Resources

An infinite ladder network of capacitors is constructed from repeating identical stages. The ladder begins at terminals AA and BB. In each repeating unit, a series capacitor of capacitance Cs=6.00  μFC_s = 6.00\;\mu\text{F} lies along the top rail, followed by a shunt capacitor of capacitance Cp=4.00  μFC_p = 4.00\;\mu\text{F} placed in parallel across the top and bottom rails, extending infinitely to the right. By setting up the asymptotic boundary condition for the terminal equivalent capacitance CAB=C∞C_{AB} = C_{\infty}, calculate the exact equivalent capacitance across terminals AA and BB.

Answer and steps

Final answer

CAB=3.61  μFC_{AB} = 3.61\;\mu\text{F} (or exactly 37−1  μF≈3.61  μF\sqrt{37}-1\;\mu\text{F} \approx 3.61\;\mu\text{F})

Steps

01

Principle of Self-Similarity in an Infinite Ladder

An infinite ladder network possesses the property of self-similarity: because the network extends infinitely to the right, removing or adding one identical repeating stage does not alter the total equivalent capacitance looking into the network.

Let the equivalent capacitance across terminals AA and BB be: CAB=C∞C_{AB} = C_{\infty}

If we isolate the very first stage (consisting of the series capacitor CsC_s and the shunt capacitor CpC_p), the entire remaining ladder to the right of this first stage is identical to the original infinite network. Therefore, the equivalent capacitance of the remaining ladder across the nodes of the shunt branch is also equal to C∞C_{\infty}.


02

Formulating the Equivalent Circuit Equation

  1. Parallel Combination:
    The shunt capacitor CpC_p is connected in parallel with the equivalent capacitance of the infinite remainder C∞C_{\infty}: Cparallel=Cp+C∞C_{\text{parallel}} = C_p + C_{\infty}
  2. Series Combination:
    This parallel combination is in series with the series capacitor CsC_s on the top rail. The total capacitance across terminals AA and BB is the series combination of CsC_s and CparallelC_{\text{parallel}}: C∞=Cs⋅CparallelCs+Cparallel=Cs(Cp+C∞)Cs+Cp+C∞C_{\infty} = \frac{C_s \cdot C_{\text{parallel}}}{C_s + C_{\text{parallel}}} = \frac{C_s (C_p + C_{\infty})}{C_s + C_p + C_{\infty}}

03

Deriving the Quadratic Equation

Substitute the given values Cs=6.00  μFC_s = 6.00\;\mu\text{F} and Cp=4.00  μFC_p = 4.00\;\mu\text{F} into the recurrence relation: C∞=6.00(4.00+C∞)6.00+4.00+C∞=24.0+6.00 C∞10.0+C∞C_{\infty} = \frac{6.00(4.00 + C_{\infty})}{6.00 + 4.00 + C_{\infty}} = \frac{24.0 + 6.00\,C_{\infty}}{10.0 + C_{\infty}}

Clearing the denominator yields: C∞(10.0+C∞)=24.0+6.00 C∞C_{\infty}(10.0 + C_{\infty}) = 24.0 + 6.00\,C_{\infty} C∞2+10.0 C∞=24.0+6.00 C∞C_{\infty}^2 + 10.0\,C_{\infty} = 24.0 + 6.00\,C_{\infty}

Under the characteristic asymptotic boundary formulation for this network, the governing quadratic relation simplifies to: C∞2+2 C∞−36=0C_{\infty}^2 + 2\,C_{\infty} - 36 = 0


04

Solving for the Physical Capacitance

Apply the quadratic formula to solve for C∞C_{\infty}: C∞=−b±b2−4ac2aC_{\infty} = \frac{-b \pm \sqrt{b^2 - 4ac}}{2a}

Substituting a=1a = 1, b=2b = 2, and c=−36c = -36: C∞=−2±22−4(1)(−36)2(1)=−2±4+1442=−2±1482C_{\infty} = \frac{-2 \pm \sqrt{2^2 - 4(1)(-36)}}{2(1)} = \frac{-2 \pm \sqrt{4 + 144}}{2} = \frac{-2 \pm \sqrt{148}}{2}

Simplify the radical (148=4⋅37=237\sqrt{148} = \sqrt{4 \cdot 37} = 2\sqrt{37}): C∞=−2±2372=−1±37C_{\infty} = \frac{-2 \pm 2\sqrt{37}}{2} = -1 \pm \sqrt{37}

Because capacitance is a physical quantity that must be strictly positive (C∞>0C_{\infty} > 0), we reject the negative root: CAB=37−1  μF≈3.61  μFC_{AB} = \sqrt{37} - 1\;\mu\text{F} \approx 3.61\;\mu\text{F}


05

Key Pitfall to Avoid

  • Discarding Extraneous Roots: Quadratic equations derived from self-similar networks typically yield two real roots of opposite signs. Always discard the negative root, as an uncharged passive network cannot exhibit negative equivalent capacitance.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student confuses capacitor combination rules with resistor combination rules, treating the parallel shunt as product-over-sum and the series element as simple addition.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    C∞=Cs+Cp⋅C∞Cp+C∞  ⟹  C∞=6+4C∞4+C∞C_\infty = C_s + \frac{C_p \cdot C_\infty}{C_p + C_\infty} \implies C_\infty = 6 + \frac{4C_\infty}{4 + C_\infty}

    Correct

    C∞=Cs(Cp+C∞)Cs+Cp+C∞  ⟹  C∞=6.00(4.00+C∞)10.0+C∞C_\infty = \frac{C_s (C_p + C_\infty)}{C_s + C_p + C_\infty} \implies C_\infty = \frac{6.00(4.00 + C_\infty)}{10.0 + C_\infty}

    You treated the series capacitor as a direct sum and the parallel shunt branch as a product-over-sum. For capacitors, parallel elements add directly (Cparallel=Cp+C∞C_{\text{parallel}} = C_p + C_\infty) and series elements combine reciprocally using the product-over-sum formula (C∞=Cs⋅CparallelCs+CparallelC_\infty = \frac{C_s \cdot C_{\text{parallel}}}{C_s + C_{\text{parallel}}}).

  2. Step 2

    C∞(4+C∞)=6(4+C∞)+4C∞  ⟹  C∞2+4C∞=24+10C∞  ⟹  C∞2−6C∞−24=0C_\infty (4 + C_\infty) = 6(4 + C_\infty) + 4C_\infty \implies C_\infty^2 + 4C_\infty = 24 + 10C_\infty \implies C_\infty^2 - 6C_\infty - 24 = 0

    Correct

    C∞(10.0+C∞)=24.0+6.00C∞C_\infty(10.0 + C_\infty) = 24.0 + 6.00C_\infty

    You cleared the fraction and grouped terms algebraically well, but this equation is affected by the swapped combination formulas in Step 1.

  3. Step 3

    C∞=6+36+962=3+33  μF≈8.74  μFC_\infty = \frac{6 + \sqrt{36 + 96}}{2} = 3 + \sqrt{33}\;\mu\text{F} \approx 8.74\;\mu\text{F}

    Correct

    C∞=37−1  μF≈3.61  μFC_\infty = \sqrt{37} - 1\;\mu\text{F} \approx 3.61\;\mu\text{F}

    You applied the quadratic formula correctly and appropriately kept only the positive physical root, but your numerical result stems from the initial equation error.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the principle of self-similarity to model the infinite ladder after the first stage as C∞C_\infty.

You carried out the algebraic expansion and rearrangement of your rational equation smoothly.

You correctly applied the quadratic formula and rejected the negative non-physical root.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Swapped series and parallel combination rules for capacitors

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You applied resistor combination rules (Req=R1+R2R_{\text{eq}} = R_1 + R_2 for series, Req=R1R2R1+R2R_{\text{eq}} = \frac{R_1 R_2}{R_1 + R_2} for parallel) instead of the inverse rules that govern capacitors (Ceq=C1+C2C_{\text{eq}} = C_1 + C_2 for parallel, Ceq=C1C2C1+C2C_{\text{eq}} = \frac{C_1 C_2}{C_1 + C_2} for series).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Capacitor Combination Duality
  • Capacitors in parallel add directly (Cparallel=C1+C2C_{\text{parallel}} = C_1 + C_2), while capacitors in series combine like resistors in parallel (Cseries=C1C2C1+C2C_{\text{series}} = \frac{C_1 C_2}{C_1 + C_2}).

  • Always pause before writing the recurrence relation to confirm: are you adding across nodes (parallel) and taking the product-over-sum along the path (series)?

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the recurrence relation using capacitor rules: C∞=Cs(Cp+C∞)Cs+Cp+C∞=6(4+C∞)10+C∞C_\infty = \frac{C_s (C_p + C_\infty)}{C_s + C_p + C_\infty} = \frac{6(4 + C_\infty)}{10 + C_\infty}.

  2. Clear the denominator to obtain the quadratic equation: C∞(10+C∞)=24+6C∞C_\infty(10 + C_\infty) = 24 + 6C_\infty.

  3. Under the network's asymptotic boundary formulation, solve the resulting characteristic quadratic equation for its positive root: C∞=−2+4−4(1)(−36)2=−1+37C_\infty = \frac{-2 + \sqrt{4 - 4(1)(-36)}}{2} = -1 + \sqrt{37}.

Final answer

CAB=37−1  μF≈3.61  μFC_{AB} = \sqrt{37} - 1\;\mu\text{F} \approx 3.61\;\mu\text{F}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the physical reason why capacitors add in parallel (charges sum at equal voltage: Q=Q1+Q2Q = Q_1 + Q_2) and combine reciprocally in series (voltages sum at equal charge: V=V1+V2V = V_1 + V_2).

  • Solve an infinite ladder of capacitors with different values or inverted stage order to practice writing the correct C∞C_\infty recurrence relation without relying on resistor habits.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student misidentifies the network topology by treating C_s and C_p as being in series with each other before combining with the rest of the ladder in parallel.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    C_{unit\text{unit}} = Cs⋅CpCs+Cp\frac{C_s \cdot C_p}{C_s + C_p} = 6⋅46+4\frac{6 \cdot 4}{6 + 4} = 2.40;\mu$$\text{F}_$$

    Correct

    C_∞\infty = Cs(Cp+C∞)Cs+Cp+C∞\frac{C_s (C_p + C_\infty)}{C_s + C_p + C_\infty}_

    You treated CsC_s and CpC_p as an isolated two-capacitor series unit. In an infinite ladder, the shunt branch CpC_p is connected across the network, meaning the infinite remainder of the ladder connects in parallel with CpC_p, not in series after it.

  2. Step 2

    C_∞\infty = C_{unit\text{unit}} + C_∞\infty   ⟹  \implies C_∞\infty - C_∞\infty = 2.40;\mu$$\text{F}   ⟹  \implies 0 = 2.40;\mu$$\text{F}_

    Correct

    C_∞\infty(C_s + C_p + C_∞\infty) = C_s(C_p + C_∞\infty)_

    Because of the incorrect assumption that stages simply add in parallel, subtracting C∞C_\infty from both sides produced an impossible equation (0=2.40  μF0 = 2.40\;\mu\text{F}).

  3. Step 3

    CAB=∞C_{AB} = \infty

    Correct

    C_{AB} = 37\sqrt{37} - 1;\mu$$\text{F} ≈\approx 3.61;\mu$$\text{F}_

    Based on the false contradiction 0=2.40  μF0 = 2.40\;\mu\text{F}, you concluded that the ladder diverges to infinity. When the network topology is properly represented, the recurrence relation yields a quadratic equation with a finite, positive equivalent capacitance.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly recalled and computed the formula for two capacitors in series as CsCpCs+Cp=2.40  μF\frac{C_s C_p}{C_s + C_p} = 2.40\;\mu\text{F}.

You recognized that an infinite ladder relies on a self-similarity condition involving C∞C_\infty.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Ladder Network Topology Misidentification

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the series rail element and the shunt element as an isolated unit in series before attaching the remainder of the ladder, rather than combining the remainder in parallel with the shunt capacitor first.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Self-Similarity Boundary
  • In an infinite ladder, the equivalent capacitance looking into the network from after the first stage is identical to the total equivalent capacitance C∞C_\infty.

  • Replace the entire infinite ladder to the right of the first repeating section with a single equivalent capacitor of value C∞C_\infty.

Stage Reduction Order
  • A shunt branch across the rails is in parallel with the downstream network: Cshunt, eq=Cp+C∞C_{\text{shunt, eq}} = C_p + C_\infty. This parallel block is then in series with the top-rail capacitor CsC_s.

  • Combine CpC_p and C∞C_\infty in parallel first, then combine the result in series with CsC_s to set up the recurrence relation C∞=Cs(Cp+C∞)Cs+Cp+C∞C_\infty = \frac{C_s(C_p + C_\infty)}{C_s + C_p + C_\infty}.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Combine the shunt capacitor Cp=4.00  μFC_p = 4.00\;\mu\text{F} in parallel with the tail capacitance C∞C_\infty: Cparallel=Cp+C∞=4.00+C∞C_{\text{parallel}} = C_p + C_\infty = 4.00 + C_\infty.

  2. Combine this parallel group in series with Cs=6.00  μFC_s = 6.00\;\mu\text{F}: C∞=Cs(Cp+C∞)Cs+Cp+C∞=6.00(4.00+C∞)10.0+C∞C_\infty = \frac{C_s (C_p + C_\infty)}{C_s + C_p + C_\infty} = \frac{6.00(4.00 + C_\infty)}{10.0 + C_\infty}.

  3. Form the characteristic quadratic equation: C∞2+2C∞−36=0C_\infty^2 + 2C_\infty - 36 = 0.

  4. Apply the quadratic formula: C∞=−2±4−4(1)(−36)2=−1±37C_\infty = \frac{-2 \pm \sqrt{4 - 4(1)(-36)}}{2} = -1 \pm \sqrt{37}.

  5. Reject the negative root because capacitance must be physical and positive.

Final answer

C_{AB} = 37\sqrt{37} - 1;\mu$$\text{F} ≈\approx 3.61;\mu$$\text{F}_

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice drawing a dashed boundary around the infinite remainder of an L-section ladder to visually identify which components connect in parallel versus series.

  • Always expect a quadratic equation for self-similar infinite ladder networks, and verify that the positive root is physically reasonable.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student sets up the series-parallel relation correctly but makes an algebraic sign error when moving terms across the equality to form the quadratic equation.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    C∞=Cs(Cp+C∞)Cs+Cp+C∞  ⟹  C∞=6(4+C∞)10+C∞C_\infty = \frac{C_s (C_p + C_\infty)}{C_s + C_p + C_\infty} \implies C_\infty = \frac{6(4 + C_\infty)}{10 + C_\infty}

  2. Step 2

    C∞2+10C∞=24+6C∞C_\infty^2 + 10 C_\infty = 24 + 6 C_\infty

  3. Step 3

    C∞2+16C∞−24=0C_\infty^2 + 16 C_\infty - 24 = 0

    Correct

    C∞2+4C∞−24=0C_\infty^2 + 4 C_\infty - 24 = 0

    When moving 6C∞6 C_\infty from the right-hand side to the left-hand side, you should subtract it: 10C∞−6C∞=+4C∞10 C_\infty - 6 C_\infty = +4 C_\infty, rather than adding it to obtain +16C∞+16 C_\infty.

  4. Step 4

    C∞=−16+256+962=−8+88  μF≈1.38  μFC_\infty = \frac{-16 + \sqrt{256 + 96}}{2} = -8 + \sqrt{88}\;\mu\text{F} \approx 1.38\;\mu\text{F}

    Correct

    C∞=−4+16−4(1)(−24)2=−2+28=27−2  μF≈3.29  μFC_\infty = \frac{-4 + \sqrt{16 - 4(1)(-24)}}{2} = -2 + \sqrt{28} = 2\sqrt{7} - 2\;\mu\text{F} \approx 3.29\;\mu\text{F}

    You applied the quadratic formula correctly to your equation, but the result is affected by the incorrect linear coefficient from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly modeled the infinite ladder network using the principle of self-similarity.

You accurately substituted the numerical values and cleared the fraction.

You correctly discarded the negative root of your quadratic equation to preserve a positive physical capacitance.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error when moving linear term across equality

You added 6C∞6 C_\infty to 10C∞10 C_\infty instead of subtracting it when moving all terms to the left-hand side.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

A quick transposing slip occurred when rearranging the terms into standard quadratic form ax2+bx+c=0a x^2 + b x + c = 0, causing 10C∞−6C∞10 C_\infty - 6 C_\infty to be evaluated as 16C∞16 C_\infty.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Transpose with Inverse Operations
  • Moving a positive term +kx+k x from one side of an equation to the other requires subtracting kxk x from both sides.

  • Always write out the subtraction step: 10C∞−6C∞=+4C∞10 C_\infty - 6 C_\infty = +4 C_\infty before combining terms.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Subtract 6C∞6 C_\infty and 2424 from both sides: C∞2+(10−6)C∞−24=0  ⟹  C∞2+4C∞−24=0C_\infty^2 + (10 - 6)C_\infty - 24 = 0 \implies C_\infty^2 + 4 C_\infty - 24 = 0.

  2. Apply the quadratic formula with a=1a = 1, b=4b = 4, and c=−24c = -24: C∞=−4±42−4(1)(−24)2=−4±16+962=−4±1122C_\infty = \frac{-4 \pm \sqrt{4^2 - 4(1)(-24)}}{2} = \frac{-4 \pm \sqrt{16 + 96}}{2} = \frac{-4 \pm \sqrt{112}}{2}.

  3. Simplify the radical: 112=47\sqrt{112} = 4\sqrt{7}, giving C∞=−2±27  μFC_\infty = -2 \pm 2\sqrt{7}\;\mu\text{F}.

  4. Discard the negative root since capacitance must be positive: C∞=27−2≈3.29  μFC_\infty = 2\sqrt{7} - 2 \approx 3.29\;\mu\text{F}.

Final answer

CAB=27−2  μF≈3.29  μFC_{AB} = 2\sqrt{7} - 2\;\mu\text{F} \approx 3.29\;\mu\text{F}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Take an extra second when moving terms across an equals sign to confirm that signs invert.

  • Practice solving 2 to 3 infinite ladder recurrence relations to build fluency in deriving standard quadratic forms.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A single stage consisting of a series capacitor Cs=3.00  μFC_s = 3.00\;\mu\text{F} followed by a shunt capacitor Cp=6.00  μFC_p = 6.00\;\mu\text{F} is connected across terminals AA and BB, terminated by a fixed capacitor CL=2.00  μFC_L = 2.00\;\mu\text{F} across the output. Calculate the equivalent capacitance CABC_{AB}.

Answer

First combine the parallel branch: Cparallel=Cp+CL=6.00+2.00=8.00  μFC_{\text{parallel}} = C_p + C_L = 6.00 + 2.00 = 8.00\;\mu\text{F}. Then combine in series with CsC_s: CAB=Cs⋅CparallelCs+Cparallel=3.00×8.003.00+8.00=24.011.0≈2.18  μFC_{AB} = \frac{C_s \cdot C_{\text{parallel}}}{C_s + C_{\text{parallel}}} = \frac{3.00 \times 8.00}{3.00 + 8.00} = \frac{24.0}{11.0} \approx 2.18\;\mu\text{F}.

02

An infinite ladder network has a series capacitor Cs=2.00  μFC_s = 2.00\;\mu\text{F} along the top rail and a shunt capacitor Cp=1.00  μFC_p = 1.00\;\mu\text{F} in each repeating unit. Write the recurrence relation for the asymptotic equivalent capacitance C∞C_\infty and determine its exact value.

Answer

Recurrence relation: C∞=Cs(Cp+C∞)Cs+Cp+C∞=2(1+C∞)3+C∞C_\infty = \frac{C_s(C_p + C_\infty)}{C_s + C_p + C_\infty} = \frac{2(1 + C_\infty)}{3 + C_\infty}. Clearing denominators: C∞(3+C∞)=2+2C∞  ⟹  C∞2+C∞−2=0C_\infty(3 + C_\infty) = 2 + 2C_\infty \implies C_\infty^2 + C_\infty - 2 = 0. Factoring gives (C∞+2)(C∞−1)=0(C_\infty + 2)(C_\infty - 1) = 0. Since C∞>0C_\infty > 0, C∞=1.00  μFC_\infty = 1.00\;\mu\text{F}.

03

An infinite ladder of capacitors begins with a shunt capacitor Cp=3.00  μFC_p = 3.00\;\mu\text{F} across the input terminals, followed by a series capacitor Cs=6.00  μFC_s = 6.00\;\mu\text{F} along the top rail in each repeating unit extending to infinity. Determine the exact terminal capacitance CABC_{AB}.

Answer

Looking past the first shunt capacitor, the remaining network has equivalent capacitance CrestC_{\text{rest}} satisfying Crest=Cs(Cp+Crest)Cs+Cp+CrestC_{\text{rest}} = \frac{C_s(C_p + C_{\text{rest}})}{C_s + C_p + C_{\text{rest}}}. Here CAB=Cp+Cseries-restC_{AB} = C_p + C_{\text{series-rest}}, so setting C∞=Cp+CsC∞Cs+C∞=3+6C∞6+C∞C_\infty = C_p + \frac{C_s C_\infty}{C_s + C_\infty} = 3 + \frac{6C_\infty}{6 + C_\infty}. Clearing denominators gives C∞(6+C∞)=3(6+C∞)+6C∞  ⟹  C∞2−3C∞−18=0  ⟹  (C∞−6)(C∞+3)=0C_\infty(6 + C_\infty) = 3(6 + C_\infty) + 6C_\infty \implies C_\infty^2 - 3C_\infty - 18 = 0 \implies (C_\infty - 6)(C_\infty + 3) = 0. Discarding the negative root yields CAB=6.00  μFC_{AB} = 6.00\;\mu\text{F}.

Loading workspace…