Resources
An airplane flies horizontally through a steady wind blowing due east with a speed of . The airspeed (speed of the airplane relative to the surrounding air) is a constant . The airplane makes a round-trip between two airfields separated by a distance . Path 1 connects two cities on an east-west line (parallel to the wind), while Path 2 connects two cities on a north-south line (perpendicular to the wind). (a) Calculate the total round-trip flight time for Path 1. (b) Calculate the total round-trip flight time for Path 2. (c) Determine the ratio and explain why the wind increases the travel time for both round trips compared to calm air.
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) (); (b) (); (c)
Steps
Part (a): Round-Trip Flight Time for Path 1 (Parallel to the Wind)
Convert the separation distance into standard SI units:
On the east-west line, the wind blows due east at , and the airplane's airspeed is .
- Downwind leg (flying east, with the wind): The ground speed is the sum of the airplane's airspeed and the wind speed: The travel time is:
- Upwind leg (flying west, against the wind): The ground speed is reduced by the wind: The travel time is:
- Total round-trip time :
Part (b): Round-Trip Flight Time for Path 2 (Perpendicular to the Wind)
On the north-south line, the airplane must maintain a straight ground track perpendicular to the eastward wind.
- Ground speed calculation: Using vector addition for relative velocity, . To travel directly north or south, the airplane must aim slightly upwind (west of north or west of south) so that its eastward velocity component cancels the wind. The magnitude of the ground speed forms the adjacent side of a right triangle where the airspeed is the hypotenuse:
- Total round-trip time : Because both legs (northbound and southbound) have the identical ground speed , the time for each leg is identical:
Part (c): Ratio of Times and Physical Explanation
- Ratio of travel times: In algebraic terms, this ratio is given by:
-
Why wind increases travel time for both paths compared to calm air: In calm air (), the round trip takes ().
- For Path 1 (Parallel): A common misconception is that the time gained from a tailwind exactly balances the time lost to an equal headwind. However, travel time is inversely proportional to speed (). Because the plane travels slower against the headwind (), it spends considerably more time () fighting the wind than it spends enjoying the boost from the tailwind ( at ). Consequently, the time lost always exceeds the time saved, leading to a net increase in total time ().
- For Path 2 (Perpendicular): To prevent drifting off course, the airplane must angle its heading into the wind. A portion of its airspeed is redirected toward countering the wind drift, which inherently reduces the forward component along the intended ground track to , resulting in a longer travel time ().
Typical errors
01 The student assumes tailwind and headwind gains and losses cancel out symmetrically, giving a round-trip time identical to calm air for Path 1.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
= v = 160 T_{} = = = 4500_
Correctt_{} = = = 1800,\quad t_{} = = = 3000 T_{\parallel} = 1800 + 3000 = 4800_
A headwind and tailwind do not cancel over equal distances because the airplane spends more time traveling at the slower upwind speed () than at the faster downwind speed (). You must compute the travel time for each leg separately and sum them.
- Step 2
v_{} = = 154.92 T_{} = 4648
- Step 3
= 0.968
CorrectBecause your value for came from the cancellation assumption, your calculated ratio was instead of . The wind increases the round-trip time for Path 1 because the time lost flying against the headwind () exceeds the time saved flying with the tailwind ().
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly converted kilometers to meters for the flight distance.
You accurately calculated the ground speed and round-trip flight time for the perpendicular path using the Pythagorean theorem.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo, this was a conceptual misconception regarding how headwind and tailwind affect travel times over fixed distances.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed that equal opposing wind speeds cancel out over equal distances, treating the average speed as the simple arithmetic mean of the speeds. In physics, when equal distances are traversed at different speeds, the average speed is the harmonic mean because more time is spent at the lower speed.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Time per leg vs. Average speed
When distances are equal, calculate the time of each leg independently using , then sum the times: .
Always compute individual leg durations and before combining them, rather than averaging the velocities directly.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationCalculate the downwind travel time: .
Calculate the upwind travel time: .
Sum the two legs to find : .
Evaluate the ratio of the two round trips: .
(a) (); (b) (); (c)
02 The student incorrectly adds the wind speed in quadrature to find ground speed on the crosswind path instead of using the airspeed as the hypotenuse.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
- Step 2Correct
To maintain a straight track due north or south, the plane must angle its nose slightly into the wind. In the vector triangle , the airspeed is the hypotenuse and the ground velocity is perpendicular to the wind . Therefore, , not .
- Step 3Correct
Your division is mathematically consistent with your previous value of , but it is numerically affected by the earlier ground speed error.
- Step 4
Wind increases Path 1 time because more time is spent at lower speed, while on Path 2 wind increases the total velocity.
CorrectWind increases travel time on Path 1 because more time is spent against the headwind than with the tailwind. On Path 2, the plane must head into the wind to prevent drifting, reducing its forward ground speed to , which increases round-trip travel time.
Your reasoning for Path 1 is accurate. However, on Path 2, the wind does not increase the ground velocity; it forces the aircraft to steer partially upwind, which decreases the speed along the intended ground track and increases travel time.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly converted the distance into meters.
You accurately found the downwind and upwind ground speeds for the parallel path.
You clearly explained why a tailwind does not fully compensate for a headwind on Path 1.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo, this is a conceptual misunderstanding about how relative velocity vectors combine to achieve a desired crosswind ground track.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou assumed the airplane points perpendicular to the wind and lets the wind blow it faster, rather than recognizing that the plane must crab into the wind so that the resultant ground track is purely perpendicular to the wind.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Resultant Track Condition
When a craft must follow a specific ground track across a current, the resultant ground velocity vector must lie entirely along that track.
Draw along the desired path first, then form the vector triangle .
- Hypotenuse Identification
In crosswind tracking where , the airspeed forms the hypotenuse of the right triangle.
Use , ensuring whenever crosswinds are present.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up the right triangle where is the hypotenuse of magnitude and the wind is an eastward leg of magnitude .
Compute the perpendicular ground speed: .
Calculate the perpendicular round-trip time: .
Evaluate the time ratio: .
(a) ; (b) ; (c) , and wind increases travel time for both paths because headwind delay outweighs tailwind gain on Path 1, while crabbing into the wind lowers forward ground speed on Path 2.
03 The student neglects to convert the path distance from kilometers to meters, producing inconsistent flight times by a factor of 1000.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
You correctly found the ground speeds with and against the wind, but you substituted directly instead of converting kilometers to meters ().
- Step 2Correct
You correctly applied the Pythagorean theorem to calculate the ground speed across the wind, but you again used rather than converting it to .
- Step 3
; On Path 1 the airplane spends longer flying against the wind, and on Path 2 part of the plane velocity must oppose the crosswind.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly used vector addition to determine the ground speeds for parallel and perpendicular flight paths.
You correctly identified that the plane spends more time at the slower headwind speed on Path 1.
You correctly recognized that angling against the crosswind reduces the forward ground speed component on Path 2.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou entered the distance as rather than .
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou matched the numeric value given in kilometers directly with speeds given in meters per second without checking unit consistency before dividing.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Unit Consistency Check
Always express distance and speed in matching base SI units (meters and meters per second) before calculating time: .
Convert any distance given in kilometers to meters by multiplying by before dividing by speed in .
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationConvert the one-way distance to meters: .
Calculate the parallel flight time: .
Calculate the perpendicular flight time: .
Calculate the ratio: .
(a) (); (b) (); (c)
Lock it in
Why does a steady wind always increase the total round-trip time along a straight line parallel to the wind compared to calm air?
Travel time is inversely proportional to ground speed (). The plane travels slower against the headwind, spending more time losing ground than the time it spends gaining ground with the tailwind.
Similar question
A boat moves at relative to the water on a river flowing at . The boat makes a round trip between two points on the riverbank separated by along the direction of flow. Calculate the total round-trip time and compare it to the time required in still water.
Answer
Downstream time: . Upstream time: . Total round-trip time: . In still water: . The current increases the round-trip time by .
An aircraft has an airspeed of . It performs a round trip over a distance each way under a constant headwind/tailwind of speed . Write the general algebraic formula for the round-trip time , and evaluate for .
Answer
For each leg, and . Combining these gives . For , , and : (), compared to in calm air.
In the Michelson-Morley experiment, light was hypothesized to travel through an 'ether wind' of speed with light speed . Using the formulas and , use a first-order binomial approximation in to find the time difference .
Answer
Using and for : and . Subtracting the two yields .