Resources
A small charged sphere of mass and charge rests on a rough horizontal surface with kinetic friction coefficient . The sphere is attached to an ideal horizontal spring with force constant . A uniform external horizontal electric field is suddenly applied in the direction of spring elongation. As the sphere moves from the unstretched position () to a displacement of , non-contact electric and gravitational forces act alongside contact spring and friction forces (). (a) Classify the four acting forces (spring force, electric force, normal force, and kinetic friction) as contact or non-contact forces. (b) Using the work-energy theorem, calculate the speed of the sphere at .
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) Spring force: contact force; Electric force: non-contact force; Normal force: contact force; Kinetic friction: contact force; (b)
Steps
Vertical Forces and Friction
Part (a): Classifying the Acting Forces
Forces in mechanics are categorized based on whether physical touch between objects is required:
- Contact forces require direct physical contact between the interacting bodies.
- Non-contact forces (field forces) act over a distance through a force field without requiring physical contact. Applying these definitions to the sphere:
- Spring force (): Contact force — exerted through the physical attachment and tension/compression of the spring coils on the sphere.
- Electric force (): Non-contact force — exerted by the external electric field on the charge across space without physical touch.
- Normal force (): Contact force — the perpendicular contact force exerted by the rough horizontal surface supporting the sphere.
- Kinetic friction (): Contact force — the parallel contact force generated by microscopic interactions at the contact interface between the sphere and surface as they slide past one another.
Part (b): Calculating the Speed Using the Work-Energy Theorem
The work-energy theorem states that the net work done by all acting forces equals the change in kinetic energy: Since the sphere starts from rest at , .
In the vertical direction, the sphere is in equilibrium:
Because the displacement is purely horizontal, the vertical forces (gravity and the normal force) do zero work: and .
The magnitude of kinetic friction opposing the motion is:
The work done by friction over the displacement is negative because it opposes the direction of motion:
Work Done by the Spring Force
As the spring stretches from to , the restoring force opposes the elongation:
Work Done by the Electric Field
The work done by the applied electric field driving the elongation is:
Net Work and Speed
Summing the individual work terms gives the net work:
Equating this net work to the kinetic state of the system yields the final speed:
Typical errors
01 The student treats the spring force as constant or forgets the negative sign in spring work, writing W_s = +kx² or + (1/2)kx² to obtain a positive kinetic energy.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
⟹
- Step 2
⟹ ⟹
- Step 3Correct
As the spring elongates, its restoring force points backward against the direction of displacement. Because the force and displacement vectors are antiparallel, the work done by the spring is negative.
- Step 4
⟹ ⟹ ⟹
Correct⟹ ⟹
Your application of the work-energy theorem and algebra were executed properly, but the result was affected by the incorrect sign on .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly categorized all four forces as contact or non-contact forces.
You correctly applied and accounted for the negative sign of friction work .
You set up the work-energy theorem correctly equating .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou used the positive elastic potential energy expression instead of the work done by the restoring force on the object, which is during stretching.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConfusing the change in elastic potential energy with the work done by the spring on the object . Whenever a spring is stretched from equilibrium, its tension pulls against the displacement, making .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Direction of Spring Restoring Force
By Hooke's Law, . When displacement is in the direction, the spring force acts in the direction.
Always draw a quick arrow for and . If they point in opposite directions, the work done by the spring must carry a negative sign.
- Work vs. Potential Energy Relation
. For a spring stretching from to , , so .
Decide at the start whether you are including the spring as work () on the left-hand side or as potential energy () on the right-hand side, and never drop the negative sign when treating it as work.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSubstitute the restoring force work formula: .
Sum all work contributions: .
Apply the work-energy theorem: and solve for .
02 The student omits the work done by friction against motion, including only electric and spring forces in the work-energy theorem and inverting the sign of work.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
Contact forces: spring force, normal force, kinetic friction ⟹ Non-contact forces: electric force
- Step 2
⟹
- Step 3Correct
You omitted the negative work done by kinetic friction, and you arbitrarily subtracted from instead of algebraically adding the signed work done by each force.
- Step 4Correct
Your algebraic isolation of speed from kinetic energy was mathematically sound, but it carries forward the incorrect net work from the previous step.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly distinguished between contact and non-contact forces based on whether physical touch is required.
You accurately evaluated the individual work formulas for the electric force and the restoring spring force.
You correctly related kinetic energy to work to solve for the final speed.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakeno
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou overlooked kinetic friction when compiling the total work acting along the horizontal path, and when the sum of the remaining terms came out negative, you manipulated their signs using absolute values rather than re-evaluating the free-body diagram and force balances.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Account for every force parallel to displacement
Every force with a component along the line of motion does work: .
Always draw a free-body diagram to verify that no contact force (such as kinetic friction) is omitted from the work sum.
- Maintain algebraic signs for work
Work is a signed scalar quantity: forces aiding motion do positive work (), while forces opposing motion do negative work ().
Add each work term with its proper sign directly rather than taking absolute values.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationFind the normal force and kinetic friction: , so .
Compute the work done by friction opposing the motion: .
Sum all work terms algebraically: .
Equate the net work to the change in kinetic energy: and solve for .
Lock it in
When a spring is stretched from its relaxed length () to elongation , what is the sign of the work done by the spring on the attached mass?
Negative (). The restoring force acts opposite to the direction of displacement.
Similar question
A block on a frictionless horizontal floor is pushed against a horizontal spring (), compressing it by . (a) Calculate the work done by the spring on the block during the compression. (b) If the block is released from rest, calculate the work done by the spring as it returns to , and find the block's speed at .
Answer
(a) During compression, force opposes displacement: . (b) During release, force and displacement are in the same direction: . By the work-energy theorem, .
A object is pulled along a rough horizontal surface () by a constant horizontal tension while attached to a spring (). Starting from rest at the unstretched position (), find the net work done on the object and its speed after moving ().
Answer
. Friction: . Spring work: . Notice , meaning the block cannot reach with this tension; its turning point occurs earlier where at .
A charged particle (, ) is attached to a vertical spring () hanging downward. A uniform downward electric field is turned on. Taking , determine the particle's speed after it falls from rest, assuming the spring was initially unstretched.
Answer
Forces in the downward direction: Gravity . Electric force . Spring force opposes downward motion: . Net work: . By work-energy theorem: .