Resources

A uniform rectangular wooden plank of mass M=18.0 kgM = 18.0\text{ kg} and total length L=3.00 mL = 3.00\text{ m} rests horizontally on a flat roof such that a length d=1.00 md = 1.00\text{ m} overhangs beyond the roof's edge. A worker of mass m=72.0 kgm = 72.0\text{ kg} steps onto the overhanging section of the plank and slowly walks toward the far edge. Calculate the critical maximum distance xmaxx_{\text{max}} from the edge of the roof that the worker can advance before the plank begins to tip over the roof's edge.

Answer and steps

Final answer

xmax=0.125 mx_{\text{max}} = 0.125\text{ m}

Steps

01

Identify the Pivot Point and the Condition for Tipping

The plank rests on a flat roof with a length d=1.00 md = 1.00\text{ m} extending over the edge, meaning the portion resting on the roof has a length of: Lroof=L−d=3.00 m−1.00 m=2.00 mL_{\text{roof}} = L - d = 3.00\text{ m} - 1.00\text{ m} = 2.00\text{ m}

As the worker steps onto the overhanging section, the normal force from the roof shifts toward the edge. At the verge of tipping, the normal force from the roof is concentrated entirely at a single line along the edge of the roof. Therefore, the edge of the roof acts as the pivot point (fulcrum).

02

Determine the Lever Arm of the Plank's Weight

Because the plank is uniform, its center of mass is located at its geometric center, which is at a distance of: xCM=L2=3.00 m2=1.50 mfrom either endx_{\text{CM}} = \frac{L}{2} = \frac{3.00\text{ m}}{2} = 1.50\text{ m}\quad \text{from either end}

Measuring from the inner end that rests on the roof:

  • The pivot (roof's edge) is located at 2.00 m2.00\text{ m} from the inner end.
  • The center of mass of the plank is located at 1.50 m1.50\text{ m} from the inner end.

Thus, the center of mass lies on the supported side of the roof, at a distance rMr_M from the pivot: rM=2.00 m−1.50 m=0.50 mr_M = 2.00\text{ m} - 1.50\text{ m} = 0.50\text{ m}

The weight of the plank, MgM g, exerts a counterclockwise (restoring) torque about the pivot.

03

Apply the Rotational Equilibrium Condition

Let xmaxx_{\text{max}} be the maximum distance the worker of mass mm can advance past the pivot onto the overhang. At this position, the worker's weight mgmg exerts a clockwise (tipping) torque about the pivot.

For static rotational balance at the tipping threshold, the net torque about the pivot must be zero: ∑τpivot=0\sum \tau_{\text{pivot}} = 0

τrestoring=τtipping\tau_{\text{restoring}} = \tau_{\text{tipping}}

Mg⋅rM=mg⋅xmaxM g \cdot r_M = m g \cdot x_{\text{max}}

Dividing both sides by the gravitational acceleration gg: M⋅rM=m⋅xmaxM \cdot r_M = m \cdot x_{\text{max}}

04

Calculate the Maximum Distance xmaxx_{\text{max}}

Substitute the given values into the expression: xmax=M⋅rMm=18.0 kg⋅0.50 m72.0 kgx_{\text{max}} = \frac{M \cdot r_M}{m} = \frac{18.0\text{ kg} \cdot 0.50\text{ m}}{72.0\text{ kg}}

xmax=9.0072.0=0.125 mx_{\text{max}} = \frac{9.00}{72.0} = 0.125\text{ m}

Common Pitfall: A common mistake is measuring the plank's center of mass directly from the edge as L/2=1.50 mL/2 = 1.50\text{ m}. Remember that the center of mass is measured relative to the whole plank's ends, not from the pivot line.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses the location of the plank's center of mass relative to the pivot with the full half-length of the plank, using 1.50 m instead of 0.50 m.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Pivot is at the roof edge

  2. Step 2

    Torque balance: M⋅g⋅(L/2)=m⋅g⋅xmax  ⟹  18.0⋅1.50=72.0⋅xmax\text{Torque balance: } M \cdot g \cdot (L/2) = m \cdot g \cdot x_{\text{max}} \implies 18.0 \cdot 1.50 = 72.0 \cdot x_{\text{max}}

    Correct

    M⋅g⋅(L/2−d)=m⋅g⋅xmax  ⟹  18.0⋅0.50=72.0⋅xmaxM \cdot g \cdot (L/2 - d) = m \cdot g \cdot x_{\text{max}} \implies 18.0 \cdot 0.50 = 72.0 \cdot x_{\text{max}}

    You used L/2=1.50 mL/2 = 1.50\text{ m} as the lever arm from the pivot to the center of mass. The center of mass is 1.50 m1.50\text{ m} from the end of the plank, but the pivot is located 1.00 m1.00\text{ m} from that same overhanging end (or 2.00 m2.00\text{ m} from the inner end). Therefore, the lever arm about the pivot is rM=1.50 m−1.00 m=0.50 mr_M = 1.50\text{ m} - 1.00\text{ m} = 0.50\text{ m}.

  3. Step 3

    27.0=72.0⋅xmax  ⟹  xmax=0.375 m27.0 = 72.0 \cdot x_{\text{max}} \implies x_{\text{max}} = 0.375\text{ m}

    Correct

    9.00=72.0⋅xmax  ⟹  xmax=0.125 m9.00 = 72.0 \cdot x_{\text{max}} \implies x_{\text{max}} = 0.125\text{ m}

    Your algebra was carried out accurately, but the value is incorrect due to the lever arm error in the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the edge of the roof as the pivot point where tipping occurs.

You correctly set up the rotational equilibrium condition equating restoring torque to tipping torque.

You solved the resulting linear equation algebraically without calculation slips.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect Lever Arm for Center of Mass

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the absolute position of the center of mass (measured from an end of the object as L/2L/2) with its lever arm relative to the chosen pivot axis (L/2−dL/2 - d).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Lever Arm vs. Position Coordinate
  • In torque calculations τ=F⋅r⊥\tau = F \cdot r_\perp, the lever arm r⊥r_\perp is always the perpendicular distance from the pivot axis to the line of action of the force, not the coordinate measured from an endpoint.

  • Draw the pivot axis first, locate the center of mass relative to an endpoint, and then compute the difference between their positions to find the lever arm.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the distance from the pivot (roof edge) to the center of mass of the plank: rM=L2−d=1.50 m−1.00 m=0.50 mr_M = \frac{L}{2} - d = 1.50\text{ m} - 1.00\text{ m} = 0.50\text{ m}.

  2. Set the restoring torque of the plank equal to the tipping torque of the worker: M⋅g⋅rM=m⋅g⋅xmaxM \cdot g \cdot r_M = m \cdot g \cdot x_{\text{max}}.

  3. Substitute the known values: 18.0 kg⋅0.50 m=72.0 kg⋅xmax18.0\text{ kg} \cdot 0.50\text{ m} = 72.0\text{ kg} \cdot x_{\text{max}}.

  4. Solve for xmaxx_{\text{max}}: xmax=9.00 kg⋅m72.0 kg=0.125 mx_{\text{max}} = \frac{9.00\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m}}{72.0\text{ kg}} = 0.125\text{ m}.

Final answer

xmax=0.125 mx_{\text{max}} = 0.125\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always sketch a quick free-body diagram showing both the pivot line and the center of gravity before writing torque terms.

  • Double-check every lever arm by asking: 'Is this distance measured from the pivot, or from the edge of the board?'

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies the lever arm of the plank's weight as the overhanging length d rather than the distance from the pivot to the center of mass.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Balance torques about the edge of the roof   ⟹  M⋅g⋅d=m⋅g⋅xmax\implies M \cdot g \cdot d = m \cdot g \cdot x_{\text{max}}

    Correct

    ∑τpivot=0  ⟹  MgrM=mgxmax\sum \tau_{\text{pivot}} = 0 \implies M g r_M = m g x_{\text{max}}, where rM=(L2−d)=0.50 mr_M = \left(\frac{L}{2} - d\right) = 0.50\text{ m}

    You correctly recognized that the edge of the roof acts as the fulcrum at the verge of tipping, but you used the overhang length d=1.00 md = 1.00\text{ m} as the lever arm for the plank's weight. The plank's weight acts at its center of mass, which lies 1.50 m1.50\text{ m} from the ends, or 0.50 m0.50\text{ m} inward from the pivot.

  2. Step 2

    18.0⋅1.00=72.0⋅xmax  ⟹  xmax=18.0/72.018.0 \cdot 1.00 = 72.0 \cdot x_{\text{max}} \implies x_{\text{max}} = 18.0 / 72.0

    Correct

    18.0⋅0.50=72.0⋅xmax  ⟹  xmax=9.0072.018.0 \cdot 0.50 = 72.0 \cdot x_{\text{max}} \implies x_{\text{max}} = \frac{9.00}{72.0}

    Your algebraic substitution and rearrangement were performed correctly, but the equation carried over the incorrect lever arm from the previous step.

  3. Step 3

    xmax=0.25 mx_{\text{max}} = 0.25\text{ m}

    Correct

    xmax=0.125 mx_{\text{max}} = 0.125\text{ m}

    Carrying through the correct lever arm of 0.50 m0.50\text{ m} yields xmax=0.125 mx_{\text{max}} = 0.125\text{ m}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the edge of the roof as the pivot line where the plank tips.

You correctly set up a torque balance equating the restoring torque to the tipping torque.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Incorrect lever arm for distributed weight

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the length of the overhang as the lever arm of the entire plank's gravitational force, forgetting that gravity acts at the plank's center of mass, so the lever arm must be measured from the pivot to the center of mass.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Locate the Center of Mass Relative to the Ends
  • For a uniform object of length LL, the center of mass is located at its geometric center, xCM=L2x_{\text{CM}} = \frac{L}{2} from either end.

  • Always mark the center of mass along the full object before setting up pivot distances.

Compute Lever Arms from the Chosen Pivot
  • The lever arm of any force is the perpendicular distance from the pivot axis to the line of action of that force.

  • Subtract the distance from the supported end to the CM from the supported length to find the distance between the pivot and the CM: rM=(L−d)−L2=L2−dr_M = (L - d) - \frac{L}{2} = \frac{L}{2} - d.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the distance from the pivot (roof edge) to the plank's center of mass: the supported portion is L−d=3.00 m−1.00 m=2.00 mL - d = 3.00\text{ m} - 1.00\text{ m} = 2.00\text{ m}, and the center of mass is 1.50 m1.50\text{ m} from the inner end, so rM=2.00 m−1.50 m=0.50 mr_M = 2.00\text{ m} - 1.50\text{ m} = 0.50\text{ m}.

  2. Equate the restoring torque of the plank to the tipping torque of the worker about the roof edge: MgrM=mgxmaxM g r_M = m g x_{\text{max}}.

  3. Substitute the given masses and solve: xmax=MrMm=18.0 kg⋅0.50 m72.0 kg=0.125 mx_{\text{max}} = \frac{M r_M}{m} = \frac{18.0\text{ kg} \cdot 0.50\text{ m}}{72.0\text{ kg}} = 0.125\text{ m}.

Final answer

xmax=0.125 mx_{\text{max}} = 0.125\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Sketch a clear free-body diagram showing the entire plank, marking its midpoint (center of gravity) and the pivot separately.

  • Practice computing lever arms by writing them explicitly as differences of coordinates measured from a single reference end.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student inverts the ratio of the masses when solving the torque balance equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    Distance of center of mass to pivot=1.50−1.00=0.50 m\text{Distance of center of mass to pivot} = 1.50 - 1.00 = 0.50\text{ m}

  2. Step 2

    Torque balance:M⋅g⋅0.50=m⋅g⋅xmax\text{Torque balance}: M \cdot g \cdot 0.50 = m \cdot g \cdot x_{\text{max}}

  3. Step 3

    xmax=(mM)⋅0.50  ⟹  xmax=(72.018.0)⋅0.50x_{\text{max}} = \left(\frac{m}{M}\right) \cdot 0.50 \implies x_{\text{max}} = \left(\frac{72.0}{18.0}\right) \cdot 0.50

    Correct

    xmax=(Mm)⋅0.50=(18.072.0)⋅0.50x_{\text{max}} = \left(\frac{M}{m}\right) \cdot 0.50 = \left(\frac{18.0}{72.0}\right) \cdot 0.50

    To isolate xmaxx_{\text{max}} from Mg(0.50)=mgxmaxM g (0.50) = m g x_{\text{max}}, you must divide both sides by mgm g, giving xmax=Mm⋅0.50x_{\text{max}} = \frac{M}{m} \cdot 0.50. You accidentally inverted the fraction to mM\frac{m}{M}.

  4. Step 4

    xmax=2.0 mx_{\text{max}} = 2.0\text{ m}

    Correct

    xmax=0.125 mx_{\text{max}} = 0.125\text{ m}

    This numerical answer is directly affected by the inverted mass ratio in the previous step. Note also that an answer of 2.0 m2.0\text{ m} exceeds the total overhang length of 1.00 m1.00\text{ m}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the distance from the pivot line to the plank's center of mass as 0.50 m0.50\text{ m}.

You formulated the correct torque equilibrium condition at the threshold of tipping.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted algebraic ratio

You accidentally divided by the plank's mass MM instead of the worker's mass mm when solving for xmaxx_{\text{max}}.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

A quick algebraic isolation error led to inverting the ratio of masses. A heavier person (72.0 kg72.0\text{ kg}) balancing a lighter plank (18.0 kg18.0\text{ kg}) requires a much shorter lever arm (xmax<rMx_{\text{max}} < r_M), so the multiplying fraction must be less than 11.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isolating Variables in Proportions
  • If A⋅rA=B⋅rBA \cdot r_A = B \cdot r_B, then rB=AB⋅rAr_B = \frac{A}{B} \cdot r_A, not BA⋅rA\frac{B}{A} \cdot r_A.

  • Always explicitly divide both sides by the coefficient of the unknown variable before substituting numbers.

Physical Reasonableness Check
  • For two balancing torques, the larger mass must have the smaller lever arm: m>M  ⟹  xmax<rMm > M \implies x_{\text{max}} < r_M.

  • Check whether your result satisfies physical bounds (such as being less than rM=0.50 mr_M = 0.50\text{ m} and within the 1.00 m1.00\text{ m} total overhang).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Divide both sides by m⋅gm \cdot g: xmax=Mm⋅0.50 mx_{\text{max}} = \frac{M}{m} \cdot 0.50\text{ m}

  2. Substitute the given masses: xmax=18.0 kg72.0 kg⋅0.50 m=14⋅0.50 mx_{\text{max}} = \frac{18.0\text{ kg}}{72.0\text{ kg}} \cdot 0.50\text{ m} = \frac{1}{4} \cdot 0.50\text{ m}

  3. Evaluate the final distance: xmax=0.125 mx_{\text{max}} = 0.125\text{ m}

Final answer

xmax=0.125 mx_{\text{max}} = 0.125\text{ m}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice isolating variables in two-mass equilibrium equations by writing out the division step explicitly.

  • Perform a physical reality check on distances to verify that a heavier object has a shorter lever arm.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A uniform plank of mass M=20.0 kgM = 20.0\text{ kg} and length L=4.00 mL = 4.00\text{ m} rests on a flat ledge with 1.50 m1.50\text{ m} hanging over the edge. A cat of mass m=5.0 kgm = 5.0\text{ kg} walks out onto the overhang. What is the maximum distance past the ledge the cat can walk before the plank tips?

Answer

xmax=2.00 mx_{\text{max}} = 2.00\text{ m}. Key steps: Center of mass is 2.00 m2.00\text{ m} from either end. The ledge is 1.50 m1.50\text{ m} from the outer end, so the plank's lever arm about the ledge is rM=2.00 m−1.50 m=0.50 mr_M = 2.00\text{ m} - 1.50\text{ m} = 0.50\text{ m}. Torque balance: M⋅rM=m⋅xmax  ⟹  20.0×0.50=5.0×xmax  ⟹  xmax=2.00 mM \cdot r_M = m \cdot x_{\text{max}} \implies 20.0 \times 0.50 = 5.0 \times x_{\text{max}} \implies x_{\text{max}} = 2.00\text{ m}.

02

A uniform wooden beam of mass M=30.0 kgM = 30.0\text{ kg} and length L=6.00 mL = 6.00\text{ m} overhangs a table edge by d=2.00 md = 2.00\text{ m}. A child of mass m=25.0 kgm = 25.0\text{ kg} stands at a distance xx from the table edge on the overhang, and a toolbox of mass mbox=10.0 kgm_{\text{box}} = 10.0\text{ kg} is placed at the far inner end of the beam on the table. Determine the maximum distance xx the child can stand without tipping the beam.

Answer

x=2.80 mx = 2.80\text{ m}. Key steps: The pivot is the table edge. The inner section on the table is L−d=4.00 mL - d = 4.00\text{ m}. Lever arm of beam CM is rCM=3.00 m−2.00 m=1.00 mr_{\text{CM}} = 3.00\text{ m} - 2.00\text{ m} = 1.00\text{ m} (on the table side). Lever arm of toolbox is 4.00 m4.00\text{ m} (at the inner end). Counter-tipping torque: τcounter=(30.0 kg)(1.00 m)+(10.0 kg)(4.00 m)=30.0+40.0=70.0 kg⋅m\tau_{\text{counter}} = (30.0\text{ kg})(1.00\text{ m}) + (10.0\text{ kg})(4.00\text{ m}) = 30.0 + 40.0 = 70.0\text{ kg}\cdot\text{m}. Tipping torque: τtip=25.0 kg⋅x\tau_{\text{tip}} = 25.0\text{ kg} \cdot x. Setting them equal: 25.0x=70.0  ⟹  x=2.80 m25.0 x = 70.0 \implies x = 2.80\text{ m}.

03

A non-uniform rod of mass M=12.0 kgM = 12.0\text{ kg} and length L=2.00 mL = 2.00\text{ m} has its center of mass located 0.70 m0.70\text{ m} from end AA. End AA rests on a table, and the rod overhangs the table edge by 0.80 m0.80\text{ m} (so end BB is out in the air). A weight m=4.0 kgm = 4.0\text{ kg} is hung from end BB. Does the rod tip, and if not, what is the net torque about the table edge?

Answer

The rod tips. Key steps: The portion on the table has length 2.00 m−0.80 m=1.20 m2.00\text{ m} - 0.80\text{ m} = 1.20\text{ m} from end AA. The center of mass is 0.70 m0.70\text{ m} from end AA, so its distance from the table edge is 1.20 m−0.70 m=0.50 m1.20\text{ m} - 0.70\text{ m} = 0.50\text{ m} (restoring side). Restoring torque: τrestoring=Mg(0.50)=12.0×0.50×g=6.0g\tau_{\text{restoring}} = M g (0.50) = 12.0 \times 0.50 \times g = 6.0 g. Tipping torque from mass mm at end BB (lever arm 0.80 m0.80\text{ m}): τtipping=mg(0.80)=4.0×0.80×g=3.2g\tau_{\text{tipping}} = m g (0.80) = 4.0 \times 0.80 \times g = 3.2 g. Here τrestoring>τtipping\tau_{\text{restoring}} > \tau_{\text{tipping}} (6.0g>3.2g6.0 g > 3.2 g), so the rod does not tip over. Net restoring torque is (6.0−3.2)g=2.8g≈27.5 N⋅m(6.0 - 3.2)g = 2.8 g \approx 27.5\text{ N}\cdot\text{m}.

Loading workspace…