Resources

A light ray travels within a dense flint glass prism (ng=1.660n_g = 1.660) toward an interface with air (na=1.000n_a = 1.000) at an incident angle of θ=40.00∘\theta = 40.00^\circ, which exceeds the critical angle. A student expects that pouring water (nw=1.333n_w = 1.333) onto the outer surface will increase the extent of total internal reflection because water is denser than air. Evaluate this claim quantitatively: determine the critical angle for the glass-air interface and the critical angle for the glass-water interface, and state whether total internal reflection still occurs at θ=40.00∘\theta = 40.00^\circ after water is added.

Answer and steps

Final answer

θc,air=37.04∘\theta_{c,\text{air}} = 37.04^\circ; θc,water=53.42∘\theta_{c,\text{water}} = 53.42^\circ; since θ=40.00∘<θc,water\theta = 40.00^\circ < \theta_{c,\text{water}}, total internal reflection is frustrated/eliminated upon adding water, and a refracted beam transmits into the water at an angle of θw=53.18∘\theta_w = 53.18^\circ to the normal.

Steps

01

Condition for Total Internal Reflection

Total internal reflection (TIR) occurs when a light wave traveling in a medium with a higher refractive index (n1n_1) strikes an interface with a medium of lower refractive index (n2<n1n_2 < n_1) at an angle of incidence θ1\theta_1 greater than the critical angle θc\theta_c.

By Snell's Law, when the angle of refraction reaches 90∘90^\circ: n1sin⁡θc=n2sin⁡90∘=n2n_1 \sin \theta_c = n_2 \sin 90^\circ = n_2

Solving for θc\theta_c: θc=arcsin⁡(n2n1)\theta_c = \arcsin\left(\frac{n_2}{n_1}\right)


02

Critical Angle at the Glass–Air Interface

For dense flint glass (ng=1.660n_g = 1.660) and air (na=1.000n_a = 1.000): sin⁡θc,air=nang=1.0001.660≈0.6024\sin \theta_{c,\text{air}} = \frac{n_a}{n_g} = \frac{1.000}{1.660} \approx 0.6024

θc,air=arcsin⁡(0.6024)≈37.04∘\theta_{c,\text{air}} = \arcsin(0.6024) \approx 37.04^\circ

Because the incident angle is θ=40.00∘\theta = 40.00^\circ, which satisfies θ>θc,air\theta > \theta_{c,\text{air}} (40.00∘>37.04∘40.00^\circ > 37.04^\circ), the light ray undergoes total internal reflection at the glass–air interface.


03

Critical Angle at the Glass–Water Interface

When water (nw=1.333n_w = 1.333) replaces air at the interface: sin⁡θc,water=nwng=1.3331.660≈0.8030\sin \theta_{c,\text{water}} = \frac{n_w}{n_g} = \frac{1.333}{1.660} \approx 0.8030

θc,water=arcsin⁡(0.8030)≈53.42∘\theta_{c,\text{water}} = \arcsin(0.8030) \approx 53.42^\circ

Adding a denser second medium increases the ratio n2n1\frac{n_2}{n_1}, which increases the critical angle from 37.04∘37.04^\circ to 53.42∘53.42^\circ.


04

Evaluating the Claim and Refraction into Water

The student's hypothesis is incorrect:

  • Increasing the refractive index of the second medium narrows the angular range over which total internal reflection can take place (it requires angles greater than 53.42∘53.42^\circ, rather than greater than 37.04∘37.04^\circ).
  • Since the incident angle θ=40.00∘\theta = 40.00^\circ is now less than the new critical angle θc,water=53.42∘\theta_{c,\text{water}} = 53.42^\circ, total internal reflection is frustrated/eliminated.

Because light escapes into the water, we calculate the angle of refraction θw\theta_w using Snell's Law: ngsin⁡θ=nwsin⁡θwn_g \sin \theta = n_w \sin \theta_w

1.660⋅sin⁡(40.00∘)=1.333⋅sin⁡θw1.660 \cdot \sin(40.00^\circ) = 1.333 \cdot \sin \theta_w

sin⁡θw=1.660⋅0.64281.333≈0.8005\sin \theta_w = \frac{1.660 \cdot 0.6428}{1.333} \approx 0.8005

θw=arcsin⁡(0.8005)≈53.18∘\theta_w = \arcsin(0.8005) \approx 53.18^\circ

Thus, light refracts into the water at an angle of 53.18∘53.18^\circ with respect to the normal.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the ratio of refractive indices when applying Snell's law for the critical angle, obtaining a sine value greater than 1 or taking the reciprocal.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    sin⁡(θc,air)=1.0001.660=0.6024  ⟹  θc,air=37.04∘\sin(\theta_{c,\text{air}}) = \frac{1.000}{1.660} = 0.6024 \implies \theta_{c,\text{air}} = 37.04^\circ

  2. Step 2

    sin⁡(θc,water)=ngnw=1.6601.333=1.245  ⟹  θc,water=arcsin⁡(11.245)=arcsin⁡(0.8030)=53.41∘\sin(\theta_{c,\text{water}}) = \frac{n_g}{n_w} = \frac{1.660}{1.333} = 1.245 \implies \theta_{c,\text{water}} = \arcsin\left(\frac{1}{1.245}\right) = \arcsin(0.8030) = 53.41^\circ

    Correct

    sin⁡(θc,water)=nwng=1.3331.660≈0.8030  ⟹  θc,water=53.42∘\sin(\theta_{c,\text{water}}) = \frac{n_w}{n_g} = \frac{1.333}{1.660} \approx 0.8030 \implies \theta_{c,\text{water}} = 53.42^\circ

    You inverted the index ratio as ngnw\frac{n_g}{n_w}, which yielded a sine value greater than 11, and then took the reciprocal to recover the angle. The correct definition is sin⁡θc=n2n1=nwng\sin\theta_c = \frac{n_2}{n_1} = \frac{n_w}{n_g}.

  3. Step 3

    Because nwn_w is closer to ngn_g, total internal reflection still occurs at 40.00∘40.00^\circ

    Correct

    Because θ=40.00∘<θc,water=53.42∘\theta = 40.00^\circ < \theta_{c,\text{water}} = 53.42^\circ, total internal reflection no longer occurs; light refracts into the water.

    Total internal reflection requires the angle of incidence to be greater than the critical angle (θ>θc\theta > \theta_c). Because adding water increases θc\theta_c to 53.42∘53.42^\circ, the incident ray at 40.00∘40.00^\circ no longer meets this condition and refracts into the water.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the glass-air critical angle as 37.04∘37.04^\circ.

You recognized that a sine value cannot exceed 11 and adjusted your calculation to find the angle of 53.41∘53.41^\circ.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
TIR condition reversal & inverted index ratio

You wrote n1n2\frac{n_1}{n_2} instead of n2n1\frac{n_2}{n_1} when setting up sin⁡θc\sin\theta_c.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You misunderstood how raising the refractive index of the second medium affects total internal reflection. Increasing n2n_2 makes n2n1\frac{n_2}{n_1} larger, which increases θc\theta_c and narrows the range of angles where total internal reflection occurs (heta>θc heta > \theta_c).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Index Ratio Check
  • Light must travel from a denser medium to a rarer medium (n1>n2n_1 > n_2), giving sin⁡θc=n2n1<1\sin\theta_c = \frac{n_2}{n_1} < 1.

  • Always place the smaller refractive index in the numerator so that sin⁡θc≤1\sin\theta_c \le 1.

TIR Inequality Check
  • Total internal reflection occurs only when θ>θc\theta > \theta_c.

  • Directly compare the actual angle of incidence θ\theta with your computed θc\theta_c rather than relying on qualitative intuition about refractive indices.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Calculate the glass-water critical angle: sin⁡(θc,water)=nwng=1.3331.660≈0.8030  ⟹  θc,water=arcsin⁡(0.8030)≈53.42∘\sin(\theta_{c,\text{water}}) = \frac{n_w}{n_g} = \frac{1.333}{1.660} \approx 0.8030 \implies \theta_{c,\text{water}} = \arcsin(0.8030) \approx 53.42^\circ.

  2. Compare the incident angle θ=40.00∘\theta = 40.00^\circ to the new critical angle: since 40.00∘<53.42∘40.00^\circ < 53.42^\circ, the condition θ>θc\theta > \theta_c is not satisfied.

  3. Conclude that total internal reflection is frustrated/eliminated, and light transmits into the water via refraction at angle θw=arcsin⁡(1.660sin⁡40.00∘1.333)≈53.18∘\theta_w = \arcsin\left(\frac{1.660 \sin 40.00^\circ}{1.333}\right) \approx 53.18^\circ.

Final answer

θc,air=37.04∘\theta_{c,\text{air}} = 37.04^\circ; θc,water=53.42∘\theta_{c,\text{water}} = 53.42^\circ; total internal reflection does not occur at 40.00∘40.00^\circ after water is added.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the critical angle formula as sin⁡θc=nsmallernlarger\sin\theta_c = \frac{n_{\text{smaller}}}{n_{\text{larger}}} to avoid inverting the ratio.

  • Practice checking the condition θ>θc\theta > \theta_c after finding any critical angle.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student mistakenly concludes that an increased critical angle facilitates total internal reflection, incorrectly asserting that TIR still occurs at 40.00°.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    sin⁡(θc,air)=1.0001.660=0.6024  ⟹  θc,air=37.04∘\sin(\theta_{c,\text{air}}) = \frac{1.000}{1.660} = 0.6024 \implies \theta_{c,\text{air}} = 37.04^\circ

  2. Step 2

    sin⁡(θc,water)=1.3331.660=0.8030  ⟹  θc,water=53.41∘\sin(\theta_{c,\text{water}}) = \frac{1.333}{1.660} = 0.8030 \implies \theta_{c,\text{water}} = 53.41^\circ

  3. Step 3

    θc increased from 37.04∘ to 53.41∘, so total internal reflection still occurs at 40.00∘\theta_c\text{ increased from }37.04^\circ\text{ to }53.41^\circ\text{, so total internal reflection still occurs at }40.00^\circ

    Correct

    Since θ=40.00∘<θc,water=53.42∘, total internal reflection ceases, and refraction into water occurs.\text{Since }\theta = 40.00^\circ < \theta_{c,\text{water}} = 53.42^\circ\text{, total internal reflection ceases, and refraction into water occurs.}

    Total internal reflection requires θ>θc\theta > \theta_c. An increased critical angle narrows the range of angles where total internal reflection happens, and since 40.00∘<53.41∘40.00^\circ < 53.41^\circ, light now transmits and refracts into the water.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the critical angle formula sin⁡θc=n2n1\sin\theta_c = \frac{n_2}{n_1} for both boundaries.

You accurately computed the numerical values of both critical angles.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misinterpreted TIR Inequality Condition

You treated an increasing critical angle as broadening or preserving total internal reflection rather than making the threshold harder to reach.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing the condition for total internal reflection (θ>θc\theta > \theta_c) with a direct proportionality. Because total internal reflection requires the incident angle to be strictly greater than the critical angle, raising θc\theta_c shrinks the angular window of total reflection [θc,90∘)[\theta_c, 90^\circ). Thus, an incident angle of 40.00∘40.00^\circ that previously exceeded 37.04∘37.04^\circ now falls below 53.41∘53.41^\circ, terminating total reflection.](streamdown:incomplete-link)

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
TIR Inequality Rule
  • Total internal reflection occurs only when light travels from a higher-index to a lower-index medium (n1>n2n_1 > n_2) and the angle of incidence satisfies θ1>θc\theta_1 > \theta_c.

  • Always compare the fixed incident angle θ\theta directly against the critical angle θc\theta_c using the inequality θ>θc\theta > \theta_c before drawing a conclusion.

Effect of Decreasing Index Contrast
  • As n2→n1n_2 \to n_1, the ratio n2n1→1\frac{n_2}{n_1} \to 1, which causes θc=arcsin⁡(n2/n1)→90∘\theta_c = \arcsin(n_2/n_1) \to 90^\circ, severely narrowing the range of total internal reflection.

  • Remember that a higher critical angle makes total internal reflection harder to achieve, not easier.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the incident angle θ=40.00∘\theta = 40.00^\circ to the new critical angle: 40.00∘<53.42∘40.00^\circ < 53.42^\circ.

  2. Conclude that because θ<θc,water\theta < \theta_{c,\text{water}}, total internal reflection is frustrated/eliminated.

  3. Apply Snell's law to confirm transmission: ngsin⁡(40.00∘)=nwsin⁡(θw)  ⟹  θw=arcsin⁡(1.660⋅sin⁡(40.00∘)1.333)≈53.18∘n_g \sin(40.00^\circ) = n_w \sin(\theta_w) \implies \theta_w = \arcsin\left(\frac{1.660 \cdot \sin(40.00^\circ)}{1.333}\right) \approx 53.18^\circ.

Final answer

θc,air=37.04∘\theta_{c,\text{air}} = 37.04^\circ, θc,water=53.42∘\theta_{c,\text{water}} = 53.42^\circ; total internal reflection does not occur at θ=40.00∘\theta = 40.00^\circ after water is added because θ<θc,water\theta < \theta_{c,\text{water}}, and light refracts into the water at an angle of 53.18∘53.18^\circ.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the inequality condition for total internal reflection: θ1>θc=arcsin⁡(n2/n1)\theta_1 > \theta_c = \arcsin(n_2/n_1).

  • Practice drawing boundary ray diagrams showing how the angular zone for total reflection shrinks as the optical densities of the two media become closer.

  • Solve problems comparing light behavior at coated or submerged optical boundaries.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misinterprets the condition for total internal reflection as requiring the incident angle to be less than the critical angle rather than greater than it.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    sin⁡(θc,air)=1.0001.660=0.6024  ⟹  θc,air=37.04∘\sin(\theta_{c,\text{air}}) = \frac{1.000}{1.660} = 0.6024 \implies \theta_{c,\text{air}} = 37.04^\circ

  2. Step 2

    sin⁡(θc,water)=1.3331.660=0.8030  ⟹  θc,water=53.41∘\sin(\theta_{c,\text{water}}) = \frac{1.333}{1.660} = 0.8030 \implies \theta_{c,\text{water}} = 53.41^\circ

  3. Step 3

    TIR requires θ<θc, so since 40.00∘<53.41∘, total internal reflection still occurs\text{TIR requires } \theta < \theta_c\text{, so since } 40.00^\circ < 53.41^\circ\text{, total internal reflection still occurs}

    Correct

    Total internal reflection requires θ>θc\theta > \theta_c. Since θ=40.00∘<53.42∘\theta = 40.00^\circ < 53.42^\circ, total internal reflection is frustrated and no longer occurs.

    You reversed the inequality condition for total internal reflection. Light only reflects totally when the angle of incidence exceeds the critical angle, not when it is below it.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used the formula sin⁡θc=n2n1\sin\theta_c = \frac{n_2}{n_1} for both boundaries.

You performed accurate trigonometric calculations to find both critical angles.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Reversed Inequality for Critical Angle Condition

You set the criterion for total internal reflection as θ<θc\theta < \theta_c rather than θ>θc\theta > \theta_c.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the angular regime where refraction is possible (angles of incidence less than the critical angle) with the regime where total internal reflection occurs (angles of incidence strictly exceeding the critical angle).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
TIR Inequality Condition
  • Total internal reflection occurs only when light travels from a denser medium to a rarer medium (n1>n2n_1 > n_2) and the incident angle satisfies θ1>θc\theta_1 > \theta_c.

  • Always verify that the incident angle is strictly greater than the critical angle before concluding that light undergoes total internal reflection.

Effect of Increasing the Outer Refractive Index
  • Increasing the refractive index of the second medium increases the ratio n2n1\frac{n_2}{n_1}, which increases θc\theta_c and shrinks the angular range over which total internal reflection can occur.

  • Check whether the incident ray still exceeds the new, larger critical angle after adding the denser surrounding fluid.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compare the incident angle θ=40.00∘\theta = 40.00^\circ with the new critical angle θc,water=53.42∘\theta_{c,\text{water}} = 53.42^\circ.

  2. Apply the TIR criterion: total internal reflection requires θ>θc\theta > \theta_c. Because 40.00∘<53.42∘40.00^\circ < 53.42^\circ, total internal reflection does not occur.

  3. Calculate the refracted angle in water using Snell's law: ngsin⁡θ=nwsin⁡θw  ⟹  sin⁡θw=1.660⋅sin⁡(40.00∘)1.333≈0.8005n_g \sin\theta = n_w \sin\theta_w \implies \sin\theta_w = \frac{1.660 \cdot \sin(40.00^\circ)}{1.333} \approx 0.8005, giving θw≈53.18∘\theta_w \approx 53.18^\circ.

Final answer

θc,air=37.04∘\theta_{c,\text{air}} = 37.04^\circ; θc,water=53.42∘\theta_{c,\text{water}} = 53.42^\circ; since θ=40.00∘<θc,water\theta = 40.00^\circ < \theta_{c,\text{water}}, total internal reflection does not occur, and light refracts into the water at θw=53.18∘\theta_w = 53.18^\circ.

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize that total internal reflection occurs when the incident ray is more grazing than the critical ray: θ>θc\theta > \theta_c.

  • Practice sketching rays at angles below, at, and above the critical angle to visually anchor when refraction ceases and pure reflection begins.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A light ray in diamond (nd=2.42n_d = 2.42) approaches an interface with air (na=1.00n_a = 1.00). Calculate the critical angle θc\theta_c. If the incident angle is 30.0∘30.0^\circ, does total internal reflection occur?

Answer

sin⁡θc=1.002.42≈0.4132  ⟹  θc=24.4∘\sin\theta_c = \frac{1.00}{2.42} \approx 0.4132 \implies \theta_c = 24.4^\circ. Since θ=30.0∘>24.4∘\theta = 30.0^\circ > 24.4^\circ, total internal reflection does occur.

02

An optical fiber core has refractive index ncore=1.62n_{\text{core}} = 1.62. It can be clad in either polymer (n1=1.40n_1 = 1.40) or silicone (n2=1.50n_2 = 1.50). Which cladding allows total internal reflection over a wider range of core angles?

Answer

For polymer: sin⁡θc,1=1.401.62  ⟹  θc,1≈59.8∘\sin\theta_{c,1} = \frac{1.40}{1.62} \implies \theta_{c,1} \approx 59.8^\circ. For silicone: sin⁡θc,2=1.501.62  ⟹  θc,2≈67.8∘\sin\theta_{c,2} = \frac{1.50}{1.62} \implies \theta_{c,2} \approx 67.8^\circ. The polymer cladding yields a smaller critical angle, so total internal reflection occurs over a wider range (59.8∘<θ<90∘59.8^\circ < \theta < 90^\circ).

03

A ray travels in glass (ng=1.55n_g = 1.55) toward a flat boundary. With air outside (n=1.00n=1.00), TIR occurs at θ=42.0∘\theta = 42.0^\circ. If an unknown oil layer replaces the air and the critical angle becomes 60.0∘60.0^\circ, find the refractive index of the oil and determine whether the same ray at θ=42.0∘\theta = 42.0^\circ still undergoes TIR.

Answer

Using sin⁡(60.0∘)=noil1.55\sin(60.0^\circ) = \frac{n_{\text{oil}}}{1.55}, we find noil=1.55×32≈1.34n_{\text{oil}} = 1.55 \times \frac{\sqrt{3}}{2} \approx 1.34. Because the new critical angle is 60.0∘60.0^\circ, the ray at θ=42.0∘<60.0∘\theta = 42.0^\circ < 60.0^\circ refracts into the oil, so TIR no longer occurs.

Loading workspace…