Resources

A toy cart of mass M=1.50 kgM = 1.50\text{ kg} is initially at rest on a frictionless horizontal track. A stream of NN identical small beads, each of mass m=0.00200 kgm = 0.00200\text{ kg}, is shot horizontally at the cart. Each bead has an initial horizontal velocity v0=12.0 m/sv_0 = 12.0\text{ m/s} and sticks to the cart upon impact. Express the cart velocity v(N)v(N) as a function of NN, and compute both the speed after N=500N = 500 beads and the theoretical asymptotic speed limit v∞v_\infty as the number of absorbed beads N→∞N \to \infty.

Answer and steps

Final answer

v(500)=4.80 m/sv(500) = 4.80\text{ m/s}, and asymptotic limit v∞=12.0 m/sv_\infty = 12.0\text{ m/s}

Steps

01

Identify the Physical Principle

The cart and the incoming stream of beads move along a frictionless horizontal track. Because there are no external horizontal forces acting on the combined system (cart plus NN beads), the total horizontal momentum is conserved:

Pinitial=PfinalP_{\text{initial}} = P_{\text{final}}

A common pitfall is to compute the collisions sequentially and worry about how the velocity changes after each individual impact. However, because no external horizontal impulse is delivered to the entire system of cart and NN beads throughout the process, the total momentum depends only on the initial state of the beads and the final combined mass.


02

Formulate the General Expression for v(N)v(N)

  • Initial State:

    • The cart of mass MM is initially at rest: vcart,0=0v_{\text{cart}, 0} = 0.
    • Each of the NN beads has mass mm and moves at velocity v0v_0.

    The total initial horizontal momentum is: Pinitial=N⋅m⋅v0+M⋅0=Nmv0P_{\text{initial}} = N \cdot m \cdot v_0 + M \cdot 0 = N m v_0

  • Final State:

    • All NN beads stick to the cart.
    • The total final mass of the combined object is: Mtotal=M+NmM_{\text{total}} = M + N m
    • The entire mass moves together at speed v(N)v(N).

    The total final momentum is: Pfinal=(M+Nm)v(N)P_{\text{final}} = (M + N m) v(N)

Equating initial and final momentum gives: (M+Nm)v(N)=Nmv0(M + N m) v(N) = N m v_0

v(N)=Nmv0M+Nmv(N) = \frac{N m v_0}{M + N m}


03

Calculate the Velocity for N=500N = 500 Beads

Substitute the given values:

  • M=1.50 kgM = 1.50\text{ kg}
  • m=0.00200 kgm = 0.00200\text{ kg}
  • v0=12.0 m/sv_0 = 12.0\text{ m/s}
  • N=500N = 500

First, determine the total mass of the 500 beads: mbeads=Nm=500⋅0.00200 kg=1.00 kgm_{\text{beads}} = N m = 500 \cdot 0.00200\text{ kg} = 1.00\text{ kg}

The total mass of the cart with the beads embedded is: Mtotal=1.50 kg+1.00 kg=2.50 kgM_{\text{total}} = 1.50\text{ kg} + 1.00\text{ kg} = 2.50\text{ kg}

Now, calculate the speed v(500)v(500): v(500)=1.00 kg⋅12.0 m/s2.50 kg=12.02.50=4.80 m/sv(500) = \frac{1.00\text{ kg} \cdot 12.0\text{ m/s}}{2.50\text{ kg}} = \frac{12.0}{2.50} = 4.80\text{ m/s}


04

Determine the Asymptotic Limit as N→∞N \to \infty

To find the theoretical maximum speed as the number of beads becomes arbitrarily large, divide the numerator and denominator of v(N)v(N) by NmN m:

v(N)=v0MNm+1v(N) = \frac{v_0}{\frac{M}{N m} + 1}

Taking the limit as N→∞N \to \infty: lim⁡N→∞MNm=0\lim_{N \to \infty} \frac{M}{N m} = 0

v∞=lim⁡N→∞v(N)=v00+1=v0=12.0 m/sv_\infty = \lim_{N \to \infty} v(N) = \frac{v_0}{0 + 1} = v_0 = 12.0\text{ m/s}

As the mass of accumulated beads vastly exceeds the original mass of the cart (Nm≫MN m \gg M), the cart's initial inertia becomes negligible, and the cart approaches the speed of the incoming beads, 12.0 m/s12.0\text{ m/s}.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to account for the mass of the embedded beads in the final total mass, leading to an overestimated speed and an unbounded limit.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Nmv0=Mv(N)  ⟹  v(N)=Nmv0MN m v_0 = M v(N) \implies v(N) = \frac{N m v_0}{M}

    Correct

    Nmv0=(M+Nm)v(N)  ⟹  v(N)=Nmv0M+NmN m v_0 = (M + N m) v(N) \implies v(N) = \frac{N m v_0}{M + N m}

    You set up conservation of momentum, but you only used the cart mass MM for the final moving object. Because the beads stick to the cart upon impact (a completely inelastic collision), the combined final mass moving at velocity v(N)v(N) must be M+NmM + N m.

  2. Step 2

    Nm=500⋅0.00200=1.00 kg  ⟹  v(500)=1.00⋅12.01.50=8.00 m/sN m = 500 \cdot 0.00200 = 1.00\text{ kg} \implies v(500) = \frac{1.00 \cdot 12.0}{1.50} = 8.00\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    v(500)=1.00 kg⋅12.0 m/s1.50 kg+1.00 kg=4.80 m/sv(500) = \frac{1.00\text{ kg} \cdot 12.0\text{ m/s}}{1.50\text{ kg} + 1.00\text{ kg}} = 4.80\text{ m/s}

    You correctly calculated the total mass of the 500 beads as 1.00 kg1.00\text{ kg}. However, substituting this into your formula divided by only 1.50 kg1.50\text{ kg} instead of the combined mass of 2.50 kg2.50\text{ kg}, resulting in an incorrect speed.

  3. Step 3

    As N→∞, v(N)→∞\text{As } N \to \infty,\ v(N) \to \infty

    Correct

    v∞=lim⁡N→∞Nmv0M+Nm=v0=12.0 m/sv_\infty = \lim_{N \to \infty} \frac{N m v_0}{M + N m} = v_0 = 12.0\text{ m/s}

    Because your formula lacked NmN m in the denominator, taking the limit gave an unbounded speed. With the correct denominator, as N→∞N \to \infty, the initial cart mass becomes negligible compared to the bead mass, meaning the cart speed asymptotically approaches the bead speed v0=12.0 m/sv_0 = 12.0\text{ m/s}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that total horizontal momentum is conserved because the track is frictionless.

You correctly computed the total mass of 500500 beads as 1.00 kg1.00\text{ kg}.

You correctly set up the initial momentum of the stream of beads as Nmv0N m v_0.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Embedded Mass in Inelastic Collision

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the cart's mass as constant throughout the absorption process, forgetting that in a completely inelastic collision, the incoming projectiles remain embedded and increase the total inertia of the final system.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Collision Type and System Mass
  • When an object absorbs or embeds incoming projectiles, the final system mass is Mfinal=Mtarget+mprojectilesM_{\text{final}} = M_{\text{target}} + m_{\text{projectiles}}.

  • Before writing Pfinal=MfinalvP_{\text{final}} = M_{\text{final}} v, always list every mass component that moves with the final velocity.

Physical Sanity Check on Limiting Velocity
  • In an inelastic collision where stationary targets absorb incoming objects moving at v0v_0, the final speed can never exceed v0v_0.

  • Check your asymptotic limit: if v(N)>v0v(N) > v_0 or diverges to infinity, re-check the denominator for missing absorbed mass.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Include the accumulated mass of the NN beads in the final momentum: Pfinal=(M+Nm)v(N)P_{\text{final}} = (M + N m) v(N).

  2. Equate initial and final momentum: (M+Nm)v(N)=Nmv0  ⟹  v(N)=Nmv0M+Nm(M + N m) v(N) = N m v_0 \implies v(N) = \frac{N m v_0}{M + N m}.

  3. For N=500N = 500, substitute Nm=1.00 kgN m = 1.00\text{ kg}: v(500)=1.00⋅12.01.50+1.00=12.02.50=4.80 m/sv(500) = \frac{1.00 \cdot 12.0}{1.50 + 1.00} = \frac{12.0}{2.50} = 4.80\text{ m/s}.

  4. Take the limit as N→∞N \to \infty: lim⁡N→∞v0MNm+1=12.00+1=12.0 m/s\lim_{N \to \infty} \frac{v_0}{\frac{M}{N m} + 1} = \frac{12.0}{0 + 1} = 12.0\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

v(N)=Nmv0M+Nmv(N) = \frac{N m v_0}{M + N m}, v(500)=4.80 m/sv(500) = 4.80\text{ m/s}, and v∞=12.0 m/sv_\infty = 12.0\text{ m/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out Mfinal=Mcart+MabsorbedM_{\text{final}} = M_{\text{cart}} + M_{\text{absorbed}} explicitly whenever projectiles stick upon impact.

  • Perform an asymptotic check on collision formulas to ensure the final speed cannot exceed the initial projectile speed.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misapplies the limit by assuming that because the total mass in the denominator grows without bound, the speed approaches zero.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Pinitial=Nmv0  ⟹  Pfinal=(M+Nm)v(N)  ⟹  v(N)=Nmv0M+NmP_{\text{initial}} = N m v_0 \implies P_{\text{final}} = (M + N m) v(N) \implies v(N) = \frac{N m v_0}{M + N m}

  2. Step 2

    Nm=500×0.00200=1.00 kg  ⟹  v(500)=1.00×12.01.50+1.00=4.80 m/sN m = 500 \times 0.00200 = 1.00\text{ kg} \implies v(500) = \frac{1.00 \times 12.0}{1.50 + 1.00} = 4.80\text{ m/s}

  3. Step 3

    As N→∞, the denominator M+Nm→∞  ⟹  v∞=0 m/s\text{As } N \to \infty\text{, the denominator } M + N m \to \infty \implies v_\infty = 0\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    v∞=lim⁡N→∞Nmv0M+Nm=lim⁡N→∞v0MNm+1=12.0 m/sv_\infty = \lim_{N \to \infty} \frac{N m v_0}{M + N m} = \lim_{N \to \infty} \frac{v_0}{\frac{M}{N m} + 1} = 12.0\text{ m/s}

    You looked only at the denominator tending to infinity and concluded that the fraction approaches zero. Because the numerator Nmv0N m v_0 also approaches infinity, this is an indeterminate form ∞∞\frac{\infty}{\infty}. Dividing both numerator and denominator by NN shows that the cart speed approaches the bead speed v0=12.0 m/sv_0 = 12.0\text{ m/s}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that horizontal momentum is conserved throughout all collisions.

You correctly derived the algebraic expression for v(N)v(N).

You accurately substituted the numerical values to compute v(500)=4.80 m/sv(500) = 4.80\text{ m/s}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Indeterminate Form Overlooked

false

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the numerator as a constant while letting the denominator grow without bound, forgetting that the total initial momentum delivered to the cart also scales linearly with NN.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Check Both Numerator and Denominator for Variable Dependence
  • When taking a limit of a rational expression P(N)Q(N)\frac{P(N)}{Q(N)} as N→∞N \to \infty, verify whether NN appears in both the top and the bottom before concluding that the fraction goes to zero.

  • Divide both numerator and denominator by the highest power of NN (or by the dominant term NmN m) to resolve indeterminate forms of type ∞∞\frac{\infty}{\infty}.

Apply Physical Intuition to Asymptotic Limits
  • Each incoming bead transfers forward momentum and moves at speed v0v_0. As N→∞N \to \infty, the accumulated bead mass dwarfs the initial cart mass (Nm≫MN m \gg M).

  • Ask yourself whether adding more fast-moving beads can ever slow down a cart moving in the same direction; the cart must inevitably approach the speed of the bead stream (v0v_0), not stop.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Write v(N)v(N) in terms of dominant powers of NN: v(N)=Nmv0M+Nm=v0MNm+1v(N) = \frac{N m v_0}{M + N m} = \frac{v_0}{\frac{M}{N m} + 1}.

  2. Take the limit as N→∞N \to \infty: since MNm→0\frac{M}{N m} \to 0, the denominator approaches 11.

  3. Compute the asymptotic limit: v∞=v00+1=v0=12.0 m/sv_\infty = \frac{v_0}{0 + 1} = v_0 = 12.0\text{ m/s}.

Final answer

v(500)=4.80 m/sv(500) = 4.80\text{ m/s}, and v∞=12.0 m/sv_\infty = 12.0\text{ m/s}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice factoring out the highest power of NN in rational functions before evaluating limits to infinity.

  • Use physical reality checks: verify whether an infinite stream of bullets/beads at 12.0 m/s12.0\text{ m/s} could ever cause the target to come to rest.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A toy cart of mass M=3.0 kgM = 3.0\text{ kg} is initially at rest on a frictionless surface. A single blob of clay of mass m=1.0 kgm = 1.0\text{ kg} is thrown horizontally at the cart with speed v0=8.0 m/sv_0 = 8.0\text{ m/s} and sticks to it. What is the speed of the cart and clay after the collision?

Answer

The final speed is 2.0 m/s2.0\text{ m/s}. By conservation of momentum, mv0=(M+m)vf  ⟹  vf=1.0 kg⋅8.0 m/s3.0 kg+1.0 kg=8.04.0=2.0 m/sm v_0 = (M + m) v_f \implies v_f = \frac{1.0\text{ kg} \cdot 8.0\text{ m/s}}{3.0\text{ kg} + 1.0\text{ kg}} = \frac{8.0}{4.0} = 2.0\text{ m/s}.

02

A stationary open hopper car of mass M=2000 kgM = 2000\text{ kg} sits on a frictionless level railway. Coal falls vertically into the car at a rate of R=50 kg/sR = 50\text{ kg/s}, while a horizontal water jet shoots water into the car at a rate of 20 kg/s20\text{ kg/s} with a horizontal speed of 15 m/s15\text{ m/s}. All coal and water remain inside the car. What is the horizontal speed of the car after t=10 st = 10\text{ s}?

Answer

The speed is 1.11 m/s1.11\text{ m/s} (or 109 m/s\frac{10}{9}\text{ m/s}). At t=10 st = 10\text{ s}, the absorbed water mass is mw=20⋅10=200 kgm_w = 20 \cdot 10 = 200\text{ kg}, and the coal mass is mc=50⋅10=500 kgm_c = 50 \cdot 10 = 500\text{ kg}. Total mass is Mtot=2000+200+500=2700 kgM_{\text{tot}} = 2000 + 200 + 500 = 2700\text{ kg}. Only the water carries initial horizontal momentum: Px=mwv0=200⋅15=3000 kg⋅m/sP_x = m_w v_0 = 200 \cdot 15 = 3000\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m/s}. Thus v=30002700=109≈1.11 m/sv = \frac{3000}{2700} = \frac{10}{9} \approx 1.11\text{ m/s}.

03

A stationary cart of mass MM collects rain falling at an angle θ=60∘\theta = 60^\circ relative to the horizontal. Rain enters the cart at a constant mass rate μ=dmdt\mu = \frac{dm}{dt} with constant speed uu. Assuming the track is frictionless and horizontal, write the differential equation for the cart's velocity v(t)v(t), and find v(t)v(t) as a function of time tt given v(0)=0v(0) = 0.

Answer

v(t)=μucos⁡θ⋅tM+μtv(t) = \frac{\mu u \cos\theta \cdot t}{M + \mu t}. The horizontal momentum delivered by rain in time tt is Px(t)=(μt)ucos⁡θP_x(t) = (\mu t) u \cos\theta. Because horizontal momentum is conserved between the absorbed rain and the cart, (M+μt)v(t)=μtucos⁡θ(M + \mu t) v(t) = \mu t u \cos\theta, which yields v(t)=μucos⁡θ⋅tM+μtv(t) = \frac{\mu u \cos\theta \cdot t}{M + \mu t}. In differential form: (M+μt)dvdt+μv=μucos⁡θ(M + \mu t)\frac{dv}{dt} + \mu v = \mu u \cos\theta.

Loading workspace…