Resources
An exploration rover of mass is winched up an adjustable icy incline. The coefficient of static friction is small, , and the winch cable pulls strictly parallel to the incline with tension . Take . (a) Write the expressions for the normal force and the minimum tension required to prevent the rover from sliding backward down the incline as explicit functions of the incline angle . (b) Evaluate the asymptotic limits of and as the slope becomes flat () and as the slope becomes vertical (), and provide the physical interpretation of each limit.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) , (for ); (b) As : and (friction alone supports the static state on flat ground); as : and (contact with the wall vanishes, static friction drops to zero, and tension must support the entire vertical weight).
Steps
Part (a): Free-Body Diagram and Equilibrium Equations
-
Establish the Coordinate System: Align the coordinate axes with the inclined plane:
- Let the -axis point up along the surface of the incline.
- Let the -axis point perpendicularly upward away from the surface.
-
Identify and Resolve All Forces:
- Gravitational force (): Acts vertically downward. Resolving into components gives:
- Normal force (): Acts perpendicular to the surface in the -direction:
- Cable tension (): Acts parallel to the incline in the -direction:
- Static friction (): Since we want the minimum tension to prevent the rover from sliding backward (downward), the rover is on the verge of slipping down. Therefore, static friction acts upward along the plane (-direction) at its maximum value:
- Equilibrium in the Perpendicular Direction (-axis): Because there is no acceleration perpendicular to the incline: Substituting and ():
- Equilibrium in the Parallel Direction (-axis): Setting the net force along the incline to zero: Substitute : Using the numerical values: (Note: This expression applies when the downslope component of gravity exceeds maximum static friction, i.e., . For smaller angles, the rover stays at rest even with .)
Part (b): Asymptotic Limits and Physical Interpretations
-
Limit as the Slope Becomes Flat ():
- For , gravity has no downslope component (). Since the slope is flat, static friction alone readily prevents any motion, so no tension is required:
- Physical Interpretation: On level ground, the normal force completely balances the rover's weight (). With no component of gravity pulling along the surface, the cable does not need to exert any tension to prevent backward sliding.
-
Limit as the Slope Becomes Vertical ():
- Physical Interpretation: When the incline is vertical, the rover no longer presses against the surface, so the normal force vanishes (). Without a normal force, static friction drops to zero (). Consequently, the winch cable must support the entire vertical weight of the rover ().
Typical errors
01 The student reverses the direction of static friction, assuming friction opposes tension rather than the downward impending motion.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
To prevent the rover from sliding backward down the slope, impending motion is directed downslope. Static friction opposes impending motion and therefore acts upslope (), helping the cable rather than opposing it.
- Step 3
;
Correct(friction alone maintains equilibrium without cable pull); (contact disappears, friction vanishes, and tension supports full weight)
Your analysis for is physically sound, but for , your reversed friction sign led to a non-zero minimum tension (). On a flat surface, the rover has no tendency to slide on its own, so zero tension is required.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly resolved the normal force perpendicular to the inclined plane as .
You correctly recognized that maximum static friction is given by .
You correctly evaluated and physically interpreted the vertical slope limit at .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that friction always opposes the pulling force (tension) instead of opposing the direction of impending relative motion (sliding backward down the incline).
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Direction of Static Friction
Static friction always opposes the direction of impending relative motion, not necessarily applied external forces.
Ask yourself: 'If the cable tension were slightly too small, which way would the rover slip?' Since it slips downslope, static friction must point upslope.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up equilibrium along the incline with impending downslope slip: .
Substitute : .
Insert the values , , and : for .
Re-evaluate : with no downslope gravity component, the rover rests naturally, giving .
(a) , ; (b) As , and ; as , and .
02 The student confuses the trigonometric components of gravity, using sine for the normal force and cosine for the parallel component.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You used instead of for the perpendicular component of gravity. When an incline has angle relative to the horizontal, the angle between the downward vertical and the normal axis is also , making the adjacent component .
- Step 2Correct
You correctly recognized that static friction acts up the incline to prevent sliding down, but you used for the parallel component of gravity instead of the opposite component .
- Step 3
; the normal force is zero and full tension is needed horizontally.
Correct; on level ground, normal force supports the full weight and static friction keeps the rover at rest without cable tension.
Your limit calculation followed your expressions from Step 1 and Step 2 correctly, but the result contradicts the physical situation on flat ground, where the surface supports the entire weight ().
- Step 4
; normal force equals full weight and tension becomes negative.
Correct; against a vertical wall, contact force drops to zero and the cable must support the full vertical weight.
This step evaluated your swapped equations correctly, but on a vertical cliff the rover loses contact with the surface, so and the cable tension must carry the full gravitational load ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly determined that maximum static friction points up the incline to resist downward sliding.
You correctly formulated the parallel equilibrium condition relating tension, friction, and the gravitational pull.
You systematically evaluated the boundary limits of your algebraic expressions.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou associated the incline angle with the opposite side when resolving gravity perpendicular to the surface, reversing the roles of and for the coordinate axes aligned with the slope.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Identifying the Reference Angle in Incline FBDs
When the incline is elevated at angle from the horizontal, the angle between the downward weight vector and the perpendicular axis into the incline is always .
Draw the right triangle formed by and the axes: the side adjacent to is , and the side opposite to is .
- Sanity Check via Extreme Angles (0° and 90°)
On a flat surface (), normal force must equal full weight () and downslope gravity must vanish ().
Before solving further, test : if your perpendicular force has , you have inverted sine and cosine.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationDecompose the gravitational force into components aligned with the incline: and .
Set the perpendicular net force to zero: .
Set the parallel net force to zero for impending downward slip: .
Substitute : (for ).
Evaluate limits: as , and ; as , and .
(a) , ; (b) As : , ; as : ,
03 The student assumes the normal force is always equal to the full weight m*g regardless of the incline angle.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
On an incline angled at , gravity must be resolved into perpendicular and parallel components. The normal force balances the perpendicular component of gravity, giving , which depends on the incline angle.
- Step 2Correct
Your equilibrium equation along the incline is set up properly, but substituting instead of carried the error into your tension formula.
- Step 3
At : , ; normal force equals total weight and friction prevents movement without tension. \nAt : , ; surface still exerts full normal force so friction reduces the tension needed to hold the weight.
CorrectAt : , (friction balances down-slope forces on level ground). \nAt : , (contact vanishes, static friction drops to zero, and the cable supports the full weight).
Because varies as , at the surface exerts zero normal force (), which means static friction vanishes and the cable must support the rover's full weight ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly resolved the component of gravity acting parallel to the incline as .
You oriented maximum static friction up the incline to prevent the rover from sliding backward.
You correctly calculated the numerical magnitude of the rover's weight as .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated the normal force as a fixed quantity equal to rather than setting up Newton's second law along the perpendicular axis (-axis) to find .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Establish Perpendicular Equilibrium
For a surface tilted at angle with no perpendicular acceleration, the normal force balances the perpendicular component of gravity: .
Always draw a tilted coordinate frame and resolve the weight vector into (perpendicular to surface) and (parallel to surface).
- Check Physical Limits
As a slope approaches a vertical wall (), an object resting without a horizontal pressing force loses contact pressure: .
Verify whether your normal force formula properly vanishes at and equals at .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationResolve forces perpendicular to the incline: .
Substitute into the parallel equilibrium equation: .
Evaluate : ; since gravity has no downslope component, tension is zero ().
Evaluate : and , meaning the winch alone holds the entire vertical weight.
(a) , (for ); (b) As : , ; as : , .
Lock it in
Which direction does static friction act on an object at rest on a surface?
It acts parallel to the contact surface, directly opposing the direction of impending relative motion.
Similar question
A crate sits on a incline with . A cable pulls upward along the slope. Taking , find the minimum cable tension needed to keep the crate from sliding down the incline.
Answer
.
A box of mass rests on an incline of angle where . A force pushes parallel to the incline. Determine the range of forces for which the box remains stationary on the incline.
Answer
For impending downward slip: . For impending upward slip: . Range: .
A block of mass is held against a vertical wall by a horizontal pushing force . The coefficient of static friction between the block and the wall is . Taking , calculate the minimum horizontal force needed to prevent the block from slipping downward.
Answer
Impending motion is downward, so static friction acts upward: . At minimum push, . Thus .