Resources

In a physics resonance tube experiment, a cylindrical column of air closed at one end is excited using a variable-frequency audio speaker to measure acoustic pitch. The lab temperature is 19.5∘C19.5^\circ\text{C}, yielding an ambient sound speed of v=343.0 m/sv = 343.0\text{ m/s}. The tube has an effective acoustic length L=0.625 mL = 0.625\text{ m}. Determine the fundamental frequency f1f_1 (first harmonic) and the next consecutive resonant frequency f3f_3 (third harmonic) that excite resonance, and calculate the beat frequency produced if the tube's third harmonic is sounded simultaneously with an imperfectly calibrated tuning fork marked 415.0 Hz415.0\text{ Hz}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Fundamental frequency f1=137.2 Hzf_1 = 137.2\text{ Hz}, Third harmonic frequency f3=411.6 Hzf_3 = 411.6\text{ Hz}, Beat frequency fbeat=3.4 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = 3.4\text{ Hz}

Steps

01

Resonant Condition for a Pipe Closed at One End

In a cylindrical pipe closed at one end and open at the other, standing sound waves require:

  • A displacement node (zero air-particle motion) at the closed boundary.
  • A displacement antinode (maximum air-particle motion) at the open boundary.

Because an antinode-to-node distance corresponds to one-quarter of a wavelength (14λ\frac{1}{4}\lambda), resonance occurs only at odd-integer multiples of a quarter wavelength: L=nλn4where n=1,3,5,…L = n\frac{\lambda_n}{4} \quad \text{where } n = 1, 3, 5, \dots

Using the wave speed relationship v=fnλnv = f_n \lambda_n, the resonant frequencies are given by: fn=nv4L(n=1,3,5,… )f_n = n\frac{v}{4L} \quad (n = 1, 3, 5, \dots)

Common Pitfall: Unlike a tube open at both ends (which supports all integer harmonics n=1,2,3,…n = 1, 2, 3, \dots with fundamental f1=v2Lf_1 = \frac{v}{2L}), a closed-end tube supports only odd harmonics. The second resonant frequency is the 3rd harmonic (n=3n = 3), not an n=2n = 2 mode.


02

Calculate the Fundamental Frequency (f1f_1)

Substitute n=1n = 1, v=343.0 m/sv = 343.0\text{ m/s}, and L=0.625 mL = 0.625\text{ m}: f1=v4L=343.0 m/s4⋅0.625 m=343.02.500 Hz=137.2 Hzf_1 = \frac{v}{4L} = \frac{343.0\text{ m/s}}{4 \cdot 0.625\text{ m}} = \frac{343.0}{2.500}\text{ Hz} = 137.2\text{ Hz}


03

Calculate the Next Resonant Frequency (f3f_3)

The next consecutive standing-wave mode is the third harmonic (n=3n = 3): f3=3⋅f1=3⋅137.2 Hz=411.6 Hzf_3 = 3 \cdot f_1 = 3 \cdot 137.2\text{ Hz} = 411.6\text{ Hz}


04

Determine the Beat Frequency

When two sound waves of slightly different frequencies fAf_A and fBf_B interfere, the acoustic intensity periodically pulses at the beat frequency, given by the absolute difference between the two frequencies: fbeat=∣ffork−f3∣f_{\text{beat}} = |f_{\text{fork}} - f_3|

Given ffork=415.0 Hzf_{\text{fork}} = 415.0\text{ Hz} and f3=411.6 Hzf_3 = 411.6\text{ Hz}: fbeat=∣415.0 Hz−411.6 Hz∣=3.4 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |415.0\text{ Hz} - 411.6\text{ Hz}| = 3.4\text{ Hz}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misapplies the boundary conditions for a pipe closed at one end by using the formula for an open pipe, producing a fundamental frequency of 274.4 Hz and second resonant frequency of 548.8 Hz.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    f1=v2L  ⟹  f1=343.02×0.625=274.4 Hzf_1 = \frac{v}{2L} \implies f_1 = \frac{343.0}{2 \times 0.625} = 274.4\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f1=v4L=343.04×0.625=137.2 Hzf_1 = \frac{v}{4L} = \frac{343.0}{4 \times 0.625} = 137.2\text{ Hz}

    You applied the fundamental formula for a pipe open at both ends (f1=v2Lf_1 = \frac{v}{2L}). Because this tube is closed at one end, the fundamental standing wave spans a quarter-wavelength, giving f1=v4Lf_1 = \frac{v}{4L}.

  2. Step 2

    f2=2f1=2×274.4=548.8 Hzf_2 = 2f_1 = 2 \times 274.4 = 548.8\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f3=3f1=3×137.2 Hz=411.6 Hzf_3 = 3f_1 = 3 \times 137.2\text{ Hz} = 411.6\text{ Hz}

    A pipe closed at one end only produces odd harmonics (n=1,3,5,…n = 1, 3, 5, \dots). The next resonant frequency is the third harmonic f3=3f1f_3 = 3f_1, so even harmonics like f2f_2 do not occur.

  3. Step 3

    fbeat=∣548.8−415.0∣=133.8 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |548.8 - 415.0| = 133.8\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    fbeat=∣415.0−411.6∣=3.4 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |415.0 - 411.6| = 3.4\text{ Hz}

    You applied the beat formula ∣fA−fB∣|f_A - f_B| correctly, but your numerical result was thrown off by the earlier incorrect resonant frequency.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that beat frequency is the absolute difference between two interfering frequencies.

You executed the arithmetic and unit handling cleanly across each step.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Boundary Condition Formula Error

Using v2L\frac{v}{2L} instead of v4L\frac{v}{4L} for an air column with one closed end.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the air column as open at both ends. For an air column closed at one end, there is a displacement node at the closed end and a displacement antinode at the open end, which restricts resonance to quarter-wavelength modes (L=nλ4L = \frac{n\lambda}{4} for odd integers n=1,3,5,…n = 1, 3, 5, \dots).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Inspect End Conditions
  • An open-open tube has fn=nv2Lf_n = n\frac{v}{2L} (n=1,2,3…n=1,2,3\dots), while a closed-open tube has fn=nv4Lf_n = n\frac{v}{4L} (n=1,3,5…n=1,3,5\dots).

  • Identify the physical boundaries (closed vs. open) before writing down the harmonic equation.

Check Allowed Harmonics
  • Closed-open tubes cannot support even harmonics (n=2,4,6,…n = 2, 4, 6, \dots).

  • Always verify that consecutive resonant modes for a closed-open tube increment by odd integers.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. f1=v4L=343.0 m/s4(0.625 m)=137.2 Hzf_1 = \frac{v}{4L} = \frac{343.0\text{ m/s}}{4(0.625\text{ m})} = 137.2\text{ Hz}

  2. f3=3f1=3(137.2 Hz)=411.6 Hzf_3 = 3f_1 = 3(137.2\text{ Hz}) = 411.6\text{ Hz}

  3. fbeat=∣ffork−f3∣=∣415.0 Hz−411.6 Hz∣=3.4 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |f_{\text{fork}} - f_3| = |415.0\text{ Hz} - 411.6\text{ Hz}| = 3.4\text{ Hz}

Final answer

f1=137.2 Hzf_1 = 137.2\text{ Hz}, f3=411.6 Hzf_3 = 411.6\text{ Hz}, fbeat=3.4 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = 3.4\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the standing wave boundary conditions for closed-open versus open-open pipes.

  • Practice sketching the displacement standing waves to visually count quarter wavelengths.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student assumes all integer harmonics exist in a pipe closed at one end and takes the next consecutive resonant frequency to be the second harmonic f₂ = 2f₁ instead of the third harmonic.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    f1=v4L=343.04×0.625=137.2 Hzf_1 = \frac{v}{4L} = \frac{343.0}{4 \times 0.625} = 137.2\text{ Hz}

  2. Step 2

    f2=2f1=2×137.2=274.4 Hzf_2 = 2f_1 = 2 \times 137.2 = 274.4\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f3=3f1=3×137.2 Hz=411.6 Hzf_3 = 3f_1 = 3 \times 137.2\text{ Hz} = 411.6\text{ Hz}

    A tube closed at one end supports only odd harmonics (n=1,3,5,…n = 1, 3, 5, \dots). The next consecutive resonant mode after the fundamental is the third harmonic f3=3f1f_3 = 3f_1, not an even multiple like f2f_2.

  3. Step 3

    fbeat=∣274.4−415.0∣=140.6 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |274.4 - 415.0| = 140.6\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    fbeat=∣415.0 Hz−411.6 Hz∣=3.4 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |415.0\text{ Hz} - 411.6\text{ Hz}| = 3.4\text{ Hz}

    You used the correct beat frequency formula fbeat=∣f−ffork∣f_{\text{beat}} = |f - f_{\text{fork}}|, but the calculation was thrown off by the incorrect harmonic frequency from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that a tube closed at one end has a fundamental frequency given by f1=v4Lf_1 = \frac{v}{4L}.

You correctly set up the absolute frequency difference to compute the beat frequency.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Even harmonic assumption in closed-end pipe

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that all integer harmonics (n=1,2,3,…n = 1, 2, 3, \dots) exist in a column closed at one end. Because a closed boundary enforces a displacement node and an open boundary enforces a displacement antinode, only odd-quarter-wavelength standing wave modes (n=1,3,5,…n = 1, 3, 5, \dots) can satisfy the boundary conditions.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Harmonic Selection for Closed-End Pipes
  • Pipes open at both ends produce all integer harmonics (fn=nf1f_n = n f_1 with n=1,2,3,…n = 1, 2, 3, \dots). Pipes closed at one end produce only odd harmonics (fn=nf1f_n = n f_1 with n=1,3,5,…n = 1, 3, 5, \dots).

  • Before calculating the next resonant frequency, check the boundary conditions: if one end is closed and the other open, skip all even multiples (n=2,4,6n = 2, 4, 6) and multiply by the next odd integer (n=3n = 3).

Beat Frequency Evaluation
  • The beat frequency between two tones is fbeat=∣fA−fB∣f_{\text{beat}} = |f_A - f_B|.

  • Substitute the corrected odd harmonic frequency into the beat equation: ∣415.0 Hz−411.6 Hz∣=3.4 Hz|415.0\text{ Hz} - 411.6\text{ Hz}| = 3.4\text{ Hz}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that the consecutive resonant mode in a pipe closed at one end is n=3n = 3: f3=3f1=3×137.2 Hz=411.6 Hzf_3 = 3f_1 = 3 \times 137.2\text{ Hz} = 411.6\text{ Hz}.

  2. Substitute f3f_3 and the tuning fork frequency ffork=415.0 Hzf_{\text{fork}} = 415.0\text{ Hz} into the beat frequency relation: fbeat=∣415.0−411.6∣=3.4 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |415.0 - 411.6| = 3.4\text{ Hz}.

Final answer

Fundamental frequency f1=137.2 Hzf_1 = 137.2\text{ Hz}, Third harmonic frequency f3=411.6 Hzf_3 = 411.6\text{ Hz}, Beat frequency fbeat=3.4 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = 3.4\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review standing wave boundary conditions for open-open versus open-closed tubes.

  • Practice identifying harmonic series indices (n=1,3,5,…n = 1, 3, 5, \dots) for quarter-wave resonators.

  • Recalculate the beat frequency whenever an imperfectly tuned source interferes with an acoustic resonance.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates the wavelength as 4L = 2.50 m but mistakenly divides the length by the sound speed instead of dividing the sound speed by the wavelength, resulting in an inverted frequency.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    λ1=4L=4×0.625=2.50 m\lambda_1 = 4L = 4 \times 0.625 = 2.50\text{ m}

  2. Step 2

    f1=λ1v=2.50343.0=0.00729 Hzf_1 = \frac{\lambda_1}{v} = \frac{2.50}{343.0} = 0.00729\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f1=vλ1=343.0 m/s2.50 m=137.2 Hzf_1 = \frac{v}{\lambda_1} = \frac{343.0\text{ m/s}}{2.50\text{ m}} = 137.2\text{ Hz}

    From the fundamental wave relation v=fλv = f\lambda, solving for frequency gives f=vλf = \frac{v}{\lambda}. Dividing wavelength by speed gives the period T=λvT = \frac{\lambda}{v} in seconds rather than the frequency in Hertz.

  3. Step 3

    f3=3f1=3×0.00729=0.0219 Hzf_3 = 3f_1 = 3 \times 0.00729 = 0.0219\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f3=3f1=3(137.2 Hz)=411.6 Hzf_3 = 3f_1 = 3(137.2\text{ Hz}) = 411.6\text{ Hz}

    Your method of multiplying the fundamental frequency by 3 to find the next resonant harmonic in a closed-end pipe is completely correct, but the numerical result is affected by your earlier error in f1f_1.

  4. Step 4

    fbeat=∣0.0219−415.0∣=415.0 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |0.0219 - 415.0| = 415.0\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    fbeat=∣f3−ffork∣=∣411.6 Hz−415.0 Hz∣=3.4 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |f_3 - f_{\text{fork}}| = |411.6\text{ Hz} - 415.0\text{ Hz}| = 3.4\text{ Hz}

    Your beat frequency relation fbeat=∣f3−ffork∣f_{\text{beat}} = |f_3 - f_{\text{fork}}| is correct, but evaluating it with your inverted harmonic frequency led to an incorrect beat rate.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the quarter-wave relationship λ1=4L\lambda_1 = 4L for a tube closed at one end.

You correctly identified that a tube closed at one end only supports odd harmonics, making n=3n = 3 the next resonant mode.

You correctly set up the beat frequency formula as the absolute difference between the two sounding frequencies.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic inversion of wave speed equation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You inverted the wave equation v=fλv = f\lambda, computing λv\frac{\lambda}{v} instead of vλ\frac{v}{\lambda}. Dimensionally, metersmeters/second=seconds\frac{\text{meters}}{\text{meters/second}} = \text{seconds}, which computes the wave period TT rather than the frequency f=1Tf = \frac{1}{T}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Wave Equation Algebraic Check
  • v=fλ  ⟹  f=vλv = f\lambda \implies f = \frac{v}{\lambda} and λ=vf\lambda = \frac{v}{f}

  • Check units before computing: Hz=s−1=m/sm\text{Hz} = \text{s}^{-1} = \frac{\text{m/s}}{\text{m}}. If your expression gives seconds, you have computed period TT, so take its reciprocal to get frequency.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Solve v=f1λ1v = f_1 \lambda_1 for frequency: f1=vλ1=343.0 m/s2.50 m=137.2 Hzf_1 = \frac{v}{\lambda_1} = \frac{343.0\text{ m/s}}{2.50\text{ m}} = 137.2\text{ Hz}.

  2. Calculate the third harmonic: f3=3f1=3×137.2 Hz=411.6 Hzf_3 = 3 f_1 = 3 \times 137.2\text{ Hz} = 411.6\text{ Hz}.

  3. Compute the beat frequency: fbeat=∣f3−ffork∣=∣411.6 Hz−415.0 Hz∣=3.4 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |f_3 - f_{\text{fork}}| = |411.6\text{ Hz} - 415.0\text{ Hz}| = 3.4\text{ Hz}.

Final answer

f1=137.2 Hzf_1 = 137.2\text{ Hz}, f3=411.6 Hzf_3 = 411.6\text{ Hz}, fbeat=3.4 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = 3.4\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always perform a unit check on derived formulas: verify that frequency has units of 1s\frac{1}{\text{s}} (or Hz\text{Hz}) by ensuring wave speed (m/s\text{m/s}) is in the numerator and wavelength (m\text{m}) is in the denominator.

  • Review the relationship between period and frequency (T=λvT = \frac{\lambda}{v} versus f=vλf = \frac{v}{\lambda}) so you can catch accidental inversions immediately.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A student uses a resonance tube closed at one end with length L=0.500 mL = 0.500\text{ m}. If the speed of sound is 340.0 m/s340.0\text{ m/s}, find the fundamental frequency f1f_1 and the third harmonic f3f_3.

Answer

f1=v4L=340.04(0.500)=170.0 Hzf_1 = \frac{v}{4L} = \frac{340.0}{4(0.500)} = 170.0\text{ Hz}; f3=3f1=3(170.0)=510.0 Hzf_3 = 3f_1 = 3(170.0) = 510.0\text{ Hz}.

02

A pipe closed at one end has a fundamental resonant frequency of 220.0 Hz220.0\text{ Hz}. When excited at its next resonant mode, it is sounded together with a tuning fork of unknown frequency, producing 5.0 Hz5.0\text{ Hz} beats. What are the two possible frequencies of the tuning fork?

Answer

The next resonant frequency is f3=3(220.0 Hz)=660.0 Hzf_3 = 3(220.0\text{ Hz}) = 660.0\text{ Hz}. Since fbeat=∣ffork−660.0∣=5.0 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |f_{\text{fork}} - 660.0| = 5.0\text{ Hz}, the tuning fork is either 655.0 Hz655.0\text{ Hz} or 665.0 Hz665.0\text{ Hz}.

03

An air column closed at one end resonates at consecutive frequencies of 375 Hz375\text{ Hz} and 625 Hz625\text{ Hz}. Determine the fundamental frequency of the column and the acoustic length LL if sound travels at 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}.

Answer

Consecutive resonant modes for a closed-open pipe are nf1n f_1 and (n+2)f1(n+2)f_1, so (n+2)f1−nf1=2f1=625−375=250 Hz(n+2)f_1 - n f_1 = 2f_1 = 625 - 375 = 250\text{ Hz}, giving f1=125 Hzf_1 = 125\text{ Hz}. Then L=v4f1=3404(125)=0.68 mL = \frac{v}{4f_1} = \frac{340}{4(125)} = 0.68\text{ m}.

Loading workspace…