Resources

A reversible heat engine operates between a high-temperature thermal reservoir at TH=650 KT_H = 650\text{ K} and a low-temperature thermal reservoir at TC=300 KT_C = 300\text{ K}. During each complete thermodynamic cycle, the engine rejects an amount of heat QC=1.80×103 JQ_C = 1.80\times 10^3\text{ J} to the cold reservoir while operating at its theoretical Carnot limit. Determine the net mechanical work output WnetW_{\text{net}} produced by the engine per cycle, and find the total heat energy QHQ_H that must be absorbed from the high-temperature reservoir each cycle.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Wnet=2.10×103 JW_{\text{net}} = 2.10\times 10^3\text{ J}, QH=3.90×103 JQ_H = 3.90\times 10^3\text{ J}

Steps

01

Relate Heat and Temperature for a Reversible (Carnot) Engine

For any ideal reversible heat engine operating between two thermal reservoirs, the ratio of heat transferred is directly proportional to the absolute thermodynamic temperatures of the reservoirs:

QHQC=THTC\frac{Q_H}{Q_C} = \frac{T_H}{T_C}

where:

  • TH=650 KT_H = 650\text{ K} is the temperature of the hot reservoir,
  • TC=300 KT_C = 300\text{ K} is the temperature of the cold reservoir,
  • QHQ_H is the heat absorbed from the hot reservoir,
  • QC=1.80×103 JQ_C = 1.80\times 10^3\text{ J} is the heat expelled to the cold reservoir.

02

Calculate the Heat Absorbed (QHQ_H)

Rearranging the Carnot relation to solve for QHQ_H:

QH=QC⋅THTCQ_H = Q_C \cdot \frac{T_H}{T_C}

Substitute the given values:

QH=(1.80×103 J)⋅650 K300 K=(1.80×103 J)⋅136=3.90×103 JQ_H = \left(1.80\times 10^3\text{ J}\right) \cdot \frac{650\text{ K}}{300\text{ K}} = \left(1.80\times 10^3\text{ J}\right) \cdot \frac{13}{6} = 3.90\times 10^3\text{ J}


03

Calculate the Net Work Output (WnetW_{\text{net}})

By the First Law of Thermodynamics, energy is conserved over a complete cycle (ΔU=0\Delta U = 0). Therefore, the net work done by the engine equals the difference between the heat absorbed and the heat rejected:

Wnet=QH−QCW_{\text{net}} = Q_H - Q_C

Substitute the values:

Wnet=3.90×103 J−1.80×103 J=2.10×103 JW_{\text{net}} = 3.90\times 10^3\text{ J} - 1.80\times 10^3\text{ J} = 2.10\times 10^3\text{ J}

(Alternative check via thermal efficiency): η=1−TCTH=1−300650=713\eta = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = 1 - \frac{300}{650} = \frac{7}{13} Wnet=ηQH=713⋅(3.90×103 J)=2.10×103 JW_{\text{net}} = \eta Q_H = \frac{7}{13} \cdot \left(3.90\times 10^3\text{ J}\right) = 2.10\times 10^3\text{ J}


Common Pitfalls to Avoid

  • Temperature Units: The Carnot ratio QHQC=THTC\frac{Q_H}{Q_C} = \frac{T_H}{T_C} holds only for absolute temperatures measured in Kelvin (K\text{K}), never in degrees Celsius or Fahrenheit.
  • Sign Conventions: Treat QHQ_H, QCQ_C, and WnetW_{\text{net}} as positive magnitudes representing energy flows into the engine, out of the engine, and work performed by the engine, respectively, where QH=Wnet+QCQ_H = W_{\text{net}} + Q_C.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student inverts the Carnot temperature ratio as TC / TH when solving for the heat absorbed from the hot reservoir, resulting in QH being smaller than QC.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    QH=QC×(TCTH)  ⟹  QH=1800×(300650)=830.77 JQ_H = Q_C \times \left(\frac{T_C}{T_H}\right) \implies Q_H = 1800 \times \left(\frac{300}{650}\right) = 830.77\text{ J}

    Correct

    QH=QC×(THTC)=1.80×103 J×(650 K300 K)=3.90×103 JQ_H = Q_C \times \left(\frac{T_H}{T_C}\right) = 1.80\times 10^3\text{ J} \times \left(\frac{650\text{ K}}{300\text{ K}}\right) = 3.90\times 10^3\text{ J}

    For an ideal reversible engine, heat flows scale directly with absolute reservoir temperatures: QHQC=THTC\frac{Q_H}{Q_C} = \frac{T_H}{T_C}. Rearranging for the absorbed heat requires multiplying by THTC\frac{T_H}{T_C}, not TCTH\frac{T_C}{T_H}. Because TH>TCT_H > T_C, the heat absorbed QHQ_H must be strictly greater than the heat expelled QCQ_C.

  2. Step 2

    Wnet=QH−QC=830.77−1800=−969.23 JW_{\text{net}} = Q_H - Q_C = 830.77 - 1800 = -969.23\text{ J}

    Correct

    Wnet=QH−QC=3.90×103 J−1.80×103 J=2.10×103 JW_{\text{net}} = Q_H - Q_C = 3.90\times 10^3\text{ J} - 1.80\times 10^3\text{ J} = 2.10\times 10^3\text{ J}

    You used the correct energy conservation formula Wnet=QH−QCW_{\text{net}} = Q_H - Q_C, but substituting your incorrect value of QHQ_H propagated the error and yielded a negative work value.

  3. Step 3

    QH=830.77 J, Wnet=−969.23 JQ_H = 830.77\text{ J},\, W_{\text{net}} = -969.23\text{ J}

    Correct

    Wnet=2.10×103 J, QH=3.90×103 JW_{\text{net}} = 2.10\times 10^3\text{ J},\, Q_H = 3.90\times 10^3\text{ J}

    The final reported values are incorrect due to the inverted temperature ratio in Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You identified that the heat ratio is connected to the reservoir temperatures for a Carnot engine.

You applied the First Law of Thermodynamics energy balance Wnet=QH−QCW_{\text{net}} = Q_H - Q_C correctly.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Inverted Carnot Temperature Ratio

You accidentally inverted the ratio of temperatures as TC/THT_C / T_H instead of TH/TCT_H / T_C when isolating QHQ_H.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Confusing direct proportionality across reservoirs when rearranging QHQC=THTC\frac{Q_H}{Q_C} = \frac{T_H}{T_C}, combined with missing a physical sanity check: a heat engine absorbs more heat from the hot reservoir than it dumps into the cold reservoir (QH>QCQ_H > Q_C) so that it can perform positive work (Wnet>0W_{\text{net}} > 0).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Direct Proportionality Alignment
  • For a reversible Carnot cycle, match subscripts directly: QHTH=QCTC\frac{Q_H}{T_H} = \frac{Q_C}{T_C}, which means QHQC=THTC\frac{Q_H}{Q_C} = \frac{T_H}{T_C}.

  • Write the proportion QHTH=QCTC\frac{Q_H}{T_H} = \frac{Q_C}{T_C} first, then isolate the unknown variable step by step.

Physical Reality Check for Heat Engines
  • A heat engine must satisfy QH=Wnet+QC>QCQ_H = W_{\text{net}} + Q_C > Q_C, ensuring Wnet>0W_{\text{net}} > 0.

  • Whenever you compute QHQ_H for a heat engine, verify that QH>QCQ_H > Q_C. If your calculated WnetW_{\text{net}} turns out negative, you are modeling a heat pump/refrigerator or have inverted a ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the reversible heat engine relation: QHQC=THTC\frac{Q_H}{Q_C} = \frac{T_H}{T_C}.

  2. Multiply both sides by QCQ_C to isolate QHQ_H: QH=QC(THTC)=(1.80×103 J)(650 K300 K)=3.90×103 JQ_H = Q_C \left(\frac{T_H}{T_C}\right) = \left(1.80\times 10^3\text{ J}\right) \left(\frac{650\text{ K}}{300\text{ K}}\right) = 3.90\times 10^3\text{ J}.

  3. Compute the net work output via energy conservation: Wnet=QH−QC=3.90×103 J−1.80×103 J=2.10×103 JW_{\text{net}} = Q_H - Q_C = 3.90\times 10^3\text{ J} - 1.80\times 10^3\text{ J} = 2.10\times 10^3\text{ J}.

Final answer

Wnet=2.10×103 JW_{\text{net}} = 2.10\times 10^3\text{ J}, QH=3.90×103 JQ_H = 3.90\times 10^3\text{ J}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the entropy balance of a Carnot cycle (ΔScycle=QHTH−QCTC=0\Delta S_{\text{cycle}} = \frac{Q_H}{T_H} - \frac{Q_C}{T_C} = 0) to reinforce why QHQC=THTC\frac{Q_H}{Q_C} = \frac{T_H}{T_C}.

  • Always perform a magnitude check on energy flows: verify that heat absorbed exceeds heat rejected for any power-producing heat engine.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student confuses the rejected heat QC with the absorbed heat QH when calculating work via efficiency, using Wnet = e × QC instead of Wnet = e × QH.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    e=1−TCTH=1−300650=0.5385e = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = 1 - \frac{300}{650} = 0.5385

  2. Step 2

    Wnet=e×QC=0.5385×1800=969.3 JW_{\text{net}} = e \times Q_C = 0.5385 \times 1800 = 969.3\text{ J}

    Correct

    QHQC=THTC  ⟹  QH=1800 J×650300=3.90×103 J  ⟹  Wnet=e×QH=713×3900 J=2.10×103 J\frac{Q_H}{Q_C} = \frac{T_H}{T_C} \implies Q_H = 1800\text{ J} \times \frac{650}{300} = 3.90 \times 10^3\text{ J} \implies W_{\text{net}} = e \times Q_H = \frac{7}{13} \times 3900\text{ J} = 2.10 \times 10^3\text{ J}

    Thermal efficiency is defined as net work output divided by the heat input from the hot reservoir, η=WnetQH\eta = \frac{W_{\text{net}}}{Q_H}. You multiplied by the rejected heat QCQ_C instead of the absorbed heat QHQ_H.

  3. Step 3

    QH=Wnet+QC=969.3+1800=2769.3 JQ_H = W_{\text{net}} + Q_C = 969.3 + 1800 = 2769.3\text{ J}

    Correct

    QH=Wnet+QC=2100 J+1800 J=3.90×103 JQ_H = W_{\text{net}} + Q_C = 2100\text{ J} + 1800\text{ J} = 3.90 \times 10^3\text{ J}

    Your energy conservation formula QH=Wnet+QCQ_H = W_{\text{net}} + Q_C is conceptually correct, but the calculated numerical value is affected by the incorrect value of WnetW_{\text{net}} from the previous step.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the Carnot engine efficiency using absolute temperatures.

You correctly stated the overall energy conservation relation QH=Wnet+QCQ_H = W_{\text{net}} + Q_C.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Misapplied Efficiency Definition to Rejected Heat

No, this is a conceptual confusion between input energy (QHQ_H) and rejected waste heat (QCQ_C) in the definition of thermal efficiency.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Thermal efficiency measures the fraction of heat supplied that is converted into work (e=Wnet/QHe = W_{\text{net}} / Q_H). When given QCQ_C rather than QHQ_H, you cannot compute work directly via Wnet=e×QCW_{\text{net}} = e \times Q_C; you must either find QHQ_H first using the reversible ratio QHQC=THTC\frac{Q_H}{Q_C} = \frac{T_H}{T_C}, or express work in terms of QCQ_C as Wnet=QC(THTC−1)W_{\text{net}} = Q_C \left(\frac{T_H}{T_C} - 1\right).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Efficiency Input vs. Output
  • e=What you getWhat you pay for=WnetQHe = \frac{\text{What you get}}{\text{What you pay for}} = \frac{W_{\text{net}}}{Q_H}

  • Always multiply efficiency by heat absorbed from the hot reservoir (QHQ_H), never by rejected heat (QCQ_C).

Carnot Heat Ratio
  • For a reversible engine, QHQC=THTC\frac{Q_H}{Q_C} = \frac{T_H}{T_C}.

  • When QCQ_C is provided, calculate QHQ_H directly from temperature ratios before computing work.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Use the Carnot heat-temperature proportionality: QHQC=THTC\frac{Q_H}{Q_C} = \frac{T_H}{T_C}

  2. Calculate QHQ_H: QH=QC(THTC)=1.80×103 J×650 K300 K=3.90×103 JQ_H = Q_C \left(\frac{T_H}{T_C}\right) = 1.80\times 10^3\text{ J} \times \frac{650\text{ K}}{300\text{ K}} = 3.90 \times 10^3\text{ J}

  3. Calculate WnetW_{\text{net}} using the first law: Wnet=QH−QC=3.90×103 J−1.80×103 J=2.10×103 JW_{\text{net}} = Q_H - Q_C = 3.90 \times 10^3\text{ J} - 1.80 \times 10^3\text{ J} = 2.10 \times 10^3\text{ J}

Final answer

Wnet=2.10×103 JW_{\text{net}} = 2.10\times 10^3\text{ J}, QH=3.90×103 JQ_H = 3.90\times 10^3\text{ J}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the definition of thermodynamic efficiency to solidify why the denominator is always total heat added (QHQ_H).

  • Practice solving Carnot problems where the given quantity is either QCQ_C, QHQ_H, or WnetW_{\text{net}}, using the proportionality QH/TH=QC/TCQ_H / T_H = Q_C / T_C as your first step.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student misremembers the first law of thermodynamics for a cyclic engine as QH = Wnet - QC instead of QH = Wnet + QC.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    QH=QC×(THTC)=1800×(650300)=3900 JQ_H = Q_C \times \left(\frac{T_H}{T_C}\right) = 1800 \times \left(\frac{650}{300}\right) = 3900\text{ J}

  2. Step 2

    Wnet=QH+QC=3900+1800=5700 JW_{\text{net}} = Q_H + Q_C = 3900 + 1800 = 5700\text{ J}

    Correct

    Wnet=QH−QC=3900 J−1800 J=2100 J=2.10×103 JW_{\text{net}} = Q_H - Q_C = 3900\text{ J} - 1800\text{ J} = 2100\text{ J} = 2.10\times 10^3\text{ J}

    By conservation of energy across a complete cycle, the heat absorbed splits into work done and heat rejected: QH=Wnet+QCQ_H = W_{\text{net}} + Q_C. Solving for work requires subtraction, Wnet=QH−QCW_{\text{net}} = Q_H - Q_C, rather than addition.

  3. Step 3

    Wnet=5700 J, QH=3900 JW_{\text{net}} = 5700\text{ J},\ Q_H = 3900\text{ J}

    Correct

    Wnet=2.10×103 J, QH=3.90×103 JW_{\text{net}} = 2.10\times 10^3\text{ J},\ Q_H = 3.90\times 10^3\text{ J}

    Your final value for QHQ_H is correct, but your final answer for WnetW_{\text{net}} is incorrect due to the sign error in the energy conservation formula.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified and applied the Carnot temperature ratio QHQC=THTC\frac{Q_H}{Q_C} = \frac{T_H}{T_C}.

You performed the arithmetic accurately to obtain QH=3900 JQ_H = 3900\text{ J}.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Sign error in First Law energy balance

You accidentally added QCQ_C instead of subtracting it from QHQ_H when calculating net work.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated the First Law of Thermodynamics as an additive sum of all heat terms (Wnet=QH+QCW_{\text{net}} = Q_H + Q_C) instead of balancing energy input against energy output (QH=Wnet+QCQ_H = W_{\text{net}} + Q_C).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Energy Balance Check
  • For any cyclic heat engine, energy entering must equal energy exiting: Qin=Wout+QoutQ_{\text{in}} = W_{\text{out}} + Q_{\text{out}}, so QH=Wnet+QCQ_H = W_{\text{net}} + Q_C.

  • Always isolate work by subtracting the exhaust heat from the input heat: Wnet=QH−QCW_{\text{net}} = Q_H - Q_C.

Sanity Check via Efficiency
  • Net work output WnetW_{\text{net}} can never exceed the heat energy absorbed QHQ_H.

  • Verify that Wnet<QHW_{\text{net}} < Q_H; obtaining 5700 J>3900 J5700\text{ J} > 3900\text{ J} indicates an unphysical work gain.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Apply the First Law of Thermodynamics over a complete cycle: QH=Wnet+QCQ_H = W_{\text{net}} + Q_C.

  2. Rearrange for net work: Wnet=QH−QCW_{\text{net}} = Q_H - Q_C.

  3. Substitute the known values: Wnet=3900 J−1800 J=2100 JW_{\text{net}} = 3900\text{ J} - 1800\text{ J} = 2100\text{ J}.

Final answer

Wnet=2.10×103 JW_{\text{net}} = 2.10\times 10^3\text{ J}, QH=3.90×103 JQ_H = 3.90\times 10^3\text{ J}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Draw an energy flow diagram showing QHQ_H splitting into WnetW_{\text{net}} and QCQ_C whenever solving heat engine problems.

  • Check that your calculated work is strictly less than the heat supplied (Wnet<QHW_{\text{net}} < Q_H).

  • Practice using the thermal efficiency formula η=1−TCTH=WnetQH\eta = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = \frac{W_{\text{net}}}{Q_H} as an independent cross-check.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A Carnot engine absorbs QH=5.00×103 JQ_H = 5.00\times 10^3\text{ J} from a reservoir at TH=800 KT_H = 800\text{ K} and exhausts heat to a reservoir at TC=320 KT_C = 320\text{ K}. Calculate the heat rejected per cycle QCQ_C and the net work output WnetW_{\text{net}}.

Answer

QC=2.00×103 JQ_C = 2.00\times 10^3\text{ J}, Wnet=3.00×103 JW_{\text{net}} = 3.00\times 10^3\text{ J}. Key steps: QC=QH(TCTH)=5.00×103 J×(320800)=2.00×103 JQ_C = Q_H \left(\frac{T_C}{T_H}\right) = 5.00\times 10^3\text{ J} \times \left(\frac{320}{800}\right) = 2.00\times 10^3\text{ J}. Then Wnet=QH−QC=5.00×103 J−2.00×103 J=3.00×103 JW_{\text{net}} = Q_H - Q_C = 5.00\times 10^3\text{ J} - 2.00\times 10^3\text{ J} = 3.00\times 10^3\text{ J}.

02

A reversible heat engine exhausts QC=900 JQ_C = 900\text{ J} of heat at TC=270 KT_C = 270\text{ K} and produces Wnet=600 JW_{\text{net}} = 600\text{ J} of useful work per cycle. Determine the heat absorbed QHQ_H and the operating temperature of the hot reservoir THT_H.

Answer

QH=1.50×103 JQ_H = 1.50\times 10^3\text{ J}, TH=450 KT_H = 450\text{ K}. Key steps: By the First Law, QH=Wnet+QC=600 J+900 J=1500 JQ_H = W_{\text{net}} + Q_C = 600\text{ J} + 900\text{ J} = 1500\text{ J}. Using the Carnot relation, TH=TC(QHQC)=270 K×(1500900)=450 KT_H = T_C \left(\frac{Q_H}{Q_C}\right) = 270\text{ K} \times \left(\frac{1500}{900}\right) = 450\text{ K}.

03

An engineer claims that a prototype heat engine operating between TH=600 KT_H = 600\text{ K} and TC=300 KT_C = 300\text{ K} rejects QC=1200 JQ_C = 1200\text{ J} per cycle while delivering Wnet=1500 JW_{\text{net}} = 1500\text{ J} of work. Determine the required heat input QHQ_H, calculate the prototype's thermal efficiency, and determine whether this engine violates the Carnot limit.

Answer

QH=2700 JQ_H = 2700\text{ J}, η=55.6%\eta = 55.6\%, and the claim violates the Carnot limit. Key steps: Energy conservation gives QH=Wnet+QC=1500 J+1200 J=2700 JQ_H = W_{\text{net}} + Q_C = 1500\text{ J} + 1200\text{ J} = 2700\text{ J}. The prototype efficiency is η=WnetQH=15002700≈55.6%\eta = \frac{W_{\text{net}}}{Q_H} = \frac{1500}{2700} \approx 55.6\%. The theoretical maximum Carnot efficiency is ηCarnot=1−TCTH=1−300600=50.0%\eta_{\text{Carnot}} = 1 - \frac{T_C}{T_H} = 1 - \frac{300}{600} = 50.0\%. Since η>ηCarnot\eta > \eta_{\text{Carnot}}, the engine is impossible.

Loading workspace…