Resources

In a physics laboratory experiment on kinematics, an ultrasonic motion sensor records the position of an air-track glider moving away from the detector at discrete 50.0 ms50.0\text{ ms} intervals: at t1=0.200 st_1 = 0.200\text{ s}, x1=0.310 mx_1 = 0.310\text{ m}; at t2=0.250 st_2 = 0.250\text{ s}, x2=0.425 mx_2 = 0.425\text{ m}; and at t3=0.300 st_3 = 0.300\text{ s}, x3=0.560 mx_3 = 0.560\text{ m}. Using the standard symmetric difference quotient approximation v(t2)≈x3−x1t3−t1v(t_2) \approx \frac{x_3 - x_1}{t_3 - t_1}, estimate the glider's instantaneous velocity at t=0.250 st = 0.250\text{ s}, and compute the percent discrepancy relative to the theoretical instantaneous velocity evaluated from the fitted trajectory model x(t)=1.00t2+2.00t+0.0500x(t) = 1.00 t^2 + 2.00 t + 0.0500 at t=0.250 st = 0.250\text{ s}.

Answer and steps

Final answer

Estimated instantaneous velocity: 2.50 m/s2.50\text{ m/s}; Theoretical instantaneous velocity: 2.50 m/s2.50\text{ m/s}; Discrepancy: 0.00%0.00\%

Steps

01

Estimate Instantaneous Velocity via Symmetric Difference Quotient

Instantaneous velocity is defined as the time derivative of position, v(t)=lim⁡Δt→0ΔxΔtv(t) = \lim_{\Delta t \to 0} \frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t}. With discrete experimental data spaced by equal intervals Δt=50.0 ms=0.050 s\Delta t = 50.0\text{ ms} = 0.050\text{ s}, the central (symmetric) difference quotient approximates the instantaneous velocity at the middle point t2t_2:

v(t2)≈x3−x1t3−t1v(t_2) \approx \frac{x_3 - x_1}{t_3 - t_1}

Substitute the experimental values:

  • t1=0.200 st_1 = 0.200\text{ s}, x1=0.310 mx_1 = 0.310\text{ m}
  • t3=0.300 st_3 = 0.300\text{ s}, x3=0.560 mx_3 = 0.560\text{ m}

v(0.250 s)≈0.560 m−0.310 m0.300 s−0.200 s=0.250 m0.100 s=2.50 m/sv(0.250\text{ s}) \approx \frac{0.560\text{ m} - 0.310\text{ m}}{0.300\text{ s} - 0.200\text{ s}} = \frac{0.250\text{ m}}{0.100\text{ s}} = 2.50\text{ m/s}


02

Determine Theoretical Instantaneous Velocity

The glider's position is modeled by the quadratic function:

x(t)=1.00t2+2.00t+0.0500x(t) = 1.00 t^2 + 2.00 t + 0.0500

Differentiating x(t)x(t) with respect to time gives the theoretical instantaneous velocity function:

vtheoretical(t)=dxdt=2.00t+2.00v_{\text{theoretical}}(t) = \frac{dx}{dt} = 2.00 t + 2.00

Evaluating this function at t=0.250 st = 0.250\text{ s}:

vtheoretical(0.250 s)=2.00(0.250)+2.00=0.500+2.00=2.50 m/sv_{\text{theoretical}}(0.250\text{ s}) = 2.00(0.250) + 2.00 = 0.500 + 2.00 = 2.50\text{ m/s}


03

Calculate Percent Discrepancy

The percent discrepancy measures the relative difference between the numerical estimate and the theoretical value:

Discrepancy=∣vestimated−vtheoretical∣vtheoretical×100%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{|v_{\text{estimated}} - v_{\text{theoretical}}|}{v_{\text{theoretical}}} \times 100\%

Discrepancy=∣2.50 m/s−2.50 m/s∣2.50 m/s×100%=0.00%\text{Discrepancy} = \frac{|2.50\text{ m/s} - 2.50\text{ m/s}|}{2.50\text{ m/s}} \times 100\% = 0.00\%

Key Insight & Common Pitfall: A common mistake is using a one-sided difference, such as x2−x1t2−t1=2.30 m/s\frac{x_2 - x_1}{t_2 - t_1} = 2.30\text{ m/s}, which yields a noticeable error. The symmetric (central) difference quotient achieves a higher-order approximation. Furthermore, for any motion undergoing constant acceleration (where position is quadratic in time), the average velocity over a symmetric time interval [t−Δt,t+Δt][t - \Delta t, t + \Delta t] is mathematically identical to the instantaneous velocity at the midpoint tt, which is why the discrepancy is exactly 0.00%0.00\%.

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student divides by the single sampling interval Δt = 0.050 s instead of the total elapsed time interval 2Δt = t₃ - t₁ = 0.100 s.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    v(t2)≈x3−x1Δt  ⟹  v(0.250)=0.560−0.3100.0500  ⟹  v(0.250)=0.2500.0500=5.00 m/sv(t_2) \approx \frac{x_3 - x_1}{\Delta t} \implies v(0.250) = \frac{0.560 - 0.310}{0.0500} \implies v(0.250) = \frac{0.250}{0.0500} = 5.00\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    v(t2)≈x3−x1t3−t1=0.560 m−0.310 m0.300 s−0.200 s=0.250 m0.100 s=2.50 m/sv(t_2) \approx \frac{x_3 - x_1}{t_3 - t_1} = \frac{0.560\text{ m} - 0.310\text{ m}}{0.300\text{ s} - 0.200\text{ s}} = \frac{0.250\text{ m}}{0.100\text{ s}} = 2.50\text{ m/s}

    You used the single sampling interval Δt=0.0500 s\Delta t = 0.0500\text{ s} in the denominator instead of the total elapsed time between x1x_1 and x3x_3, which spans two time steps: t3−t1=0.300 s−0.200 s=0.100 st_3 - t_1 = 0.300\text{ s} - 0.200\text{ s} = 0.100\text{ s}.

  2. Step 2

    vtheory(t)=dxdt=2.00t+2.00  ⟹  vtheory(0.250)=2.00(0.250)+2.00=2.50 m/sv_{\text{theory}}(t) = \frac{dx}{dt} = 2.00t + 2.00 \implies v_{\text{theory}}(0.250) = 2.00(0.250) + 2.00 = 2.50\text{ m/s}

  3. Step 3

    Percent discrepancy=∣5.00−2.502.50∣×100%=100%\text{Percent discrepancy} = \left|\frac{5.00 - 2.50}{2.50}\right| \times 100\% = 100\%

    Correct

    Percent discrepancy=∣2.50−2.502.50∣×100%=0.00%\text{Percent discrepancy} = \left|\frac{2.50 - 2.50}{2.50}\right| \times 100\% = 0.00\%

    You applied the percent discrepancy formula correctly, but your result was affected by the erroneous numerical velocity from step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly used calculus to find the theoretical instantaneous velocity from the quadratic position function.

You set up the percent discrepancy calculation properly using your estimated and theoretical values.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Interval Misalignment in Symmetric Difference

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You confused the spacing between adjacent data points Δt=t2−t1\Delta t = t_2 - t_1 with the total interval spanned by the central difference t3−t1=2Δtt_3 - t_1 = 2\Delta t.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Match the Numerator Span to the Denominator Span
  • In any difference quotient xb−xaΔttotal\frac{x_b - x_a}{\Delta t_{\text{total}}}, the denominator must be the exact elapsed time between position xbx_b and position xax_a, namely Δttotal=tb−ta\Delta t_{\text{total}} = t_b - t_a.

  • Whenever you take a symmetric difference between index k+1k+1 and index k−1k-1, check that the denominator is tk+1−tk−1=2Δtt_{k+1} - t_{k-1} = 2\Delta t, not Δt\Delta t.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Substitute the total time interval t3−t1=0.300 s−0.200 s=0.100 st_3 - t_1 = 0.300\text{ s} - 0.200\text{ s} = 0.100\text{ s} into the denominator: v(0.250 s)≈0.560 m−0.310 m0.100 s=2.50 m/sv(0.250\text{ s}) \approx \frac{0.560\text{ m} - 0.310\text{ m}}{0.100\text{ s}} = 2.50\text{ m/s}.

  2. Use this estimated velocity in the percent discrepancy formula: Discrepancy=∣2.50−2.502.50∣×100%=0.00%\text{Discrepancy} = \left|\frac{2.50 - 2.50}{2.50}\right| \times 100\% = 0.00\%.

Final answer

Estimated instantaneous velocity: 2.50 m/s2.50\text{ m/s}; Theoretical instantaneous velocity: 2.50 m/s2.50\text{ m/s}; Discrepancy: 0.00%0.00\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Always write out the time coordinates explicitly as t3−t1t_3 - t_1 before simplifying to an elapsed time value.

  • Remember that for motion with constant acceleration, the central difference quotient over [t−Δt,t+Δt][t - \Delta t, t + \Delta t] gives the exact instantaneous velocity at midpoint tt.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to apply the power rule derivative to the quadratic term and omits the factor of 2 when finding theoretical velocity.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    v(t2)≈x3−x1t3−t1  ⟹  v(0.250)=0.560−0.3100.300−0.200  ⟹  v(0.250)=0.2500.100=2.50 m/sv(t_2) \approx \frac{x_3 - x_1}{t_3 - t_1} \implies v(0.250) = \frac{0.560 - 0.310}{0.300 - 0.200} \implies v(0.250) = \frac{0.250}{0.100} = 2.50\text{ m/s}

  2. Step 2

    vtheory(t)=1.00t+2.00v_{\text{theory}}(t) = 1.00 t + 2.00

    Correct

    vtheoretical(t)=dxdt=ddt(1.00t2+2.00t+0.0500)=2.00t+2.00v_{\text{theoretical}}(t) = \frac{dx}{dt} = \frac{d}{dt}(1.00 t^2 + 2.00 t + 0.0500) = 2.00 t + 2.00

    You differentiated 1.00t21.00 t^2 as 1.00t1.00 t instead of applying the power rule ddt(atn)=natn−1\frac{d}{dt}(a t^n) = n a t^{n-1}, which gives 2(1.00)t=2.00t2(1.00)t = 2.00 t.

  3. Step 3

    vtheory(0.250)=1.00(0.250)+2.00=2.25 m/sv_{\text{theory}}(0.250) = 1.00(0.250) + 2.00 = 2.25\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    vtheoretical(0.250)=2.00(0.250)+2.00=2.50 m/sv_{\text{theoretical}}(0.250) = 2.00(0.250) + 2.00 = 2.50\text{ m/s}

    You substituted t=0.250 st = 0.250\text{ s} into your incorrect velocity expression; with the correct derivative, v(0.250 s)=2.50 m/sv(0.250\text{ s}) = 2.50\text{ m/s}.

  4. Step 4

    Percent discrepancy=∣2.50−2.25∣2.25×100%=11.1%\text{Percent discrepancy} = \frac{|2.50 - 2.25|}{2.25} \times 100\% = 11.1\%

    Correct

    Percent discrepancy=∣2.50 m/s−2.50 m/s∣2.50 m/s×100%=0.00%\text{Percent discrepancy} = \frac{|2.50\text{ m/s} - 2.50\text{ m/s}|}{2.50\text{ m/s}} \times 100\% = 0.00\%

    Your percent discrepancy formula setup was sound, but it inherited the incorrect theoretical velocity value.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You accurately substituted experimental data into the symmetric difference quotient formula.

You correctly structured the relative percent discrepancy expression.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Power rule coefficient omission in differentiation

You reduced the exponent of t2t^2 to tt without multiplying the term by the original exponent 22.

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Incomplete execution of the power rule for derivatives: forgetting to bring down the exponent nn as a multiplicative factor when evaluating ddt(ctn)=c⋅ntn−1\frac{d}{dt}(c t^n) = c \cdot n t^{n-1}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Power Rule Check
  • ddt(atn)=a⋅ntn−1\frac{d}{dt}(a t^n) = a \cdot n t^{n-1}. For a quadratic term at2a t^2, the derivative is always 2at2a t.

  • Multiply the coefficient by the current power before subtracting one from the exponent.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Differentiate the position function correctly: v(t)=ddt(1.00t2+2.00t+0.0500)=2.00t+2.00v(t) = \frac{d}{dt}(1.00 t^2 + 2.00 t + 0.0500) = 2.00 t + 2.00.

  2. Evaluate theoretical velocity at t=0.250 st = 0.250\text{ s}: v(0.250)=2.00(0.250)+2.00=0.500+2.00=2.50 m/sv(0.250) = 2.00(0.250) + 2.00 = 0.500 + 2.00 = 2.50\text{ m/s}.

  3. Compute percent discrepancy: ∣2.50−2.50∣2.50×100%=0.00%\frac{|2.50 - 2.50|}{2.50} \times 100\% = 0.00\%.

Final answer

Estimated velocity: 2.50 m/s2.50\text{ m/s}; Theoretical velocity: 2.50 m/s2.50\text{ m/s}; Discrepancy: 0.00%0.00\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Double-check every derivative term by explicitly writing out n⋅c⋅tn−1n \cdot c \cdot t^{n-1} before simplifying.

  • Remember that for constant acceleration (quadratic position curves), the symmetric difference quotient matches the instantaneous velocity at the midpoint exactly, yielding 0%0\% error.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student uses an asymmetric forward difference quotient using adjacent points x₃ and x₂ instead of the requested symmetric difference quotient across x₃ and x₁.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    v(t2)≈x3−x2t3−t2  ⟹  v(0.250)=0.560−0.4250.300−0.250=0.1350.0500=2.70 m/sv(t_2) \approx \frac{x_3 - x_2}{t_3 - t_2} \implies v(0.250) = \frac{0.560 - 0.425}{0.300 - 0.250} = \frac{0.135}{0.0500} = 2.70\text{ m/s}

    Correct

    v(t2)≈x3−x1t3−t1=0.560 m−0.310 m0.300 s−0.200 s=0.250 m0.100 s=2.50 m/sv(t_2) \approx \frac{x_3 - x_1}{t_3 - t_1} = \frac{0.560\text{ m} - 0.310\text{ m}}{0.300\text{ s} - 0.200\text{ s}} = \frac{0.250\text{ m}}{0.100\text{ s}} = 2.50\text{ m/s}

    You applied a one-sided forward difference quotient x3−x2t3−t2\frac{x_3 - x_2}{t_3 - t_2} instead of the symmetric (central) difference quotient x3−x1t3−t1\frac{x_3 - x_1}{t_3 - t_1} explicitly requested by the problem.

  2. Step 2

    vtheory(t)=dxdt=2.00t+2.00  ⟹  vtheory(0.250)=2.00(0.250)+2.00=2.50 m/sv_{\text{theory}}(t) = \frac{dx}{dt} = 2.00 t + 2.00 \implies v_{\text{theory}}(0.250) = 2.00(0.250) + 2.00 = 2.50\text{ m/s}

  3. Step 3

    Percent discrepancy=∣2.70−2.50∣2.50×100%=8.00%\text{Percent discrepancy} = \frac{|2.70 - 2.50|}{2.50} \times 100\% = 8.00\%

    Correct

    Percent discrepancy=∣2.50−2.50∣2.50×100%=0.00%\text{Percent discrepancy} = \frac{|2.50 - 2.50|}{2.50} \times 100\% = 0.00\%

    Your discrepancy calculation follows the correct relative error formula, but the result is affected by using your incorrect velocity estimate of 2.70 m/s2.70\text{ m/s} from Step 1.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly differentiated the position function x(t)x(t) to find the theoretical instantaneous velocity.

You accurately evaluated the theoretical velocity at t=0.250 st = 0.250\text{ s}.

You correctly set up and evaluated the percent discrepancy formula using your estimated and theoretical values.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Asymmetric Difference Approximation

no

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You selected an asymmetric forward difference formula using the right adjacent interval instead of spanning the symmetric interval [t1,t3][t_1, t_3] around the target point t2t_2.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Symmetric Difference Quotient Setup
  • To approximate the derivative at an interior point tkt_k, the symmetric difference quotient uses the points immediately before and after: v(tk)≈xk+1−xk−1tk+1−tk−1v(t_k) \approx \frac{x_{k+1} - x_{k-1}}{t_{k+1} - t_{k-1}}.

  • Ensure your difference quotient spans both sides of the point of interest by using endpoints tk−1t_{k-1} and tk+1t_{k+1}, rather than a one-sided interval.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute the symmetric difference quotient using t1=0.200 st_1 = 0.200\text{ s} and t3=0.300 st_3 = 0.300\text{ s}: v(0.250)≈x3−x1t3−t1=0.560−0.3100.300−0.200=0.2500.100=2.50 m/sv(0.250) \approx \frac{x_3 - x_1}{t_3 - t_1} = \frac{0.560 - 0.310}{0.300 - 0.200} = \frac{0.250}{0.100} = 2.50\text{ m/s}.

  2. Substitute the correct estimate into the discrepancy formula: Percent discrepancy=∣2.50−2.50∣2.50×100%=0.00%\text{Percent discrepancy} = \frac{|2.50 - 2.50|}{2.50} \times 100\% = 0.00\%.

Final answer

Estimated instantaneous velocity: 2.50 m/s2.50\text{ m/s}; Theoretical instantaneous velocity: 2.50 m/s2.50\text{ m/s}; Discrepancy: 0.00%0.00\%

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review the geometric difference between secant lines for forward, backward, and symmetric difference quotients.

  • Notice that for quadratic motion x(t)=at2+bt+cx(t) = a t^2 + b t + c (constant acceleration), the symmetric difference quotient over [t−Δt,t+Δt][t - \Delta t, t + \Delta t] always equals the exact instantaneous velocity at the midpoint tt.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A photogate timer records the positions of a cart at equal intervals of Δt=0.10 s\Delta t = 0.10\text{ s}: at t1=0.40 st_1 = 0.40\text{ s}, x1=0.28 mx_1 = 0.28\text{ m}; at t2=0.50 st_2 = 0.50\text{ s}, x2=0.45 mx_2 = 0.45\text{ m}; and at t3=0.60 st_3 = 0.60\text{ s}, x3=0.66 mx_3 = 0.66\text{ m}. Using the symmetric difference quotient, estimate the instantaneous velocity at t=0.50 st = 0.50\text{ s}.

Answer

v(0.50 s)≈x3−x1t3−t1=0.66 m−0.28 m0.60 s−0.40 s=0.38 m0.20 s=1.9 m/sv(0.50\text{ s}) \approx \frac{x_3 - x_1}{t_3 - t_1} = \frac{0.66\text{ m} - 0.28\text{ m}}{0.60\text{ s} - 0.40\text{ s}} = \frac{0.38\text{ m}}{0.20\text{ s}} = 1.9\text{ m/s}.

02

A particle moves according to x(t)=2.0t2+1.0tx(t) = 2.0t^2 + 1.0t. Positions are sampled at t1=1.00 st_1 = 1.00\text{ s} and t3=1.04 st_3 = 1.04\text{ s} with midpoint t2=1.02 st_2 = 1.02\text{ s}. Calculate: (a) the theoretical velocity at t2t_2, and (b) the numerical velocity using the central difference quotient x(t3)−x(t1)t3−t1\frac{x(t_3) - x(t_1)}{t_3 - t_1}.

Answer

(a) v(t)=dxdt=4.0t+1.0  ⟹  v(1.02)=4.0(1.02)+1.0=5.08 m/sv(t) = \frac{dx}{dt} = 4.0t + 1.0 \implies v(1.02) = 4.0(1.02) + 1.0 = 5.08\text{ m/s}. (b) x(1.00)=3.000 mx(1.00) = 3.000\text{ m}, x(1.04)=2(1.0816)+1.04=3.2032 mx(1.04) = 2(1.0816) + 1.04 = 3.2032\text{ m}. vest=3.2032−3.0001.04−1.00=0.20320.04=5.08 m/sv_{\text{est}} = \frac{3.2032 - 3.000}{1.04 - 1.00} = \frac{0.2032}{0.04} = 5.08\text{ m/s}.

03

A student uses positions x1x_1 at t1t_1 and x2x_2 at t2t_2 to estimate velocity at t1t_1 (forward difference: x2−x1Δt\frac{x_2 - x_1}{\Delta t}) for x(t)=ct2x(t) = c t^2 (c>0c > 0). Express the relative error of this forward difference compared to the symmetric difference centered at t1t_1 spanning [t1−Δt,t1+Δt][t_1 - \Delta t, t_1 + \Delta t].

Answer

The true instantaneous velocity is v(t1)=2ct1v(t_1) = 2c t_1, which equals the symmetric difference. The forward difference is c(t1+Δt)2−ct12Δt=2ct1+cΔt\frac{c(t_1 + \Delta t)^2 - c t_1^2}{\Delta t} = 2c t_1 + c\Delta t. The relative error is (2ct1+cΔt)−2ct12ct1=Δt2t1\frac{(2c t_1 + c\Delta t) - 2c t_1}{2c t_1} = \frac{\Delta t}{2 t_1}.

Loading workspace…