Resources
Two tensile specimens, Wire A and Wire B, are fabricated from the identical homogeneous copper alloy with Young's modulus . Wire B is manufactured with twice the diameter () and three times the original length () of Wire A. A novice student predicts that because Wire B is much longer and thicker, it will store vastly more elastic potential energy than Wire A when both are stretched by the exact same applied tension force . Evaluate this scenario: (a) derive the analytical ratio of the effective spring constant , (b) compute the numerical ratio of the resulting elongations , and (c) compute the numerical ratio of elastic potential energy stored under this identical tensile force , confirming whether student intuition holds or fails.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) ; (b) ; (c) (student intuition fails; Wire B stores 25% less elastic energy than Wire A)
Steps
Relating Cross-Sectional Area and Spring Constant
From Hooke's Law for elastic deformation, the tension force acting on a uniform wire is related to its elongation by:
Comparing this with the linear spring equation , the effective stiffness (spring constant) of a wire is:
The cross-sectional area of a circular wire with diameter is:
Given , the area ratio is:
Using the length ratio and identical Young's modulus :
Finding the Ratio of Elongations
Under an identical tensile load , the elongation is inversely proportional to stiffness:
Taking the ratio:
Wire B stretches only as much as Wire A.
Determining the Ratio of Elastic Potential Energy
The elastic strain energy stored in a linearly elastic wire can be expressed in terms of force and elongation:
Because the applied tensile force is identical for both wires:
Alternatively, using :
Pitfall to Avoid and Intuition Check
- Common Pitfall: A common mistake is using and reasoning that a larger spring constant or larger volume implies greater energy storage. When the force is held constant (rather than elongation), energy scales as .
- Conclusion: Wire B is stiffer overall () because the quadrupled cross-sectional area dominates the tripled length. As a result, Wire B elongates less and stores less elastic potential energy than Wire A under the same load. The novice student's intuition fails.
Typical errors
01 The student assumes cross-sectional area scales linearly with diameter rather than with the square of the diameter, leading to an incorrect area ratio of 2.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
The error occurred in writing . Cross-sectional area is a two-dimensional quantity given by . Doubling the diameter scales the cross-sectional area by a factor of , which leads to .
- Step 3Correct
Your reasoning that elongation is inversely proportional to stiffness under an identical tension force is completely correct, but the numerical value was affected by the incorrect stiffness ratio from Step 2.
- Step 4Correct
You chose the ideal form of the potential energy formula for a constant-load comparison, but the evaluated ratio inherited the propagated error from Step 3.
- Step 5Correct
Because the true energy ratio is , Wire B actually stores less elastic energy than Wire A under the same load, so the novice student's intuition fails.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly derived the relationship between material stiffness and geometry using .
You correctly applied Hooke's law to recognize that elongation is inversely proportional to stiffness when force is held constant.
You smartly selected to evaluate the energy ratio directly from the elongation ratio.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeEquating the cross-sectional area ratio to the diameter ratio rather than squaring it.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated cross-sectional area as scaling linearly with diameter rather than with diameter squared (), which underestimated Wire B's stiffness and reversed the comparison between Wire A and Wire B.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Geometric Scaling of Cross Sections
For any cylindrical wire or rod, cross-sectional area scales with the square of linear transverse dimensions: , so .
Always write out explicitly before computing scaling ratios to prevent linear substitution slips.
- Constant-Force Energy Scaling
When two elastic bodies experience the exact same load , elastic energy scales as .
Remember that under equal force, a stiffer body deforms less and therefore stores less strain energy.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCompute the cross-sectional area ratio: .
Determine the effective stiffness ratio: .
Compute the elongation ratio under identical load : .
Compute the stored energy ratio under identical load : .
(a) ; (b) ; (c) (student intuition fails; Wire B stores less elastic potential energy than Wire A).
02 The student uses the potential energy formula U = 1/2 k x² and assumes elongation ΔL is the same for both wires instead of finding U under constant force F, which inverts the energy ratio.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2
- Step 3Correct
(the student's intuition fails)
You assumed was equal for both wires even though you correctly showed in part (b) that . Under constant force , elastic potential energy scales inversely with stiffness () or directly with elongation (), so Wire B actually stores less energy than Wire A.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly formulated the effective spring constant and handled the area scaling with .
You accurately found that Wire B is stiffer than Wire A with .
You correctly determined that under the same tensile force, Wire B elongates less than Wire A by a factor of .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou selected the formula and treated as constant across both specimens, rather than expressing potential energy in terms of the conserved constraint (), which gives .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identify the Fixed Constraint
When comparing systems with different stiffnesses, express energy using the quantity held fixed across both systems.
Check whether force or elongation is identical. If is constant, use ; if is constant, use .
- Verify Internal Consistency
Intermediate values derived in earlier sub-parts must remain true in subsequent sub-parts unless conditions explicitly change.
Do not assume is equal when part (b) already established .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite the elastic potential energy in terms of the constant force : .
Form the ratio: .
Substitute into the ratio: .
Compare with 1: Since , Wire B stores less elastic potential energy than Wire A under the same tension, so the novice student's intuition fails.
(a) ; (b) ; (c) (student intuition fails; Wire B stores less energy)
03 The student confuses the relationship between spring constant and elongation under tension, incorrectly taking elongation to be directly proportional to k rather than inversely proportional.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
Hooke's law relates tensile force and deformation by , which means elongation is . Because elongation is inversely proportional to stiffness for a fixed force, the ratio should be .
- Step 3Correct
Your relationship and your ratio setup are mathematically sound, but this step inherited the inverted value from your previous elongation calculation.
- Step 4Correct
Because the true ratio is , Wire B actually stores less elastic potential energy under the same tensile force, meaning the novice intuition fails.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly related the elastic spring constant to Young's modulus, area, and length.
You accurately accounted for the quadratic scaling of cross-sectional area with diameter.
You correctly identified that elastic potential energy under constant tension is proportional to elongation.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou wrote instead of rearranging into , reversing the inverse proportionality between stiffness and elongation.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Stiffness vs. Compliance
Hooke's law states , so elongation is . A stiffer wire stretches less under the same load.
Whenever a problem gives constant applied force , express deformation as or compliance to keep the inverse relationship clear.
- Constant-Force Strain Energy
Under constant applied force , stored elastic potential energy is , which scales inversely with stiffness .
Check whether force or elongation is held constant before choosing between and .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationRearrange Hooke's law for elongation: .
Compute the elongation ratio under identical force : .
Substitute into the strain energy ratio: .
Evaluate the intuition: because , Wire B stores less energy, so the student's intuition fails.
(a) ; (b) ; (c) (student intuition fails)
Lock it in
How does the cross-sectional area of a cylindrical wire scale when its diameter is multiplied by a factor of ?
, so the area scales by . For example, doubling the diameter () quadruples the cross-sectional area ().
Similar question
Two steel rods, Rod 1 and Rod 2, have the same Young's modulus. Rod 2 has three times the radius () and six times the length () of Rod 1. When both rods are subjected to the same tensile force , calculate the ratio of their elongations .
Answer
.
Key steps:
- Area ratio: .
- Stiffness ratio: .
- Elongation ratio under identical : .
Two aluminum wires of circular cross section have the same Young's modulus. Wire Y has half the diameter () and one-third the length () of Wire X. Find the ratio of the elastic potential energy stored in Wire Y compared to Wire X () when identical tensile forces are applied to both.
Answer
.
Key steps:
- Area ratio: .
- Stiffness ratio: .
- Under identical force : .
A structural engineer needs to replace a copper cable of diameter and length with a new copper cable that stores at most half the elastic strain energy of the original cable under the same working load . If the new cable must be twice as long (), what is the minimum required diameter ratio ?
Answer
.
Key steps:
- For under constant force , we require .
- Since , this means .
- Solving gives .