Resources

In a precision physics laboratory, a Faraday ice pail connected to a calibrated digital electrometer is used to verify Faraday's law of charge conservation during electrostatic induction and contact transfer. A conducting proof plane mounted on an insulating handle carries an unknown initial charge QxQ_x. The proof plane is completely lowered inside the conductive inner bucket of the Faraday ice pail without touching the walls, producing an electrometer reading of +4.20 V+4.20\text{ V}. The effective input capacitance of the pail-electrometer system is C=150 pFC = 150\text{ pF}. Next, the proof plane is allowed to touch the interior surface of the inner bucket and is then completely withdrawn. (a) Calculate the magnitude and sign of the charge QxQ_x on the proof plane prior to contact. (b) Predict the electrometer voltage reading while the proof plane touches the interior wall and after it is withdrawn. (c) What is the final net charge remaining on the proof plane after removal from the pail?

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Qx=+6.30×10−10 C=+0.630 nCQ_x = +6.30 \times 10^{-10}\text{ C} = +0.630\text{ nC}; (b) The electrometer voltage remains +4.20 V+4.20\text{ V} during contact and stays at +4.20 V+4.20\text{ V} after withdrawal; (c) 0.00 C0.00\text{ C} (all excess charge resides entirely on the exterior surface of the outer system).

Steps

Part (a): Determining the Initial Charge QxQ_x on the Proof Plane

When a charged object carrying charge QxQ_x is lowered deep inside a closed or nearly closed hollow conductor (a Faraday ice pail) without making contact:

  1. By electrostatic induction, an equal and opposite charge, −Qx-Q_x, is drawn to the inner surface of the pail.
  2. By the conservation of electric charge, a charge +Qx+Q_x is pushed to the outer surface of the pail and the connected electrometer.

The relationship between the charge on the outer surface, Qouter=QxQ_{\text{outer}} = Q_x, the system's effective capacitance CC, and the measured potential difference VV is: Qx=C⋅VQ_x = C \cdot V

Substitute the given values (C=150 pF=150×10−12 FC = 150\text{ pF} = 150 \times 10^{-12}\text{ F} and V=+4.20 VV = +4.20\text{ V}): Qx=(150×10−12 F)⋅(4.20 V)=6.30×10−10 C=+0.630 nCQ_x = (150 \times 10^{-12}\text{ F}) \cdot (4.20\text{ V}) = 6.30 \times 10^{-10}\text{ C} = +0.630\text{ nC}

Because the electrometer measures a positive potential (+4.20 V+4.20\text{ V}), the charge QxQ_x is positive: Qx=+6.30×10−10 C=+0.630 nCQ_x = +6.30 \times 10^{-10}\text{ C} = +0.630\text{ nC}


Part (b): Electrometer Voltage During and After Contact

  • During contact: When the proof plane touches the inner wall of the pail, it temporarily forms a single continuous conductor with the bucket. In electrostatic equilibrium, any net excess charge resides strictly on the outer surface of a conductor (by Gauss's law, ∮E⃗⋅dA⃗=0\oint \vec{E} \cdot d\vec{A} = 0 inside the conducting material). The charge −Qx-Q_x on the inner surface neutralizes the charge QxQ_x on the proof plane. The total charge residing on the outer surface remains exactly +Qx+Q_x. Therefore, the electrometer voltage remains constant at: V=+4.20 VV = +4.20\text{ V}
  • After withdrawal: Since the neutralization occurred inside the hollow cavity and all excess charge remains distributed over the external surface, withdrawing the uncharged proof plane causes no redistribution of charge. The electrometer voltage stays at: V=+4.20 VV = +4.20\text{ V}

Part (c): Final Net Charge on the Proof Plane

Because all excess charge transferred completely to the exterior surface of the pail system during contact, no charge remains on the interior surface or on the proof plane.

Therefore, upon removal, the final net charge on the proof plane is: Qfinal=0.00 CQ_{\text{final}} = 0.00\text{ C}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets that electrostatic induction redistributes opposite charge to the outer surface, mistakenly believing the electrometer measures an opposite induced charge, yielding a negative initial charge.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Qx=−C⋅V  ⟹  Qx=−(150×10−12 F)⋅(4.20 V)=−6.30×10−10 CQ_x = -C \cdot V \implies Q_x = -(150 \times 10^{-12}\text{ F}) \cdot (4.20\text{ V}) = -6.30 \times 10^{-10}\text{ C}

    Correct

    Qx=C⋅V=(150×10−12 F)⋅(4.20 V)=+6.30×10−10 CQ_x = C \cdot V = (150 \times 10^{-12}\text{ F}) \cdot (4.20\text{ V}) = +6.30 \times 10^{-10}\text{ C}

    You added a negative sign to the formula. When a positive charge QxQ_x enters the pail, it induces an opposite charge −Qx-Q_x on the inner surface and an equal like charge +Qx+Q_x on the outer surface connected to the electrometer. Since the electrometer measures +4.20 V+4.20\text{ V}, the outer charge and the source charge QxQ_x are both positive.

  2. Step 2

    During contact: V=−4.20 V  ⟹  After withdrawal: V=−4.20 V\text{During contact: } V = -4.20\text{ V} \implies \text{After withdrawal: } V = -4.20\text{ V}

    Correct

    During contact: V=+4.20 V  ⟹  After withdrawal: V=+4.20 V\text{During contact: } V = +4.20\text{ V} \implies \text{After withdrawal: } V = +4.20\text{ V}

    You recognized that the voltage remains unchanged during contact and after removal, which is physically correct. However, your values inherited the incorrect negative sign from your initial step instead of matching the measured +4.20 V+4.20\text{ V}.

  3. Step 3

    Net charge remaining on proof plane=0 C\text{Net charge remaining on proof plane} = 0\text{ C}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly applied the capacitance relation Q=C⋅VQ = C \cdot V to calculate the magnitude of the charge.

You correctly recognized that the electrometer voltage does not change during contact or after withdrawal.

You correctly identified that the final net charge on the proof plane is zero after contacting the interior wall.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Charge induction sign convention

You mistook the charge on the outer surface of the Faraday pail for the induced inner charge rather than the like charge displaced to the electrometer.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the sign of the induced inner surface charge (−Qx-Q_x) with the sign of the charge pushed to the exterior surface and electrometer (+Qx+Q_x). By Gauss's law, a Gaussian surface inside the conducting walls encloses zero net charge, so the inner surface acquires −Qx-Q_x. By conservation of charge on the initially neutral pail, the exterior receives +Qx+Q_x.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Outer Surface Charge Rule
  • An enclosed charge QinQ_{\text{in}} induces −Qin-Q_{\text{in}} on the inner wall and +Qin+Q_{\text{in}} on the exterior of an isolated neutral hollow conductor.

  • Always set the exterior charge (and electrometer reading) to the same sign as the enclosed object.

Cavity Contact Transfer
  • Touching the inner wall allows the enclosed charge to neutralize the inner induced charge, leaving all excess charge on the outer wall.

  • Keep the electrometer reading constant at its pre-contact value throughout contact and withdrawal.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Identify that the electrometer connects to the exterior surface of the Faraday pail.

  2. Apply charge conservation: Qouter=+QxQ_{\text{outer}} = +Q_x.

  3. Calculate Qx=C⋅V=(150×10−12 F)⋅(+4.20 V)=+6.30×10−10 CQ_x = C \cdot V = (150 \times 10^{-12}\text{ F}) \cdot (+4.20\text{ V}) = +6.30 \times 10^{-10}\text{ C}.

  4. State that the electrometer continues to measure the exterior potential: +4.20 V+4.20\text{ V} during contact and +4.20 V+4.20\text{ V} after withdrawal.

Final answer

(a) Qx=+6.30×10−10 CQ_x = +6.30 \times 10^{-10}\text{ C}; (b) +4.20 V+4.20\text{ V} during contact and +4.20 V+4.20\text{ V} after withdrawal; (c) 0 C0\text{ C}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch the induced charges on both the inner and outer walls of a hollow conductor before writing down charge equations.

  • Practice tracking how charges redistribute when a charged body touches the inside versus the outside of a conductor.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student incorrectly treats contact with the interior bucket as sharing charge between two isolated conductors in parallel rather than realizing all charge resides on the outer surface of a hollow conductor.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Qx=C⋅V  ⟹  Qx=(150×10−12 F)⋅(4.20 V)=+6.30×10−10 CQ_x = C \cdot V \implies Q_x = (150 \times 10^{-12}\text{ F}) \cdot (4.20\text{ V}) = +6.30 \times 10^{-10}\text{ C}

  2. Step 2

    During contact: V=+4.20 V  ⟹  After withdrawal: V=+2.10 V\text{During contact: } V = +4.20\text{ V} \implies \text{After withdrawal: } V = +2.10\text{ V}

    Correct

    During contact: V=+4.20 V;After withdrawal: V=+4.20 V\text{During contact: } V = +4.20\text{ V};\quad \text{After withdrawal: } V = +4.20\text{ V}

    You correctly identified that the potential remains +4.20 V+4.20\text{ V} during contact. However, after withdrawal, the reading does not drop to +2.10 V+2.10\text{ V}; it remains +4.20 V+4.20\text{ V} because no charge leaves the bucket with the proof plane.

  3. Step 3

    Charge is shared equally between the proof plane and the pail  ⟹  Qfinal=Qx2=+3.15×10−10 C\text{Charge is shared equally between the proof plane and the pail} \implies Q_{\text{final}} = \frac{Q_x}{2} = +3.15 \times 10^{-10}\text{ C}

    Correct

    Qfinal=0.00 CQ_{\text{final}} = 0.00\text{ C}

    When a charged conductor touches the interior wall of a hollow conductor, it becomes part of the interior cavity. In electrostatic equilibrium, all excess charge resides strictly on the outer surface of the outer conductor, leaving 0 C0\text{ C} on the proof plane.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the electrostatic capacitance equation Q=C⋅VQ = C \cdot V to calculate the magnitude and sign of the initial charge.

You correctly recognized that the electrometer voltage remains +4.20 V+4.20\text{ V} while the proof plane is in contact with the inner wall.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Cavity Charge Transfer Misconception

You assumed contact inside a Faraday ice pail behaves like two identical isolated conductors sharing charge equally.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You overlooked Gauss's law for conductors in electrostatic equilibrium, which requires that any net excess charge on a hollow conductor reside entirely on its outermost surface, transferring 100%100\% of the internal charge to the pail's exterior.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Gauss's Law inside a Conductor
  • Inside conducting material in electrostatic equilibrium, E⃗=0\vec{E} = 0, so Gaussian surfaces enclosing the interior cavity prove that zero net charge can reside on interior surfaces after contact.

  • Whenever an object touches the inside of a hollow conducting container, transfer 100%100\% of its excess charge to the exterior surface.

Electrometer Independence after Contact Transfer
  • Because all excess charge resides on the exterior surface of the pail, removing an uncharged object from the interior cavity does not alter the exterior charge or the measured voltage.

  • Keep the electrometer reading constant before contact, during contact, and after withdrawing the neutralized probe.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Recognize that upon touching the inner wall, the proof plane and the pail form a single continuous conductor.

  2. By electrostatic equilibrium and Gauss's law, all excess charge +Qx+Q_x moves to the exterior surface of the outer bucket.

  3. The inner surface and the proof plane neutralize completely to 0 C0\text{ C}.

  4. Withdrawing the completely discharged proof plane leaves all +Qx+Q_x on the exterior bucket.

  5. Because the exterior charge remains Q=+6.30×10−10 CQ = +6.30 \times 10^{-10}\text{ C}, the voltage stays V=QC=+4.20 VV = \frac{Q}{C} = +4.20\text{ V}.

Final answer

(a) Qx=+6.30×10−10 CQ_x = +6.30 \times 10^{-10}\text{ C}; (b) V=+4.20 VV = +4.20\text{ V} during contact and after withdrawal; (c) Qfinal=0.00 CQ_{\text{final}} = 0.00\text{ C}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Faraday's ice pail experiment and why interior contact results in complete charge transfer rather than parallel charge sharing.

  • Practice applying Gauss's law to hollow conducting shells containing cavities and charges.

  • Work through scenarios comparing contact made on the inside surface versus contact made on the outside surface of a hollow conductor.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misinterprets withdrawing the proof plane as removing the inducing charge from the bucket, concluding the electrometer reading drops to zero after removal.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Qx=C⋅V  ⟹  Qx=(150×10−12 F)⋅(4.20 V)=+6.30×10−10 CQ_x = C \cdot V \implies Q_x = (150 \times 10^{-12}\text{ F}) \cdot (4.20\text{ V}) = +6.30 \times 10^{-10}\text{ C}

  2. Step 2

    During contact: V=+4.20 V\text{During contact: } V = +4.20\text{ V}

  3. Step 3

    After withdrawal: V=0 V\text{After withdrawal: } V = 0\text{ V}

    Correct

    After withdrawal: V=+4.20 V\text{After withdrawal: } V = +4.20\text{ V}

    Because the proof plane touched the interior surface, its excess charge transferred completely to the pail system. Withdrawing the now-neutral proof plane does not remove charge from the bucket, so the reading remains +4.20 V+4.20\text{ V}.

  4. Step 4

    Net charge remaining on proof plane=0 C\text{Net charge remaining on proof plane} = 0\text{ C}

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly related the induced outer charge to the electrometer capacitance and voltage.

You correctly identified that the voltage reading stays constant while contact is maintained.

You correctly determined that the proof plane retains zero charge upon removal.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Induction vs. contact transfer confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated electrostatics without contact (where withdrawing the inducing object restores the initial neutral state of 0 V0\text{ V}) with contact transfer inside a Faraday ice pail (where touching the interior transfers all charge permanently to the outer bucket surface).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Gauss's Law and Hollow Conductors
  • In electrostatic equilibrium, all net charge resides on the exterior surface of a closed conducting cavity, leaving zero charge on inner surfaces.

  • When an object touches the inside of a hollow conductor, it becomes part of the interior and loses all its charge to the outer surface.

Induction vs. Transfer
  • If no contact occurs, withdrawing the charged object removes the inducing field and returns the exterior potential to zero. If contact occurs, the charge transfer is permanent.

  • Check whether contact occurred before withdrawal; if contact happened, the charge remains on the container and the electrometer continues to read the transferred charge.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Upon contact, the proof plane and bucket form one continuous conductor, pushing all excess charge +Qx+Q_x permanently to the outer surface.

  2. The inner surface and proof plane neutralize each other to 0 C0\text{ C}.

  3. Withdrawing the uncharged proof plane carries away no charge.

  4. The pail retains +Qx+Q_x, so the electrometer reading remains V=+4.20 VV = +4.20\text{ V}.

Final answer

After withdrawal, V=+4.20 VV = +4.20\text{ V}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Contrast the three classic stages of the Faraday ice pail experiment: insertion without contact, contact with the inner wall, and withdrawal after contact.

  • Verify internal consistency in multi-part electrostatics problems: if the proof plane left behind all its charge (0 C0\text{ C}), that charge must remain on the bucket system.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A charged sphere carrying Q=−0.40 nCQ = -0.40\text{ nC} is lowered into a neutral Faraday ice pail connected to an electrometer with effective capacitance C=80 pFC = 80\text{ pF}. What voltage does the electrometer read before contact?

Answer

V=−5.0 VV = -5.0\text{ V}. An enclosed charge of −0.40 nC-0.40\text{ nC} induces +0.40 nC+0.40\text{ nC} on the inner surface and pushes −0.40 nC-0.40\text{ nC} to the outer surface: V=QouterC=−0.40×10−9 F80×10−12 F=−5.0 VV = \frac{Q_{\text{outer}}}{C} = \frac{-0.40 \times 10^{-9}\text{ F}}{80 \times 10^{-12}\text{ F}} = -5.0\text{ V}.

02

A Faraday ice pail setup with capacitance C=200 pFC = 200\text{ pF} reads +3.0 V+3.0\text{ V} when a charged rod is lowered inside. The rod touches the inner wall, is removed, and is then touched to the outside of an identical, uncharged second pail (C=200 pFC = 200\text{ pF}). What does the electrometer on the second pail read?

Answer

0 V0\text{ V}. Touching the inside of the first pail completely neutralizes the rod (Qrod=0 CQ_{\text{rod}} = 0\text{ C}), so transferring it to the second pail transfers no charge.

03

An uncharged Faraday pail (C=120 pFC = 120\text{ pF}) has a positively charged bead +Q+Q inserted, reading +2.5 V+2.5\text{ V}. While the bead remains suspended inside without touching, the outside of the pail is momentarily grounded and then ungrounded. What does the electrometer read (a) while the bead is still inside after ungrounding, and (b) after the bead is completely withdrawn without touching?

Answer

(a) 0 V0\text{ V}; (b) −2.5 V-2.5\text{ V}. Grounding removes the outer +Q+Q leaving 0 V0\text{ V}. The inner surface retains −Q-Q. When the bead is removed, the remaining −Q-Q redistributes to the outer surface, yielding V=−2.5 VV = -2.5\text{ V}.

Loading workspace…