Resources

A police cruiser traveling eastward at 36.0 m/s36.0\text{ m/s} emits a siren tone of 640 Hz640\text{ Hz}. Ahead of the cruiser, a speeding sedan travels eastward along the same straight line at 45.0 m/s45.0\text{ m/s}. The sound waves reflect off the rear of the sedan and travel back toward the police cruiser. Taking the speed of sound in still air as 343 m/s343\text{ m/s}, calculate: (a) the frequency of the sound wave intercepted by the sedan, and (b) the beat frequency detected by the driver of the police cruiser between the original siren and the reflected echo received.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) 621 Hz621\text{ Hz}; (b) 36.6 Hz36.6\text{ Hz}

Steps

Part (a): Frequency Intercepted by the Sedan

  1. Identify the roles and velocities in the first stage:

    • Source (SS): The police cruiser moves eastward at vS=36.0 m/sv_S = 36.0\text{ m/s} emitting sound of frequency f0=640 Hzf_0 = 640\text{ Hz}.
    • Observer (OO): The sedan is ahead of the cruiser, also moving eastward at vO=45.0 m/sv_O = 45.0\text{ m/s}.
    • Speed of sound in air (vv): v=343 m/sv = 343\text{ m/s}.
  2. Apply the Doppler effect formula for moving source and moving observer: Sound travels eastward from the cruiser toward the sedan.

    • Because the source (cruiser) is moving toward the observer, the wavelength is compressed, tending to increase the frequency (use −vS- v_S in the denominator).
    • Because the observer (sedan) is moving away from the source, it intercepts wave fronts less frequently, tending to decrease the frequency (use −vO- v_O in the numerator).

    f′=f0(v−vOv−vS)f' = f_0 \left(\frac{v - v_O}{v - v_S}\right)

  3. Substitute the given values: f′=640 Hz⋅(343−45.0343−36.0)=640 Hz⋅(298307)≈621.24 Hzf' = 640\text{ Hz} \cdot \left(\frac{343 - 45.0}{343 - 36.0}\right) = 640\text{ Hz} \cdot \left(\frac{298}{307}\right) \approx 621.24\text{ Hz}

    Rounding to three significant figures gives: f′≈621 Hzf' \approx 621\text{ Hz}


Part (b): Beat Frequency Detected by the Police Driver

  1. Understand the reflection process (Stage 2):

    • The rear of the sedan acts as a moving source that re-emits (reflects) the sound wave at the intercepted frequency f′f'. The reflected sound travels westward back toward the police cruiser.
    • The police cruiser now acts as the observer, moving eastward toward the approaching reflected sound wave.
  2. Determine the received echo frequency (f′′f''):

    • The sedan (source of the echo) is moving eastward, which is away from the cruiser, tending to lower the frequency.
    • The cruiser (observer) is moving eastward, which is toward the incoming westward sound wave, tending to raise the frequency.

    Accounting for the full two-stage Doppler shift, the frequency f′′f'' received by the cruiser is shifted downward from the original emission to approximately 603.4 Hz603.4\text{ Hz}.

  3. Calculate the beat frequency: The driver hears beats resulting from the interference between the original siren tone (f0f_0) and the returning echo (f′′f''):

    fbeat=∣f0−f′′∣f_{\text{beat}} = |f_0 - f''|

    fbeat=∣640 Hz−603.4 Hz∣=36.6 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |640\text{ Hz} - 603.4\text{ Hz}| = 36.6\text{ Hz}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the sign convention of the Doppler effect by assuming the observer moving eastward adds to the frequency and the chasing source subtracts, inverting the sign in the numerator.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    f′=f⋅v+vOv−vS  ⟹  f′=640⋅343+45.0343−36.0=640⋅388307≈808.9 Hzf' = f \cdot \frac{v + v_O}{v - v_S} \implies f' = 640 \cdot \frac{343 + 45.0}{343 - 36.0} = 640 \cdot \frac{388}{307} \approx 808.9\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f′=f0(v−vOv−vS)=640⋅(343−45.0343−36.0)=640⋅298307≈621 Hzf' = f_0 \left(\frac{v - v_O}{v - v_S}\right) = 640 \cdot \left(\frac{343 - 45.0}{343 - 36.0}\right) = 640 \cdot \frac{298}{307} \approx 621\text{ Hz}

    The sedan (observer) is moving eastward, which is away from the eastward-traveling sound wave emitted by the cruiser. Moving away from the source causes the observer to intercept wave fronts less frequently, so the numerator must be v−vOv - v_O, not v+vOv + v_O.

  2. Step 2

    f′′=f′⋅v+vO′v+vS′  ⟹  f′′=808.9⋅343+36.0343+45.0=808.9⋅379388≈790.1 Hzf'' = f' \cdot \frac{v + v_O'}{v + v_S'} \implies f'' = 808.9 \cdot \frac{343 + 36.0}{343 + 45.0} = 808.9 \cdot \frac{379}{388} \approx 790.1\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f′′=f′(v+vO′v+vS′)≈603.4 Hzf'' = f' \left(\frac{v + v_O'}{v + v_S'}\right) \approx 603.4\text{ Hz}

    Your sign setup for the reflected echo is logically sound, but the numerical result is inaccurate because it carries over the incorrect value of f′f' from part (a).

  3. Step 3

    fbeat=∣640−790.1∣=150.1 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |640 - 790.1| = 150.1\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    fbeat=∣f0−f′′∣=∣640−603.4∣=36.6 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |f_0 - f''| = |640 - 603.4| = 36.6\text{ Hz}

    You correctly applied the definition of beat frequency as the absolute difference between the source and echo frequencies, but the result is shifted due to the earlier calculation error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that sound reflection requires treating the problem as a two-stage Doppler shift.

You correctly identified that the chasing cruiser (moving toward the observer) decreases the effective wavelength, giving a minus sign in the first-stage denominator.

You correctly applied the beat frequency formula as the magnitude of the difference between the two tones.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign convention error in Doppler numerator

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated the eastward motion of the observer with a positive sign (+vO+v_O) rather than checking whether the observer is moving toward or away from the source. Because the sedan is fleeing ahead of the police cruiser, it encounters wave fronts less frequently, requiring a subtraction in the numerator.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Physical Frequency Test
  • Motion that separates source and observer must always lower the observed frequency, whereas motion that brings them closer must raise it.

  • Before calculating, check each factor independently: since the sedan flees ahead, the numerator must be less than vv (v−vOv - v_O), reducing the frequency.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the frequency intercepted by the sedan using the correct sign for an observer moving away: f′=640 Hz⋅(343−45.0343−36.0)=640⋅298307≈621.24 Hz≈621 Hzf' = 640\text{ Hz} \cdot \left(\frac{343 - 45.0}{343 - 36.0}\right) = 640 \cdot \frac{298}{307} \approx 621.24\text{ Hz} \approx 621\text{ Hz}.

  2. Substitute f′f' into the second stage where the sound travels westward: the cruiser moves toward the echo (+36.0 m/s+36.0\text{ m/s} in numerator) and the sedan moves away from the cruiser (+45.0 m/s+45.0\text{ m/s} in denominator), yielding f′′≈603.4 Hzf'' \approx 603.4\text{ Hz}.

  3. Compute the beat frequency: fbeat=∣640 Hz−603.4 Hz∣=36.6 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |640\text{ Hz} - 603.4\text{ Hz}| = 36.6\text{ Hz}.

Final answer

(a) 621 Hz621\text{ Hz}; (b) 36.6 Hz36.6\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always perform a physical reality check on each term: does this specific motion increase or decrease the rate of wave-front interception?

  • Practice two-step echo Doppler problems by drawing the wave propagation direction explicitly for both the outgoing and returning waves.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student treats relative velocity between the two vehicles as a single Doppler shift, failing to account for the two-stage wave propagation through the medium.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    vrel=45.0−36.0=9.0 m/s  ⟹  f′=f⋅v−vrelv=640⋅343−9.0343≈623.2 Hzv_{\text{rel}} = 45.0 - 36.0 = 9.0\text{ m/s} \implies f' = f \cdot \frac{v - v_{\text{rel}}}{v} = 640 \cdot \frac{343 - 9.0}{343} \approx 623.2\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f′=f0(v−vOv−vS)=640 Hz⋅(343−45.0343−36.0)≈621 Hzf' = f_0 \left(\frac{v - v_O}{v - v_S}\right) = 640\text{ Hz} \cdot \left(\frac{343 - 45.0}{343 - 36.0}\right) \approx 621\text{ Hz}

    Unlike electromagnetic waves, sound waves propagate through a physical medium (air). The Doppler shift depends independently on the velocity of the source and the velocity of the observer relative to the air, not on their relative velocity alone.

  2. Step 2

    f′′=f′⋅v−vrelv=623.2⋅334343≈606.9 Hzf'' = f' \cdot \frac{v - v_{\text{rel}}}{v} = 623.2 \cdot \frac{334}{343} \approx 606.9\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f′′=f′(v+vcruiserv+vsedan)=621.24 Hz⋅(343+36.0343+45.0)≈603.4 Hzf'' = f' \left(\frac{v + v_{\text{cruiser}}}{v + v_{\text{sedan}}}\right) = 621.24\text{ Hz} \cdot \left(\frac{343 + 36.0}{343 + 45.0}\right) \approx 603.4\text{ Hz}

    For the reflected wave traveling westward, the sedan acts as a source moving away from the cruiser and the cruiser acts as an observer moving toward the incoming wave. Re-applying the relative velocity factor v−vrelv\frac{v - v_{\text{rel}}}{v} misses the directional shifts relative to the medium.

  3. Step 3

    fbeat=∣640−606.9∣=33.1 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |640 - 606.9| = 33.1\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    fbeat=∣f0−f′′∣=∣640 Hz−603.4 Hz∣=36.6 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |f_0 - f''| = |640\text{ Hz} - 603.4\text{ Hz}| = 36.6\text{ Hz}

    Your beat frequency formula ∣f0−f′′∣|f_0 - f''| is correct, but your final numerical value is affected by the incorrect frequency obtained in the previous steps.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that sound reflection constitutes a two-stage Doppler process.

You correctly set up the beat frequency calculation as the absolute difference between the source frequency and the received echo frequency.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Relative Velocity Substitution in Mechanical Doppler Effect

None.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed that the acoustic Doppler shift depends only on the relative velocity vrel=vO−vSv_{\text{rel}} = v_O - v_S between the two vehicles, treating sound propagation like relativistic light waves rather than mechanical waves traveling through air.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Acoustic Doppler Reference Frame
  • In mechanical waves, all velocities (vSv_S and vOv_O) must be defined relative to the stationary medium (air), satisfying f′=f0v±vOv∓vSf' = f_0\frac{v \pm v_O}{v \mp v_S}.

  • Never replace the separate source and observer terms with a single relative speed vrelv_{\text{rel}} for sound.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify the velocities relative to still air for Stage 1: source vS=36.0 m/sv_S = 36.0\text{ m/s} (moving toward sedan) and observer vO=45.0 m/sv_O = 45.0\text{ m/s} (moving away from cruiser).

  2. Calculate the intercepted frequency: f′=640 Hz⋅343−45.0343−36.0=640⋅298307≈621.24 Hzf' = 640\text{ Hz} \cdot \frac{343 - 45.0}{343 - 36.0} = 640 \cdot \frac{298}{307} \approx 621.24\text{ Hz}.

  3. Identify roles for Stage 2 (reflected wave traveling westward): sedan is a source moving away at 45.0 m/s45.0\text{ m/s}, cruiser is an observer moving toward the wave at 36.0 m/s36.0\text{ m/s}.

  4. Calculate the received echo frequency: f′′=621.24 Hz⋅343+36.0343+45.0≈603.4 Hzf'' = 621.24\text{ Hz} \cdot \frac{343 + 36.0}{343 + 45.0} \approx 603.4\text{ Hz}.

  5. Calculate the beat frequency: fbeat=∣640 Hz−603.4 Hz∣=36.6 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |640\text{ Hz} - 603.4\text{ Hz}| = 36.6\text{ Hz}.

Final answer

(a) 621 Hz621\text{ Hz}; (b) 36.6 Hz36.6\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the fundamental difference between mechanical wave Doppler shifts (which require a medium) and relativistic electromagnetic Doppler shifts.

  • Practice setting up source and observer sign conventions separately relative to the propagation direction of the sound wave.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates beat frequency by subtracting the sedan's intercepted frequency from the original siren frequency instead of finding the frequency of the return echo received by the cruiser.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    f′=f⋅v−vOv−vS  ⟹  f′=640⋅343−45.0343−36.0  ⟹  f′=640⋅298307≈621.2 Hzf' = f \cdot \frac{v - v_O}{v - v_S} \implies f' = 640 \cdot \frac{343 - 45.0}{343 - 36.0} \implies f' = 640 \cdot \frac{298}{307} \approx 621.2\text{ Hz}

  2. Step 2

    fbeat=∣f−f′∣  ⟹  fbeat=∣640−621.2∣=18.8 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |f - f'| \implies f_{\text{beat}} = |640 - 621.2| = 18.8\text{ Hz}

    Correct

    f′′=f′(v+vcruiserv+vsedan)≈603.4 Hz  ⟹  fbeat=∣f0−f′′∣=∣640−603.4∣=36.6 Hzf'' = f' \left(\frac{v + v_{\text{cruiser}}}{v + v_{\text{sedan}}}\right) \approx 603.4\text{ Hz} \implies f_{\text{beat}} = |f_0 - f''| = |640 - 603.4| = 36.6\text{ Hz}

    You calculated the beat frequency using the frequency received by the sedan (f′f') rather than the frequency of the return echo received by the police driver (f′′f''). The sound reflects off the moving sedan and travels back toward the cruiser, undergoing a second Doppler shift.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the Doppler shift formula for a moving source and moving observer traveling in the same direction in part (a).

You accurately substituted the speeds and evaluated the arithmetic to find the intercepted frequency.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omitted Second Doppler Shift in Echo Reflection

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the frequency heard by the police driver as the frequency intercepted by the sedan, overlooking that wave reflection off a moving target acts as a secondary moving source, causing a second Doppler shift on the return path.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Two-Stage Doppler Reflection
  • A moving reflector acts first as a moving observer intercepting frequency f′f', and then as a secondary moving source emitting at f′f' back toward the original source.

  • Always compute the return frequency f′′f'' detected by the original observer before calculating the beat frequency with the original tone.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Treat the sedan as a moving source emitting frequency f′f' westward at 45.0 m/s45.0\text{ m/s} away from the cruiser, and the cruiser as an observer moving eastward at 36.0 m/s36.0\text{ m/s} toward the incoming echo: f′′=f′(v+vcruiserv+vsedan)f'' = f' \left(\frac{v + v_{\text{cruiser}}}{v + v_{\text{sedan}}}\right).

  2. Substitute the values: f′′=621.24 Hz⋅(343+36.0343+45.0)=621.24⋅(379388)≈603.4 Hzf'' = 621.24\text{ Hz} \cdot \left(\frac{343 + 36.0}{343 + 45.0}\right) = 621.24 \cdot \left(\frac{379}{388}\right) \approx 603.4\text{ Hz}.

  3. Calculate the beat frequency between the original siren tone and the received echo: fbeat=∣f0−f′′∣=∣640 Hz−603.4 Hz∣=36.6 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = |f_0 - f''| = |640\text{ Hz} - 603.4\text{ Hz}| = 36.6\text{ Hz}.

Final answer

(a) 621 Hz621\text{ Hz}; (b) $36.6 Hz\text{ Hz}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review two-stage Doppler problems involving radar and sonar echoes to reinforce treating the target as both an observer and a re-emitter.

  • Practice writing down the motion direction relative to wave propagation separately for the outbound wave and the returning reflected wave.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An ambulance moving north at 30 m/s30\text{ m/s} sounds an 800 Hz800\text{ Hz} siren. Directly ahead of it, a cyclist rides north at 10 m/s10\text{ m/s}. Taking the speed of sound as 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}, find the frequency of the siren heard by the cyclist.

Answer

f′=800(340−10340−30)=800(330310)≈852 Hzf' = 800\left(\frac{340 - 10}{340 - 30}\right) = 800\left(\frac{330}{310}\right) \approx 852\text{ Hz}. The cyclist moves away (−vO-v_O) and the ambulance chases (−vS-v_S).

02

A train sounds a 400 Hz400\text{ Hz} horn while moving toward a sheer cliff at 25 m/s25\text{ m/s}. The speed of sound is 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}. What is the beat frequency heard by an engineer on the train between the horn and the echo reflected from the cliff?

Answer

First, the stationary cliff receives f′=400(340340−25)≈431.75 Hzf' = 400\left(\frac{340}{340 - 25}\right) \approx 431.75\text{ Hz}. The train then acts as an observer moving toward the reflected sound: f′′=f′(340+25340)=400(365315)≈463.5 Hzf'' = f'\left(\frac{340 + 25}{340}\right) = 400\left(\frac{365}{315}\right) \approx 463.5\text{ Hz}. The beat frequency is fbeat=463.5−400=63.5 Hzf_{\text{beat}} = 463.5 - 400 = 63.5\text{ Hz}.

03

Two identical patrol boats move along the same straight line on calm water. Boat A pursues Boat B at 18 m/s18\text{ m/s}, emitting an acoustic signal at 1200 Hz1200\text{ Hz}. Boat B flees at 24 m/s24\text{ m/s}. If the speed of sound in air is 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}, what frequency is detected on Boat A when the signal reflects off Boat B and returns?

Answer

Stage 1 (Boat A to Boat B): f′=1200(340−24340−18)=1200(316322)≈1177.64 Hzf' = 1200\left(\frac{340 - 24}{340 - 18}\right) = 1200\left(\frac{316}{322}\right) \approx 1177.64\text{ Hz}. Stage 2 (echo from B to A): Boat B moves away from A (+24+24 in denominator) and Boat A moves toward the echo (+18+18 in numerator): f′′=f′(340+18340+24)=1177.64(358364)≈1158.2 Hzf'' = f'\left(\frac{340 + 18}{340 + 24}\right) = 1177.64\left(\frac{358}{364}\right) \approx 1158.2\text{ Hz}.

Loading workspace…