Resources

A stationary laser directs a horizontal beam at a flat vertical mirror, reflecting it back along its original path. The mirror is then rotated about a vertical axis through its center by an angle of ϕ=14.5∘\phi = 14.5^\circ. A student incorrectly assumes that the reflected beam also turns by 14.5∘14.5^\circ. Calculate: (a) the true angular rotation Δθray\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} of the reflected beam, and (b) the resulting lateral shift ss of the reflected laser spot on a target screen placed perpendicular to the original beam at a distance of D=4.20 mD = 4.20\text{ m} from the mirror rotation axis.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Δθray=29.0∘\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = 29.0^\circ; (b) s=2.33 ms = 2.33\text{ m}

Steps

Part (a): Angular Rotation of the Reflected Beam

  1. Initial Alignment and Law of Reflection: Initially, the incident ray is perpendicular to the mirror surface. The angle of incidence relative to the normal is: θi=0∘\theta_i = 0^\circ By the law of reflection (θr=θi\theta_r = \theta_i), the reflected beam reflects directly back along its original path at θr=0∘\theta_r = 0^\circ.
  2. Effect of Rotating the Mirror: When the mirror is rotated by an angle ϕ=14.5∘\phi = 14.5^\circ, the normal vector perpendicular to the mirror's surface also rotates by the same angle ϕ=14.5∘\phi = 14.5^\circ. Since the incoming laser beam remains stationary, the new angle of incidence relative to the new normal is: θi′=ϕ=14.5∘\theta_i' = \phi = 14.5^\circ
  3. Determining the Deflection Angle: According to the law of reflection, the new angle of reflection is equal to the new angle of incidence: θr′=θi′=ϕ=14.5∘\theta_r' = \theta_i' = \phi = 14.5^\circ The total angle between the incident ray and the reflected ray is the sum of the angles on either side of the normal: Δθray=θi′+θr′=2ϕ\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = \theta_i' + \theta_r' = 2\phi Substituting ϕ=14.5∘\phi = 14.5^\circ: Δθray=2(14.5∘)=29.0∘\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = 2(14.5^\circ) = 29.0^\circ

Common Pitfall: A frequent mistake is assuming that rotating the mirror by ϕ\phi shifts the reflected beam by ϕ\phi. Because both the angle of incidence and the angle of reflection increase by ϕ\phi relative to the mirror normal, the reflected beam turns through twice the mirror's angle of rotation (2ϕ2\phi).


Part (b): Lateral Shift of the Reflected Spot on the Screen

  1. Geometric Relationship: The target screen is perpendicular to the original beam line at a distance D=4.20 mD = 4.20\text{ m} from the mirror's axis of rotation. The reflected ray deviates from this original beam axis by the angle Δθray=29.0∘\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = 29.0^\circ.
  2. Calculating the Displacement ss: Applying the right-triangle trigonometric relationship: tan⁡(Δθray)=sD\tan(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}) = \frac{s}{D} Rearranging to solve for the lateral displacement ss: s=Dtan⁡(Δθray)s = D \tan(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}) Substitute D=4.20 mD = 4.20\text{ m} and Δθray=29.0∘\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = 29.0^\circ: s=4.20 m⋅tan⁡(29.0∘)≈4.20 m⋅0.5543=2.328 m≈2.33 ms = 4.20\text{ m} \cdot \tan(29.0^\circ) \approx 4.20\text{ m} \cdot 0.5543 = 2.328\text{ m} \approx 2.33\text{ m}

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student assumes the reflected beam rotates by the same angle as the mirror (Δθ_ray = φ = 14.5°), leading to an underestimated lateral shift.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Δθray=ϕ=14.5∘\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = \phi = 14.5^\circ

    Correct

    Δθray=2ϕ=2(14.5∘)=29.0∘\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = 2\phi = 2(14.5^\circ) = 29.0^\circ

    When a flat mirror rotates by an angle ϕ\phi, its surface normal also rotates by ϕ\phi. Because the law of reflection requires θr=θi=ϕ\theta_r = \theta_i = \phi relative to the new normal, the total angular deflection of the reflected ray is Δθray=θi+θr=2ϕ\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = \theta_i + \theta_r = 2\phi.

  2. Step 2

    s=D⋅tan⁡(Δθray)  ⟹  s=4.20⋅tan⁡(14.5∘)  ⟹  s=4.20⋅0.2586=1.09 ms = D \cdot \tan(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}) \implies s = 4.20 \cdot \tan(14.5^\circ) \implies s = 4.20 \cdot 0.2586 = 1.09\text{ m}

    Correct

    s=D⋅tan⁡(29.0∘)=4.20⋅0.5543≈2.33 ms = D \cdot \tan(29.0^\circ) = 4.20 \cdot 0.5543 \approx 2.33\text{ m}

    Your trigonometric setup s=Dtan⁡(Δθray)s = D\tan(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}) is correct, but substituting the un-doubled angle 14.5∘14.5^\circ propagated the error to your final distance.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the lateral shift on the screen follows the right-triangle relation s=Dtan⁡(Δθray)s = D \tan(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}).

You performed the trigonometric evaluation and decimal arithmetic accurately for the angle you chose.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Optical lever angular doubling omitted

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating mirror tilt with reflected ray deflection by overlooking that rotating the mirror turns the normal line, which simultaneously alters both the angle of incidence and the angle of reflection by ϕ\phi.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Rotating Mirror Ray Deflection
  • A mirror rotated by angle ϕ\phi rotates the reflected ray by 2ϕ2\phi when the incident beam remains fixed.

  • Always draw the rotated normal first: θi′=ϕ\theta_i' = \phi and θr′=ϕ\theta_r' = \phi, giving total beam deflection Δθ=θi′+θr′=2ϕ\Delta\theta = \theta_i' + \theta_r' = 2\phi.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Δθray=2ϕ=2(14.5∘)=29.0∘\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = 2\phi = 2(14.5^\circ) = 29.0^\circ

  2. s=Dtan⁡(Δθray)=4.20 m⋅tan⁡(29.0∘)s = D \tan(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}) = 4.20\text{ m} \cdot \tan(29.0^\circ)

  3. s=4.20 m⋅0.5543=2.328 m≈2.33 ms = 4.20\text{ m} \cdot 0.5543 = 2.328\text{ m} \approx 2.33\text{ m}

Final answer

(a) Δθray=29.0∘\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = 29.0^\circ; (b) s=2.33 ms = 2.33\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch a ray diagram with the normal explicitly shown before and after a mirror tilt to verify why the angle doubles.

  • Recalculate the lateral displacement using Δθray=29.0∘\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = 29.0^\circ to confirm s=2.33 ms = 2.33\text{ m}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student uses the sine function instead of the tangent function to calculate the lateral deflection on the flat screen, confusing the perpendicular opposite side with the hypotenuse.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Δθray=2ϕ=2⋅14.5∘=29.0∘\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = 2\phi = 2 \cdot 14.5^\circ = 29.0^\circ

  2. Step 2

    s=D⋅sin⁡(Δθray)  ⟹  s=4.20⋅sin⁡(29.0∘)s = D \cdot \sin(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}) \implies s = 4.20 \cdot \sin(29.0^\circ)

    Correct

    s=Dtan⁡(Δθray)=4.20tan⁡(29.0∘)s = D \tan(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}) = 4.20 \tan(29.0^\circ)

    In the right triangle formed by the original beam path (adjacent side DD) and the flat screen (opposite side ss), the ratio of ss to DD is given by the tangent function: tan⁡(Δθray)=sD\tan(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}) = \frac{s}{D}. Using the sine function mistakenly treats the perpendicular distance to the screen DD as the hypotenuse.

  3. Step 3

    s=4.20⋅0.4848=2.04 ms = 4.20 \cdot 0.4848 = 2.04\text{ m}

    Correct

    s=4.20⋅tan⁡(29.0∘)≈2.33 ms = 4.20 \cdot \tan(29.0^\circ) \approx 2.33\text{ m}

    Your arithmetic follows correctly from using the sine function, but the numerical value is incorrect due to the trigonometric error in the preceding step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that the reflected ray turns through twice the mirror rotation angle: Δθray=2ϕ\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = 2\phi.

You accurately substituted the given distance D=4.20 mD = 4.20\text{ m} and evaluated your chosen trigonometric expression.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Trigonometric Ratio Misidentification

You chose sin⁡(Δθray)\sin(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}) instead of tan⁡(Δθray)\tan(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}) when relating the lateral spot shift on a flat screen to the adjacent distance.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the adjacent leg of the right triangle (the fixed perpendicular distance DD to the screen) with the hypotenuse (the actual path length of the deflected beam to the screen), leading to the incorrect formula s=Dsin⁡θs = D\sin\theta rather than s=Dtan⁡θs = D\tan\theta.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify Adjacent vs. Hypotenuse on a Flat Screen
  • When a beam strikes a flat screen perpendicular to the baseline at distance DD, the baseline is the adjacent side of the right triangle, making tan⁡θ=sD\tan\theta = \frac{s}{D}.

  • Always sketch the right triangle and verify whether the known distance is along the original axis (adjacent leg) or along the slanted ray (hypotenuse).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use the right-triangle relation tan⁡(Δθray)=sD\tan(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}) = \frac{s}{D}.

  2. Solve for the lateral displacement: s=Dtan⁡(Δθray)=4.20 m⋅tan⁡(29.0∘)s = D \tan(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}) = 4.20\text{ m} \cdot \tan(29.0^\circ).

  3. Evaluate: s=4.20⋅0.5543≈2.33 ms = 4.20 \cdot 0.5543 \approx 2.33\text{ m}.

Final answer

(a) Δθray=29.0∘\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = 29.0^\circ; (b) s=2.33 ms = 2.33\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review right-triangle trigonometry definitions, paying specific attention to flat-screen projection geometry where distance is adjacent, not hypotenuse.

  • Practice solving beam deflection problems with both flat screens (s=Dtan⁡θs = D\tan\theta) and curved cylindrical screens (s=Dθs = D\theta).

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses the small-angle approximation s = D · Δθ_ray in radians, but enters the angle in degrees directly without converting to radians.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Δθray=2ϕ=2⋅14.5∘=29.0∘\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = 2\phi = 2 \cdot 14.5^\circ = 29.0^\circ

  2. Step 2

    s=D⋅Δθray  ⟹  s=4.20⋅29.0=121.8 ms = D \cdot \Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} \implies s = 4.20 \cdot 29.0 = 121.8\text{ m}

    Correct

    s=Dtan⁡(Δθray)=4.20 m⋅tan⁡(29.0∘)≈2.33 ms = D \tan(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}) = 4.20\text{ m} \cdot \tan(29.0^\circ) \approx 2.33\text{ m}

    You multiplied the distance directly by the angle in degrees. For a flat screen perpendicular to the original beam, the right-triangle geometry requires s=Dtan⁡(Δθray)s = D \tan(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}). Furthermore, any direct product formula relating radius and angle (s=Dθs = D\theta) requires θ\theta to be expressed in radians, not degrees.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recognized that rotating the mirror by ϕ\phi doubles the deflection angle of the reflected ray.

You accurately calculated the reflected beam's deflection angle as Δθray=29.0∘\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = 29.0^\circ.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Angle Unit and Trigonometry Mismatch

Multiplying a linear distance directly by an angle in degrees produced an unphysically large displacement of 121.8 m121.8\text{ m}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You substituted an angle in degrees into an arc-length-style formula without converting to radians, and you bypassed the tangent function needed for a flat screen.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Flat Screen vs. Circular Arc
  • On a flat screen at normal distance DD, the lateral shift is s=Dtan⁡θs = D \tan\theta, whereas on a circular cylindrical screen it is the arc length s=Dθs = D\theta (with θ\theta in radians).

  • Draw the right triangle formed by the original beam axis, the screen, and the deflected beam to identify tan⁡θ=sD\tan\theta = \frac{s}{D}.

Angle Units in Formulas
  • Whenever an angle appears outside a trigonometric function (such as in s=Rθs = R\theta or ω=θt\omega = \frac{\theta}{t}), it must be expressed in radians (1∘=π180∘ rad1^\circ = \frac{\pi}{180^\circ}\text{ rad}).

  • Always convert degree measures to radians before performing direct algebraic multiplication.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the right triangle for the flat screen: tan⁡(Δθray)=sD\tan(\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}}) = \frac{s}{D}.

  2. Rearrange for lateral shift: s=Dtan⁡(29.0∘)s = D \tan(29.0^\circ).

  3. Evaluate using tan⁡(29.0∘)≈0.5543\tan(29.0^\circ) \approx 0.5543: s=4.20 m×0.5543≈2.33 ms = 4.20\text{ m} \times 0.5543 \approx 2.33\text{ m}.

Final answer

(a) Δθray=29.0∘\Delta\theta_{\text{ray}} = 29.0^\circ; (b) s=2.33 ms = 2.33\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch the right triangle between the mirror, the screen, and the deflected ray whenever finding linear spot shifts.

  • Check that angles used outside trigonometric functions are converted to radians, and verify whether the small-angle approximation tan⁡θ≈θ\tan\theta \approx \theta is valid.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A stationary horizontal laser beam strikes a flat vertical mirror perpendicularly. The mirror is rotated by 8.0∘8.0^\circ about a vertical axis. Find the angular deflection of the reflected ray and its spot displacement on a wall 3.00 m3.00\text{ m} away.

Answer

Δθ=2(8.0∘)=16.0∘\Delta\theta = 2(8.0^\circ) = 16.0^\circ; s=Dtan⁡(Δθ)=3.00 m⋅tan⁡(16.0∘)≈0.860 ms = D\tan(\Delta\theta) = 3.00\text{ m} \cdot \tan(16.0^\circ) \approx 0.860\text{ m}.

02

In an optical lever setup, a light beam reflects off a mirror onto a scale at distance D=2.50 mD = 2.50\text{ m}. If the light spot moves by a distance of s=0.350 ms = 0.350\text{ m}, through what angle ϕ\phi did the mirror rotate? (Assume small angles where tan⁡θ≈θ\tan\theta \approx \theta).

Answer

Beam rotation: Δθ=arctan⁡(s/D)=arctan⁡(0.350/2.50)≈7.97∘\Delta\theta = \arctan(s/D) = \arctan(0.350/2.50) \approx 7.97^\circ. Mirror tilt: ϕ=12Δθ≈3.98∘\phi = \frac{1}{2}\Delta\theta \approx 3.98^\circ (or 0.070 rad0.070\text{ rad} using the small-angle approximation ϕ≈s2D\phi \approx \frac{s}{2D}).

03

A beam of light is incident at an angle of 25.0∘25.0^\circ to the normal of a flat mirror. The mirror is then tilted by 6.0∘6.0^\circ in the direction that decreases the angle of incidence. What is the total angle through which the reflected beam rotates?

Answer

The reflected beam rotates by Δθ=2(6.0∘)=12.0∘\Delta\theta = 2(6.0^\circ) = 12.0^\circ. The new angle of incidence is 19.0∘19.0^\circ, so the angle between the fixed incident ray and the new reflected ray changes from 50.0∘50.0^\circ to 38.0∘38.0^\circ, a change of exactly 12.0∘12.0^\circ (2ϕ2\phi).

Loading workspace…