Resources

An electron in a semiconductor quantum well has an effective position given by x(t)=4.0t+2.0t2x(t) = 4.0t + 2.0t^2, where xx is in micrometers (μm\mu\text{m}) and tt is in picoseconds (ps\text{ps}). To evaluate the instantaneous velocity at t0=3.0 pst_0 = 3.0\text{ ps} strictly from first principles, compute the average velocity vˉΔt=x(t0+Δt)−x(t0)Δt\bar{v}_{\Delta t} = \frac{x(t_0 + \Delta t) - x(t_0)}{\Delta t} across finite time increments of Δt=0.10 ps\Delta t = 0.10\text{ ps}, Δt=0.010 ps\Delta t = 0.010\text{ ps}, and determine the exact analytical limit as Δt→0\Delta t \to 0. Express the limiting instantaneous velocity in μm/ps\mu\text{m/ps}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

For Δt=0.10 ps\Delta t = 0.10\text{ ps}, vˉ=16.2μm/ps\bar{v} = 16.2\mu\text{m/ps}; for Δt=0.010 ps\Delta t = 0.010\text{ ps}, vˉ=16.02μm/ps\bar{v} = 16.02\mu\text{m/ps}; limiting instantaneous velocity lim⁡Δt→0vˉΔt=16.0μm/ps\lim_{\Delta t \to 0} \bar{v}_{\Delta t} = 16.0\mu\text{m/ps}.

Steps

01

Formulate the General Expression for Average Velocity

The average velocity over a time interval from t0t_0 to t0+Δtt_0 + \Delta t is defined as the change in position divided by the elapsed time:

vˉΔt=ΔxΔt=x(t0+Δt)−x(t0)Δt\bar{v}_{\Delta t} = \frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t} = \frac{x(t_0 + \Delta t) - x(t_0)}{\Delta t}

Given the position function x(t)=4.0t+2.0t2x(t) = 4.0t + 2.0t^2 and the initial time t0=3.0 pst_0 = 3.0\text{ ps}:

  1. Calculate the initial position at t0=3.0 pst_0 = 3.0\text{ ps}: x(3.0)=4.0(3.0)+2.0(3.0)2=12.0+18.0=30.0 μmx(3.0) = 4.0(3.0) + 2.0(3.0)^2 = 12.0 + 18.0 = 30.0\ \mu\text{m}
  2. Expand the position function at t0+Δt=3.0+Δtt_0 + \Delta t = 3.0 + \Delta t: x(3.0+Δt)=4.0(3.0+Δt)+2.0(3.0+Δt)2x(3.0 + \Delta t) = 4.0(3.0 + \Delta t) + 2.0(3.0 + \Delta t)^2 x(3.0+Δt)=12.0+4.0Δt+2.0(9.0+6.0Δt+(Δt)2)x(3.0 + \Delta t) = 12.0 + 4.0\Delta t + 2.0\left(9.0 + 6.0\Delta t + (\Delta t)^2\right) x(3.0+Δt)=12.0+4.0Δt+18.0+12.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2x(3.0 + \Delta t) = 12.0 + 4.0\Delta t + 18.0 + 12.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2 x(3.0+Δt)=30.0+16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2x(3.0 + \Delta t) = 30.0 + 16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2
  3. Subtract x(3.0)x(3.0) to determine the displacement Δx\Delta x: Δx=x(3.0+Δt)−x(3.0)=16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2\Delta x = x(3.0 + \Delta t) - x(3.0) = 16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2
  4. Divide by Δt\Delta t (for Δt≠0\Delta t \neq 0): vˉΔt=16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2Δt=16.0+2.0Δt\bar{v}_{\Delta t} = \frac{16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2}{\Delta t} = 16.0 + 2.0\Delta t

02

Calculate vˉ\bar{v} for the Finite Increments

Using the derived relation vˉΔt=16.0+2.0Δt\bar{v}_{\Delta t} = 16.0 + 2.0\Delta t:

  • For Δt=0.10 ps\Delta t = 0.10\text{ ps}: vˉ0.10=16.0+2.0(0.10)=16.2 μm/ps\bar{v}_{0.10} = 16.0 + 2.0(0.10) = 16.2\ \mu\text{m/ps}
  • For Δt=0.010 ps\Delta t = 0.010\text{ ps}: vˉ0.010=16.0+2.0(0.010)=16.02 μm/ps\bar{v}_{0.010} = 16.0 + 2.0(0.010) = 16.02\ \mu\text{m/ps}

03

Determine the Limiting Instantaneous Velocity

The instantaneous velocity v(t0)v(t_0) is the analytical limit of the average velocity as the elapsed time Δt\Delta t approaches zero:

v(3.0)=lim⁡Δt→0vˉΔt=lim⁡Δt→0(16.0+2.0Δt)=16.0 μm/psv(3.0) = \lim_{\Delta t \to 0} \bar{v}_{\Delta t} = \lim_{\Delta t \to 0} (16.0 + 2.0\Delta t) = 16.0\ \mu\text{m/ps}

Common Pitfall: Setting Δt=0\Delta t = 0 before simplifying leads to an indeterminate form 00\frac{0}{0}. The term Δt\Delta t must first be factored out and canceled from numerator and denominator before evaluating the limit.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student forgets to square the binomial term when expanding (3.0 + Δt)², incorrectly writing 3.0² + Δt² without the cross term, leading to an incorrect difference quotient and limit.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    x(3.0)=4.0(3.0)+2.0(3.0)2=30.0 μm  ⟹  x(3.1)=4.0(3.1)+2.0(3.1)2=31.62 μm  ⟹  vˉ0.10=31.62−30.00.10=16.2 μm/psx(3.0) = 4.0(3.0) + 2.0(3.0)^2 = 30.0\ \mu\text{m} \implies x(3.1) = 4.0(3.1) + 2.0(3.1)^2 = 31.62\ \mu\text{m} \implies \bar{v}_{0.10} = \frac{31.62 - 30.0}{0.10} = 16.2\ \mu\text{m/ps}

  2. Step 2

    x(3.01)=4.0(3.01)+2.0(3.01)2=30.1602 μm  ⟹  vˉ0.010=30.1602−30.00.010=16.02 μm/psx(3.01) = 4.0(3.01) + 2.0(3.01)^2 = 30.1602\ \mu\text{m} \implies \bar{v}_{0.010} = \frac{30.1602 - 30.0}{0.010} = 16.02\ \mu\text{m/ps}

  3. Step 3

    x(3.0+Δt)=4.0(3.0+Δt)+2.0(3.02+Δt2)  ⟹  x(3.0+Δt)−x(3.0)=12.0+4.0Δt+18.0+2.0(Δt)2−30.0=4.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2x(3.0 + \Delta t) = 4.0(3.0 + \Delta t) + 2.0(3.0^2 + \Delta t^2) \implies x(3.0 + \Delta t) - x(3.0) = 12.0 + 4.0\Delta t + 18.0 + 2.0(\Delta t)^2 - 30.0 = 4.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2

    Correct

    x(3.0+Δt)=4.0(3.0+Δt)+2.0(3.0+Δt)2=30.0+16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2  ⟹  Δx=16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2x(3.0 + \Delta t) = 4.0(3.0 + \Delta t) + 2.0(3.0 + \Delta t)^2 = 30.0 + 16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2 \implies \Delta x = 16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2

    You expanded (3.0+Δt)2(3.0 + \Delta t)^2 as 3.02+Δt23.0^2 + \Delta t^2, omitting the middle cross term 2(3.0)(Δt)=6.0Δt2(3.0)(\Delta t) = 6.0\Delta t. Multiplying by 2.02.0 would add 12.0Δt12.0\Delta t to the linear term.

  4. Step 4

    vˉΔt=4.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2Δt=4.0+2.0Δt  ⟹  lim⁡Δt→0(4.0+2.0Δt)=4.0 μm/ps\bar{v}_{\Delta t} = \frac{4.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2}{\Delta t} = 4.0 + 2.0\Delta t \implies \lim_{\Delta t \to 0} (4.0 + 2.0\Delta t) = 4.0\ \mu\text{m/ps}

    Correct

    vˉΔt=16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2Δt=16.0+2.0Δt  ⟹  lim⁡Δt→0(16.0+2.0Δt)=16.0 μm/ps\bar{v}_{\Delta t} = \frac{16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2}{\Delta t} = 16.0 + 2.0\Delta t \implies \lim_{\Delta t \to 0} (16.0 + 2.0\Delta t) = 16.0\ \mu\text{m/ps}

    Your limit evaluation process was structurally correct, but the resulting numerical value was affected by the missing cross term in Step 3.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the numerical average velocities for both finite increments Δt=0.10 ps\Delta t = 0.10\text{ ps} and Δt=0.010 ps\Delta t = 0.010\text{ ps}.

You correctly set up the difference quotient definition of average velocity and evaluated the limit as Δt→0\Delta t \to 0.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Algebraic Expansion Error

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the square of a sum (a+b)2(a + b)^2 as the sum of squares a2+b2a^2 + b^2, omitting the cross term 2ab2ab. Notice that your numerical answers (16.216.2 and 16.0216.02) clearly approached 16.016.0, which is a helpful clue that your analytical limit of 4.04.0 was missing a term.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Binomial Expansion Identity
  • (a+b)2=a2+2ab+b2(a + b)^2 = a^2 + 2ab + b^2

  • Always write out all three terms when squaring a binomial before distributing coefficients.

Sanity Check with Numerical Trends
  • As Δt→0\Delta t \to 0, finite difference values vˉΔt\bar{v}_{\Delta t} must converge toward the analytical limit.

  • Compare your analytical limit (4.04.0) with your numerical progression (16.2→16.0216.2 \to 16.02); a mismatch signals an algebraic error.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Expand the quadratic term: (3.0+Δt)2=3.02+2(3.0)(Δt)+(Δt)2=9.0+6.0Δt+(Δt)2(3.0 + \Delta t)^2 = 3.0^2 + 2(3.0)(\Delta t) + (\Delta t)^2 = 9.0 + 6.0\Delta t + (\Delta t)^2.

  2. Substitute into x(3.0+Δt)x(3.0 + \Delta t): 4.0(3.0+Δt)+2.0(9.0+6.0Δt+(Δt)2)=12.0+4.0Δt+18.0+12.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2=30.0+16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)24.0(3.0 + \Delta t) + 2.0(9.0 + 6.0\Delta t + (\Delta t)^2) = 12.0 + 4.0\Delta t + 18.0 + 12.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2 = 30.0 + 16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2.

  3. Subtract x(3.0)=30.0x(3.0) = 30.0: Δx=16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2\Delta x = 16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2.

  4. Divide by Δt\Delta t: vˉΔt=16.0+2.0Δt\bar{v}_{\Delta t} = 16.0 + 2.0\Delta t.

  5. Take the limit: lim⁡Δt→0(16.0+2.0Δt)=16.0 μm/ps\lim_{\Delta t \to 0}(16.0 + 2.0\Delta t) = 16.0\ \mu\text{m/ps}.

Final answer

lim⁡Δt→0vˉΔt=16.0 μm/ps\lim_{\Delta t \to 0} \bar{v}_{\Delta t} = 16.0\ \mu\text{m/ps}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Practice expanding binomials (t0+Δt)2(t_0 + \Delta t)^2 carefully by writing the middle term 2t0Δt2t_0\Delta t explicitly.

  • Use your numerical calculations as a built-in check: the sequence 16.2,16.02,…16.2, 16.02, \dots must approach your algebraic limit.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student divides only the change in position by the final time instead of the time increment Δt, calculating x(t₀ + Δt) - x(t₀) divided by t₀ + Δt.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    x(3.0)=4.0(3.0)+2.0(3.0)2=30.0 μm  ⟹  x(3.10)=4.0(3.10)+2.0(3.10)2=31.62 μm  ⟹  vˉ0.10=31.62−30.03.10=1.623.10=0.523 μm/psx(3.0) = 4.0(3.0) + 2.0(3.0)^2 = 30.0\ \mu\text{m} \implies x(3.10) = 4.0(3.10) + 2.0(3.10)^2 = 31.62\ \mu\text{m} \implies \bar{v}_{0.10} = \frac{31.62 - 30.0}{3.10} = \frac{1.62}{3.10} = 0.523\ \mu\text{m/ps}

    Correct

    vˉ0.10=x(3.10)−x(3.0)0.10=1.620.10=16.2 μm/ps\bar{v}_{0.10} = \frac{x(3.10) - x(3.0)}{0.10} = \frac{1.62}{0.10} = 16.2\ \mu\text{m/ps}

    You found the correct positions x(3.0)=30.0 μmx(3.0) = 30.0\ \mu\text{m} and x(3.10)=31.62 μmx(3.10) = 31.62\ \mu\text{m}, but you placed the final time 3.10 ps3.10\text{ ps} in the denominator instead of the elapsed interval Δt=0.10 ps\Delta t = 0.10\text{ ps}.

  2. Step 2

    x(3.010)=4.0(3.010)+2.0(3.010)2=30.1602 μm  ⟹  vˉ0.010=30.1602−30.03.010=0.16023.010=0.0532 μm/psx(3.010) = 4.0(3.010) + 2.0(3.010)^2 = 30.1602\ \mu\text{m} \implies \bar{v}_{0.010} = \frac{30.1602 - 30.0}{3.010} = \frac{0.1602}{3.010} = 0.0532\ \mu\text{m/ps}

    Correct

    vˉ0.010=x(3.010)−x(3.0)0.010=0.16020.010=16.02 μm/ps\bar{v}_{0.010} = \frac{x(3.010) - x(3.0)}{0.010} = \frac{0.1602}{0.010} = 16.02\ \mu\text{m/ps}

    You correctly computed x(3.010)=30.1602 μmx(3.010) = 30.1602\ \mu\text{m}, but you again divided by the final time 3.010 ps3.010\text{ ps} rather than Δt=0.010 ps\Delta t = 0.010\text{ ps}.

  3. Step 3

    x(3.0+Δt)−x(3.0)=16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2  ⟹  vˉΔt=16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)23.0+Δtx(3.0 + \Delta t) - x(3.0) = 16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2 \implies \bar{v}_{\Delta t} = \frac{16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2}{3.0 + \Delta t}

    Correct

    vˉΔt=x(3.0+Δt)−x(3.0)Δt=16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2Δt=16.0+2.0Δt\bar{v}_{\Delta t} = \frac{x(3.0 + \Delta t) - x(3.0)}{\Delta t} = \frac{16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2}{\Delta t} = 16.0 + 2.0\Delta t

    You expanded the displacement Δx=16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2\Delta x = 16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2 accurately, but you defined average velocity as Δxt0+Δt\frac{\Delta x}{t_0 + \Delta t} instead of ΔxΔt\frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t}.

  4. Step 4

    lim⁡Δt→0[Δt(16.0+2.0Δt)3.0+Δt]=0 μm/ps\lim_{\Delta t \to 0} \left[ \frac{\Delta t(16.0 + 2.0\Delta t)}{3.0 + \Delta t} \right] = 0\ \mu\text{m/ps}

    Correct

    v(3.0)=lim⁡Δt→0(16.0+2.0Δt)=16.0 μm/psv(3.0) = \lim_{\Delta t \to 0} (16.0 + 2.0\Delta t) = 16.0\ \mu\text{m/ps}

    Your limit calculation followed consistently from your incorrect expression, leading to an apparent velocity of 0 μm/ps0\ \mu\text{m/ps} because the factor of Δt\Delta t remained in the numerator.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly evaluated the position values x(3.0)x(3.0), x(3.10)x(3.10), and x(3.010)x(3.010).

You correctly expanded the polynomial difference x(3.0+Δt)−x(3.0)x(3.0 + \Delta t) - x(3.0) to get 16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)216.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2.

You correctly applied algebraic factoring when taking your final limit.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Confusing Elapsed Time with Clock Time

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused elapsed time interval (Δt=t2−t1\Delta t = t_2 - t_1) with the instantaneous clock reading (t2t_2). Average rate of change always divides by the change in the independent variable, not the final coordinate.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Average Velocity Definition
  • vˉ=ΔxΔt=x(t2)−x(t1)t2−t1\bar{v} = \frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t} = \frac{x(t_2) - x(t_1)}{t_2 - t_1}

  • Always verify that the denominator is strictly the difference between the two times (t2−t1=Δtt_2 - t_1 = \Delta t), never just t2t_2.

First-Principles Limit Form
  • v(t0)=lim⁡Δt→0x(t0+Δt)−x(t0)Δtv(t_0) = \lim_{\Delta t \to 0} \frac{x(t_0 + \Delta t) - x(t_0)}{\Delta t}

  • Check that dividing by Δt\Delta t cancels the first-order Δt\Delta t in the numerator, leaving a non-zero constant term as Δt→0\Delta t \to 0.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Divide the displacement by Δt\Delta t: vˉΔt=16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2Δt=16.0+2.0Δt\bar{v}_{\Delta t} = \frac{16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2}{\Delta t} = 16.0 + 2.0\Delta t.

  2. Evaluate for Δt=0.10 ps\Delta t = 0.10\text{ ps}: vˉ0.10=16.0+2.0(0.10)=16.2 μm/ps\bar{v}_{0.10} = 16.0 + 2.0(0.10) = 16.2\ \mu\text{m/ps}.

  3. Evaluate for Δt=0.010 ps\Delta t = 0.010\text{ ps}: vˉ0.010=16.0+2.0(0.010)=16.02 μm/ps\bar{v}_{0.010} = 16.0 + 2.0(0.010) = 16.02\ \mu\text{m/ps}.

  4. Take the limit as Δt→0\Delta t \to 0: v(3.0)=lim⁡Δt→0(16.0+2.0Δt)=16.0 μm/psv(3.0) = \lim_{\Delta t \to 0}(16.0 + 2.0\Delta t) = 16.0\ \mu\text{m/ps}.

Final answer

For Δt=0.10 ps\Delta t = 0.10\text{ ps}, vˉ=16.2 μm/ps\bar{v} = 16.2\ \mu\text{m/ps}; for Δt=0.010 ps\Delta t = 0.010\text{ ps}, vˉ=16.02 μm/ps\bar{v} = 16.02\ \mu\text{m/ps}; limiting instantaneous velocity is 16.0 μm/ps16.0\ \mu\text{m/ps}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Rework finite difference quotients by explicitly writing Δt=tf−ti\Delta t = t_f - t_i in the denominator before substituting numbers.

  • Practice deriving instantaneous velocity algebraically from v(t)=lim⁡Δt→0ΔxΔtv(t) = \lim_{\Delta t \to 0} \frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t} for quadratic and cubic position functions.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student computes the average velocity as the simple arithmetic average of the position values x(t₀ + Δt) and x(t₀) rather than their difference divided by Δt.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    x(3.0)=4.0(3.0)+2.0(3.0)2=30.0 μm  ⟹  x(3.10)=4.0(3.10)+2.0(3.10)2=31.62 μm  ⟹  vˉ0.10=30.0+31.622=30.81 μm/psx(3.0) = 4.0(3.0) + 2.0(3.0)^2 = 30.0\ \mu\text{m} \implies x(3.10) = 4.0(3.10) + 2.0(3.10)^2 = 31.62\ \mu\text{m} \implies \bar{v}_{0.10} = \frac{30.0 + 31.62}{2} = 30.81\ \mu\text{m/ps}

    Correct

    vˉ0.10=x(3.10)−x(3.0)0.10=31.62−30.00.10=16.2 μm/ps\bar{v}_{0.10} = \frac{x(3.10) - x(3.0)}{0.10} = \frac{31.62 - 30.0}{0.10} = 16.2\ \mu\text{m/ps}

    You correctly calculated the positions x(3.0)=30.0 μmx(3.0) = 30.0\ \mu\text{m} and x(3.10)=31.62 μmx(3.10) = 31.62\ \mu\text{m}. However, average velocity is defined as displacement divided by elapsed time, ΔxΔt\frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t}, not the arithmetic midpoint of the two position values.

  2. Step 2

    x(3.010)=4.0(3.010)+2.0(3.010)2=30.1602 μm  ⟹  vˉ0.010=30.0+30.16022=30.0801 μm/psx(3.010) = 4.0(3.010) + 2.0(3.010)^2 = 30.1602\ \mu\text{m} \implies \bar{v}_{0.010} = \frac{30.0 + 30.1602}{2} = 30.0801\ \mu\text{m/ps}

    Correct

    vˉ0.010=x(3.010)−x(3.0)0.010=30.1602−30.00.010=16.02 μm/ps\bar{v}_{0.010} = \frac{x(3.010) - x(3.0)}{0.010} = \frac{30.1602 - 30.0}{0.010} = 16.02\ \mu\text{m/ps}

    You accurately found x(3.010)=30.1602 μmx(3.010) = 30.1602\ \mu\text{m}, but you again averaged the two positions together instead of dividing the difference Δx=30.1602−30.0\Delta x = 30.1602 - 30.0 by Δt=0.010 ps\Delta t = 0.010\ \text{ps}.

  3. Step 3

    x(3.0+Δt)=30.0+16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2  ⟹  vˉΔt=30.0+30.0+16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)22=30.0+8.0Δt+(Δt)2  ⟹  lim⁡Δt→0(30.0+8.0Δt+(Δt)2)=30.0 μm/psx(3.0 + \Delta t) = 30.0 + 16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2 \implies \bar{v}_{\Delta t} = \frac{30.0 + 30.0 + 16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2}{2} = 30.0 + 8.0\Delta t + (\Delta t)^2 \implies \lim_{\Delta t \to 0} (30.0 + 8.0\Delta t + (\Delta t)^2) = 30.0\ \mu\text{m/ps}

    Correct

    vˉΔt=x(3.0+Δt)−x(3.0)Δt=16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2Δt=16.0+2.0Δt  ⟹  lim⁡Δt→0(16.0+2.0Δt)=16.0 μm/ps\bar{v}_{\Delta t} = \frac{x(3.0 + \Delta t) - x(3.0)}{\Delta t} = \frac{16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2}{\Delta t} = 16.0 + 2.0\Delta t \implies \lim_{\Delta t \to 0} (16.0 + 2.0\Delta t) = 16.0\ \mu\text{m/ps}

    You expanded x(3.0+Δt)x(3.0 + \Delta t) completely correctly. However, defining vˉΔt\bar{v}_{\Delta t} as x(t0)+x(t0+Δt)2\frac{x(t_0) + x(t_0+\Delta t)}{2} gives an expression whose limit as Δt→0\Delta t \to 0 is the position x(3.0)=30.0 μmx(3.0) = 30.0\ \mu\text{m}, rather than the instantaneous rate of change.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly substituted time values into x(t)=4.0t+2.0t2x(t) = 4.0t + 2.0t^2 to find exact position values.

You executed the algebraic binomial expansion of x(3.0+Δt)x(3.0 + \Delta t) accurately.

You correctly evaluated the mathematical limit of your derived algebraic expression as Δt→0\Delta t \to 0.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Definition Confusion: Arithmetic Mean vs. Rate of Change

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You conflated the everyday statistical meaning of 'average' (the arithmetic mean of two numbers, a+b2\frac{a+b}{2}) with the kinematic definition of 'average velocity' (the ratio of displacement to elapsed time, ΔxΔt\frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t}). Notice also that x1+x22\frac{x_1 + x_2}{2} has units of distance (μm\mu\text{m}), whereas velocity must have units of distance over time (μm/ps\mu\text{m/ps}).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Kinematic Definition of Average Velocity
  • Average velocity over a time interval Δt\Delta t is always vˉ=ΔxΔt=x(t0+Δt)−x(t0)Δt\bar{v} = \frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t} = \frac{x(t_0 + \Delta t) - x(t_0)}{\Delta t}.

  • Subtract the initial position from the final position to find Δx\Delta x, then divide by the elapsed time Δt\Delta t.

Dimensional Analysis Sanity Check
  • Velocity requires dimensions of [length]/[time][\text{length}] / [\text{time}].

  • Always verify that your formula divides by elapsed time Δt\Delta t; dividing the sum of two lengths by a dimensionless scalar 2 leaves units of length, not speed.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Form the difference Δx=x(3.0+Δt)−x(3.0)=16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2\Delta x = x(3.0 + \Delta t) - x(3.0) = 16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2.

  2. Divide by Δt\Delta t: vˉΔt=16.0Δt+2.0(Δt)2Δt=16.0+2.0Δt\bar{v}_{\Delta t} = \frac{16.0\Delta t + 2.0(\Delta t)^2}{\Delta t} = 16.0 + 2.0\Delta t.

  3. Substitute Δt=0.10 ps\Delta t = 0.10\ \text{ps}: vˉ0.10=16.0+2.0(0.10)=16.2 μm/ps\bar{v}_{0.10} = 16.0 + 2.0(0.10) = 16.2\ \mu\text{m/ps}.

  4. Substitute Δt=0.010 ps\Delta t = 0.010\ \text{ps}: vˉ0.010=16.0+2.0(0.010)=16.02 μm/ps\bar{v}_{0.010} = 16.0 + 2.0(0.010) = 16.02\ \mu\text{m/ps}.

  5. Take the limit: v(3.0)=lim⁡Δt→0(16.0+2.0Δt)=16.0 μm/psv(3.0) = \lim_{\Delta t \to 0} (16.0 + 2.0\Delta t) = 16.0\ \mu\text{m/ps}.

Final answer

For Δt=0.10 ps\Delta t = 0.10\ \text{ps}, vˉ=16.2 μm/ps\bar{v} = 16.2\ \mu\text{m/ps}; for Δt=0.010 ps\Delta t = 0.010\ \text{ps}, vˉ=16.02 μm/ps\bar{v} = 16.02\ \mu\text{m/ps}; limiting instantaneous velocity is 16.0 μm/ps16.0\ \mu\text{m/ps}.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the distinction between the arithmetic midpoint of positions, x1+x22\frac{x_1 + x_2}{2}, and average velocity, x2−x1t2−t1\frac{x_2 - x_1}{t_2 - t_1}.

  • Practice computing difference quotients f(t0+Δt)−f(t0)Δt\frac{f(t_0+\Delta t) - f(t_0)}{\Delta t} and factoring out Δt\Delta t before taking the limit Δt→0\Delta t \to 0.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A particle moves along a straight line with position x(t)=3.0t2+5.0tx(t) = 3.0t^2 + 5.0t (in meters, tt in seconds). Using first principles, expand x(2.0+Δt)−x(2.0)x(2.0 + \Delta t) - x(2.0) and find the instantaneous velocity v(2.0)v(2.0).

Answer

v(2.0)=17 m/sv(2.0) = 17\text{ m/s}. Expand x(2.0+Δt)=3.0(4.0+4.0Δt+(Δt)2)+5.0(2.0+Δt)=22.0+17.0Δt+3.0(Δt)2x(2.0 + \Delta t) = 3.0(4.0 + 4.0\Delta t + (\Delta t)^2) + 5.0(2.0 + \Delta t) = 22.0 + 17.0\Delta t + 3.0(\Delta t)^2. Then Δx=17.0Δt+3.0(Δt)2\Delta x = 17.0\Delta t + 3.0(\Delta t)^2, so vˉ=17.0+3.0Δt→17 m/s\bar{v} = 17.0 + 3.0\Delta t \to 17\text{ m/s}.

02

An ion moves in an electric field with position y(t)=1.5t2−4.0ty(t) = 1.5t^2 - 4.0t (in mm, tt in ms). Compute the average velocity for Δt=0.05 ms\Delta t = 0.05\text{ ms} starting at t0=4.0 mst_0 = 4.0\text{ ms}, and determine the exact instantaneous velocity v(4.0)v(4.0) via the limit of the difference quotient.

Answer

vˉ0.05=8.075 mm/ms\bar{v}_{0.05} = 8.075\text{ mm/ms} and v(4.0)=8.0 mm/msv(4.0) = 8.0\text{ mm/ms}. With y(4.0+Δt)−y(4.0)=8.0Δt+1.5(Δt)2y(4.0 + \Delta t) - y(4.0) = 8.0\Delta t + 1.5(\Delta t)^2, the difference quotient is 8.0+1.5Δt8.0 + 1.5\Delta t. For Δt=0.05\Delta t = 0.05, vˉ=8.075 mm/ms\bar{v} = 8.075\text{ mm/ms}; as Δt→0\Delta t \to 0, v(4.0)=8.0 mm/msv(4.0) = 8.0\text{ mm/ms}.

03

A quantum dot carrier position is given by s(t)=t3s(t) = t^3 (in nm, tt in ps). Find the instantaneous velocity at t=2.0 pst = 2.0\text{ ps} strictly from the definition of the derivative by expanding (2.0+Δt)3(2.0 + \Delta t)^3.

Answer

v(2.0)=12 nm/psv(2.0) = 12\text{ nm/ps}. Using the binomial expansion (2.0+Δt)3=8.0+12.0Δt+6.0(Δt)2+(Δt)3(2.0 + \Delta t)^3 = 8.0 + 12.0\Delta t + 6.0(\Delta t)^2 + (\Delta t)^3, subtract s(2.0)=8.0s(2.0) = 8.0 to get Δs=12.0Δt+6.0(Δt)2+(Δt)3\Delta s = 12.0\Delta t + 6.0(\Delta t)^2 + (\Delta t)^3. Dividing by Δt\Delta t gives 12.0+6.0Δt+(Δt)212.0 + 6.0\Delta t + (\Delta t)^2, which approaches 12 nm/ps12\text{ nm/ps} as Δt→0\Delta t \to 0.

Loading workspace…