Resources

An industrial cable-and-counterweight hoist is lowering an equipment container of mass m=450 kgm = 450\text{ kg} vertically downward through a height of h=14.0 mh = 14.0\text{ m} at a constant descending velocity. To maintain constant speed against gravitational acceleration, the hoist motor exerts an upward tension force on the support cable, effectively performing negative work on the container by absorbing mechanical energy at an average rate. Over the duration of the descent, which takes t=20.0 st = 20.0\text{ s}, the internal brake and motor system dissipates thermal energy at a rate of Pdiss=820 WP_{\text{diss}} = 820\text{ W} due to mechanical friction and electrical resistance. Defining efficiency for an energy-absorption/regenerative braking process as the ratio of useful energy recovered to total available mechanical work entering the system, determine: (a) the magnitude of the gravitational work rate ∣Pin∣|P_{\text{in}}|, and (b) the mechanical recovery efficiency η\eta. (Take g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2.)

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) ∣Pin∣=3.09 kW|P_{\text{in}}| = 3.09\text{ kW}; (b) η=73.4%\eta = 73.4\%

Steps

01

Calculate the Total Mechanical Work and Gravitational Power Input

Since the container descends at a constant velocity, the net force acting on it is zero. The upward cable tension equals the downward gravitational force:

FT=mgF_T = m g

The work done on the container by gravity as it descends through vertical distance hh is:

Wg=mghW_g = m g h

Substitute the given numerical values:

Wg=(450 kg)(9.80 m/s2)(14.0 m)=61,740 JW_g = (450\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2)(14.0\text{ m}) = 61{,}740\text{ J}

Because the motion occurs at a constant speed, the mechanical energy supplied by gravity is transferred directly to the hoist cable as input energy over time t=20.0 st = 20.0\text{ s}. The magnitude of the gravitational work rate (mechanical power input, ∣Pin∣|P_{\text{in}}|) is:

∣Pin∣=Wgt=61,740 J20.0 s=3087 W=3.087 kW|P_{\text{in}}| = \frac{W_g}{t} = \frac{61{,}740\text{ J}}{20.0\text{ s}} = 3087\text{ W} = 3.087\text{ kW}

Rounding to three significant figures gives:

∣Pin∣=3.09 kW|P_{\text{in}}| = 3.09\text{ kW}


02

Determine Useful Recovered Power

By the conservation of energy, the total mechanical power entering the hoist system divides into useful recovered power and dissipated thermal power:

∣Pin∣=Puseful+Pdiss|P_{\text{in}}| = P_{\text{useful}} + P_{\text{diss}}

Rearranging for the useful power recovered by the system:

Puseful=∣Pin∣−PdissP_{\text{useful}} = |P_{\text{in}}| - P_{\text{diss}}

Substitute the calculated input power and given dissipation rate:

Puseful=3087 W−820 W=2267 WP_{\text{useful}} = 3087\text{ W} - 820\text{ W} = 2267\text{ W}


03

Calculate the Mechanical Recovery Efficiency

Efficiency η\eta for a regenerative or energy-absorbing system is defined as the ratio of useful power recovered to the total available mechanical power entering the system:

η=Puseful∣Pin∣×100%\eta = \frac{P_{\text{useful}}}{|P_{\text{in}}|} \times 100\%

Substitute the values:

η=2267 W3087 W×100%≈73.437%\eta = \frac{2267\text{ W}}{3087\text{ W}} \times 100\% \approx 73.437\%

Rounding to three significant figures gives:

η=73.4%\eta = 73.4\%

(Common Pitfall: Do not define efficiency as the ratio of dissipated power to input power, or divide by useful power instead of total input mechanical power.)

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses useful energy output with dissipated energy loss, calculating efficiency as dissipated power divided by input power.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Win=mgh=(450)(9.80)(14.0)=61740 J  ⟹  ∣Pin∣=6174020.0=3087 WW_{\text{in}} = m g h = (450)(9.80)(14.0) = 61740\text{ J} \implies |P_{\text{in}}| = \frac{61740}{20.0} = 3087\text{ W}

  2. Step 2

    η=Pdiss∣Pin∣  ⟹  η=8203087≈0.266=26.6%\eta = \frac{P_{\text{diss}}}{|P_{\text{in}}|} \implies \eta = \frac{820}{3087} \approx 0.266 = 26.6\%

    Correct

    η=Puseful∣Pin∣=∣Pin∣−Pdiss∣Pin∣=3087 W−820 W3087 W≈73.4%\eta = \frac{P_{\text{useful}}}{|P_{\text{in}}|} = \frac{|P_{\text{in}}| - P_{\text{diss}}}{|P_{\text{in}}|} = \frac{3087\text{ W} - 820\text{ W}}{3087\text{ W}} \approx 73.4\%

    You set the numerator to the dissipated power PdissP_{\text{diss}} rather than the useful recovered power Puseful=∣Pin∣−PdissP_{\text{useful}} = |P_{\text{in}}| - P_{\text{diss}}. Efficiency represents the fraction of input energy successfully utilized or recovered, not the fraction lost.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used W=mghW = m g h to calculate the mechanical work done by gravity on the descending load.

You divided the total work by time to find the correct mechanical input power of 3087 W3087\text{ W}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
efficiency definition confusion

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the power lost through dissipation with the useful power output, calculating the loss fraction (Pdiss/PinP_{\text{diss}}/P_{\text{in}}) instead of the recovery efficiency (Puseful/PinP_{\text{useful}}/P_{\text{in}}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Conservation of Power
  • Total power entering a system equals useful power plus dissipated power: Pin=Puseful+PdissP_{\text{in}} = P_{\text{useful}} + P_{\text{diss}}.

  • Always find useful power by subtracting dissipated power from total input power before setting up the efficiency ratio.

Definition of Efficiency
  • Efficiency is always defined as η=PusefulPin=1−PdissPin\eta = \frac{P_{\text{useful}}}{P_{\text{in}}} = 1 - \frac{P_{\text{diss}}}{P_{\text{in}}}.

  • Check whether your numerator represents what you want to keep/recover rather than what was wasted as heat.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Find the useful recovered power: Puseful=∣Pin∣−Pdiss=3087 W−820 W=2267 WP_{\text{useful}} = |P_{\text{in}}| - P_{\text{diss}} = 3087\text{ W} - 820\text{ W} = 2267\text{ W}.

  2. Substitute into the efficiency formula: η=2267 W3087 W×100%≈73.437%\eta = \frac{2267\text{ W}}{3087\text{ W}} \times 100\% \approx 73.437\%.

  3. Round to three significant figures: η=73.4%\eta = 73.4\%.

Final answer

(a) ∣Pin∣=3.09 kW|P_{\text{in}}| = 3.09\text{ kW}; (b) η=73.4%\eta = 73.4\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Write out the energy balance Pin=Puseful+PdissP_{\text{in}} = P_{\text{useful}} + P_{\text{diss}} explicitly before calculating efficiency.

  • Verify your final percentage: an efficiency of 26.6%26.6\% paired with a dissipation of 820 W820\text{ W} out of 3087 W3087\text{ W} implies more energy is lost than recovered, which contradicts the numbers given.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies total input power as the sum of gravitational power and dissipated power instead of recognizing gravitational power as the total available input.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Win=mgh=(450)(9.80)(14.0)=61740 J  ⟹  ∣Pin∣=6174020.0=3087 WW_{\text{in}} = mgh = (450)(9.80)(14.0) = 61740\text{ J} \implies |P_{\text{in}}| = \frac{61740}{20.0} = 3087\text{ W}

  2. Step 2

    Ptotal=∣Pin∣+Pdiss=3087+820=3907 WP_{\text{total}} = |P_{\text{in}}| + P_{\text{diss}} = 3087 + 820 = 3907\text{ W}

    Correct

    Puseful=∣Pin∣−Pdiss=3087 W−820 W=2267 WP_{\text{useful}} = |P_{\text{in}}| - P_{\text{diss}} = 3087\text{ W} - 820\text{ W} = 2267\text{ W}

    The gravitational work entering the cable is already the total available input power (∣Pin∣|P_{\text{in}}|). By conservation of energy, the input divides into useful recovered power and dissipated thermal power: ∣Pin∣=Puseful+Pdiss|P_{\text{in}}| = P_{\text{useful}} + P_{\text{diss}}. Adding PdissP_{\text{diss}} to ∣Pin∣|P_{\text{in}}| double-counts the energy instead of subtracting the losses.

  3. Step 3

    η=∣Pin∣Ptotal=30873907≈0.790=79.0%\eta = \frac{|P_{\text{in}}|}{P_{\text{total}}} = \frac{3087}{3907} \approx 0.790 = 79.0\%

    Correct

    η=Puseful∣Pin∣=2267 W3087 W≈73.4%\eta = \frac{P_{\text{useful}}}{|P_{\text{in}}|} = \frac{2267\text{ W}}{3087\text{ W}} \approx 73.4\%

    Because you defined PtotalP_{\text{total}} incorrectly in the previous step, your efficiency formula placed input power in the numerator and an inflated total in the denominator instead of evaluating PusefulPin\frac{P_{\text{useful}}}{P_{\text{in}}}.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly computed the total gravitational work done on the descending container.

You correctly found the average rate of energy absorption ∣Pin∣|P_{\text{in}}| by dividing the total work by the duration.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Energy conservation boundary error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the total available input energy with one of the output branches. In regenerative braking or lowering processes, the mechanical work absorbed from gravity is the sole energy source (PinP_{\text{in}}). It splits into useful recovered power and dissipated thermal losses (Pin=Puseful+PdissP_{\text{in}} = P_{\text{useful}} + P_{\text{diss}}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Identify the Energy Boundary
  • Pinput=Puseful+PlossP_{\text{input}} = P_{\text{useful}} + P_{\text{loss}}

  • Always list what energy enters the system first. Any internal friction, heat, or electrical resistance represents losses subtracted from this input, never added to it.

Definition of Efficiency
  • η=PusefulPinput=Pinput−PlossPinput\eta = \frac{P_{\text{useful}}}{P_{\text{input}}} = \frac{P_{\text{input}} - P_{\text{loss}}}{P_{\text{input}}}

  • Ensure the denominator is the total power fed into the machine, and the numerator represents only the successfully captured or utilized power.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. State the power conservation relation: ∣Pin∣=Puseful+Pdiss|P_{\text{in}}| = P_{\text{useful}} + P_{\text{diss}}

  2. Substitute known values to find useful power: Puseful=3087 W−820 W=2267 WP_{\text{useful}} = 3087\text{ W} - 820\text{ W} = 2267\text{ W}

  3. Compute efficiency: η=Puseful∣Pin∣=2267 W3087 W≈0.7344\eta = \frac{P_{\text{useful}}}{|P_{\text{in}}|} = \frac{2267\text{ W}}{3087\text{ W}} \approx 0.7344

Final answer

(a) ∣Pin∣=3.09 kW|P_{\text{in}}| = 3.09\text{ kW}; (b) η=73.4%\eta = 73.4\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice drawing energy flow (Sankey) diagrams for energy-absorbing systems to clearly distinguish input streams from loss streams.

  • Double-check that for any passive or regenerative process, Puseful≤PinP_{\text{useful}} \le P_{\text{in}} and the denominator of efficiency is always the source energy entering the boundary.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student multiplies the work by time instead of dividing by time when calculating the work rate in part (a), leading to an incorrect power and an invalid efficiency calculation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Win=mgh=(450)(9.80)(14.0)=61740 JW_{\text{in}} = mgh = (450)(9.80)(14.0) = 61740\text{ J}

  2. Step 2

    ∣Pin∣=Win⋅t=61740⋅20.0=1234800 W|P_{\text{in}}| = W_{\text{in}} \cdot t = 61740 \cdot 20.0 = 1234800\text{ W}

    Correct

    ∣Pin∣=Wgt=61,740 J20.0 s=3087 W=3.09 kW|P_{\text{in}}| = \frac{W_g}{t} = \frac{61{,}740\text{ J}}{20.0\text{ s}} = 3087\text{ W} = 3.09\text{ kW}

    Power is the rate of doing work, defined as energy or work divided by time (P=WtP = \frac{W}{t}), not work multiplied by time (W⋅tW \cdot t). Multiplying produced units of J⋅s\text{J}\cdot\text{s} instead of watts (J/s\text{J/s}).

  3. Step 3

    Puseful=1234800−820=1233980 WP_{\text{useful}} = 1234800 - 820 = 1233980\text{ W}

    Correct

    Puseful=∣Pin∣−Pdiss=3087 W−820 W=2267 WP_{\text{useful}} = |P_{\text{in}}| - P_{\text{diss}} = 3087\text{ W} - 820\text{ W} = 2267\text{ W}

    Your energy balance relation Puseful=∣Pin∣−PdissP_{\text{useful}} = |P_{\text{in}}| - P_{\text{diss}} is conceptually sound, but the numerical result is affected by the incorrect value of ∣Pin∣|P_{\text{in}}| from Step 2.

  4. Step 4

    η=12339801234800≈0.999=99.9%\eta = \frac{1233980}{1234800} \approx 0.999 = 99.9\%

    Correct

    η=Puseful∣Pin∣=2267 W3087 W≈73.4%\eta = \frac{P_{\text{useful}}}{|P_{\text{in}}|} = \frac{2267\text{ W}}{3087\text{ W}} \approx 73.4\%

    Your definition of efficiency as the ratio of useful power to total input power is correct, but your calculation inherited the erroneous power value from Step 2.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified that the gravitational potential energy lost is the mechanical work input W=mghW = mgh.

You correctly applied conservation of energy to relate total input power, dissipated power, and useful recovered power.

You set up the mechanical efficiency ratio η=PusefulPin\eta = \frac{P_{\text{useful}}}{P_{\text{in}}} accurately.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverse Rate Formula Error

You multiplied work by time (W⋅tW \cdot t) rather than dividing work by time (Wt\frac{W}{t}) when finding power.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Conflating the definition of power (P=ΔEΔtP = \frac{\Delta E}{\Delta t}) with an energy integral or product relationship, overlooking dimensional consistency where 1 W=1 J/s1\text{ W} = 1\text{ J/s}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Rate vs. Quantity
  • Any physical rate with respect to time divides the accumulated quantity by time: Rate=Δ(Quantity)Δt\text{Rate} = \frac{\Delta(\text{Quantity})}{\Delta t}.

  • Whenever you see 'work rate' or 'power', check that you divide joules by seconds.

Dimensional Sanity Check
  • 1 Watt=1 Joule per second=1 J⋅s−11\text{ Watt} = 1\text{ Joule per second} = 1\text{ J}\cdot\text{s}^{-1}.

  • Verify that multiplying energy by time gives J⋅s\text{J}\cdot\text{s}, which is action, not power.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. ∣Pin∣=Wgt=61,740 J20.0 s=3087 W=3.09 kW|P_{\text{in}}| = \frac{W_g}{t} = \frac{61{,}740\text{ J}}{20.0\text{ s}} = 3087\text{ W} = 3.09\text{ kW}

  2. Puseful=∣Pin∣−Pdiss=3087 W−820 W=2267 WP_{\text{useful}} = |P_{\text{in}}| - P_{\text{diss}} = 3087\text{ W} - 820\text{ W} = 2267\text{ W}

  3. η=Puseful∣Pin∣=2267 W3087 W≈73.4%\eta = \frac{P_{\text{useful}}}{|P_{\text{in}}|} = \frac{2267\text{ W}}{3087\text{ W}} \approx 73.4\%

Final answer

(a) ∣Pin∣=3.09 kW|P_{\text{in}}| = 3.09\text{ kW}; (b) η=73.4%\eta = 73.4\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the fundamental definitions of work (W=FdW = F d) and average power (P=WtP = \frac{W}{t}).

  • Perform unit checks on intermediate steps to verify that your evaluated quantities have units of watts (J/s\text{J/s}).

Lock it in

Similar question

01

An elevator cab of mass 800 kg800\text{ kg} descends vertically at a constant speed of 2.50 m/s2.50\text{ m/s} while driving a regenerative generator. The system experiences friction and electrical losses at a rate of 3.60 kW3.60\text{ kW}. Taking g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2, calculate: (a) the total input power magnitude ∣Pin∣|P_{\text{in}}|, and (b) the recovery efficiency η\eta.

Answer

(a) ∣Pin∣=mgv=(800 kg)(9.80 m/s2)(2.50 m/s)=19,600 W=19.6 kW|P_{\text{in}}| = m g v = (800\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2)(2.50\text{ m/s}) = 19{,}600\text{ W} = 19.6\text{ kW}. (b) Useful power is Puseful=19.6 kW−3.60 kW=16.0 kWP_{\text{useful}} = 19.6\text{ kW} - 3.60\text{ kW} = 16.0\text{ kW}, so η=16.0 kW19.6 kW≈81.6%\eta = \frac{16.0\text{ kW}}{19.6\text{ kW}} \approx 81.6\%.

02

A mine hoist lowers ore carts down an incline, absorbing mechanical work at an average rate of 45.0 kW45.0\text{ kW}. If the regenerative braking system operates at an efficiency of 68.0%68.0\%, determine the rate at which heat energy is dissipated by the braking mechanisms.

Answer

Useful recovered power is Puseful=ηPin=0.680×45.0 kW=30.6 kWP_{\text{useful}} = \eta P_{\text{in}} = 0.680 \times 45.0\text{ kW} = 30.6\text{ kW}. By conservation of energy, Pdiss=Pin−Puseful=(1−η)Pin=(1−0.680)(45.0 kW)=14.4 kWP_{\text{diss}} = P_{\text{in}} - P_{\text{useful}} = (1 - \eta)P_{\text{in}} = (1 - 0.680)(45.0\text{ kW}) = 14.4\text{ kW}.

03

A crane lowers a 1200 kg1200\text{ kg} concrete beam through a vertical height of 25.0 m25.0\text{ m} in 30.0 s30.0\text{ s} at a constant speed. The crane's regeneration system stores electrical energy in a battery bank at a rate of 6.20 kW6.20\text{ kW}. Taking g=9.80 m/s2g = 9.80\text{ m/s}^2, find: (a) the rate of thermal dissipation PdissP_{\text{diss}}, and (b) the overall efficiency η\eta of the lowering operation.

Answer

(a) Input power ∣Pin∣=mght=(1200 kg)(9.80 m/s2)(25.0 m)30.0 s=9800 W=9.80 kW|P_{\text{in}}| = \frac{m g h}{t} = \frac{(1200\text{ kg})(9.80\text{ m/s}^2)(25.0\text{ m})}{30.0\text{ s}} = 9800\text{ W} = 9.80\text{ kW}. Dissipation is Pdiss=Pin−Puseful=9.80 kW−6.20 kW=3.60 kWP_{\text{diss}} = P_{\text{in}} - P_{\text{useful}} = 9.80\text{ kW} - 6.20\text{ kW} = 3.60\text{ kW}. (b) η=PusefulPin=6.20 kW9.80 kW≈63.3%\eta = \frac{P_{\text{useful}}}{P_{\text{in}}} = \frac{6.20\text{ kW}}{9.80\text{ kW}} \approx 63.3\%.

Loading workspace…