Resources
A stone is tied to a string and whirled in a horizontal circle counterclockwise at high speed. A common misconception states: 'Because the centripetal force pulls the stone directly toward the center, if the string suddenly breaks, the stone will initially fly radially outward away from the center due to centrifugal force.' (a) Refute this misconception using Newton's First Law of Motion and the instantaneous direction of velocity. (b) If the string snaps at the exact instant the stone is at position coordinates while moving counterclockwise with speed , write the parametric equations of motion and for the stone immediately after the break (neglect air resistance, with at the break).
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) The misconception is false because the instantaneous velocity of the stone is purely tangential (perpendicular to the radial string) and has zero radial component; by Newton's First Law, when the tension ceases (), the stone continues along its instantaneous velocity vector in a straight line tangent to the circle, not radially outward; (b) and (or position vector for ).
Steps
Part (a): Refuting the Misconception
-
Direction of Instantaneous Velocity in Circular Motion: At any instant during uniform circular motion, the velocity vector of an object is tangent to the circular path and perpendicular to the radius vector pointing from the center of the circle to the object. Therefore:
- The stone has a non-zero tangential component of velocity.
- The stone has zero radial component of velocity ().
- Application of Newton's First Law: Newton's First Law of Motion states that an object continues in its state of rest or of uniform motion in a straight line unless acted upon by a net external force: While the string is intact, the tension force acts as the centripetal force directed toward the center, continuously altering the direction of the velocity.
-
Motion After the String Snaps:
- The moment the string breaks, the tension abruptly vanishes. In the horizontal plane, the net force on the stone becomes zero ().
- A fictitious "centrifugal force" only appears in a non-inertial rotating reference frame; in an inertial frame, no outward physical force acts on the stone.
- Because the stone already possesses a velocity directed along the tangent and zero velocity along the radius, it simply continues to travel along a straight line in the tangential direction at constant speed, rather than flying radially outward.
Part (b): Parametric Equations of Motion
-
Initial Conditions at :
- The stone is located on the positive -axis at .
- The radius of the circular path is , centered at the origin .
- Since the motion is counterclockwise, at the point , the tangential direction points along the positive -axis:
- Formulating the Equations of Motion: Because no horizontal force acts on the stone after the snap ( and ), the position coordinates as functions of time are given by:
Equivalently, the position vector is:
Common Pitfall: Do not confuse the outward tendency perceived in a rotating frame with actual outward motion. At the instant of release, the stone has zero outward radial velocity, so its trajectory can never begin along the radial line.
Typical errors
01 The student believes the stone flies straight outward along the radius away from the center due to a perceived centrifugal force.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
When the string breaks, centrifugal force pushes the stone directly outward away from the center. Therefore, by Newton's First Law, the stone moves along the radial line away from the origin.
CorrectIn an inertial frame, there is no physical outward centrifugal force. The stone's instantaneous velocity is purely tangential () with zero radial velocity (). When the string breaks, the net force becomes zero (), so by Newton's First Law, the stone continues in a straight line along its instantaneous tangential velocity vector.
You treated centrifugal force as a real physical force pushing the object outward. In an inertial frame, circular motion requires an inward centripetal force (tension); once tension vanishes, no force acts, so the stone maintains its existing tangential velocity.
- Step 2
At , outward motion is in the positive -direction with and .
CorrectAt moving counterclockwise around the origin, the tangent points in the positive -direction, not along the radial positive -axis.
- Step 3Correct
Your kinematic formula was applied consistently, but it inherited the swapped velocity components from Step 2.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that after the string breaks, Newton's First Law implies motion in a straight line at constant velocity.
You correctly applied the uniform rectilinear motion formula and using your stated initial velocity components.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou treated the fictitious centrifugal force as an active physical force and assumed circular motion carries outward radial velocity.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating the sensation of an outward pull in a rotating (non-inertial) reference frame with actual velocity in an inertial frame. In reality, circular motion has purely tangential velocity (); an object released from circular motion immediately travels along the tangent line.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Direction of Velocity in Circular Motion
The instantaneous velocity vector of an object in circular motion is always tangent to the circle and perpendicular to the radius vector: .
Identify the tangent direction at the release point before writing velocity components; remember that radial velocity is always zero ().
- Newton's First Law upon Release
When the centripetal force ceases, , so velocity remains constant in both magnitude and direction along the tangent line: .
Do not add an outward radial velocity component when the restraining force is removed; simply let the object continue along its instantaneous tangential vector.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationAt , the radial line lies along the positive -axis.
For counterclockwise circular motion, the tangent line perpendicular to the positive -axis points in the positive -direction.
Therefore, the initial velocity vector is purely tangential: (, ).
With , the stone moves at constant velocity: and .
(a) The misconception is false because the instantaneous velocity is purely tangential with zero radial component; by Newton's First Law, when tension vanishes, the stone continues in a straight line tangent to the circle. (b) and
02 The student confuses counterclockwise motion with clockwise motion, assigning the tangential velocity in the negative y-direction instead of the positive y-direction.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
According to Newton's First Law, when the tension force becomes zero, the stone continues in a straight line along its instantaneous tangential velocity. Because velocity is tangent to the circle, the stone flies off tangentially rather than radially.
- Step 2
At , moving along the circle gives tangential velocity and .
Correctand
At the point on the positive -axis, counterclockwise circular motion carries the stone upward into quadrant I toward , so the tangential velocity points along the positive -axis (), not the negative -axis.
- Step 3Correct
and
You set up the constant-velocity position formulas correctly, but the negative sign from your previous velocity step carried over into .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou clearly applied Newton's First Law to disprove the radial-escape misconception.
You recognized that an object undergoing circular motion has a purely tangential velocity vector.
You correctly integrated zero horizontal acceleration to form linear parametric equations in time.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou reversed the sign of the tangential velocity component by treating counterclockwise motion as clockwise.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou may have visualized the circle's rotation direction backwards at the positive -axis intercept, forgetting that counterclockwise (standard positive angular direction) rotates from toward .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Tangent Direction Check
In standard Cartesian coordinates, counterclockwise motion follows the unit tangent vector .
Sketch the circle with directional arrows before writing coordinate components to ensure counterclockwise points toward increasing angle .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationIdentify the angle of the stone at as .
For counterclockwise motion at , the instantaneous tangent points in the -direction: .
With zero net force after the break, the stone moves with constant velocity: and .
and (for )
03 The student combines tangential and radial outward velocities, incorrectly believing the stone travels diagonally outward at a 45-degree angle.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
By Newton's First Law, the stone keeps moving forward along the tangent while the released outward inertia pushes it away from the center. Thus, the stone moves diagonally outward between the tangent and the radius.
CorrectInstantaneous velocity in circular motion is purely tangential, meaning the radial component is zero (). By Newton's First Law, when the string breaks and net force becomes zero, the stone continues in a straight line along its instantaneous tangent vector, with no outward radial motion.
You treated inertia as an active outward force or velocity source. Inertia is not a force; it is simply the tendency of an object to maintain its existing state of motion. Because the stone has zero radial velocity at the instant of release, it cannot travel diagonally outward.
- Step 2
The velocity has both outward radial component and tangential component .
Correctand
Because of the misconception introduced in part (a), you assigned an outward velocity . At in counterclockwise circular motion, the tangent points entirely in the -direction, so the initial velocity along the -axis is zero.
- Step 3
x(t) = 1.50 + 8.50t y(t) = 8.50t
Correctx(t) = 1.50 \quad \quad y(t) = (8.50)t
Your equation for correctly reflects the tangential motion, but is affected by the erroneous radial velocity component.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly identified that the stone retains tangential motion immediately upon release.
You correctly integrated the tangential velocity component into your parametric equation for .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou treated 'inertia' as an active outward push that creates a radial velocity component, rather than recognizing that inertia merely preserves the stone's existing, purely tangential velocity vector.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Direction of Instantaneous Velocity
In circular motion, the velocity vector is always purely tangent to the circle: , so .
Always draw the instantaneous velocity vector as purely perpendicular to the radius vector before setting up motion equations.
- Newton's First Law (Inertial Frame)
When , an object moves in a straight line along its instantaneous velocity vector: .
Do not invent new velocity components that were not present right before the net force vanished.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationAt , the counterclockwise tangent vector points along the positive -axis.
Identify the instantaneous velocity components: and .
Apply Newton's First Law with zero acceleration: and .
and
Lock it in
What is the direction of an object's instantaneous velocity vector during circular motion relative to its position vector from the center?
Instantaneous velocity is always purely tangential and perpendicular to the radius vector (, so ).
Similar question
A puck on a frictionless horizontal table is tethered to a central peg at and moves counterclockwise in a circle of radius at a constant speed of . The string snaps when the puck is at . Write the parametric equations of motion and for .
Answer
At , counterclockwise motion has a tangent pointing in the negative -direction, so and . By Newton's First Law, and .
A small metal sphere is whirled in a horizontal circle of radius centered at the origin in a clockwise direction at . At , the sphere is at when it is released. Determine the position vector of the sphere at .
Answer
At moving clockwise, the tangential velocity points along , so . The position function is . At , .
A car travels counterclockwise around a circular track of radius centered at at a constant speed of . At the moment the car is at , it hits a patch of frictionless ice. (a) State the direction of motion on the ice. (b) Find the distance between the car and the track's center at after hitting the ice.
Answer
(a) The car moves along the tangent line in the -direction with constant velocity . (b) At , and . The distance from the center is .