Resources

In an optical bench laboratory experiment, an illuminated crosshairs target (the object) and a viewing screen are fixed at the opposite ends of a precision optical bench track separated by a total distance D=100.0 cmD = 100.0\text{ cm}. A thin biconvex lens mounted on a sliding carriage is translated between them. The experimenter locates exactly two distinct carriage positions, separated by a displacement distance d=40.0 cmd = 40.0\text{ cm}, where a sharply focused real image forms on the screen (the Bessel displacement method). Using the analytical Bessel relation f=D2−d24Df = \frac{D^2 - d^2}{4D}, calculate the focal length ff of the lens, and determine the ratio of the image height of the magnified image to that of the diminished image, hi,1hi,2\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

f=21.0 cmf = 21.0\text{ cm}, hi,1hi,2=499≈5.44\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{49}{9} \approx 5.44

Steps

01

Calculate the Focal Length ff

In Bessel's displacement method, an illuminated object and a screen are placed at a fixed separation DD. For a converging lens of focal length f<D4f < \frac{D}{4}, there exist two distinct positions of the lens that form a sharp, real image on the screen. If the separation between these two lens positions is dd, the focal length is given by:

f=D2−d24Df = \frac{D^2 - d^2}{4D}

Substitute the given values, D=100.0 cmD = 100.0\text{ cm} and d=40.0 cmd = 40.0\text{ cm}:

f=(100.0 cm)2−(40.0 cm)24(100.0 cm)=10000−1600400 cm=8400400 cm=21.0 cmf = \frac{(100.0\text{ cm})^2 - (40.0\text{ cm})^2}{4(100.0\text{ cm})} = \frac{10000 - 1600}{400}\text{ cm} = \frac{8400}{400}\text{ cm} = 21.0\text{ cm}


02

Determine Object and Image Distances for Both Positions

By the reversibility of light and the symmetry of the thin lens equation 1u+1v=1f\frac{1}{u} + \frac{1}{v} = \frac{1}{f}, the object distance and image distance interchange between the two sharp image configurations:

  • For the first position (closer to the object, forming a magnified image): u1=D−d2=100.0 cm−40.0 cm2=30.0 cmu_1 = \frac{D - d}{2} = \frac{100.0\text{ cm} - 40.0\text{ cm}}{2} = 30.0\text{ cm} v1=D+d2=100.0 cm+40.0 cm2=70.0 cmv_1 = \frac{D + d}{2} = \frac{100.0\text{ cm} + 40.0\text{ cm}}{2} = 70.0\text{ cm}
  • For the second position (closer to the screen, forming a diminished image): u2=D+d2=70.0 cmu_2 = \frac{D + d}{2} = 70.0\text{ cm} v2=D−d2=30.0 cmv_2 = \frac{D - d}{2} = 30.0\text{ cm}

03

Calculate the Magnification Ratio

The lateral magnification magnitude is m=vum = \frac{v}{u}, so the image height is hi=m⋅hoh_i = m \cdot h_o:

  • For the magnified image: m1=v1u1=70.030.0=73m_1 = \frac{v_1}{u_1} = \frac{70.0}{30.0} = \frac{7}{3}
  • For the diminished image: m2=v2u2=30.070.0=37m_2 = \frac{v_2}{u_2} = \frac{30.0}{70.0} = \frac{3}{7}

Taking the ratio of the two image heights:

hi,1hi,2=m1hom2ho=m1m2=7/33/7=(73)2=499≈5.44\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{m_1 h_o}{m_2 h_o} = \frac{m_1}{m_2} = \frac{7/3}{3/7} = \left(\frac{7}{3}\right)^2 = \frac{49}{9} \approx 5.44

Common Pitfall: Avoid calculating the image ratio simply as the ratio of displacements D+dD−d\frac{D+d}{D-d}. The image height is proportional to linear magnification m=vum = \frac{v}{u}, meaning the ratio of the two heights depends quadratically on the distance ratio: hi,1hi,2=(D+dD−d)2\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \left(\frac{D+d}{D-d}\right)^2.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the magnification of the magnified image with the ratio of the two image heights, reporting m₁ instead of m₁/m₂.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    f=100.02−40.024×100.0  ⟹  f=10000−1600400.0=21.0 cmf = \frac{100.0^2 - 40.0^2}{4 \times 100.0} \implies f = \frac{10000 - 1600}{400.0} = 21.0\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    u1=100.0−40.02=30.0 cm  ⟹  v1=100.0−30.0=70.0 cmu_1 = \frac{100.0 - 40.0}{2} = 30.0\text{ cm} \implies v_1 = 100.0 - 30.0 = 70.0\text{ cm}

  3. Step 3

    hi,1hi,2=v1u1=70.030.0=73\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{v_1}{u_1} = \frac{70.0}{30.0} = \frac{7}{3}

    Correct

    hi,1hi,2=m1hom2ho=m1m2=v1/u1v2/u2=(70.030.0)2=499≈5.44\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{m_1 h_o}{m_2 h_o} = \frac{m_1}{m_2} = \frac{v_1 / u_1}{v_2 / u_2} = \left(\frac{70.0}{30.0}\right)^2 = \frac{49}{9} \approx 5.44

    You calculated the linear magnification of the magnified image relative to the object (m1=hi,1ho=73m_1 = \frac{h_{i,1}}{h_o} = \frac{7}{3}), rather than the ratio between the heights of the two images (hi,1hi,2=m1m2\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{m_1}{m_2}). Because the second image has magnification m2=u1v1=37m_2 = \frac{u_1}{v_1} = \frac{3}{7}, the ratio of their heights is m12=499m_1^2 = \frac{49}{9}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted the track distance and lens displacement into Bessel's formula to find the focal length.

You correctly calculated the object and image distances for the first lens position using the displacement geometry.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula confusion between magnification and ratio of image heights

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the ratio of the two image heights hi,1hi,2\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} as the ratio of image distance to object distance for a single lens position (v1u1\frac{v_1}{u_1}), overlooking that the denominator is the diminished image height hi,2h_{i,2} rather than the original object height hoh_o.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Distinguish single magnification from image-to-image ratio
  • For an object of height hoh_o, the individual image heights are hi,1=m1hoh_{i,1} = m_1 h_o and hi,2=m2hoh_{i,2} = m_2 h_o. Therefore, hi,1hi,2=m1m2\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{m_1}{m_2}.

  • Always write down the heights in terms of both magnifications before simplifying, ensuring that the object height cancels out properly.

Use conjugate symmetry in Bessel's method
  • Because the two lens positions interchange object and image distances, m1=v1u1m_1 = \frac{v_1}{u_1} and m2=u1v1=1m1m_2 = \frac{u_1}{v_1} = \frac{1}{m_1}.

  • Express the ratio of image heights as hi,1hi,2=m1m2=m12=(D+dD−d)2\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{m_1}{m_2} = m_1^2 = \left(\frac{D+d}{D-d}\right)^2.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the magnification of the first (magnified) image: m1=v1u1=70.0 cm30.0 cm=73m_1 = \frac{v_1}{u_1} = \frac{70.0\text{ cm}}{30.0\text{ cm}} = \frac{7}{3}.

  2. Identify the magnification of the second (diminished) image by conjugate symmetry: m2=v2u2=u1v1=30.0 cm70.0 cm=37m_2 = \frac{v_2}{u_2} = \frac{u_1}{v_1} = \frac{30.0\text{ cm}}{70.0\text{ cm}} = \frac{3}{7}.

  3. Compute the ratio of the two image heights: hi,1hi,2=m1m2=7/33/7=(73)2=499≈5.44\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{m_1}{m_2} = \frac{7/3}{3/7} = \left(\frac{7}{3}\right)^2 = \frac{49}{9} \approx 5.44.

Final answer

f=21.0 cm,hi,1hi,2=499≈5.44f = 21.0\text{ cm}, \quad \frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{49}{9} \approx 5.44

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review conjugate focal relationships in thin lens imaging, noting how object and image distances switch between the two sharp positions.

  • Practice expressing ratios of derived quantities (such as two different image sizes) in terms of base definitions before substituting numerical values.

  • Work through Bessel displacement problems to reinforce the relation hi,1hi,2=m12\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = m_1^2 and ho=hi,1hi,2h_o = \sqrt{h_{i,1} h_{i,2}}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets the factor of 4 in the denominator of the Bessel formula, resulting in a focal length four times too large.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    f = D2−d2D\frac{D^2 - d^2}{D}   ⟹  \implies f = 100.02−40.02100.0\frac{100.0^2 - 40.0^2}{100.0}   ⟹  \implies f = 10000−1600100.0\frac{10000 - 1600}{100.0} = 84.0 cm\text{ cm}

    Correct

    f = D2−d24D\frac{D^2 - d^2}{4D} = (100.0 cm)2−(40.0 cm)24(100.0 cm)\frac{(100.0\text{ cm})^2 - (40.0\text{ cm})^2}{4(100.0\text{ cm})} = 21.0 cm\text{ cm}

    You omitted the factor of 44 in the denominator of Bessel's displacement formula. The relation is f=D2−d24Df = \frac{D^2 - d^2}{4D}, which yields f=21.0 cmf = 21.0\text{ cm}. Notice also that a real image requires D≥4fD \ge 4f; a focal length of 84.0 cm84.0\text{ cm} with D=100.0 cmD = 100.0\text{ cm} would make real image formation impossible.

  2. Step 2

    u_1 = (100.0 - 40.0)/2 = 30.0 cm\text{ cm}   ⟹  \implies v_1 = 70.0 cm\text{ cm}   ⟹  \implies u_2 = 70.0 cm\text{ cm},, v_2 = 30.0 cm\text{ cm}

  3. Step 3

    m_1 = 70.0/30.0 = 73\frac{7}{3},, m_2 = 30.070.0\frac{30.0}{70.0} = 37\frac{3}{7}   ⟹  \implies h_{i,1}/h_{i,2} = 7/33/7\frac{7/3}{3/7} = 499\frac{49}{9}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the displacement relation to find the conjugate object and image distances uu and vv.

You correctly identified the two magnifications as reciprocal values using optical reversibility.

You calculated the ratio of image heights hi,1hi,2=499\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{49}{9} accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted denominator factor in Bessel formula

You wrote f=D2−d2Df = \frac{D^2 - d^2}{D} instead of f=D2−d24Df = \frac{D^2 - d^2}{4D}, forgetting the factor of 44 in the denominator.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

In Bessel's method, the two lens positions satisfy u1=D−d2u_1 = \frac{D-d}{2} and v1=D+d2v_1 = \frac{D+d}{2}. Substituting these into 1f=1u1+1v1=u1+v1u1v1\frac{1}{f} = \frac{1}{u_1} + \frac{1}{v_1} = \frac{u_1 + v_1}{u_1 v_1} gives numerator u1+v1=Du_1 + v_1 = D and denominator u1v1=D2−d24u_1 v_1 = \frac{D^2 - d^2}{4}, leading directly to f=D2−d24Df = \frac{D^2 - d^2}{4D}. Omission of the factor 4 also violates the physical condition D≥4fD \ge 4f necessary for real image formation on a screen.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Bessel Formula Structure
  • For fixed object-screen distance DD and displacement dd, the focal length is f=D2−d24Df = \frac{D^2 - d^2}{4D}.

  • Always verify that the denominator has 4D4D, which arises from uv=D−d2⋅D+d2=D2−d24u v = \frac{D - d}{2} \cdot \frac{D + d}{2} = \frac{D^2 - d^2}{4}.

Physical Reality Sanity Check
  • A thin converging lens can project a real image onto a screen only if the object-screen separation satisfies D≥4fD \ge 4f.

  • Check if your computed focal length satisfies f≤D4=25.0 cmf \le \frac{D}{4} = 25.0\text{ cm}. A value of 84.0 cm84.0\text{ cm} is greater than 25.0 cm25.0\text{ cm}, which immediately flags an error.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write the standard Bessel relation: f=D2−d24Df = \frac{D^2 - d^2}{4D}.

  2. Substitute D=100.0 cmD = 100.0\text{ cm} and d=40.0 cmd = 40.0\text{ cm}: f=100.02−40.024(100.0)=10000−1600400 cmf = \frac{100.0^2 - 40.0^2}{4(100.0)} = \frac{10000 - 1600}{400}\text{ cm}.

  3. Divide: f=8400400 cm=21.0 cmf = \frac{8400}{400}\text{ cm} = 21.0\text{ cm}.

Final answer

f=21.0 cmf = 21.0\text{ cm}, hi,1hi,2=499≈5.44\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{49}{9} \approx 5.44

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize Bessel's formula by deriving it once from u=(D−d)/2u = (D-d)/2 and v=(D+d)/2v = (D+d)/2.

  • Perform a quick order-of-magnitude check using f≤D/4f \le D/4 whenever calculating focal length from an optical bench experiment.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the requested ratio and calculates the ratio of the diminished image height to the magnified image height.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    f=100.02−40.024×100.0  ⟹  f=8400400.0=21.0 cmf = \frac{100.0^2 - 40.0^2}{4 \times 100.0} \implies f = \frac{8400}{400.0} = 21.0\text{ cm}

  2. Step 2

    u1=30.0 cm, v1=70.0 cm  ⟹  u2=70.0 cm, v2=30.0 cmu_1 = 30.0\text{ cm},\, v_1 = 70.0\text{ cm} \implies u_2 = 70.0\text{ cm},\, v_2 = 30.0\text{ cm}

  3. Step 3

    m1=70.030.0=73  ⟹  m2=30.070.0=37m_1 = \frac{70.0}{30.0} = \frac{7}{3} \implies m_2 = \frac{30.0}{70.0} = \frac{3}{7}

  4. Step 4

    hi,1hi,2=m2m1=3/77/3=949\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{m_2}{m_1} = \frac{3/7}{7/3} = \frac{9}{49}

    Correct

    hi,1hi,2=m1m2=7/33/7=499≈5.44\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{m_1}{m_2} = \frac{7/3}{3/7} = \frac{49}{9} \approx 5.44

    Because image height is directly proportional to magnification (hi=m⋅hoh_i = m \cdot h_o), the ratio of the first (magnified) image height to the second (diminished) image height must be m1m2\frac{m_1}{m_2}, not m2m1\frac{m_2}{m_1}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted the track separation DD and displacement dd into Bessel's formula to find the focal length.

You correctly identified that the object and image distances swap between the two sharp image configurations.

You accurately calculated the individual lateral magnifications m1=73m_1 = \frac{7}{3} and m2=37m_2 = \frac{3}{7}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ratio inversion error

You equated the ratio of image heights hi,1hi,2\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} to m2m1\frac{m_2}{m_1} instead of m1m2\frac{m_1}{m_2}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You accidentally applied an inverse-proportion relationship instead of a direct-proportion relationship between image height and magnification, or you mismatched the subscripts between image heights and magnifications.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Direct Proportion Check
  • Since hi=m⋅hoh_i = m \cdot h_o and the object height hoh_o is fixed, image height is directly proportional to magnification: hi,1hi,2=m1m2\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{m_1}{m_2}.

  • Always verify that the indices align directly on both sides of the ratio (11 on top, 22 on the bottom).

Physical Sanity Check
  • The ratio of a magnified image (m1>1m_1 > 1) to a diminished image (m2<1m_2 < 1) must always be strictly greater than 11.

  • Check your final numerical ratio: if it is less than 11, you have inverted the intended comparison.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express the ratio of image heights directly in terms of magnifications: hi,1hi,2=m1hom2ho=m1m2\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{m_1 h_o}{m_2 h_o} = \frac{m_1}{m_2}.

  2. Substitute the calculated values m1=73m_1 = \frac{7}{3} and m2=37m_2 = \frac{3}{7}: hi,1hi,2=7/33/7=(73)2=499\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{7/3}{3/7} = \left(\frac{7}{3}\right)^2 = \frac{49}{9}.

Final answer

f=21.0 cm, hi,1hi,2=499≈5.44f = 21.0\text{ cm},\, \frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{49}{9} \approx 5.44

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the defining equation hi=mhoh_i = m h_o before forming ratios to guarantee subscript alignment.

  • Perform a quick magnitude sanity check: a magnified-to-diminished ratio must exceed 11.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

In a Bessel displacement setup, the distance between the object and the screen is D=90.0 cmD = 90.0\text{ cm}. A converging lens produces two sharp images when placed at two positions separated by d=30.0 cmd = 30.0\text{ cm}. Find the ratio of the larger image height to the smaller image height, hi,1hi,2\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}}.

Answer

hi,1hi,2=4\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = 4. First find u1=D−d2=90.0−30.02=30.0 cmu_1 = \frac{D - d}{2} = \frac{90.0 - 30.0}{2} = 30.0\text{ cm} and v1=D−u1=60.0 cmv_1 = D - u_1 = 60.0\text{ cm}. The magnification of the larger image is m1=v1u1=60.030.0=2m_1 = \frac{v_1}{u_1} = \frac{60.0}{30.0} = 2. By conjugate symmetry, m2=12m_2 = \frac{1}{2}, so hi,1hi,2=m1m2=22=4\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = \frac{m_1}{m_2} = 2^2 = 4.

02

A converging lens forms two sharp images of an object of unknown height hoh_o on a screen placed 120.0 cm120.0\text{ cm} away. The height of the magnified image is hi,1=8.0 cmh_{i,1} = 8.0\text{ cm} and the height of the diminished image is hi,2=2.0 cmh_{i,2} = 2.0\text{ cm}. Determine the object height hoh_o and the displacement distance dd between the two lens positions.

Answer

ho=4.0 cm,d=40.0 cmh_o = 4.0\text{ cm}, \quad d = 40.0\text{ cm}. The object height is the geometric mean ho=hi,1hi,2=8.0×2.0=4.0 cmh_o = \sqrt{h_{i,1} h_{i,2}} = \sqrt{8.0 \times 2.0} = 4.0\text{ cm}. The magnifications are m1=8.04.0=2m_1 = \frac{8.0}{4.0} = 2 and m2=2.04.0=0.5m_2 = \frac{2.0}{4.0} = 0.5. Since m1=D+dD−d=2m_1 = \frac{D+d}{D-d} = 2, we solve D+d=2(D−d)  ⟹  d=D3=120.03=40.0 cmD + d = 2(D - d) \implies d = \frac{D}{3} = \frac{120.0}{3} = 40.0\text{ cm}.

03

In an optical bench experiment with fixed object-to-screen distance D=100.0 cmD = 100.0\text{ cm}, a thin lens of focal length f=24.0 cmf = 24.0\text{ cm} is moved between the two focus positions. Calculate the displacement dd between the two positions, and determine the percentage difference between the magnification ratio hi,1hi,2\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} and the single magnification m1m_1 relative to the true ratio.

Answer

d=20.0 cmd = 20.0\text{ cm}, true ratio hi,1hi,2=2.25\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = 2.25, and the single magnification m1=1.5m_1 = 1.5 underestimates the true ratio by 33.3%33.3\%. Using f=D2−d24Df = \frac{D^2 - d^2}{4D}, we have 24.0=10000−d2400  ⟹  d2=400  ⟹  d=20.0 cm24.0 = \frac{10000 - d^2}{400} \implies d^2 = 400 \implies d = 20.0\text{ cm}. The conjugate distances are u1=100−202=40.0 cmu_1 = \frac{100 - 20}{2} = 40.0\text{ cm} and v1=60.0 cmv_1 = 60.0\text{ cm}, giving m1=6040=1.5m_1 = \frac{60}{40} = 1.5. The true ratio is hi,1hi,2=m12=1.52=2.25\frac{h_{i,1}}{h_{i,2}} = m_1^2 = 1.5^2 = 2.25. The percentage difference is ∣1.5−2.25∣2.25×100%=33.3%\frac{|1.5 - 2.25|}{2.25} \times 100\% = 33.3\%.

Loading workspace…