Resources
A student tests the impact characteristics of two balls of identical mass : Ball A is made of super-elastic rubber, and Ball B is made of soft modeling clay. Both balls are projected horizontally at against a rigid vertical wall. Ball B sticks completely to the wall upon impact () during an interaction time of . Ball A rebounds elastically in the opposite direction at over an interaction time of . A student predicts that Ball B experiences the greater impulse because the wall had to 'absorb and destroy all of its kinetic energy.' (a) Evaluate the student's prediction by calculating the magnitude of the impulse received by Ball A () and Ball B (). (b) Calculate the ratio of the average contact force on Ball A to that on Ball B, .
Answer and steps
Final answer
(a) , (the student's prediction is incorrect; ); (b) .
Steps
Part (a): Evaluating the Student's Prediction and Calculating Impulses
The impulse-momentum theorem states that the net impulse exerted on an object equals its change in linear momentum :
Taking the initial direction of motion toward the wall as the positive direction ():
-
For Ball A (rubber ball):
- Initial velocity:
- Final velocity:
- Change in momentum:
- The magnitude of the impulse is:
-
For Ball B (clay ball):
- Initial velocity:
- Final velocity:
- Change in momentum:
- The magnitude of the impulse is:
Evaluation of the student's claim:
The student's prediction is incorrect. Impulse depends on the change in velocity (a vector), not the loss of kinetic energy (a scalar). Bringing Ball B to a complete stop requires changing its velocity by , whereas bouncing Ball A back at the same speed requires stopping it and then re-accelerating it in the opposite direction, creating a total velocity change of . Thus, .
Part (b): Ratio of Average Contact Forces
The magnitude of the average contact force exerted by the wall during an impact interval is given by:
Using the given interaction times and :
Substitute the known values into the ratio:
The average force exerted on the bouncing rubber ball is times greater than that exerted on the clay ball.
Typical errors
01 The student treats velocity as a scalar without direction, calculating Δv for Ball A as 14.0 - 14.0 = 0 instead of accounting for the sign reversal, concluding Ball A receives zero impulse.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Velocity is a directional vector quantity. Because Ball A rebounds in the opposite direction, its final velocity is negative: . The change in velocity is , giving an impulse magnitude of .
- Step 2
, so magnitude is
- Step 3
The student is correct because Ball B experiences while Ball A experiences .
CorrectThe student's prediction is incorrect because ().
Because this conclusion relied on your earlier finding that , it resulted in the wrong conclusion. In reality, bouncing back requires twice the velocity change of simply stopping, so Ball A receives twice the impulse.
- Step 4Correct
Your force formula and conversion of milliseconds to seconds were correct, but substituting led to an incorrect final ratio of instead of .
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recalled the impulse-momentum theorem formula .
You accurately evaluated the stopping impulse on Ball B as .
You correctly applied the relationship between impulse, average force, and collision time duration .
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeNo; this reflects a conceptual trap where speed is substituted into vector change rather than accounting for the reversal of direction.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisTreating velocity as a scalar quantity rather than a vector. When an object rebounds, its direction of motion reverses, meaning its final velocity has the opposite sign of its initial velocity: , not .
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Vector Sign Convention
Velocity is a vector quantity; reversing direction requires changing its algebraic sign.
Assign a positive direction (e.g., toward the wall as ) and write rebounding velocities as negative ().
- Stopping vs. Rebounding
Stopping requires , while rebounding elastically at the same speed requires .
Check that a bouncing collision always produces a larger change in momentum than a sticking collision with the same initial speed.
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationSet up a coordinate axis with the initial motion toward the wall as positive: .
Since Ball A bounces backward, its rebound velocity is .
Compute the impulse magnitude for Ball A: .
Compare the two impulses: , so the student's prediction is incorrect.
Calculate the ratio of average forces: .
(a) , (the prediction is incorrect); (b)
02 The student confuses impulse with kinetic energy change, calculating ΔK instead of Δp to evaluate impulse.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1Correct
Impulse is defined as the change in linear momentum (), not the change in kinetic energy (). Because Ball A reverses its direction from to , its velocity change is , giving a non-zero impulse of magnitude .
- Step 2Correct
You calculated the loss of kinetic energy rather than momentum change. For Ball B, the momentum change has magnitude .
- Step 3
Magnitudes are and , so the student is correct that Ball B receives greater impulse.
Correct, so the student's prediction is incorrect.
Because your impulse values were derived from kinetic energy calculations, your conclusion regarding which ball received the greater impulse was reversed.
- Step 4Correct
You correctly related average force to impulse and time (), but the erroneous impulse values carried forward into this ratio.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly recognized that the magnitude of an average force is related to the impulse divided by the contact time duration.
You carefully tracked the initial and final speeds and kept units aligned throughout your intermediate steps.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistakenone
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisYou conflated impulse () with work (). Momentum is a vector linear in velocity (), whereas kinetic energy is a scalar quadratic in speed (). When an object rebounds, its kinetic energy change can be zero while its momentum change is maximized.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Impulse is change in momentum, not energy
Net impulse over time equals momentum change: , with units of or .
Always write down when dealing with collision forces and contact times, reserving strictly for work and energy questions.
- Rebounds double the momentum change
When an object of mass rebounds elastically from to , , so .
Pay close attention to direction signs: reversing direction requires more impulse than simply stopping ( versus ).
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationApply the impulse-momentum theorem for Ball A: .
Apply the impulse-momentum theorem for Ball B: .
Compare the magnitudes: , showing the student's prediction was incorrect.
Compute the ratio of average contact forces: .
(a) , (the student's prediction is incorrect); (b)
03 The student forgets to convert the interaction times from milliseconds to seconds, but in part (b) inverts the ratio of times when calculating the ratio of forces.
Sample Student Work
Reviewed by ACEpath TeacherStep-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher- Step 1
⟹ ⟹ The student's prediction is incorrect because Ball A experiences while Ball B experiences .
- Step 2Correct
Because average force is inversely proportional to time (), dividing the two expressions requires multiplying by the reciprocal of the denominator fraction, which inverts the time ratio to .
- Step 3Correct
Your arithmetic was carried out accurately, but the inverted time ratio from the previous step carried through to an incorrect final ratio.
WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your TeacherYou correctly applied the impulse-momentum theorem to both impacts.
You properly preserved the negative sign for Ball A's rebound velocity.
You drew the correct conceptual conclusion that rebounding requires a greater impulse than stopping.
THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the MistakeYou placed in the numerator and in the denominator instead of inverting the denominator fraction when calculating the ratio of forces.
WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's DiagnosisConflating direct and inverse variation when building ratios from fractional formulas: since , force is inversely proportional to collision duration, meaning shorter duration leads to a larger force.
REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach- Compound Fraction Division
Always write the full fraction explicitly before simplifying into product form.
- Physical Sanity Check
Shorter contact time must increase average force for a given impulse.
Verify that Ball A (larger impulse, shorter contact time) experiences a substantially larger force than Ball B ().
CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's DemonstrationWrite out the ratio of forces using the definition :
Multiply by the reciprocal of the denominator fraction:
Substitute the values:
Lock it in
How does reversing direction affect the sign of velocity in 1D kinematics and momentum?
Velocity is a vector: if motion in the initial direction is defined as positive (), motion in the opposite direction after a bounce must be negative ().
Similar question
A tennis ball strikes a wall horizontally at and rebounds horizontally at . (a) Calculate the impulse delivered by the wall to the ball. (b) If the contact time is , find the average contact force.
Answer
(a) (magnitude ). (b) .
Two identical carts () moving at hit a barrier. Cart 1 has a spring bumper and rebounds at in . Cart 2 has a clay bumper and stops completely () in . Find the ratio of the average force on Cart 1 to Cart 2, .
Answer
; . ; . Ratio .
A rubber ball of mass is dropped from height onto a hard floor and bounces back to height . Taking downward as positive and : (a) Determine the impact velocity and rebound velocity . (b) Express the impulse imparted by the floor in terms of .
Answer
(a) Downward before impact: . Upward after impact: . (b) (magnitude is directed upward).