Resources

A slab of mass M=12.0 kgM = 12.0\text{ kg} rests on a frictionless horizontal floor. A smaller block of mass m=4.00 kgm = 4.00\text{ kg} is placed on top of the slab. The coefficient of static friction between the block and the slab is μs=0.350\mu_s = 0.350, and the coefficient of kinetic friction is μk=0.280\mu_k = 0.280. A horizontal force F⃗\vec{F} directed to the right is applied directly to the bottom slab. Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2. (a) Determine the threshold magnitude FmaxF_{\text{max}} of the applied force beyond which the top block slips relative to the slab. (b) At this exact impending slip threshold, identify the magnitude, direction, and recipient body of the Newton's third law reaction partner to the static friction force accelerating the top block.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) 54.9 N54.9\text{ N}; (b) The reaction force is the static friction force exerted by the top block on the bottom slab, having a magnitude of 13.7 N13.7\text{ N} directed to the left, acting on the bottom slab.

Steps

Part (a): Finding the Maximum Applied Force FmaxF_{\text{max}}

  1. Identify the force causing the top block to accelerate:
    The top block of mass mm has no external pulling force directly applied to it. The only horizontal force acting on it is the static friction force f⃗s\vec{f}_s exerted by the bottom slab. Therefore, the maximum horizontal acceleration amaxa_{\text{max}} the top block can experience without slipping is determined solely by the maximum available static friction fs,maxf_{s,\text{max}}: fs,max=μsNmf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s N_m Since there is no vertical acceleration, the normal force on the block is: Nm=mgN_m = m g fs,max=μsmg=0.350⋅4.00 kg⋅9.80 m/s2=13.72 Nf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s m g = 0.350 \cdot 4.00\text{ kg} \cdot 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 = 13.72\text{ N}
  2. Calculate the maximum acceleration without slipping:
    Applying Newton's second law to the top block: amax=fs,maxm=μsg=0.350⋅9.80 m/s2=3.43 m/s2a_{\text{max}} = \frac{f_{s,\text{max}}}{m} = \mu_s g = 0.350 \cdot 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 = 3.43\text{ m/s}^2
  3. Treat the combined system at impending slip:
    Right at the slip threshold, both masses accelerate together at amaxa_{\text{max}} as a single composite system of mass (M+m)(M + m): Fmax=(M+m)amaxF_{\text{max}} = (M + m) a_{\text{max}} Substitute the given values: Fmax=(12.0 kg+4.00 kg)⋅3.43 m/s2=16.0 kg⋅3.43 m/s2=54.88 N≈54.9 NF_{\text{max}} = (12.0\text{ kg} + 4.00\text{ kg}) \cdot 3.43\text{ m/s}^2 = 16.0\text{ kg} \cdot 3.43\text{ m/s}^2 = 54.88\text{ N} \approx 54.9\text{ N}

    Common Pitfall: Do not use the kinetic friction coefficient μk\mu_k for impending slip. Slip has not yet occurred, so the contact surfaces remain mutually at rest, which requires the static friction coefficient μs\mu_s.


Part (b): Identifying the Newton's Third Law Reaction Partner

  1. Action Force Definition:
    The static friction force acting on the top block is: f⃗slab on block\vec{f}_{\text{slab on block}} It has a magnitude of 13.7 N13.7\text{ N} and points to the right (in the direction of acceleration).
  2. Newton's Third Law Pair:
    Newton's third law states that if body AA exerts a force on body BB, then body BB exerts an equal and opposite force on body AA: f⃗block on slab=−f⃗slab on block\vec{f}_{\text{block on slab}} = -\vec{f}_{\text{slab on block}}

    • Magnitude: Equal to the action force, 13.7 N13.7\text{ N}.
    • Direction: Directed horizontally to the left (opposing the relative motion tendency of the slab).
    • Recipient body: The bottom slab MM.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student uses the kinetic friction coefficient instead of the static friction coefficient to determine the maximum force before slipping occurs.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    fmax=μk⋅m⋅g=0.280⋅4.00⋅9.80=10.976 Nf_{\text{max}} = \mu_k \cdot m \cdot g = 0.280 \cdot 4.00 \cdot 9.80 = 10.976\text{ N}

    Correct

    fs,max=μsmg=0.350⋅4.00 kg⋅9.80 m/s2=13.72 Nf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s m g = 0.350 \cdot 4.00\text{ kg} \cdot 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 = 13.72\text{ N}

    You used the kinetic friction coefficient μk=0.280\mu_k = 0.280. Because the block and slab are still moving together without relative sliding right at the threshold of slipping, you need to use the coefficient of static friction μs=0.350\mu_s = 0.350.

  2. Step 2

    amax=fmaxm=0.280⋅9.80=2.744 m/s2a_{\text{max}} = \frac{f_{\text{max}}}{m} = 0.280 \cdot 9.80 = 2.744\text{ m/s}^2

    Correct

    amax=fs,maxm=μsg=0.350⋅9.80 m/s2=3.43 m/s2a_{\text{max}} = \frac{f_{s,\text{max}}}{m} = \mu_s g = 0.350 \cdot 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 = 3.43\text{ m/s}^2

    Your formula a=fma = \frac{f}{m} is correct, but your calculated acceleration inherits the incorrect friction force from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    Fmax=(M+m)⋅amax=(12.0+4.00)⋅2.744=43.9 NF_{\text{max}} = (M + m) \cdot a_{\text{max}} = (12.0 + 4.00) \cdot 2.744 = 43.9\text{ N}

    Correct

    Fmax=(M+m)amax=(12.0 kg+4.00 kg)⋅3.43 m/s2≈54.9 NF_{\text{max}} = (M + m) a_{\text{max}} = (12.0\text{ kg} + 4.00\text{ kg}) \cdot 3.43\text{ m/s}^2 \approx 54.9\text{ N}

    You correctly treated the two blocks as a combined composite system of mass (M+m)(M + m), but the final force value is lower than expected due to the earlier friction coefficient error.

  4. Step 4

    Reaction force magnitude=10.976 N  ⟹  Direction=to the left  ⟹  Recipient body=bottom slab\text{Reaction force magnitude} = 10.976\text{ N} \implies \text{Direction} = \text{to the left} \implies \text{Recipient body} = \text{bottom slab}

    Correct

    Magnitude=13.7 N,  Direction=to the left,  Recipient body=bottom slab\text{Magnitude} = 13.7\text{ N},\; \text{Direction} = \text{to the left},\; \text{Recipient body} = \text{bottom slab}

    You accurately identified both the direction (to the left) and the recipient body (bottom slab) for the third law pair, but the numerical magnitude reflects your earlier friction calculation.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that static friction on the top block provides its forward acceleration.

You applied Newton's second law to the combined system (M+m)(M + m) to determine the total required pulling force.

You correctly identified that the third law reaction force acts on the bottom slab and points opposite to the friction force on the top block.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Kinetic vs. Static Friction Confusion at Impending Motion

You substituted the coefficient of kinetic friction μk=0.280\mu_k = 0.280 instead of static friction μs=0.350\mu_s = 0.350.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated impending slip with kinetic friction because motion is about to occur, overlooking that the surfaces remain mutually at rest relative to each other until slip actually begins.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Relative Surface Motion
  • If two surfaces are moving together with zero relative velocity at the contact interface, friction between them is static, even if both objects are accelerating relative to the ground.

  • Always use fs,max=μsNf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s N for threshold or 'impending slip' conditions, and reserve μk\mu_k for cases where relative sliding is already occurring.

Third Law Reaction Partners
  • If object AA exerts friction force f⃗A on B\vec{f}_{A \text{ on } B} on object BB, then object BB exerts f⃗B on A=−f⃗A on B\vec{f}_{B \text{ on } A} = -\vec{f}_{A \text{ on } B} on object AA.

  • Ensure the reaction partner has the identical magnitude, acts along the exact opposite direction, and acts on the other interacting body.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. fs,max=μsmg=0.350⋅(4.00 kg)⋅(9.80 m/s2)=13.72 Nf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s m g = 0.350 \cdot (4.00\text{ kg}) \cdot (9.80\text{ m/s}^2) = 13.72\text{ N}

  2. amax=fs,maxm=13.72 N4.00 kg=3.43 m/s2a_{\text{max}} = \frac{f_{s,\text{max}}}{m} = \frac{13.72\text{ N}}{4.00\text{ kg}} = 3.43\text{ m/s}^2

  3. Fmax=(M+m)amax=(12.0 kg+4.00 kg)⋅3.43 m/s2=54.88 N≈54.9 NF_{\text{max}} = (M + m) a_{\text{max}} = (12.0\text{ kg} + 4.00\text{ kg}) \cdot 3.43\text{ m/s}^2 = 54.88\text{ N} \approx 54.9\text{ N}

  4. Reaction force:magnitude=13.7 N,  direction=to the left,  recipient body=bottom slab\text{Reaction force}: \text{magnitude} = 13.7\text{ N},\; \text{direction} = \text{to the left},\; \text{recipient body} = \text{bottom slab}

Final answer

(a) 54.9 N54.9\text{ N}; (b) Magnitude 13.7 N13.7\text{ N}, directed to the left, acting on the bottom slab.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between 'moving relative to the ground' and 'moving relative to the contact surface'.

  • Practice identifying whether friction is static or kinetic by testing if the contact surfaces are slipping past one another.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student incorrectly assumes that the threshold force F_max is simply equal to the maximum static friction force between the block and the slab.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    fs,max=μs∗m∗g=0.350∗4.00∗9.80=13.72 Nf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s * m * g = 0.350 * 4.00 * 9.80 = 13.72\text{ N}

  2. Step 2

    Fmax=fs,max=13.72 NF_{\text{max}} = f_{s,\text{max}} = 13.72\text{ N}

    Correct

    amax=fs,maxm=μsg=3.43 m/s2  ⟹  Fmax=(M+m)amax=(12.0 kg+4.00 kg)(3.43 m/s2)≈54.9 Na_{\text{max}} = \frac{f_{s,\text{max}}}{m} = \mu_s g = 3.43\text{ m/s}^2 \implies F_{\text{max}} = (M + m)a_{\text{max}} = (12.0\text{ kg} + 4.00\text{ kg})(3.43\text{ m/s}^2) \approx 54.9\text{ N}

    You set the applied force FmaxF_{\text{max}} equal to the internal friction force fs,maxf_{s,\text{max}}. Because the bottom slab rests on a frictionless floor, the applied force FF must accelerate both masses (M+m)(M + m) together up to the maximum common acceleration amax=μsga_{\text{max}} = \mu_s g.

  3. Step 3

    Magnitude=13.72 N  ⟹  Direction=to the left  ⟹  Recipient body=bottom slab\text{Magnitude} = 13.72\text{ N} \implies \text{Direction} = \text{to the left} \implies \text{Recipient body} = \text{bottom slab}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the maximum static friction force acting on the top block using fs,max=μsmgf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s m g.

You correctly applied Newton's third law to find the magnitude, direction, and recipient body of the friction reaction force.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Equating external applied force to internal friction in an accelerating system

Setting Fmax=fs,maxF_{\text{max}} = f_{s,\text{max}} as if the slab were held fixed in static equilibrium.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating an accelerating coupled system as a static equilibrium problem where pulling force equals friction, instead of applying Newton's second law ΣF=(M+m)a\Sigma F = (M + m)a to the combined accelerating system.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify What Accelerates the Coupled System
  • In stacked-block problems on a frictionless surface, the external force accelerates the combined mass (M+m)(M + m), while friction is an internal contact force that accelerates the unpulled block.

  • First find the maximum acceleration of the unpulled block using amax=μsga_{\text{max}} = \mu_s g, then multiply by the total system mass: Fmax=(M+m)amaxF_{\text{max}} = (M + m)a_{\text{max}}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the maximum horizontal acceleration of the top block before slipping: amax=fs,maxm=μsg=0.350⋅9.80 m/s2=3.43 m/s2a_{\text{max}} = \frac{f_{s,\text{max}}}{m} = \mu_s g = 0.350 \cdot 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 = 3.43\text{ m/s}^2.

  2. Apply Newton's second law to the combined system (M+m)(M + m) moving at this maximum acceleration: Fmax=(M+m)amaxF_{\text{max}} = (M + m)a_{\text{max}}.

  3. Substitute the masses: Fmax=(12.0 kg+4.00 kg)(3.43 m/s2)=16.0 kg⋅3.43 m/s2=54.88 N≈54.9 NF_{\text{max}} = (12.0\text{ kg} + 4.00\text{ kg})(3.43\text{ m/s}^2) = 16.0\text{ kg} \cdot 3.43\text{ m/s}^2 = 54.88\text{ N} \approx 54.9\text{ N}.

Final answer

(a) 54.9 N54.9\text{ N}; (b) Magnitude: 13.7 N13.7\text{ N}, Direction: to the left, Recipient body: bottom slab

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write Newton's second law for the entire composite system (Fnet=mtotalaF_{\text{net}} = m_{\text{total}} a) whenever bodies accelerate together without relative slipping.

  • Distinguish internal interaction pairs (like friction between the two blocks) from external forces applied to the system.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misidentifies the normal force on the block or floor as the Newton's third law reaction partner to the friction force.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    fs,max=μs∗m∗g=0.350∗4.00∗9.80=13.72 N  ⟹  amax=13.724.00=3.43 m/s2f_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s * m * g = 0.350 * 4.00 * 9.80 = 13.72\text{ N} \implies a_{\text{max}} = \frac{13.72}{4.00} = 3.43\text{ m/s}^2

  2. Step 2

    Fmax=(12.0+4.00)∗3.43=54.88 NF_{\text{max}} = (12.0 + 4.00) * 3.43 = 54.88\text{ N}

  3. Step 3

    N=m∗g=4.00∗9.80=39.2 N  ⟹  Reaction force magnitude=39.2 N,  Direction=downward,  Recipient body=bottom slabN = m * g = 4.00 * 9.80 = 39.2\text{ N} \implies \text{Reaction force magnitude} = 39.2\text{ N},\; \text{Direction} = \text{downward},\; \text{Recipient body} = \text{bottom slab}

    Correct

    Magnitude=13.7 N,  Direction=to the left,  Recipient body=bottom slab\text{Magnitude} = 13.7\text{ N},\; \text{Direction} = \text{to the left},\; \text{Recipient body} = \text{bottom slab}

    You calculated the normal force between the block and the slab instead of identifying the reaction partner to the friction force. An action-reaction pair must represent the exact same interaction: if the slab exerts a static friction force of 13.7 N13.7\text{ N} to the right on the block, the block must exert a static friction force of 13.7 N13.7\text{ N} to the left on the slab.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the static friction coefficient to find the maximum horizontal force on the top block.

You correctly applied Newton's second law to the combined mass (M+m)(M + m) at the slip threshold.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Newton's Third Law Pair Misidentification

You calculated the vertical contact normal force rather than the horizontal contact friction force.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated the term 'reaction force' with the normal force (N=mgN = mg) rather than applying the definition of a Newton's third law pair, which states that the reaction to F⃗A on B\vec{F}_{A \text{ on } B} is always an equal and opposite force of the same type, F⃗B on A\vec{F}_{B \text{ on } A}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Action-Reaction Identity Rule
  • Every Newton's third law pair involves the same two bodies and the same physical type of force: F⃗A on B=−F⃗B on A\vec{F}_{A \text{ on } B} = -\vec{F}_{B \text{ on } A}.

  • To find the reaction partner to 'slab pushes block via friction to the right', simply swap the agent and recipient: 'block pushes slab via friction to the left' with equal magnitude.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the original action force: the static friction force exerted by the bottom slab on the top block, f⃗slab on block\vec{f}_{\text{slab on block}}, which equals 13.72 N≈13.7 N13.72\text{ N} \approx 13.7\text{ N} directed to the right.

  2. Apply Newton's third law by swapping the agent and recipient while reversing the direction: f⃗block on slab=−f⃗slab on block\vec{f}_{\text{block on slab}} = -\vec{f}_{\text{slab on block}}.

  3. State the magnitude (13.7 N13.7\text{ N}), direction (to the left), and recipient body (bottom slab).

Final answer

(a) 54.9 N54.9\text{ N}; (b) Magnitude: 13.7 N13.7\text{ N}, Direction: to the left, Recipient body: bottom slab

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the strict definition of Newton's third law pairs: they never act on the same body and are always the same type of force (friction pairs with friction, normal pairs with normal).

  • Practice naming forces with explicit 'Agent on Recipient' subscripts to avoid confusing normal force with friction.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 2.0 kg2.0\text{ kg} book sits on a horizontal wooden tray of mass 3.0 kg3.0\text{ kg}. The coefficient of static friction between the book and tray is μs=0.45\mu_s = 0.45, and the tray rests on a frictionless table. What maximum horizontal force can be applied to the tray so that the book does not slip? (Use g=9.8 m/s2g = 9.8\text{ m/s}^2.)

Answer

Fmax=22 NF_{\text{max}} = 22\text{ N}. Key steps: amax=μsg=0.45⋅9.8=4.41 m/s2a_{\text{max}} = \mu_s g = 0.45 \cdot 9.8 = 4.41\text{ m/s}^2; Fmax=(mbook+mtray)amax=(2.0+3.0)⋅4.41=22.05 N≈22 NF_{\text{max}} = (m_{\text{book}} + m_{\text{tray}}) a_{\text{max}} = (2.0 + 3.0) \cdot 4.41 = 22.05\text{ N} \approx 22\text{ N}.

02

Two blocks are stacked on a frictionless floor: bottom block M=8.0 kgM = 8.0\text{ kg} and top block m=2.0 kgm = 2.0\text{ kg}. The friction coefficients between the blocks are μs=0.50\mu_s = 0.50 and μk=0.35\mu_k = 0.35. A pulling force F=40 NF = 40\text{ N} is applied to MM. (a) Does the top block slip? (b) State the magnitude and direction of the friction force acting on the top block.

Answer

(a) No, it does not slip. (b) fs=8.0 Nf_s = 8.0\text{ N} to the right. Key steps: Assuming no slip, a=FM+m=4010.0=4.0 m/s2a = \frac{F}{M + m} = \frac{40}{10.0} = 4.0\text{ m/s}^2. The required force on mm is fs=ma=2.0⋅4.0=8.0 Nf_s = m a = 2.0 \cdot 4.0 = 8.0\text{ N}. The maximum available static friction is fs,max=μsmg=0.50⋅2.0⋅9.8=9.8 Nf_{s,\text{max}} = \mu_s m g = 0.50 \cdot 2.0 \cdot 9.8 = 9.8\text{ N}. Since 8.0 N≤9.8 N8.0\text{ N} \le 9.8\text{ N}, no slip occurs.

03

In a two-tier block system (m=3.0 kgm = 3.0\text{ kg} on top of M=9.0 kgM = 9.0\text{ kg} on a frictionless surface), a horizontal force FF pulls the bottom slab. The coefficients between the blocks are μs=0.40\mu_s = 0.40 and μk=0.25\mu_k = 0.25. Once FF exceeds FmaxF_{\text{max}} and the blocks slip relative to each other, identify the magnitude and direction of the friction force exerted by the top block on the bottom slab. Take g=9.8 m/s2g = 9.8\text{ m/s}^2.

Answer

fk=7.35 Nf_k = 7.35\text{ N} directed to the left. Key steps: Once relative motion begins, kinetic friction acts: fk=μkmg=0.25⋅3.0 kg⋅9.8 m/s2=7.35 Nf_k = \mu_k m g = 0.25 \cdot 3.0\text{ kg} \cdot 9.8\text{ m/s}^2 = 7.35\text{ N}. By Newton's third law, the top block exerts an equal and opposite force directed to the left on the bottom slab.

Loading workspace…