Resources

A newly detected comet moves in an eccentric orbit around the Sun. Its perihelion distance (closest approach) is rp=0.550 AUr_{\text{p}} = 0.550\text{ AU}, and its orbital period is determined to be T=64.0 yrT = 64.0\text{ yr}. According to Kepler's laws of planetary motion, what is the orbital eccentricity ee of this comet's elliptical orbit? Express your answer to three significant figures.

Answer and steps

Final answer

e=0.966e = 0.966

Steps

01

Find the semi-major axis aa using Kepler's Third Law

To find the orbital eccentricity ee, we use Kepler's third law to determine the semi-major axis aa, and then relate aa to the perihelion distance rpr_{\text{p}}.

Kepler's third law states that the square of the orbital period TT of a body orbiting the Sun is proportional to the cube of its semi-major axis aa: T2=a3T^2 = a^3 when TT is measured in Earth years (yr\text{yr}) and aa is measured in astronomical units (AU\text{AU}).

Given T=64.0 yrT = 64.0\text{ yr}: a=T2/3=(64.0 yr)2/3a = T^{2/3} = (64.0\text{ yr})^{2/3}

Since 64=4364 = 4^3: a=(43)2/3=42=16.0 AUa = (4^3)^{2/3} = 4^2 = 16.0\text{ AU}


02

Relate the perihelion distance to the eccentricity

In an elliptical orbit with semi-major axis aa and eccentricity ee, the perihelion distance (the closest distance to the Sun at one focus) is given by: rp=a(1−e)r_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e)

Rearranging this formula to solve for the eccentricity ee: rpa=1−e\frac{r_{\text{p}}}{a} = 1 - e e=1−rpae = 1 - \frac{r_{\text{p}}}{a}

Common Pitfall: Be careful not to confuse perihelion rp=a(1−e)r_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e) with aphelion ra=a(1+e)r_{\text{a}} = a(1 + e). The perihelion corresponds to the minimum distance from the focus to the ellipse.


03

Calculate ee

Substitute the known values rp=0.550 AUr_{\text{p}} = 0.550\text{ AU} and a=16.0 AUa = 16.0\text{ AU}: e=1−0.550 AU16.0 AUe = 1 - \frac{0.550\text{ AU}}{16.0\text{ AU}} e=1−0.034375=0.965625e = 1 - 0.034375 = 0.965625

Rounding to three significant figures gives: e=0.966e = 0.966

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misremembers Kepler's third law with inverted exponents as T³ = a², resulting in an incorrect semi-major axis and an unphysical or incorrect eccentricity formula evaluation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    T3=a2  ⟹  a=64.03=512 AUT^3 = a^2 \implies a = \sqrt{64.0^3} = 512\text{ AU}

    Correct

    T2=a3  ⟹  a=T2/3=(64.0)2/3=16.0 AUT^2 = a^3 \implies a = T^{2/3} = (64.0)^{2/3} = 16.0\text{ AU}

    In Kepler's third law, the square of the orbital period is proportional to the cube of the semi-major axis (T2=a3T^2 = a^3 when TT is in years and aa is in AU\text{AU}). You inverted the exponents as T3=a2T^3 = a^2.

  2. Step 2

    rp=a(1−e)  ⟹  e=1−rpar_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e) \implies e = 1 - \frac{r_{\text{p}}}{a}

  3. Step 3

    e=1−0.550512  ⟹  e=0.999e = 1 - \frac{0.550}{512} \implies e = 0.999

    Correct

    e=1−0.55016.0=1−0.034375  ⟹  e=0.966e = 1 - \frac{0.550}{16.0} = 1 - 0.034375 \implies e = 0.966

    Your algebra and evaluation were executed correctly using your value a=512 AUa = 512\text{ AU}, but the final numerical result is affected by the incorrect value of aa calculated in Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly remembered that perihelion distance is given by rp=a(1−e)r_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e).

You correctly rearranged the equation to isolate the orbital eccentricity e=1−rpae = 1 - \frac{r_{\text{p}}}{a}.

You carried out the arithmetic evaluation accurately based on your computed values.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Exponents in Kepler's Third Law

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You swapped the powers in Kepler's third law, writing period cubed equals axis squared (T3=a2T^3 = a^2) rather than period squared equals axis cubed (T2=a3T^2 = a^3).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Exponent Check for Kepler's Third Law
  • For any orbit around the Sun with TT in Earth years and aa in astronomical units, T2=a3T^2 = a^3.

  • A helpful memory aid is 'time squared, distance cubed' or checking units/proportions: an object at a=4 AUa = 4\text{ AU} takes T=43=8 yrT = \sqrt{4^3} = 8\text{ yr}, not 423\sqrt[3]{4^2}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply Kepler's third law with correct powers: T2=a3T^2 = a^3

  2. Solve for the semi-major axis: a=T2/3=(64.0)2/3=(43)2/3=42=16.0 AUa = T^{2/3} = (64.0)^{2/3} = (4^3)^{2/3} = 4^2 = 16.0\text{ AU}

  3. Substitute a=16.0 AUa = 16.0\text{ AU} and rp=0.550 AUr_{\text{p}} = 0.550\text{ AU} into e=1−rpae = 1 - \frac{r_{\text{p}}}{a}: e=1−0.55016.0=1−0.034375=0.965625e = 1 - \frac{0.550}{16.0} = 1 - 0.034375 = 0.965625

  4. Round to three significant figures: e=0.966e = 0.966

Final answer

e=0.966e = 0.966

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Kepler's third law formula: always verify that time is squared (T2T^2) and orbital distance is cubed (a3a^3).

  • Before moving to the next step, do a quick sanity check on aa: an orbital period of 64 yr64\text{ yr} should correspond to a moderately distant orbit (16 AU16\text{ AU}, between Saturn and Uranus), whereas 512 AU512\text{ AU} would correspond to a period of over 11,000 yr11{,}000\text{ yr}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the perihelion formula rp = a(1 - e) with the aphelion formula ra = a(1 + e), leading to an erroneous calculation of the eccentricity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    T2=a3  ⟹  a=(64.0)2/3=16.0 AUT^2 = a^3 \implies a = (64.0)^{2/3} = 16.0\text{ AU}

  2. Step 2

    rp=a(1+e)  ⟹  1+e=0.55016.0=0.0344r_{\text{p}} = a(1 + e) \implies 1 + e = \frac{0.550}{16.0} = 0.0344

    Correct

    rp=a(1−e)  ⟹  1−e=0.55016.0=0.034375r_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e) \implies 1 - e = \frac{0.550}{16.0} = 0.034375

    Perihelion is the closest approach to the Sun, so its distance from the focus is rp=a(1−e)r_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e). The formula with a plus sign, ra=a(1+e)r_{\text{a}} = a(1 + e), gives the aphelion (farthest distance).

  3. Step 3

    e=−0.966e = -0.966

    Correct

    e=1−0.034375≈0.966e = 1 - 0.034375 \approx 0.966

    Carrying through the incorrect sign produced a negative eccentricity, whereas orbital eccentricity for an elliptical orbit must be non-negative (0≤e<10 \le e < 1).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled and calculated Kepler's third law relating orbital period to semi-major axis.

You accurately executed the arithmetic steps and correctly identified the target variable.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Formula confusion: perihelion vs. aphelion

You used rp=a(1+e)r_{\text{p}} = a(1 + e) instead of rp=a(1−e)r_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the geometric expressions for perihelion (closest distance to the focus) and aphelion (farthest distance from the focus). Remembering that perihelion must be strictly smaller than the semi-major axis aa gives the cue that the factor must be (1−e)(1 - e) rather than (1+e)(1 + e).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Apsides of an Ellipse
  • For an orbit with semi-major axis aa and eccentricity ee, closest approach is rp=a(1−e)r_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e) and farthest approach is ra=a(1+e)r_{\text{a}} = a(1 + e).

  • Always check whether the problem specifies perihelion (minimum distance, minus sign) or aphelion (maximum distance, plus sign).

Sanity Check on Eccentricity
  • An elliptical orbit always has 0≤e<10 \le e < 1.

  • If your calculated eccentricity is negative or greater than 1, check your apsis formula signs and algebraic rearrangements.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the correct perihelion relationship: rp=a(1−e)r_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e).

  2. Substitute rp=0.550 AUr_{\text{p}} = 0.550\text{ AU} and a=16.0 AUa = 16.0\text{ AU}: 1−e=0.55016.0=0.0343751 - e = \frac{0.550}{16.0} = 0.034375.

  3. Solve for eccentricity: e=1−0.034375=0.965625e = 1 - 0.034375 = 0.965625.

Final answer

e=0.966e = 0.966

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the mnemonic: 'Perihelion = Proximal = Minus' and 'Aphelion = Away = Add'.

  • Whenever you calculate an eccentricity, verify that it falls strictly in the range 0≤e<10 \le e < 1 for an ellipse.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student confuses the semi-major axis a with the total major axis 2a when applying Kepler's third law, halving the actual semi-major axis before finding eccentricity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    T^2 = (2a)^3   ⟹  \implies 2a = (64.0)^{2/3} = 16.0 AU\text{ AU}   ⟹  \implies a = 8.00 AU\text{ AU}

    Correct

    T^2 = a^3   ⟹  \implies a = (64.0)^{2/3} = 16.0 AU\text{ AU}

    In Kepler's third law (T2=a3T^2 = a^3), the symbol aa represents the semi-major axis (half the length of the major axis), not the full major axis 2a2a. Therefore, (64.0)2/3=16.0 AU(64.0)^{2/3} = 16.0\text{ AU} is the value of aa itself, not 2a2a.

  2. Step 2

    r_p = a(1 - e)   ⟹  \implies e = 1 - 0.5508.00\frac{0.550}{8.00} = 0.931

    Correct

    e = 1 - rpa\frac{r_p}{a} = 1 - 0.55016.0\frac{0.550}{16.0} = 0.966

    You correctly stated the perihelion formula and solved for ee, but your result was affected by substituting a=8.00 AUa = 8.00\text{ AU} instead of 16.0 AU16.0\text{ AU}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled that orbital period and orbit size are related by a 2/32/3 power law.

You correctly evaluated (64.0)2/3=16.0(64.0)^{2/3} = 16.0.

You used the correct relationship between perihelion distance, semi-major axis, and eccentricity: rp=a(1−e)r_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e).

You correctly solved for ee algebraically and rounded your numerical calculation to three significant figures.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Major axis vs semi-major axis confusion in Kepler's Third Law

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You defined Kepler's third law in terms of the total major axis 2a2a instead of the semi-major axis aa, leading you to divide the computed distance of 16.0 AU16.0\text{ AU} by 2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Kepler's Third Law Definition
  • In Kepler's third law (T2=a3T^2 = a^3 or T2=4π2GMa3T^2 = \frac{4\pi^2}{GM}a^3), aa always represents the semi-major axis (the distance from the center of the ellipse to either vertex along the major axis).

  • Always set aa directly equal to T2/3T^{2/3} when TT is in years and aa is in AU for orbits around the Sun.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply Kepler's third law with semi-major axis aa: a=T2/3=(64.0)2/3=16.0 AUa = T^{2/3} = (64.0)^{2/3} = 16.0\text{ AU}.

  2. Substitute a=16.0 AUa = 16.0\text{ AU} and rp=0.550 AUr_{\text{p}} = 0.550\text{ AU} into e=1−rpae = 1 - \frac{r_{\text{p}}}{a}.

  3. Calculate e=1−0.55016.0=1−0.034375=0.965625e = 1 - \frac{0.550}{16.0} = 1 - 0.034375 = 0.965625.

Final answer

e = 0.966

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the geometric definitions of an ellipse: semi-major axis aa, semi-minor axis bb, and focal distance c=eac = ea.

  • Remember that Kepler's laws and gravitational orbital formulas consistently use the semi-major axis aa, never the full diameter or major axis 2a2a.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A dwarf planet orbits the Sun with an orbital period of T=125 yrT = 125\text{ yr}. What is its semi-major axis aa in astronomical units (AU\text{AU})?

Answer

a=25.0 AUa = 25.0\text{ AU}. Using Kepler's third law T2=a3T^2 = a^3, a=T2/3=(125)2/3=(53)2/3=52=25.0 AUa = T^{2/3} = (125)^{2/3} = (5^3)^{2/3} = 5^2 = 25.0\text{ AU}.

02

A comet has an orbital period of T=27.0 yrT = 27.0\text{ yr} and an eccentricity of e=0.800e = 0.800. Calculate its perihelion distance rpr_{\text{p}} in AU\text{AU}.

Answer

rp=1.80 AUr_{\text{p}} = 1.80\text{ AU}. First, find a=T2/3=(27.0)2/3=(33)2/3=9.00 AUa = T^{2/3} = (27.0)^{2/3} = (3^3)^{2/3} = 9.00\text{ AU}. Then use rp=a(1−e)=9.00(1−0.800)=9.00(0.200)=1.80 AUr_{\text{p}} = a(1 - e) = 9.00(1 - 0.800) = 9.00(0.200) = 1.80\text{ AU}.

03

An asteroid has a perihelion distance of rp=1.20 AUr_{\text{p}} = 1.20\text{ AU} and an aphelion distance of ra=6.80 AUr_{\text{a}} = 6.80\text{ AU}. Determine its orbital period TT in years.

Answer

T=8.00 yrT = 8.00\text{ yr}. The semi-major axis is a=rp+ra2=1.20+6.802=4.00 AUa = \frac{r_{\text{p}} + r_{\text{a}}}{2} = \frac{1.20 + 6.80}{2} = 4.00\text{ AU}. By Kepler's third law, T=a3/2=(4.00)3/2=23=8.00 yrT = a^{3/2} = (4.00)^{3/2} = 2^3 = 8.00\text{ yr}.

Loading workspace…