correctly substituted the numerical values into your algebraic setup and solved the arithmetic accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Doppler sign convention for approaching source

You accidentally added the source speed in the denominator instead of subtracting it, leading to a frequency below the emitted pitch.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the sign convention for source motion in the Doppler formula. An approaching source compresses wavefronts, which decreases the denominator and raises the observed frequency.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Physical Reality Check
  • When a sound source approaches an observer, the pitch heard by the observer must always be higher than the emitted pitch (fobs>fsourcef_{\text{obs}} > f_{\text{source}}).

  • Check whether your calculated answer (412.2 Hz412.2\text{ Hz}) is higher than the emitted pitch (440 Hz440\text{ Hz}). Since it was lower, reverse the denominator sign to make the denominator smaller than the numerator.

Denominator Sign for Moving Source
  • In the Doppler formula fL=f0(v±vLv∓vs)f_{\text{L}} = f_0 \left(\frac{v \pm v_{\text{L}}}{v \mp v_{\text{s}}}\right), an approaching source uses the minus sign in the denominator to increase the fraction.

  • Write the denominator as (veff−vs)(v_{\text{eff}} - v_{\text{s}}) whenever the source moves toward the observer.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the Doppler equation for an approaching source: fL=f0(veffveff−vs)f_{\text{L}} = f_0\left(\frac{v_{\text{eff}}}{v_{\text{eff}} - v_{\text{s}}}\right).

  2. Substitute veff=356 m/sv_{\text{eff}} = 356\text{ m/s}, vs=24.0 m/sv_{\text{s}} = 24.0\text{ m/s}, and f0=440 Hzf_0 = 440\text{ Hz}: fL=440(356356−24.0)=440(356332)f_{\text{L}} = 440\left(\frac{356}{356 - 24.0}\right) = 440\left(\frac{356}{332}\right).

  3. Evaluate the quotient: fL≈471.8 Hz≈472 Hzf_{\text{L}} \approx 471.8\text{ Hz} \approx 472\text{ Hz}.

Final answer

472 Hz472\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Before finishing any Doppler calculation, verify that an approaching source results in an observed frequency higher than the source frequency.

  • Practice identifying the denominator sign by associating 'approaching source' with 'smaller denominator' to yield a higher frequency.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A stationary factory siren emits a sound at 500 Hz500\text{ Hz}. A listener stands downwind where a steady wind blows at 15.0 m/s15.0\text{ m/s} directly from the siren toward the listener. If the speed of sound in calm air is 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}, what frequency does the listener hear?

Answer

500 Hz500\text{ Hz}. When both the source and the observer are stationary relative to the ground, wind changes the wavelength and wave speed by the same factor (λ=v+vwf0\lambda = \frac{v + v_{\text{w}}}{f_0} and veff=v+vwv_{\text{eff}} = v + v_{\text{w}}), so the observed frequency f′=veffλ=f0f' = \frac{v_{\text{eff}}}{\lambda} = f_0 remains unchanged.

02

A car moves at 20.0 m/s20.0\text{ m/s} directly away from a stationary observer, blowing a horn at 300 Hz300\text{ Hz}. A steady wind of 10.0 m/s10.0\text{ m/s} blows from the car toward the observer. The speed of sound in calm air is 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}. Calculate the frequency heard by the observer.

Answer

284 Hz284\text{ Hz}. Sound travels from car to observer, so wind assists sound: veff=340+10.0=350 m/sv_{\text{eff}} = 340 + 10.0 = 350\text{ m/s}. The source moves away from the observer, so f′=f0(veffveff+vs)=300(350350+20.0)=300(350370)≈284 Hzf' = f_0 \left(\frac{v_{\text{eff}}}{v_{\text{eff}} + v_{\text{s}}}\right) = 300 \left(\frac{350}{350 + 20.0}\right) = 300 \left(\frac{350}{370}\right) \approx 284\text{ Hz}.

03

An ambulance travels north at 30.0 m/s30.0\text{ m/s} with a 600 Hz600\text{ Hz} siren. A cyclist travels north at 10.0 m/s10.0\text{ m/s} ahead of the ambulance. A steady wind blows south at 15.0 m/s15.0\text{ m/s} (opposing the ambulance's motion). Take the speed of sound in calm air as 345 m/s345\text{ m/s}. What frequency does the cyclist hear?

Answer

640 Hz640\text{ Hz}. Sound propagates northward from ambulance to cyclist, against the southward wind, so veff=345−15.0=330 m/sv_{\text{eff}} = 345 - 15.0 = 330\text{ m/s}. Both source and observer move north: vs=30.0 m/sv_{\text{s}} = 30.0\text{ m/s} (approaching) and vo=10.0 m/sv_{\text{o}} = 10.0\text{ m/s} (receding). Applying Doppler: f′=f0(veff−voveff−vs)=600(330−10.0330−30.0)=600(320300)=640 Hzf' = f_0 \left(\frac{v_{\text{eff}} - v_{\text{o}}}{v_{\text{eff}} - v_{\text{s}}}\right) = 600 \left(\frac{330 - 10.0}{330 - 30.0}\right) = 600 \left(\frac{320}{300}\right) = 640\text{ Hz}.

Loading workspace…