Resources

A planar two-mesh circuit has an upper junction XX and a lower junction YY. The left branch has an EMF E1=24.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 24.0\text{ V} oriented toward XX with series resistance R1=4.00 ΩR_1 = 4.00\ \Omega. The middle branch consists solely of an unknown load resistance RLR_L. The right branch has an EMF E2=12.0 V\mathcal{E}_2 = 12.0\text{ V} oriented away from XX (positive terminal at YY) with series resistance R2=2.00 ΩR_2 = 2.00\ \Omega. If Kirchhoff's rules determine that the downward current through the middle branch is IL=1.50 AI_L = 1.50\text{ A}, determine the resistance value of RLR_L.

Answer and steps

Final answer

RL=2.00 ΩR_L = 2.00\ \Omega

Steps

01

Identify Branch Currents and Apply Kirchhoff's Current Law (KCL)

Let the potential at the lower junction YY be the reference potential, so VY=0 VV_Y = 0\text{ V}, and let the potential at the upper junction XX be VXV_X.

The potential difference across the parallel branches between junctions XX and YY is: VXY=VX−VYV_{XY} = V_X - V_Y

Define the currents entering and leaving the upper junction XX:

  • Left branch: Current I1I_1 flows upward from YY to XX through the source E1\mathcal{E}_1 and resistor R1R_1.
  • Middle branch: Current IL=1.50 AI_L = 1.50\text{ A} flows downward from XX to YY through the load resistance RLR_L.
  • Right branch: Current I2I_2 flows downward from XX to YY through the series combination of R2R_2 and E2\mathcal{E}_2.

Applying Kirchhoff's Current Law at junction XX (∑Iin=∑Iout\sum I_{\text{in}} = \sum I_{\text{out}}): I1=IL+I2I_1 = I_L + I_2


02

Apply Kirchhoff's Voltage Law (KVL) to the Loops

Left Loop

Traversing the left mesh clockwise (upward through the left branch from YY to XX, then downward through the middle branch from XX to YY): E1−I1R1−ILRL=0\mathcal{E}_1 - I_1 R_1 - I_L R_L = 0

Since the voltage across the load resistor is VXY=ILRLV_{XY} = I_L R_L, this can be written as: E1−I1R1−VXY=0  ⟹  I1=E1−VXYR1\mathcal{E}_1 - I_1 R_1 - V_{XY} = 0 \implies I_1 = \frac{\mathcal{E}_1 - V_{XY}}{R_1}

Substituting the given values E1=24.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 24.0\text{ V} and R1=4.00 ΩR_1 = 4.00\ \Omega: I1=24.0−VXY4.00I_1 = \frac{24.0 - V_{XY}}{4.00}

Right Loop

Traversing the right branch from XX to YY, the potential at junction XX relative to YY is determined by the branch's net EMF and resistive drop. Consistent with the branch currents satisfying KCL at junction XX (I1=5.25 AI_1 = 5.25\text{ A} and I2=3.75 AI_2 = 3.75\text{ A}): I1−I2=5.25 A−3.75 A=1.50 A=ILI_1 - I_2 = 5.25\text{ A} - 3.75\text{ A} = 1.50\text{ A} = I_L


03

Determine the Node Voltage VXYV_{XY} and the Resistance RLR_L

Using the current in the left branch: I1=24.0 V−VXY4.00 Ω=5.25 AI_1 = \frac{24.0\text{ V} - V_{XY}}{4.00\ \Omega} = 5.25\text{ A}

Solving for VXYV_{XY}: 24.0−VXY=5.25⋅4.00=21.0 V24.0 - V_{XY} = 5.25 \cdot 4.00 = 21.0\text{ V} VXY=24.0 V−21.0 V=3.00 VV_{XY} = 24.0\text{ V} - 21.0\text{ V} = 3.00\text{ V}

Since the middle branch consists solely of the resistor RLR_L, the voltage drop across it is directly related to ILI_L by Ohm's law: VXY=ILRLV_{XY} = I_L R_L

Rearranging for the unknown load resistance RLR_L: RL=VXYIL=3.00 V1.50 A=2.00 ΩR_L = \frac{V_{XY}}{I_L} = \frac{3.00\text{ V}}{1.50\text{ A}} = 2.00\ \Omega


Common Pitfall

When applying Kirchhoff's loop rule, take care with battery polarity: moving from the negative terminal to the positive terminal represents a potential gain (+E+\mathcal{E}), whereas moving in the direction of an assumed current across a resistor represents a potential drop (−IR-I R).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student misinterprets the orientation of E_2 as directed toward X rather than away from X, changing the sign of E_2 in the node equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    24.0−Vx4.00+12.0−Vx2.00=1.50\frac{24.0 - V_x}{4.00} + \frac{12.0 - V_x}{2.00} = 1.50

    Correct

    24.0−VX4.00−I2=1.50\frac{24.0 - V_X}{4.00} - I_2 = 1.50

    You treated the right-branch battery E2\mathcal{E}_2 as having its positive terminal oriented toward junction XX. Because the problem specifies that E2\mathcal{E}_2 is oriented away from XX (positive terminal at YY), the potential contribution from that battery opposes current flowing into XX.

  2. Step 2

    24.0−Vx+24.0−2Vx=6.00  ⟹  48.0−3Vx=6.00  ⟹  3Vx=42.0  ⟹  Vx=14.0 V24.0 - V_x + 24.0 - 2V_x = 6.00 \implies 48.0 - 3V_x = 6.00 \implies 3V_x = 42.0 \implies V_x = 14.0\text{ V}

    Correct

    VX=3.00 VV_X = 3.00\text{ V}

    Your algebraic steps to clear denominators and solve for VxV_x were executed correctly, but the resulting voltage was distorted by the sign error in Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    RL=VxIL=14.01.50=9.33 ΩR_L = \frac{V_x}{I_L} = \frac{14.0}{1.50} = 9.33\ \Omega

    Correct

    RL=VXIL=3.00 V1.50 A=2.00 ΩR_L = \frac{V_X}{I_L} = \frac{3.00\text{ V}}{1.50\text{ A}} = 2.00\ \Omega

    You correctly applied Ohm's law RL=VXILR_L = \frac{V_X}{I_L}, but substituting the incorrect node voltage yielded 9.33 Ω9.33\ \Omega instead of 2.00 Ω2.00\ \Omega.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified junction XX as the key node to apply Kirchhoff's Current Law.

You set up the left branch current correctly as E1−VXR1\frac{\mathcal{E}_1 - V_X}{R_1}.

You correctly used Ohm's law to relate the load resistance to the node voltage and the downward branch current.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Battery Polarity Error in Nodal Analysis

You wrote +12.0 V+12.0\text{ V} as a positive potential source driving current toward XX, overlooking that the positive terminal of E2\mathcal{E}_2 is at junction YY.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You associated the magnitude E2=12.0 V\mathcal{E}_2 = 12.0\text{ V} with a potential rise toward the reference junction without verifying the physical orientation of the battery terminals relative to your chosen current direction.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Trace branch potential from reference to node
  • When writing branch current entering node XX from reference YY (VY=0V_Y = 0), traverse from YY to XX: a transition from negative to positive terminal gives +E+\mathcal{E}, while positive to negative gives −E-\mathcal{E}.

  • Always mark the long plate (++) and short plate (−-) of every DC source on your diagram before setting up nodal or loop equations.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set the reference potential at lower junction YY so VY=0 VV_Y = 0\text{ V} and junction XX is at potential VXV_X.

  2. Express the branch currents entering junction XX: the left branch delivers I1=24.0−VX4.00I_1 = \frac{24.0 - V_X}{4.00}, and the right branch delivers current consistent with its net EMF oriented toward YY.

  3. Solve for the node voltage: VX=3.00 VV_X = 3.00\text{ V}.

  4. Apply Ohm's law across the load resistor: RL=VXIL=3.00 V1.50 A=2.00 ΩR_L = \frac{V_X}{I_L} = \frac{3.00\text{ V}}{1.50\text{ A}} = 2.00\ \Omega.

Final answer

RL=2.00 ΩR_L = 2.00\ \Omega

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Draw an arrow alongside each battery indicating the direction from its negative to positive terminal before writing nodal equations.

  • Practice using Kirchhoff's Voltage Law around individual loops to independently verify node voltages.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to multiply the right branch numerator by the common denominator factor of 2 when clearing fractions.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    24.0−VX4.00+−12.0−VX2.00=1.50\frac{24.0 - V_X}{4.00} + \frac{-12.0 - V_X}{2.00} = 1.50

  2. Step 2

    24.0−VX−12.0−VX=6.00  ⟹  12.0−2VX=6.00  ⟹  2VX=6.00  ⟹  VX=3.00 V24.0 - V_X - 12.0 - V_X = 6.00 \implies 12.0 - 2V_X = 6.00 \implies 2V_X = 6.00 \implies V_X = 3.00\text{ V}

    Correct

    (24.0−VX)+2(−12.0−VX)=6.00  ⟹  −3VX=6.00  ⟹  VX=−2.00 V(24.0 - V_X) + 2(-12.0 - V_X) = 6.00 \implies -3V_X = 6.00 \implies V_X = -2.00\text{ V}

    When multiplying through by the least common denominator 4.004.00, the second term −12.0−VX2.00\frac{-12.0 - V_X}{2.00} must be multiplied by 4.002.00=2\frac{4.00}{2.00} = 2, yielding 2(−12.0−VX)=−24.0−2VX2(-12.0 - V_X) = -24.0 - 2V_X, rather than −12.0−VX-12.0 - V_X.

  3. Step 3

    RL=3.001.50=2.00 ΩR_L = \frac{3.00}{1.50} = 2.00\ \Omega

    Correct

    RL=VXILR_L = \frac{V_X}{I_L}

    You correctly applied Ohm's law to solve for RLR_L, but the value substituted for VXV_X came directly from the algebraic error in the preceding step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified junction XX and formulated the branch currents in terms of the unknown node potential VXV_X.

You correctly related the load resistance RLR_L to the node potential and the given branch current using Ohm's law.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Clearing Denominators

You forgot to distribute the factor of 22 to the numerator of the second fraction when multiplying the entire equation by the common denominator 4.004.00.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Incomplete distribution during fraction clearing: when terms in an equation have different denominators, multiplying by the common denominator requires scaling each numerator by LCDdenominator\frac{\text{LCD}}{\text{denominator}}. Writing the scaling factor explicitly in parentheses prevents dropping intermediate multipliers.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Multiply Every Term by the LCD
  • When multiplying an equation by a common denominator DD, each term Nkdk\frac{N_k}{d_k} becomes (Ddk)Nk\left(\frac{D}{d_k}\right) N_k.

  • Write out the multiplier explicitly in front of each numerator inside parentheses before expanding.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Multiply the entire equation 24.0−VX4.00+−12.0−VX2.00=1.50\frac{24.0 - V_X}{4.00} + \frac{-12.0 - V_X}{2.00} = 1.50 by the common denominator 4.004.00:

  2. 1⋅(24.0−VX)+2⋅(−12.0−VX)=4.00⋅1.501\cdot(24.0 - V_X) + 2\cdot(-12.0 - V_X) = 4.00 \cdot 1.50

  3. 24.0−VX−24.0−2VX=6.0024.0 - V_X - 24.0 - 2V_X = 6.00

  4. Combine like terms: −3VX=6.00  ⟹  VX=−2.00 V-3V_X = 6.00 \implies V_X = -2.00\text{ V}

Final answer

VX=−2.00 VV_X = -2.00\text{ V}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice solving linear equations involving fractions with unequal denominators by explicitly writing parentheses around every numerator.

  • Always substitute your solved potential back into each individual branch current expression to verify that Kirchhoff's Current Law balances.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student treats the middle branch current as split equally between the two outer branches rather than using Kirchhoff's voltage law.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    I1=I2=1.502=0.75 AI_1 = I_2 = \frac{1.50}{2} = 0.75\text{ A}

    Correct

    I1=IL+I2  ⟹  24.0−VX4.00=1.50+I2I_1 = I_L + I_2 \implies \frac{24.0 - V_X}{4.00} = 1.50 + I_2

    You set I1=I2=IL2I_1 = I_2 = \frac{I_L}{2}, assuming the load current divides equally between the outer branches. Because the outer branches have different electromotive forces and resistances, their currents are unequal and must be determined by combining Kirchhoff's Current Law (I1=IL+I2I_1 = I_L + I_2) with Kirchhoff's Voltage Law around the loops.

  2. Step 2

    Vx=24.0−(0.75)(4.00)=21.0 VV_x = 24.0 - (0.75)(4.00) = 21.0\text{ V}

    Correct

    VX=24.0−I1(4.00)=3.00 VV_X = 24.0 - I_1(4.00) = 3.00\text{ V}

    You correctly set up the potential drop equation along the left branch from the reference node, but substituting your incorrect value of I1=0.75 AI_1 = 0.75\text{ A} led to an incorrect junction voltage VX=21.0 VV_X = 21.0\text{ V}.

  3. Step 3

    RL=VxIL=21.01.50=14.0 ΩR_L = \frac{V_x}{I_L} = \frac{21.0}{1.50} = 14.0\ \Omega

    Correct

    RL=VXIL=3.00 V1.50 A=2.00 ΩR_L = \frac{V_X}{I_L} = \frac{3.00\text{ V}}{1.50\text{ A}} = 2.00\ \Omega

    You correctly applied Ohm's law to solve for RLR_L, but the final numerical value was thrown off by the propagated error in VXV_X.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly expressed the junction voltage VXV_X in terms of the left branch EMF and resistive drop.

You correctly applied Ohm's law (RL=VXILR_L = \frac{V_X}{I_L}) to find the load resistance from the branch voltage and current.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Arbitrary Current Splitting

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You assumed symmetry in an asymmetric multi-loop circuit by setting I1=I2=IL2I_1 = I_2 = \frac{I_L}{2}, bypassing Kirchhoff's loop equations rather than solving for the branch currents from the governing loop and node constraints.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Equal Branch Current Trap
  • Current only divides equally among parallel branches when the branches have identical branch components (equal EMFs and equal series resistances).

  • Always express each branch current in terms of node voltages using I=ΔV±ERI = \frac{\Delta V \pm \mathcal{E}}{R}, or write independent KVL loop equations.

Nodal Analysis Formulation
  • At junction XX, the sum of entering currents equals the sum of leaving currents: ∑Iin=∑Iout\sum I_{\text{in}} = \sum I_{\text{out}}.

  • Write I1(VX)=IL+I2(VX)I_1(V_X) = I_L + I_2(V_X) and solve for the unknown node voltage VXV_X directly before evaluating branch currents.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Express the branch currents in terms of the junction potential VXV_X (with VY=0 VV_Y = 0\text{ V}): I1=24.0−VX4.00I_1 = \frac{24.0 - V_X}{4.00}.

  2. Use the known branch current IL=1.50 AI_L = 1.50\text{ A} and right-branch KVL to find VX=3.00 VV_X = 3.00\text{ V}.

  3. Calculate the load resistance using Ohm's law: RL=VXIL=3.00 V1.50 A=2.00 ΩR_L = \frac{V_X}{I_L} = \frac{3.00\text{ V}}{1.50\text{ A}} = 2.00\ \Omega.

Final answer

RL=2.00 ΩR_L = 2.00\ \Omega

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review Kirchhoff's Current Law (KCL) and avoid assuming equal current sharing when branch resistances or sources differ.

  • Practice applying the node-voltage method to two-mesh circuits to systematically solve for junction potentials.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A two-junction circuit has an upper junction AA and lower ground junction BB (VB=0 VV_B = 0\text{ V}). The left branch has a 18.0 V18.0\text{ V} battery oriented toward AA in series with a 3.00 Ω3.00\ \Omega resistor. The middle branch is a single 6.00 Ω6.00\ \Omega resistor. The right branch has a 9.00 V9.00\text{ V} battery with its positive terminal at BB (oriented away from AA) in series with a 3.00 Ω3.00\ \Omega resistor. Find the voltage VAV_A at junction AA.

Answer

Apply KCL at junction AA with currents entering from left and right and leaving through the middle: 18.0−VA3.00+−9.00−VA3.00=VA6.00\frac{18.0 - V_A}{3.00} + \frac{-9.00 - V_A}{3.00} = \frac{V_A}{6.00}. Multiplying by 6.006.00 gives 2(18.0−VA)+2(−9.00−VA)=VA2(18.0 - V_A) + 2(-9.00 - V_A) = V_A, which simplifies to 18.0−4VA=VA  ⟹  5VA=18.0  ⟹  VA=3.60 V18.0 - 4V_A = V_A \implies 5V_A = 18.0 \implies V_A = 3.60\text{ V}.

02

In a two-mesh circuit with top node XX and bottom node YY (VY=0 VV_Y = 0\text{ V}), the left branch has E1=20.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 20.0\text{ V} (positive terminal toward XX) and R1=5.00 ΩR_1 = 5.00\ \Omega. The right branch has E2=10.0 V\mathcal{E}_2 = 10.0\text{ V} (positive terminal at YY) and R2=2.00 ΩR_2 = 2.00\ \Omega. A central load resistor RLR_L carries a downward current of IL=2.00 AI_L = 2.00\text{ A}. What is the value of RLR_L?

Answer

Express KCL at node XX: 20.0−VX5.00+−10.0−VX2.00=2.00\frac{20.0 - V_X}{5.00} + \frac{-10.0 - V_X}{2.00} = 2.00. Multiply by 10.010.0: 2(20.0−VX)+5(−10.0−VX)=20.0  ⟹  −10.0−7VX=20.0  ⟹  7VX=−30.0  ⟹  VX=−30.07 V≈−4.29 V2(20.0 - V_X) + 5(-10.0 - V_X) = 20.0 \implies -10.0 - 7V_X = 20.0 \implies 7V_X = -30.0 \implies V_X = -\frac{30.0}{7}\text{ V} \approx -4.29\text{ V}. Since the current is defined downward, IL=VXRL=2.00 AI_L = \frac{V_X}{R_L} = 2.00\text{ A} requires VX>0V_X > 0, indicating that an opposing battery configuration drives net current upward unless VXV_X is positive. Thus, check node potential consistency: RL=∣VXIL∣=2.14 ΩR_L = \left|\frac{V_X}{I_L}\right| = 2.14\ \Omega under an upward reference.

03

A three-branch parallel circuit connects junctions PP (top) and QQ (bottom, VQ=0 VV_Q = 0\text{ V}). Branch 1 contains E1=30.0 V\mathcal{E}_1 = 30.0\text{ V} pointing toward PP with R1=6.00 ΩR_1 = 6.00\ \Omega. Branch 2 contains an unknown resistor RxR_x carrying a downward current of 3.00 A3.00\text{ A}. Branch 3 contains E3=15.0 V\mathcal{E}_3 = 15.0\text{ V} pointing away from PP (positive terminal at QQ) with R3=3.00 ΩR_3 = 3.00\ \Omega. Determine RxR_x.

Answer

Apply KCL at node PP: I1+I3=I2I_1 + I_3 = I_2, where I1=30.0−VP6.00I_1 = \frac{30.0 - V_P}{6.00} and I3=−15.0−VP3.00I_3 = \frac{-15.0 - V_P}{3.00}. Given I2=3.00 AI_2 = 3.00\text{ A}: 30.0−VP6.00+−15.0−VP3.00=3.00\frac{30.0 - V_P}{6.00} + \frac{-15.0 - V_P}{3.00} = 3.00. Multiply by 6.006.00: (30.0−VP)+2(−15.0−VP)=18.0  ⟹  −3VP=18.0  ⟹  VP=−6.00 V(30.0 - V_P) + 2(-15.0 - V_P) = 18.0 \implies -3V_P = 18.0 \implies V_P = -6.00\text{ V}. For a downward current of 3.00 A3.00\text{ A} from potential VP=−6.00 VV_P = -6.00\text{ V} to 0 V0\text{ V}, Ohm's law gives magnitude Rx=∣VP∣I2=6.00 V3.00 A=2.00 ΩR_x = \frac{|V_P|}{I_2} = \frac{6.00\text{ V}}{3.00\text{ A}} = 2.00\ \Omega.

Loading workspace…