Resources
A passenger of mass sits in a passenger car traveling due east at a constant speed of . The car enters a horizontal curve of radius turning toward the north (counter-clockwise when viewed from above). Take the -axis to point east and the -axis to point north. (a) In an inertial frame attached to the ground, explain why the passenger perceives a sensation of being 'thrown outward' (toward the south/right) using Newton's first law, and contrast this with the real physical force acting on the passenger. (b) Identify the direction of the net physical force acting on the passenger during the turn and calculate its magnitude . (c) If the passenger sits on a horizontal vinyl seat with static friction coefficient , state whether friction alone can keep the passenger moving along the circular path without sliding, providing the numerical margin.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) By Newton's first law, the passenger's inertia tends to preserve their instantaneous straight-line tangential velocity due east (-direction); the perceived outward 'centrifugal' tendency is a fictitious effect of being inside a non-inertial rotating frame, whereas the only real physical force is the inward static friction directed toward the center of curvature (-direction). (b) The net force is directed radially inward toward the center of curvature (north, -direction) with magnitude . (c) Yes; the required centripetal force is while the maximum available static friction is ... Wait, since , friction alone cannot keep the passenger on the circular path; the passenger will slip outward by a deficit of unless restrained.
Steps
Part (a): Inertia and the "Outward" Sensation
According to Newton's First Law of Motion (the law of inertia), an object maintains its state of rest or constant velocity in a straight line unless acted upon by a net external force:
- Natural Inertial Tendency: Just as the car enters the turn heading east, the passenger's inertia naturally tends to keep them moving in a straight line in the -direction (due east) at constant speed .
-
Perceived Outward Push vs. Real Physical Force: As the car turns left (toward the north, ), the car's seat and door pivot inward beneath and around the passenger.
- From the non-inertial (accelerating) reference frame of the turning car, the passenger feels an apparent "centrifugal force" throwing them outward to the right (south, ). This is a fictitious force arising entirely from observing motion from an accelerated frame.
- In a true inertial frame (fixed to the ground), there is no outward physical force. The only real horizontal force acting on the passenger is the inward contact force (static friction from the seat and/or normal force from the seatbelt/door) directed toward the center of curvature (north, ), forcing the passenger to deviate from their straight-line path.
Part (b): Magnitude and Direction of the Net Force
For an object following a circular path of radius at constant speed , it undergoes centripetal acceleration directed toward the center of curvature:
- Direction of Net Force: Because the car is initially heading east () and turning counter-clockwise toward the north (), the center of the turning circle lies directly to the left, which is due north (-direction). By Newton's second law, , so the net physical force must point radially inward toward the center of the turn (due north / -direction).
-
Magnitude of Net Force:
Substitute the given values:
Part (c): Friction Analysis
To prevent sliding, static friction must supply the entire centripetal force required to maintain the circular path.
-
Maximum Available Static Friction: On a level horizontal surface, the normal force is . The maximum static friction force is:
Taking :
-
Comparison:
- Required force:
- Maximum static friction:
Because , friction alone cannot keep the passenger moving along the circular path without sliding. The passenger will slide outward toward the right door unless supported by an additional restraining force (such as a seatbelt or the car door) with a numerical deficit of:
Typical errors
01 The student forgets to square the velocity when calculating the centripetal acceleration, yielding an underestimated required force and an incorrect conclusion that friction is sufficient.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
By Newton's first law, the passenger's body tends to keep moving straight ahead due to inertia. As the car turns north, the car turns into the passenger, making it feel like an outward push. The only real physical force is directed inward toward the center of the turn.
- Step 2
+y
- Step 3
F_{} = = = 20.4_
Correct|\Sigma | = = = 489.6 490
You forgot to square the speed in the centripetal force formula. Centripetal acceleration is , so the net force is , not .
- Step 4
f_{s,\max} = _s mg = 0.650 68.0 9.80 = 433.2
- Step 5
= f_{s,\max} - F_{} = 433.2 - 20.4 = +412.8
Correctf_{s,\max} - F_{} = 433.2 - 489.6 = -56.4 56.4.
Your comparison logic was sound, but your conclusion was thrown off by the incorrect net force from Step 3. Because the required force () exceeds maximum static friction (), friction alone is insufficient.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly applied Newton's first law to explain why the passenger feels an outward sensation.
You correctly distinguished between the fictitious outward feeling and the real inward centripetal force.
You correctly calculated the maximum available static friction using .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou wrote instead of , omitting the exponent on .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou used an incomplete expression for centripetal acceleration ( instead of ), likely confusing circular acceleration with angular velocity formulas (like ) or dimensional units.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Dimensional Check for Force
Force must have units of . The term has units , which is not a unit of force.
Always verify that your acceleration formula has units of , requiring or .
- Centripetal Force Formula
Centripetal acceleration is , making .
Write out explicitly before substituting numbers to make sure the square is not skipped.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecalculate the net centripetal force using the correct formula: .
Compare the required centripetal force to the maximum available static friction: .
Compute the deficit margin: .
Friction alone is insufficient to prevent sliding; the passenger will slip outward unless an additional force of at least (or ) is provided by a seatbelt or the car door.
02 The student believes an actual physical centrifugal force acts outward, incorrectly identifying the direction of the net real physical force as south.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
The passenger is pushed outward because a real centrifugal force acts on objects moving in a circle. ⟹ The real physical force acts toward the outside of the curve, pointing south.
CorrectBy Newton's first law, the passenger's inertia tends to preserve their straight-line tangential velocity due east (-direction). In an inertial frame attached to the ground, there is no physical outward force; the sensation of being thrown outward is an apparent effect of being in an accelerating reference frame. The only real horizontal physical force acts inward toward the center of curvature (north, -direction).
You treated 'centrifugal force' as an actual physical interaction. In an inertial frame, centrifugal force does not exist; the outward sensation is caused by your body's inertia wanting to continue moving in a straight line while the vehicle curves beneath you.
- Step 2
Direction: outward away from the center of curvature (south, -y direction) ⟹
Correctpoints radially inward toward the center of curvature (due north, -direction);
You calculated the numerical magnitude of the net force accurately as . However, because the car turns toward the north, the centripetal acceleration and the net physical force must point inward toward the center of the turn (-direction, north), not outward (south).
- Step 3
⟹ ⟹ Since by , friction alone is not sufficient to keep the passenger from sliding.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used the formula for centripetal force magnitude and evaluated it to .
You correctly calculated the maximum static friction force using .
You correctly concluded that friction alone cannot keep the passenger on the circular path because the required force exceeds the maximum available friction.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou interpreted the perceived outward push experienced in a turning vehicle as an actual physical force (centrifugal force) acting in an inertial frame, which led you to assign an outward direction (south) to the real net physical force rather than an inward centripetal direction (north).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Inertia vs. Real Force
In an inertial reference frame, an object in uniform circular motion has an acceleration pointing strictly toward the center of the circular path: . By , the net physical force must also point toward the center.
Always identify the center of the circular arc. Draw the net real force vector pointing directly toward that center, and attribute any 'outward' feeling to the body's inertia trying to maintain a straight-line path.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRecognize that as the car turns north from an eastward heading, the center of curvature lies due north ().
Apply Newton's first law: the passenger's body tends to continue moving straight east (). As the car turns north, the seat/door must push the passenger north toward the center.
State the direction of the net physical force as radially inward toward the center of curvature (north, -direction).
(a) Sensation is due to inertia resisting deviation from the straight eastward path; the real force points inward (north). (b) Net physical force points due north () with magnitude . (c) Friction alone cannot keep the passenger on the path; deficit is .
03 The student confuses the static friction coefficient with the required centripetal acceleration, calculating maximum friction as μ_s m v² / R instead of μ_s m g.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
According to Newton's first law, the passenger's inertia carries them in a straight line. ⟹ The sensation of being thrown outward is due to the car turning under them, not an outward force. ⟹ The real physical force points inward toward the center of the turn.
- Step 2
+y F_{} = = = 489.6_
- Step 3
f_{s,\max} = _s = 0.650 489.6 = 318.2
Correctf_{s,\max} = _s F_N = s m g = 0.650 68.0 9.80^2 = 433.2
You multiplied the friction coefficient by the centripetal force instead of the vertical normal force . Friction depends on how hard the surfaces press against each other vertically, not on the horizontal acceleration.
- Step 4
= f_{s,\max} - F_{} = 318.2 - 489.6 = -171.4 -171.4
Correct= f_{s,\max} - F_{} = 433.2 - 489.6 = -56.4 56.4
Your qualitative conclusion that friction alone is insufficient is correct, but your numerical deficit is inaccurate due to the calculation error in Step 3.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly applied Newton's first law to explain why an occupant feels an apparent outward push during a turn.
You correctly identified that the actual net horizontal force points radially inward toward the center of curvature.
You evaluated the required centripetal force formula with accurate numerical values.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou substituted the horizontal net centripetal force into the friction equation instead of using the vertical normal force .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify Normal Force from Perpendicular Equilibrium
On a level, unbanked horizontal surface with no vertical acceleration, the normal force balances gravity: .
Draw a vertical free-body diagram to find before computing maximum static friction .
- Separate Force Capacity from Required Force
The maximum available static friction is an upper limit determined by the surface contact, while is the kinetic requirement to hold the turn.
Compute using vertical contact forces and compare it against the horizontal centripetal requirement .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFind the normal force acting on the passenger along the vertical axis: .
Calculate the maximum available static friction: .
Compare available friction with the required centripetal force: .
Friction alone cannot keep the passenger on the path; there is a deficit of (or a margin of ).
Lock it in
What is the formula for the centripetal acceleration of an object moving at tangential speed along a circular path of radius ?
(or ). Note that speed must be squared so the units are .
Similar question
A car rounds a flat, horizontal curve of radius at a constant speed of . Calculate the magnitude of the net horizontal force needed to keep the car on the curve.
Answer
. Key steps: directed radially inward.
An cyclist negotiates an unbanked circular turn of radius on a level road with static friction coefficient . Find the maximum speed at which the cyclist can turn without skidding (take ).
Answer
. Key steps: Set , which simplifies to .
A box of mass sits on a flat rotating turntable at a distance of from the central axis. The coefficient of static friction is . If the turntable rotates at an angular speed of , determine whether the box will slip, and find the margin between the available friction and the required force ().
Answer
The box will not slip; friction exceeds the required force by a positive margin of . Key steps: . Maximum static friction is ... Wait: , so the box will slip with a deficit of .