Resources

A marathon runner completes an out-and-back training run on a straight course. She runs outbound from the start line to a checkpoint located 12.0 km12.0\text{ km} away at an average pace corresponding to a constant speed of vout=15.0 km/hv_{\text{out}} = 15.0\text{ km/h}. On the return journey along the exact same path, fatigue slows her constant speed to vback=10.0 km/hv_{\text{back}} = 10.0\text{ km/h}. (a) Calculate the average speed for the complete 24.0 km24.0\text{ km} out-and-back run. (b) Explain mathematically why the average speed is strictly less than the simple arithmetic mean of the two speeds 15.0+10.02=12.5 km/h\frac{15.0 + 10.0}{2} = 12.5\text{ km/h}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Average speed = 12.0 km/h12.0\text{ km/h}; (b) The runner spends more time traveling at the slower speed (1.20 h1.20\text{ h} at 10.0 km/h10.0\text{ km/h}) than at the faster speed (0.80 h0.80\text{ h} at 15.0 km/h15.0\text{ km/h}); because average speed is a time-weighted harmonic mean rather than a simple distance-weighted mean, the slower speed is weighted more heavily in the time denominator.

Steps

Part (a): Calculating the Average Speed

  1. Definition of Average Speed: Average speed vavgv_{\text{avg}} is defined as the total distance traveled divided by the total time taken: vavg=dtotalttotalv_{\text{avg}} = \frac{d_{\text{total}}}{t_{\text{total}}}
  2. Calculate the Time for Each Leg:

    • Outbound leg: tout=dvout=12.0 km15.0 km/h=0.80 ht_{\text{out}} = \frac{d}{v_{\text{out}}} = \frac{12.0\text{ km}}{15.0\text{ km/h}} = 0.80\text{ h}
    • Return leg: tback=dvback=12.0 km10.0 km/h=1.20 ht_{\text{back}} = \frac{d}{v_{\text{back}}} = \frac{12.0\text{ km}}{10.0\text{ km/h}} = 1.20\text{ h}
  3. Calculate the Total Distance and Total Time: dtotal=12.0 km+12.0 km=24.0 kmd_{\text{total}} = 12.0\text{ km} + 12.0\text{ km} = 24.0\text{ km} ttotal=tout+tback=0.80 h+1.20 h=2.00 ht_{\text{total}} = t_{\text{out}} + t_{\text{back}} = 0.80\text{ h} + 1.20\text{ h} = 2.00\text{ h}
  4. Compute the Average Speed: vavg=24.0 km2.00 h=12.0 km/hv_{\text{avg}} = \frac{24.0\text{ km}}{2.00\text{ h}} = 12.0\text{ km/h}

Part (b): Mathematical Explanation for Why vavg<varithmeticv_{\text{avg}} < v_{\text{arithmetic}}

A common pitfall is to calculate the average speed as the simple arithmetic mean of the two speeds: varithmetic=15.0+10.02=12.5 km/hv_{\text{arithmetic}} = \frac{15.0 + 10.0}{2} = 12.5\text{ km/h}

However, this arithmetic average is only valid if the runner spends an equal amount of time at each speed.

  1. Time-Weighted Mean vs. Equal Distances: Expressing average speed in terms of time shows that it is a time-weighted average: vavg=vouttout+vbacktbacktout+tbackv_{\text{avg}} = \frac{v_{\text{out}} t_{\text{out}} + v_{\text{back}} t_{\text{back}}}{t_{\text{out}} + t_{\text{back}}} Because the runner covers the same distance at both speeds, the time spent on each leg is inversely proportional to speed (t=dvt = \frac{d}{v}). Consequently, the runner spends significantly more time running at the slower speed (1.20 h1.20\text{ h} at 10.0 km/h10.0\text{ km/h}) than at the faster speed (0.80 h0.80\text{ h} at 15.0 km/h15.0\text{ km/h}).
  2. The Harmonic Mean Formula: For equal distances dd, the total average speed reduces to the harmonic mean: vavg=2ddv1+dv2=21v1+1v2=2v1v2v1+v2v_{\text{avg}} = \frac{2d}{\frac{d}{v_1} + \frac{d}{v_2}} = \frac{2}{\frac{1}{v_1} + \frac{1}{v_2}} = \frac{2 v_1 v_2}{v_1 + v_2} Comparing this to the arithmetic mean via the Arithmetic Mean-Harmonic Mean inequality (AM≥HM\text{AM} \ge \text{HM}): v1+v22−2v1v2v1+v2=(v1−v2)22(v1+v2)\frac{v_1 + v_2}{2} - \frac{2 v_1 v_2}{v_1 + v_2} = \frac{(v_1 - v_2)^2}{2(v_1 + v_2)} Since v1≠v2v_1 \neq v_2, the difference (v1−v2)2(v_1 - v_2)^2 is strictly positive. Therefore, the average speed must be strictly less than the arithmetic mean, pulled downward because the slower speed occupies a greater fraction of the total journey time.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student mistakenly calculates the average speed as the simple arithmetic mean of the two speeds, assuming equal weighting between legs.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    vavg=vout+vback2  ⟹  vavg=15.0 km/h+10.0 km/h2=12.5 km/hv_{\text{avg}} = \frac{v_{\text{out}} + v_{\text{back}}}{2} \implies v_{\text{avg}} = \frac{15.0\text{ km/h} + 10.0\text{ km/h}}{2} = 12.5\text{ km/h}

    Correct

    tout=12.0 km15.0 km/h=0.80 ht_{\text{out}} = \frac{12.0\text{ km}}{15.0\text{ km/h}} = 0.80\text{ h}, tback=12.0 km10.0 km/h=1.20 h  ⟹  vavg=dtotalttotal=24.0 km0.80 h+1.20 h=12.0 km/ht_{\text{back}} = \frac{12.0\text{ km}}{10.0\text{ km/h}} = 1.20\text{ h} \implies v_{\text{avg}} = \frac{d_{\text{total}}}{t_{\text{total}}} = \frac{24.0\text{ km}}{0.80\text{ h} + 1.20\text{ h}} = 12.0\text{ km/h}

    Average speed is defined as total distance divided by total time (vavg=dtotalttotalv_{\text{avg}} = \frac{d_{\text{total}}}{t_{\text{total}}}). The arithmetic mean v1+v22\frac{v_1 + v_2}{2} only applies when equal time is spent at each speed, not equal distance.

  2. Step 2

    "The average speed is equal to (15.0+10.0)/2=12.5 km/h(15.0 + 10.0)/2 = 12.5\text{ km/h}, so it is not strictly less than the arithmetic mean."

    Correct

    "Because the distances are equal, the runner spends more time at the slower speed (1.20 h>0.80 h1.20\text{ h} > 0.80\text{ h}); this time weighting pulls the average speed down to 12.0 km/h12.0\text{ km/h}, making it strictly less than the arithmetic mean (12.5 km/h12.5\text{ km/h})."

    Because your calculation in part (a) produced 12.5 km/h12.5\text{ km/h}, your conclusion for part (b) was directly affected by that initial error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the outbound speed and return speed from the problem statement.

You calculated the arithmetic mean of 15.0 km/h15.0\text{ km/h} and 10.0 km/h10.0\text{ km/h} accurately as 12.5 km/h12.5\text{ km/h}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Arithmetic Mean Fallacy in Average Speed

You treated average speed as the simple average of the speeds instead of applying the fundamental definition of total distance over total time.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed equal weighting between the two legs of the trip. Equal distance does not mean equal time; because time is inversely proportional to speed (t=dvt = \frac{d}{v}), more time is spent at the slower speed, which weights the overall average toward the lower value.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Definition of Average Speed
  • Average speed is always vavg=dtotalttotalv_{\text{avg}} = \frac{d_{\text{total}}}{t_{\text{total}}}, never v1+v22\frac{v_1 + v_2}{2} unless time intervals are explicitly equal.

  • Always find total distance and total time first before computing average speed.

Time-Weighted Average Concept
  • For equal distances, the average speed is given by the harmonic mean: vavg=2v1v2v1+v2<v1+v22v_{\text{avg}} = \frac{2 v_1 v_2}{v_1 + v_2} < \frac{v_1 + v_2}{2}.

  • Check whether the runner or vehicle spends equal time or equal distance at each speed to choose the proper weighting.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate outbound time: tout=12.0 km15.0 km/h=0.80 ht_{\text{out}} = \frac{12.0\text{ km}}{15.0\text{ km/h}} = 0.80\text{ h}.

  2. Calculate return time: tback=12.0 km10.0 km/h=1.20 ht_{\text{back}} = \frac{12.0\text{ km}}{10.0\text{ km/h}} = 1.20\text{ h}.

  3. Find total distance and total time: dtotal=24.0 kmd_{\text{total}} = 24.0\text{ km}, ttotal=0.80 h+1.20 h=2.00 ht_{\text{total}} = 0.80\text{ h} + 1.20\text{ h} = 2.00\text{ h}.

  4. Divide to find average speed: vavg=24.0 km2.00 h=12.0 km/hv_{\text{avg}} = \frac{24.0\text{ km}}{2.00\text{ h}} = 12.0\text{ km/h}.

Final answer

(a) 12.0 km/h12.0\text{ km/h}; (b) The runner spends more time traveling at the slower speed (1.20 h1.20\text{ h} vs. 0.80 h0.80\text{ h}), so the time-weighted average speed is pulled downward, making it strictly less than 12.5 km/h12.5\text{ km/h}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice calculating average speed by strictly writing vavg=dtotalttotalv_{\text{avg}} = \frac{d_{\text{total}}}{t_{\text{total}}} as your first line every time.

  • Compare problems where time intervals are equal versus where distances are equal to see when arithmetic mean works and when harmonic mean is required.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student uses the total distance of 24.0 km instead of the single-leg distance 12.0 km when computing each leg's travel time, resulting in an average speed of 6.0 km/h.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    tout=24.0 km/15.0 km/h=1.6 h  ⟹  tback=24.0 km/10.0 km/h=2.4 ht_{\text{out}} = 24.0\text{ km} / 15.0\text{ km/h} = 1.6\text{ h} \implies t_{\text{back}} = 24.0\text{ km} / 10.0\text{ km/h} = 2.4\text{ h}

    Correct

    tout=12.0 km15.0 km/h=0.80 h  ⟹  tback=12.0 km10.0 km/h=1.20 ht_{\text{out}} = \frac{12.0\text{ km}}{15.0\text{ km/h}} = 0.80\text{ h} \implies t_{\text{back}} = \frac{12.0\text{ km}}{10.0\text{ km/h}} = 1.20\text{ h}

    You used the full round-trip distance of 24.0 km24.0\text{ km} for both the outbound and return legs. Since the checkpoint is 12.0 km12.0\text{ km} away, each one-way leg has a distance of only 12.0 km12.0\text{ km}.

  2. Step 2

    ttotal=1.6 h+2.4 h=4.0 h  ⟹  vavg=24.0 km/4.0 h=6.0 km/ht_{\text{total}} = 1.6\text{ h} + 2.4\text{ h} = 4.0\text{ h} \implies v_{\text{avg}} = 24.0\text{ km} / 4.0\text{ h} = 6.0\text{ km/h}

    Correct

    ttotal=0.80 h+1.20 h=2.00 h  ⟹  vavg=24.0 km2.00 h=12.0 km/ht_{\text{total}} = 0.80\text{ h} + 1.20\text{ h} = 2.00\text{ h} \implies v_{\text{avg}} = \frac{24.0\text{ km}}{2.00\text{ h}} = 12.0\text{ km/h}

    Your method of summing the segment times and dividing total distance by total time is completely correct, but the numerical result is halved due to the doubled times from Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    More time is spent running at 10.0 km/h10.0\text{ km/h} (2.4 h2.4\text{ h}) than at 15.0 km/h15.0\text{ km/h} (1.6 h1.6\text{ h}), so the time-weighted average is pulled toward the slower speed and is strictly less than 12.5 km/h12.5\text{ km/h}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled that average speed is defined as total distance divided by total time.

You correctly summed the two leg durations to find the total time.

You accurately identified that average speed is time-weighted rather than distance-weighted in part (b).

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Segment Distance Misattribution

You substituted the total round-trip distance (24.0 km24.0\text{ km}) into the individual leg time formulas instead of the one-way distance (12.0 km12.0\text{ km}).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the total course distance with the distance of an individual segment when applying t=d/vt = d/v to separate legs of a multi-stage journey.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Segment vs. Total Values
  • When calculating travel time for a specific leg (ti=di/vit_i = d_i / v_i), always use the distance did_i of that specific segment, not the total round-trip distance dtotald_{\text{total}}.

  • Before calculating t=d/vt = d/v, verify that the distance dd matches the exact span where speed vv was maintained.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the outbound time: tout=12.0 km15.0 km/h=0.80 ht_{\text{out}} = \frac{12.0\text{ km}}{15.0\text{ km/h}} = 0.80\text{ h}.

  2. Calculate the return time: tback=12.0 km10.0 km/h=1.20 ht_{\text{back}} = \frac{12.0\text{ km}}{10.0\text{ km/h}} = 1.20\text{ h}.

  3. Find total time: ttotal=0.80 h+1.20 h=2.00 ht_{\text{total}} = 0.80\text{ h} + 1.20\text{ h} = 2.00\text{ h}.

  4. Compute average speed: vavg=24.0 km2.00 h=12.0 km/hv_{\text{avg}} = \frac{24.0\text{ km}}{2.00\text{ h}} = 12.0\text{ km/h}.

Final answer

(a) 12.0 km/h12.0\text{ km/h}; (b) The runner spends more time at the slower speed (1.20 h1.20\text{ h} vs. 0.80 h0.80\text{ h}), so the time-weighted average is pulled below the arithmetic mean of 12.5 km/h12.5\text{ km/h}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice breaking multi-leg journeys into an explicit table with separate columns for distance, speed, and time for each leg before computing totals.

  • Watch out for problem statements that give both one-way distance and round-trip distance to avoid using the total distance prematurely.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A cyclist rides 30 km30\text{ km} uphill at a steady speed of 10 km/h10\text{ km/h} and returns down the same 30 km30\text{ km} route at 30 km/h30\text{ km/h}. Calculate the cyclist's average speed for the entire round trip.

Answer

15 km/h15\text{ km/h}. Outbound time is t1=3010=3.0 ht_1 = \frac{30}{10} = 3.0\text{ h}, return time is t2=3030=1.0 ht_2 = \frac{30}{30} = 1.0\text{ h}. Total distance is 60 km60\text{ km}, total time is 4.0 h4.0\text{ h}, so vavg=60 km4.0 h=15 km/hv_{\text{avg}} = \frac{60\text{ km}}{4.0\text{ h}} = 15\text{ km/h}.

02

A car travels along a straight highway in two stages: (1) for 1.5 h1.5\text{ h} at 80 km/h80\text{ km/h}, and (2) for 1.5 h1.5\text{ h} at 100 km/h100\text{ km/h}. Find the car's average speed and explain why the arithmetic mean is valid in this scenario.

Answer

90 km/h90\text{ km/h}. Distance in leg 1 is 120 km120\text{ km} and leg 2 is 150 km150\text{ km}. Total distance is 270 km270\text{ km} in 3.0 h3.0\text{ h}, giving vavg=90 km/hv_{\text{avg}} = 90\text{ km/h}. The arithmetic mean 80+1002=90 km/h\frac{80+100}{2} = 90\text{ km/h} works because the time intervals are equal (t1=t2t_1 = t_2).

03

A delivery drone completes a three-leg triangular patrol of equal perimeter segments, traveling each leg of length LL at speeds vv, 2v2v, and 3v3v, respectively. Express the drone's average speed for the full patrol in terms of vv.

Answer

1811v≈1.64v\frac{18}{11}v\approx 1.64v. Total distance is 3L3L. Total time is t=Lv+L2v+L3v=L(1+12+13)=11L6vt = \frac{L}{v} + \frac{L}{2v} + \frac{L}{3v} = L\left(1 + \frac{1}{2} + \frac{1}{3}\right) = \frac{11L}{6v}. Therefore, vavg=3Lt=3L11L6v=1811vv_{\text{avg}} = \frac{3L}{t} = \frac{3L}{\frac{11L}{6v}} = \frac{18}{11}v.

Loading workspace…