Resources

A mechanical hand-truck mechanism functions as a second-class lever where the wheel axle serves as the fulcrum. A heavy crate exerting a vertical load of Fload=850 NF_{\text{load}} = 850\text{ N} rests at a fixed distance of dL=0.350 md_L = 0.350\text{ m} from the fulcrum axle. An operator applies an upward lifting effort force of Feffort=210 NF_{\text{effort}} = 210\text{ N} at the handle grips. At what total distance dEd_E from the wheel axle along the lever must the handle grips be located to achieve rotational equilibrium?

Answer and steps

Final answer

dE=1.42 md_E = 1.42\text{ m}

Steps

01

Calculate the Torque Produced by the Load

Principle of Rotational Equilibrium

For an object to be in rotational equilibrium, the sum of all torques acting about any pivot point (fulcrum) must equal zero: ∑τ=0\sum \tau = 0 Taking the wheel axle as the pivot point:

  • The downward load force FloadF_{\text{load}} creates a clockwise torque that tends to rotate the hand-truck toward the ground.
  • The upward effort force FeffortF_{\text{effort}} applied at the handles creates a counterclockwise torque that counteracts the load. τeffort=τload\tau_{\text{effort}} = \tau_{\text{load}}

Torque is the product of the perpendicular force and its lever arm distance from the fulcrum:

τload=Fload⋅dL\tau_{\text{load}} = F_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L

Substitute the given values:

τload=850 N⋅0.350 m=297.5 N⋅m\tau_{\text{load}} = 850\text{ N} \cdot 0.350\text{ m} = 297.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}


02

Set Up the Equilibrium Condition for the Effort

The counterclockwise torque exerted by the operator's effort must balance the clockwise torque of the load:

Feffort⋅dE=τloadF_{\text{effort}} \cdot d_E = \tau_{\text{load}}

Substitute Feffort=210 NF_{\text{effort}} = 210\text{ N}:

210 N⋅dE=297.5 N⋅m210\text{ N} \cdot d_E = 297.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}


03

Solve for the Effort Arm Distance dEd_E

Rearrange the equation to isolate dEd_E:

dE=297.5 N⋅m210 N≈1.4167 md_E = \frac{297.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}}{210\text{ N}} \approx 1.4167\text{ m}

Rounding to three significant figures gives:

dE=1.42 md_E = 1.42\text{ m}

Common Pitfall: In a second-class lever, both the load and the effort are on the same side of the fulcrum, so the distance to the effort dEd_E is measured all the way from the fulcrum (the wheel axle), not from the crate's position. Adding the two distances instead of measuring each from the fulcrum is a frequent mistake.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the torque equilibrium ratio, dividing the effort force by the load torque instead of dividing load torque by effort force.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Fload⋅dL=850⋅0.350=297.5 N⋅mF_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L = 850 \cdot 0.350 = 297.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}

  2. Step 2

    dE=FeffortFload⋅dLd_E = \frac{F_{\text{effort}}}{F_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L}

    Correct

    dE=Fload⋅dLFeffortd_E = \frac{F_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L}{F_{\text{effort}}}

    In static equilibrium, Feffort⋅dE=Fload⋅dLF_{\text{effort}} \cdot d_E = F_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L. When isolating dEd_E, you divide both sides by FeffortF_{\text{effort}}, which gives Fload⋅dLFeffort\frac{F_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L}{F_{\text{effort}}}, not FeffortFload⋅dL\frac{F_{\text{effort}}}{F_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L}.

  3. Step 3

    dE=210297.5  ⟹  dE≈0.706 md_E = \frac{210}{297.5} \implies d_E \approx 0.706\text{ m}

    Correct

    dE=297.5210≈1.42 md_E = \frac{297.5}{210} \approx 1.42\text{ m}

    This calculation followed directly from your inverted formula. Evaluating the correct ratio yields dE≈1.42 md_E \approx 1.42\text{ m}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the system must satisfy rotational equilibrium about the wheel axle fulcrum.

You accurately calculated the load torque as 297.5 N⋅m297.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic rearrangement error / Inverted torque balance ratio

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You inverted the torque equilibrium equation when isolating the unknown lever arm distance, resulting in dividing force by torque ([N]/[N⋅m]=m−1[\text{N}]/[\text{N}\cdot\text{m}] = \text{m}^{-1}) rather than torque by force ([N⋅m]/[N]=m[\text{N}\cdot\text{m}]/[\text{N}] = \text{m}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Torque Balance Equation
  • For static balance, τeffort=τload  ⟹  Feffort⋅dE=Fload⋅dL\tau_{\text{effort}} = \tau_{\text{load}} \implies F_{\text{effort}} \cdot d_E = F_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L.

  • Write out the full balanced product Feffort⋅dE=Fload⋅dLF_{\text{effort}} \cdot d_E = F_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L explicitly before isolating the unknown variable.

Dimensional Check
  • Dividing force by torque yields units of m−1\text{m}^{-1}, whereas distance requires units of meters\text{meters}.

  • Always verify that your isolated expression has the correct physical units before substituting numbers.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Divide both sides by FeffortF_{\text{effort}}: dE=297.5 N⋅m210 Nd_E = \frac{297.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}}{210\text{ N}}

  2. Compute the numerical quotient: dE≈1.4167 md_E \approx 1.4167\text{ m}

  3. Round to three significant figures to match the given data.

Final answer

dE=1.42 md_E = 1.42\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the direct equality F1d1=F2d2F_1 d_1 = F_2 d_2 before moving variables across the equals sign.

  • Perform a quick dimensional analysis check on your isolated formula to ensure units match what you are solving for.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misremembers the lever principle as an inverse relationship between distance and force product, calculating d_E = (F_effort · d_L) / F_load.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Feffort⋅dL=Fload⋅dE  ⟹  210⋅0.350=850⋅dEF_{\text{effort}} \cdot d_L = F_{\text{load}} \cdot d_E \implies 210 \cdot 0.350 = 850 \cdot d_E

    Correct

    Feffort⋅dE=Fload⋅dL  ⟹  210⋅dE=850⋅0.350F_{\text{effort}} \cdot d_E = F_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L \implies 210 \cdot d_E = 850 \cdot 0.350

    Torque is each individual force multiplied by its own perpendicular lever arm from the fulcrum. The effort torque is Feffort⋅dEF_{\text{effort}} \cdot d_E and the load torque is Fload⋅dLF_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L, but you paired FeffortF_{\text{effort}} with dLd_L and FloadF_{\text{load}} with dEd_E.

  2. Step 2

    73.5=850⋅dE  ⟹  dE=73.585073.5 = 850 \cdot d_E \implies d_E = \frac{73.5}{850}

    Correct

    210⋅dE=297.5  ⟹  dE=297.5210210 \cdot d_E = 297.5 \implies d_E = \frac{297.5}{210}

    You accurately solved for the variable from your initial setup, but the numerical values were carried over from the mismatched torque equation.

  3. Step 3

    dE≈0.0865 md_E \approx 0.0865\text{ m}

    Correct

    dE≈1.42 md_E \approx 1.42\text{ m}

    Because of the swapped lever arms, your resulting distance was smaller than the load distance, whereas lifting a heavy load with a smaller effort force requires a longer effort arm.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You recognized that rotational equilibrium requires balancing two opposing torques.

You carried out the algebraic rearrangement and division accurately according to your written formula.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Mismatched Force-Arm Pairing

You accidentally cross-paired the forces and distances, writing F1d2=F2d1F_1 d_2 = F_2 d_1 instead of matching each force to its own lever arm F1d1=F2d2F_1 d_1 = F_2 d_2.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the lever formula FloadFeffort=dEdL\frac{F_{\text{load}}}{F_{\text{effort}}} = \frac{d_E}{d_L} with direct multiplication, leading to an inverted equation where effort force is multiplied by load arm.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match Torque by Force and Arm
  • Each torque contribution is τi=Fi⋅di\tau_i = F_i \cdot d_i, where did_i is the distance from the pivot directly to the line of action of FiF_i.

  • Label each force and its corresponding lever arm together before equating torques: τeffort=FeffortdE\tau_{\text{effort}} = F_{\text{effort}} d_E and τload=FloaddL\tau_{\text{load}} = F_{\text{load}} d_L.

Reasonableness Check via Mechanical Advantage
  • When the effort force is smaller than the load force (Feffort<FloadF_{\text{effort}} < F_{\text{load}}), the effort arm must be strictly longer than the load arm (dE>dLd_E > d_L).

  • Compare your calculated effort distance (0.0865 m0.0865\text{ m}) against the load distance (0.350 m0.350\text{ m}). A smaller distance with a smaller force would not balance a heavier load.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the torque balance equation about the fulcrum: Feffort⋅dE=Fload⋅dLF_{\text{effort}} \cdot d_E = F_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L

  2. Substitute the given quantities: 210 N⋅dE=850 N⋅0.350 m210\text{ N} \cdot d_E = 850\text{ N} \cdot 0.350\text{ m}

  3. Compute the load torque: 210 N⋅dE=297.5 N⋅m210\text{ N} \cdot d_E = 297.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}

  4. Divide by the effort force to isolate dEd_E: dE=297.5210≈1.4167 md_E = \frac{297.5}{210} \approx 1.4167\text{ m}

Final answer

dE=1.42 md_E = 1.42\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice pairing each force with its specific lever arm by writing τ1=τ2\tau_1 = \tau_2 as F1d1=F2d2F_1 d_1 = F_2 d_2.

  • Use a quick physical reality check: if you exert less force than the load, your lever arm must be longer than the load arm.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student treats the distance between the load and the effort as d_E instead of measuring from the fulcrum, subtracting d_L from the total effort arm or setting F_effort · (d_E - d_L) = F_load · d_L as if the load were the fulcrum.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Feffort⋅(dE−dL)=Fload⋅dL  ⟹  210⋅(dE−0.350)=850⋅0.350F_{\text{effort}} \cdot (d_E - d_L) = F_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L \implies 210 \cdot (d_E - 0.350) = 850 \cdot 0.350

    Correct

    Feffort⋅dE=Fload⋅dL  ⟹  210⋅dE=850⋅0.350F_{\text{effort}} \cdot d_E = F_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L \implies 210 \cdot d_E = 850 \cdot 0.350

    In rotational equilibrium, every lever arm must be measured directly from the chosen pivot point (the wheel axle fulcrum). Because dEd_E is already defined as the total distance from the wheel axle to the handle grips, the effort's lever arm is simply dEd_E, not (dE−dL)(d_E - d_L).

  2. Step 2

    210⋅(dE−0.350)=297.5  ⟹  dE−0.350=1.417  ⟹  dE=1.417+0.350  ⟹  dE≈1.77 m210 \cdot (d_E - 0.350) = 297.5 \implies d_E - 0.350 = 1.417 \implies d_E = 1.417 + 0.350 \implies d_E \approx 1.77\text{ m}

    Correct

    210⋅dE=297.5  ⟹  dE=297.5210≈1.42 m210 \cdot d_E = 297.5 \implies d_E = \frac{297.5}{210} \approx 1.42\text{ m}

    Your algebra and arithmetic were executed correctly based on your equation, but the final value was shifted by adding dLd_L due to the initial lever-arm error in Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that rotational equilibrium requires balancing the clockwise and counterclockwise torques.

You calculated the load torque accurately as 850 N⋅0.350 m=297.5 N⋅m850\text{ N} \cdot 0.350\text{ m} = 297.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}.

You carried out all algebraic steps and arithmetic operations accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect lever arm reference point in a second-class lever

You subtracted the load distance dLd_L from the effort distance dEd_E, treating the distance between the two forces as the lever arm instead of measuring all lever arms from the fulcrum.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Misunderstanding how lever arms are defined for second-class levers. In a second-class lever, both the load and the effort lie on the same side of the fulcrum. Every torque arm must extend from the common pivot point (the fulcrum) to the line of action of each force, so each force's distance is measured independently from the axle.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Establish the Pivot Point First
  • Every lever arm in τ=F⋅d\tau = F \cdot d must be measured from the chosen pivot point (the fulcrum).

  • Locate the fulcrum (wheel axle) and draw position vectors pointing from that fulcrum to each applied force.

Recognize Second-Class Lever Geometry
  • In a second-class lever, both forces share the same pivot, so dE>dLd_E > d_L and both distances are measured from the fulcrum.

  • Do not use the distance between forces (dE−dL)(d_E - d_L) as a torque arm about the axle; use dEd_E directly as the full effort arm.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the torque balance directly about the wheel axle fulcrum: Feffort⋅dE=Fload⋅dLF_{\text{effort}} \cdot d_E = F_{\text{load}} \cdot d_L

  2. Substitute the given values: 210 N⋅dE=850 N⋅0.350 m=297.5 N⋅m210\text{ N} \cdot d_E = 850\text{ N} \cdot 0.350\text{ m} = 297.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}

  3. Isolate dEd_E: dE=297.5 N⋅m210 N≈1.4167 md_E = \frac{297.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}}{210\text{ N}} \approx 1.4167\text{ m}

Final answer

dE=1.42 md_E = 1.42\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch a simple free-body diagram showing the fulcrum at one end and mark arrows for both forces.

  • Draw dimension lines for both dLd_L and dEd_E starting from the fulcrum to make sure both lever arms share the same reference origin.

  • Practice identifying lever classes and writing torque equilibrium equations without subtracting intermediate segments.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A wheelbarrow carries a load that exerts a downward force of 600 N600\text{ N} at a distance of 0.40 m0.40\text{ m} from the wheel axle fulcrum. What upward effort force must an operator apply at handles located 1.20 m1.20\text{ m} from the axle to keep it balanced?

Answer

Feffort=200 NF_{\text{effort}} = 200\text{ N}. Torque balance gives Feffort⋅(1.20 m)=600 N⋅0.40 m=240 N⋅mF_{\text{effort}} \cdot (1.20\text{ m}) = 600\text{ N} \cdot 0.40\text{ m} = 240\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}. Thus, Feffort=240 N⋅m1.20 m=200 NF_{\text{effort}} = \frac{240\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}}{1.20\text{ m}} = 200\text{ N}.

02

A nutcracker is a second-class lever. A walnut placed 4.0 cm4.0\text{ cm} from the pivot requires a compressive force of 180 N180\text{ N} to crack. If a person squeezes the handles at a distance of 16.0 cm16.0\text{ cm} from the pivot, what minimum squeeze force must be applied?

Answer

Feffort=45 NF_{\text{effort}} = 45\text{ N}. Set τeffort=τload  ⟹  Feffort⋅16.0 cm=180 N⋅4.0 cm=720 N⋅cm\tau_{\text{effort}} = \tau_{\text{load}} \implies F_{\text{effort}} \cdot 16.0\text{ cm} = 180\text{ N} \cdot 4.0\text{ cm} = 720\text{ N}\cdot\text{cm}. Solving yields Feffort=720 N⋅cm16.0 cm=45 NF_{\text{effort}} = \frac{720\text{ N}\cdot\text{cm}}{16.0\text{ cm}} = 45\text{ N}.

03

A heavy crate of mass 120 kg120\text{ kg} is lifted using a uniform 3.00 m3.00\text{ m} crowbar pivoted at one end against the ground (second-class lever). The crate rests 0.50 m0.50\text{ m} from the pivot. Taking g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2 and neglecting the bar's mass, find the mechanical advantage of the setup and the upward lifting force required at the opposite end of the crowbar.

Answer

MA=6.00\text{MA} = 6.00, Feffort=196 NF_{\text{effort}} = 196\text{ N}. Load force FL=120×9.80=1176 NF_L = 120 \times 9.80 = 1176\text{ N}. Mechanical advantage MA=dEdL=3.00 m0.50 m=6.00\text{MA} = \frac{d_E}{d_L} = \frac{3.00\text{ m}}{0.50\text{ m}} = 6.00. Effort force Feffort=FLMA=1176 N6.00=196 NF_{\text{effort}} = \frac{F_L}{\text{MA}} = \frac{1176\text{ N}}{6.00} = 196\text{ N} (or via torque: FE=1176×0.503.00=196 NF_E = \frac{1176 \times 0.50}{3.00} = 196\text{ N}).

Loading workspace…