Resources

A circular hard disk platter rotates at a constant angular rate of 7200 rpm7200\text{ rpm}. Track AA is located at radius rA=2.00 cmr_A = 2.00\text{ cm} and Track BB is located at radius rB=4.00 cmr_B = 4.00\text{ cm} from the central spindle. A student conjectures that because Track BB has twice the circumference of Track AA, a sector on Track BB must take twice as long to complete one revolution. Evaluate this claim by calculating the rotational period TT and tangential linear speed vv for a data bit located on Track AA versus Track BB.

Answer and steps

Final answer

The student's claim is incorrect: both tracks share the identical period T=8.33×10−3 sT = 8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s} (f=120 Hzf = 120\text{ Hz}) because all points on a rigid body possess the same angular velocity. However, tangential speeds differ: vA=15.1 m/sv_A = 15.1\text{ m/s} and vB=30.2 m/sv_B = 30.2\text{ m/s}.

Steps

01

Rotational Frequency and Period

The hard disk platter behaves as a rigid rotating body. Every point on the platter completes one full rotation in the exact same amount of time, regardless of its radial distance from the center.

Convert the rotational rate from revolutions per minute (rpm\text{rpm}) to frequency ff in hertz (Hz\text{Hz} or rev/s\text{rev/s}):

f=7200 rev60 s=120 Hzf = \frac{7200\text{ rev}}{60\text{ s}} = 120\text{ Hz}

The rotational period TT is the reciprocal of the frequency:

T=1f=1120 s−1≈8.33×10−3 sT = \frac{1}{f} = \frac{1}{120\text{ s}^{-1}} \approx 8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}

Since the disk rotates as a single rigid unit, Track AA and Track BB share the exact same period:

TA=TB=8.33×10−3 sT_A = T_B = 8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}


02

Angular Velocity

The uniform angular velocity ω\omega of the entire platter is given by:

ω=2πf=2π(120 s−1)=240π rad/s≈754 rad/s\omega = 2\pi f = 2\pi (120\text{ s}^{-1}) = 240\pi\text{ rad/s} \approx 754\text{ rad/s}


03

Tangential Linear Speeds

The tangential speed vv of a point located at radius rr is:

v=ωr=2πrTv = \omega r = \frac{2\pi r}{T}

Convert the radii to meters:

  • rA=2.00 cm=0.0200 mr_A = 2.00\text{ cm} = 0.0200\text{ m}
  • rB=4.00 cm=0.0400 mr_B = 4.00\text{ cm} = 0.0400\text{ m}

Calculate the tangential speed for each track:

  • Track AA: vA=(240π rad/s)(0.0200 m)≈15.1 m/sv_A = (240\pi\text{ rad/s})(0.0200\text{ m}) \approx 15.1\text{ m/s}
  • Track BB: vB=(240π rad/s)(0.0400 m)≈30.2 m/sv_B = (240\pi\text{ rad/s})(0.0400\text{ m}) \approx 30.2\text{ m/s}

04

Evaluating the Student's Claim

  • Common Pitfall: Conflating angular parameters (period TT, angular speed ω\omega) with linear parameters (arc length ss, tangential speed vv).
  • Conclusion: The student's claim is incorrect. While Track BB indeed has twice the circumference of Track AA, it also travels at twice the tangential speed (vB=2vAv_B = 2v_A). As a result, both tracks complete one revolution in the same time interval (T=8.33×10−3 sT = 8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses rotational period with circumference, assuming that because the path length is doubled, the period must also double at constant linear speed.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    f=720060=120 rev/s  ⟹  TA=1120 s≈0.00833 sf = \frac{7200}{60} = 120\text{ rev/s} \implies T_A = \frac{1}{120}\text{ s} \approx 0.00833\text{ s}

  2. Step 2

    TB=2×TA=2120 s≈0.0167 s  ⟹  The claim is correct because Track B has twice the perimeter so it takes twice the time.T_B = 2 \times T_A = \frac{2}{120}\text{ s} \approx 0.0167\text{ s} \implies \text{The claim is correct because Track B has twice the perimeter so it takes twice the time.}

    Correct

    TB=TA=1f≈8.33×10−3 s  ⟹  The claim is incorrect.T_B = T_A = \frac{1}{f} \approx 8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s} \implies \text{The claim is incorrect.}

    You assumed that a larger circular path requires more time per revolution. On a rigid rotating body, all points rotate together through the same angle in any given time interval, so every track has the exact same period T=8.33×10−3 sT = 8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}.

  3. Step 3

    vA=2π(0.0200)0.00833≈15.1 m/svB=2π(0.0400)0.0167≈15.1 m/sv_A = \frac{2\pi(0.0200)}{0.00833} \approx 15.1\text{ m/s} \quad v_B = \frac{2\pi(0.0400)}{0.0167} \approx 15.1\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vA=2π(0.0200 m)8.33×10−3 s≈15.1 m/svB=2π(0.0400 m)8.33×10−3 s≈30.2 m/sv_A = \frac{2\pi(0.0200\text{ m})}{8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}} \approx 15.1\text{ m/s} \quad v_B = \frac{2\pi(0.0400\text{ m})}{8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}} \approx 30.2\text{ m/s}

    Your formula v=2πrTv = \frac{2\pi r}{T} is correct, and vAv_A is accurate. However, substituting the doubled period into the calculation for Track BB led to an incorrect tangential speed of 15.1 m/s15.1\text{ m/s} instead of 30.2 m/s30.2\text{ m/s}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly converted 7200 rpm7200\text{ rpm} into a frequency of 120 Hz120\text{ Hz}.

You used the correct relationship between frequency and period, T=1fT = \frac{1}{f}, to find TAT_A.

You applied the correct formula v=2πrTv = \frac{2\pi r}{T} to calculate tangential linear speed.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Rigid body kinematics misconception: conflating angular period with linear travel time at constant linear speed

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the linear speed vv as constant across different radii rather than recognizing that points on a rigid rotating body share a constant angular velocity ω\omega and constant period TT. Doubling the radius doubles the distance traveled per turn, but it also doubles the tangential speed, keeping the period unchanged.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Rigid Body Angular Uniformity
  • Every point on a rigid body rotating about a fixed axis shares the exact same angular velocity ω\omega, frequency ff, and period TT.

  • Always set TA=TB=1fT_A = T_B = \frac{1}{f} for points on the same continuous rigid disk.

Linear vs. Angular Speed Scaling
  • Linear speed scales proportionally with radius: v=ωr=2πrTv = \omega r = \frac{2\pi r}{T}.

  • When radius doubles at a fixed angular rate, double the linear speed vv, not the period TT.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that the platter is a rigid body, so Track BB rotates at the same angular frequency as Track AA: TB=TA=1120 s≈8.33×10−3 sT_B = T_A = \frac{1}{120}\text{ s} \approx 8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}.

  2. Conclude that the conjecture is incorrect: Track BB does not take twice as long to complete one revolution.

  3. Substitute the correct period TB=8.33×10−3 sT_B = 8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s} and radius rB=0.0400 mr_B = 0.0400\text{ m} into vB=2πrBTBv_B = \frac{2\pi r_B}{T_B} to obtain vB=2π(0.0400 m)8.33×10−3 s≈30.2 m/sv_B = \frac{2\pi(0.0400\text{ m})}{8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}} \approx 30.2\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

The claim is incorrect: both tracks share the identical period T=8.33×10−3 sT = 8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s} (f=120 Hzf = 120\text{ Hz}). The tangential linear speeds are vA=15.1 m/sv_A = 15.1\text{ m/s} and vB=30.2 m/sv_B = 30.2\text{ m/s}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between angular quantities (ω\omega, ff, TT, which are identical for all points on a rigid body) and tangential quantities (ss, vv, ata_t, which scale with radial distance rr).

  • Practice checking whether an object rotates as a single rigid unit before calculating individual track periods.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to convert revolutions per minute to revolutions per second, using 7200 directly as the frequency in Hertz.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    f=7200 Hzf = 7200\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f=7200 rev60 s=120 Hzf = \frac{7200\text{ rev}}{60\text{ s}} = 120\text{ Hz}

    You treated revolutions per minute directly as revolutions per second (Hz). Because 1 min=60 s1\text{ min} = 60\text{ s}, you must divide the rotational rate in rpm\text{rpm} by 6060 to obtain the frequency in hertz.

  2. Step 2

    TA=TB=17200 s≈0.000139 sT_A = T_B = \frac{1}{7200}\text{ s} \approx 0.000139\text{ s}

    Correct

    TA=TB=1120 s−1≈8.33×10−3 sT_A = T_B = \frac{1}{120\text{ s}^{-1}} \approx 8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}

    Your formula T=1fT = \frac{1}{f} and your understanding that both tracks share the same period are correct, but the numerical answer is affected by your earlier frequency error.

  3. Step 3

    The claim is false because both tracks have the same period.

  4. Step 4

    ω=2πf=2π(7200)=14400π rad/s\omega = 2\pi f = 2\pi(7200) = 14400\pi\text{ rad/s}

    Correct

    ω=2πf=2π(120 s−1)=240π rad/s≈754 rad/s\omega = 2\pi f = 2\pi(120\text{ s}^{-1}) = 240\pi\text{ rad/s} \approx 754\text{ rad/s}

    Your formula ω=2πf\omega = 2\pi f is correct, but substituting f=7200 Hzf = 7200\text{ Hz} instead of 120 Hz120\text{ Hz} led to an angular speed that is 60 times too large.

  5. Step 5

    vA=(0.0200)(14400π)=288π m/s≈905 m/s  ⟹  vB=(0.0400)(14400π)=576π m/s≈1810 m/sv_A = (0.0200)(14400\pi) = 288\pi\text{ m/s} \approx 905\text{ m/s} \implies v_B = (0.0400)(14400\pi) = 576\pi\text{ m/s} \approx 1810\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vA=(240π rad/s)(0.0200 m)≈15.1 m/s  ⟹  vB=(240π rad/s)(0.0400 m)≈30.2 m/sv_A = (240\pi\text{ rad/s})(0.0200\text{ m}) \approx 15.1\text{ m/s} \implies v_B = (240\pi\text{ rad/s})(0.0400\text{ m}) \approx 30.2\text{ m/s}

    You converted the radii to meters and applied v=ωrv = \omega r correctly, but the resulting speeds inherited the factor-of-60 error from ω\omega.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that a rigid rotating body gives every track the identical rotational period and angular velocity.

You correctly refuted the conjecture that larger circumference implies a longer period.

You converted centimeters to meters accurately before computing linear speeds.

You correctly applied the fundamental relationships T=1fT = \frac{1}{f}, ω=2πf\omega = 2\pi f, and v=ωrv = \omega r.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unit Conversion Error

You set f=7200 Hzf = 7200\text{ Hz} directly instead of converting revolutions per minute to revolutions per second by dividing by 60.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Overlooking the difference between time units in rotational rates: 'rpm' counts cycles per minute, whereas the SI unit 'Hz' counts cycles per second.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Rotational Rate Units
  • Rotational speed given in rpm\text{rpm} is not in SI base units. 1 Hz=1 rev/s=60 rpm1\text{ Hz} = 1\text{ rev/s} = 60\text{ rpm}.

  • Always multiply by 1 min60 s\frac{1\text{ min}}{60\text{ s}} to convert rpm\text{rpm} to Hz\text{Hz} before calculating TT, ω\omega, or vv.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert rotational rate to frequency: f=7200 rev/min60 s/min=120 Hzf = \frac{7200\text{ rev/min}}{60\text{ s/min}} = 120\text{ Hz}.

  2. Compute the rotational period: TA=TB=1f=1120 s−1≈8.33×10−3 sT_A = T_B = \frac{1}{f} = \frac{1}{120\text{ s}^{-1}} \approx 8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}.

  3. Determine the angular velocity: ω=2πf=2π(120 s−1)=240π rad/s≈754 rad/s\omega = 2\pi f = 2\pi(120\text{ s}^{-1}) = 240\pi\text{ rad/s} \approx 754\text{ rad/s}.

  4. Compute tangential speeds using rA=0.0200 mr_A = 0.0200\text{ m} and rB=0.0400 mr_B = 0.0400\text{ m}: vA=(240π)(0.0200)≈15.1 m/sv_A = (240\pi)(0.0200) \approx 15.1\text{ m/s} and vB=(240π)(0.0400)≈30.2 m/sv_B = (240\pi)(0.0400) \approx 30.2\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

The claim is incorrect. Both tracks share the period T=8.33×10−3 sT = 8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}. The tangential speeds are vA=15.1 m/sv_A = 15.1\text{ m/s} and vB=30.2 m/sv_B = 30.2\text{ m/s}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice converting rotational quantities between rpm\text{rpm}, Hz\text{Hz}, and rad/s\text{rad/s} as an automatic first step.

  • Verify calculated tangential speeds against physical intuition: 905 m/s905\text{ m/s} is almost Mach 3, which is unrealistically high for a hard drive platter.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student keeps radius in centimeters instead of converting to meters, resulting in tangential speeds that are 100 times too large.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    f=7200/60=120 rev/s  ⟹  TA=TB=1120 s≈0.00833 sf = 7200/60 = 120\text{ rev/s} \implies T_A = T_B = \frac{1}{120}\text{ s} \approx 0.00833\text{ s}

  2. Step 2

    The claim is incorrect because all points on the platter complete one revolution in the same period.

  3. Step 3

    ω=2π(120)=240π rad/s\omega = 2\pi(120) = 240\pi\text{ rad/s}

  4. Step 4

    vA=rA×ω=2.00×240π=480π cm/s≈1508 m/sv_A = r_A \times \omega = 2.00 \times 240\pi = 480\pi\text{ cm/s} \approx 1508\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vA=ωrA=(240π rad/s)(0.0200 m)≈15.1 m/sv_A = \omega r_A = (240\pi\text{ rad/s})(0.0200\text{ m}) \approx 15.1\text{ m/s}

    You calculated 480π≈1508 cm/s480\pi \approx 1508\text{ cm/s}, but you wrote the unit as m/s\text{m/s} without dividing by 100 cm/m100\text{ cm/m}. Converting to SI units gives vA=15.1 m/sv_A = 15.1\text{ m/s}.

  5. Step 5

    vB=rB×ω=4.00×240π=960π cm/s≈3016 m/sv_B = r_B \times \omega = 4.00 \times 240\pi = 960\pi\text{ cm/s} \approx 3016\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vB=ωrB=(240π rad/s)(0.0400 m)≈30.2 m/sv_B = \omega r_B = (240\pi\text{ rad/s})(0.0400\text{ m}) \approx 30.2\text{ m/s}

    You repeated the same unit conversion error for Track BB. The value 30163016 is in cm/s\text{cm/s}; dividing by 100100 gives vB≈30.2 m/sv_B \approx 30.2\text{ m/s}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly converted the rotational rate from rpm\text{rpm} to frequency in rev/s\text{rev/s}.

You recognized that all points on a rigid rotating body share the exact same rotational period.

You correctly calculated the angular velocity using ω=2πf\omega = 2\pi f.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Unit conversion omission in linear speed

You calculated the numerical value using radius in centimeters (480π≈1508 cm/s480\pi \approx 1508\text{ cm/s}) and then directly replaced the unit symbol with m/s\text{m/s} instead of dividing by 100100.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Inconsistent handling of SI base units: substituting radius in centimeters into v=ωrv = \omega r yields centimeters per second, requiring an explicit factor of 10−210^{-2} to express the result in standard meters per second.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Convert lengths to meters before calculating
  • In kinematics formulas like v=ωrv = \omega r, ω\omega is in rad/s\text{rad/s} and rr must be in meters (m\text{m}) for vv to come out in standard SI units (m/s\text{m/s}).

  • Always convert centimeters to meters (r=2.00 cm=0.0200 mr = 2.00\text{ cm} = 0.0200\text{ m}) at the very beginning before plugging values into equations.

Sanity check physical magnitudes
  • Compare calculated speeds against intuitive physical benchmarks.

  • A speed of 1508 m/s1508\text{ m/s} is roughly Mach 4.4, which is physically impossible for a consumer hard disk platter. Noticing this extreme speed alerts you to an unscaled centimeter-to-meter conversion.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Convert each radius to SI base units: rA=2.00 cm=0.0200 mr_A = 2.00\text{ cm} = 0.0200\text{ m} and rB=4.00 cm=0.0400 mr_B = 4.00\text{ cm} = 0.0400\text{ m}.

  2. Compute Track AA speed: vA=ωrA=(240π rad/s)(0.0200 m)=4.80π m/s≈15.1 m/sv_A = \omega r_A = (240\pi\text{ rad/s})(0.0200\text{ m}) = 4.80\pi\text{ m/s} \approx 15.1\text{ m/s}.

  3. Compute Track BB speed: vB=ωrB=(240π rad/s)(0.0400 m)=9.60π m/s≈30.2 m/sv_B = \omega r_B = (240\pi\text{ rad/s})(0.0400\text{ m}) = 9.60\pi\text{ m/s} \approx 30.2\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

The claim is incorrect: both tracks share the identical period T=8.33×10−3 sT = 8.33 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s}, but their tangential speeds are vA=15.1 m/sv_A = 15.1\text{ m/s} and vB=30.2 m/sv_B = 30.2\text{ m/s}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice converting non-SI prefixes (like cm\text{cm} or mm\text{mm}) into base meters during the initial 'given' step.

  • Solve a set of rotational problems comparing linear tangential quantities (s,v,ats, v, a_t) with angular quantities (θ,ω,α\theta, \omega, \alpha).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A vinyl record spins at a constant rate of 3313 rpm33\frac{1}{3}\text{ rpm}. Point PP is located at radius rP=6.0 cmr_P = 6.0\text{ cm} and Point QQ is at radius rQ=12.0 cmr_Q = 12.0\text{ cm}. Calculate the period TT for each point and determine the ratio of their tangential speeds vQvP\frac{v_Q}{v_P}.

Answer

TP=TQ=1.8 sT_P = T_Q = 1.8\text{ s}, and vQvP=2.0\frac{v_Q}{v_P} = 2.0. Frequency f=100/360=59 Hzf = \frac{100/3}{60} = \frac{5}{9}\text{ Hz}, giving period T=1f=1.8 sT = \frac{1}{f} = 1.8\text{ s} for all points on the record. Since v=ωrv = \omega r, the speed ratio equals the radius ratio: vQvP=rQrP=12.06.0=2.0\frac{v_Q}{v_P} = \frac{r_Q}{r_P} = \frac{12.0}{6.0} = 2.0.

02

A compact disc (CD) rotates with a period of T=0.050 sT = 0.050\text{ s}. Compare two data pits: Pit 1 at r1=2.5 cmr_1 = 2.5\text{ cm} and Pit 2 at r2=5.0 cmr_2 = 5.0\text{ cm}. Calculate the tangential speed of each pit and the angular distance each sweeps out in 0.025 s0.025\text{ s}.

Answer

v1=3.14 m/sv_1 = 3.14\text{ m/s}, v2=6.28 m/sv_2 = 6.28\text{ m/s}; both sweep out π rad\pi\text{ rad} (180∘180^\circ). Angular velocity is ω=2πT=40π rad/s\omega = \frac{2\pi}{T} = 40\pi\text{ rad/s}. Then v1=(40π)(0.025)≈3.14 m/sv_1 = (40\pi)(0.025) \approx 3.14\text{ m/s} and v2=(40π)(0.050)≈6.28 m/sv_2 = (40\pi)(0.050) \approx 6.28\text{ m/s}. In t=0.025 st = 0.025\text{ s}, Δθ=ωt=(40π)(0.025)=π rad\Delta\theta = \omega t = (40\pi)(0.025) = \pi\text{ rad} for both pits.

03

A centrifuge rotor accelerates uniformly from rest to 12,000 rpm12{,}000\text{ rpm} in 30.0 s30.0\text{ s}. Once at top speed, test tube position XX is at radius 8.0 cm8.0\text{ cm} and position YY is at radius 16.0 cm16.0\text{ cm}. Determine: (a) the steady-state frequency ff and period TT for each position, and (b) the centripetal acceleration aca_c at position YY relative to position XX.

Answer

(a) f=200 Hzf = 200\text{ Hz} and T=5.00×10−3 sT = 5.00 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s} for both positions; (b) ac,Y=2ac,Xa_{c,Y} = 2a_{c,X} (ac,Y≈2.53×105 m/s2a_{c,Y} \approx 2.53 \times 10^5\text{ m/s}^2, ac,X≈1.26×105 m/s2a_{c,X} \approx 1.26 \times 10^5\text{ m/s}^2). Frequency is f=1200060=200 Hzf = \frac{12000}{60} = 200\text{ Hz}, so T=1200=5.00×10−3 sT = \frac{1}{200} = 5.00 \times 10^{-3}\text{ s} identically for all points on the rotor. With ω=2πf=400π rad/s\omega = 2\pi f = 400\pi\text{ rad/s}, centripetal acceleration is ac=ω2ra_c = \omega^2 r, meaning ac,Y/ac,X=rY/rX=2a_{c,Y} / a_{c,X} = r_Y / r_X = 2.

Loading workspace…