Resources

In a laboratory experiment measuring the entropy of an irreversible phase change, an insulated aluminum calorimeter cup of mass mcal=0.120 kgm_{\text{cal}} = 0.120\text{ kg} (cal=900 J/(kg⋅K)c_{\text{al}} = 900\text{ J}/(\text{kg}\cdot\text{K})) contains mw=0.200 kgm_w = 0.200\text{ kg} of liquid water (cw=4186 J/(kg⋅K)c_w = 4186\text{ J}/(\text{kg}\cdot\text{K}) at an initial calibrated temperature of T0=295.15 KT_0 = 295.15\text{ K} (22.0∘C22.0^\circ\text{C}). A student adds an ice cube of mass mice=0.0350 kgm_{\text{ice}} = 0.0350\text{ kg} taken directly from an ice-water bath at Tice=273.15 KT_{\text{ice}} = 273.15\text{ K} (0.0∘C0.0^\circ\text{C}, Lf=3.33×105 J/kgL_f = 3.33 \times 10^5\text{ J}/\text{kg}). The system is sealed and allowed to reach complete thermal equilibrium without external heat leaks. (a) Determine the final equilibrium temperature TfT_f in Kelvin. (b) Calculate the total entropy change ΔSice\Delta S_{\text{ice}} for the melting and warming of the ice. (c) Calculate the total entropy change ΔScal+water\Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} for the cooling of the calorimeter and water. (d) Determine the net entropy generated ΔStotal\Delta S_{\text{total}} during this experimental run.

Answer and steps

Final answer

(a) Tf=279.79 KT_f = 279.79\text{ K} (6.64∘C6.64^\circ\text{C}); (b) ΔSice=+46.22 J/K\Delta S_{\text{ice}} = +46.22\text{ J}/\text{K}; (c) ΔScal+water=−44.59 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = -44.59\text{ J}/\text{K}; (d) ΔStotal=+1.63 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = +1.63\text{ J}/\text{K}

Steps

Part (a): Determining the Final Equilibrium Temperature TfT_f

In an insulated calorimeter, no heat enters or leaves the system from the outside. By the conservation of energy (the First Law of Thermodynamics), the heat gained by the cold substance must equal the heat lost by the warmer substances:

Qgained=QlostQ_{\text{gained}} = Q_{\text{lost}}

  1. Heat gained by the ice:
    The ice cube first absorbs latent heat to melt completely at Tice=273.15 KT_{\text{ice}} = 273.15\text{ K}, and the resulting liquid water then warms up to the final equilibrium temperature TfT_f: Qice=miceLf+micecw(Tf−Tice)Q_{\text{ice}} = m_{\text{ice}} L_f + m_{\text{ice}} c_w (T_f - T_{\text{ice}})
  2. Heat lost by the calorimeter cup and water:
    The aluminum calorimeter and the initial liquid water both cool down from T0=295.15 KT_0 = 295.15\text{ K} to TfT_f: Qlost=(mcalcal+mwcw)(T0−Tf)Q_{\text{lost}} = (m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{al}} + m_w c_w)(T_0 - T_f)

Equating the heat gained to the heat lost: miceLf+micecw(Tf−Tice)=(mcalcal+mwcw)(T0−Tf)m_{\text{ice}} L_f + m_{\text{ice}} c_w (T_f - T_{\text{ice}}) = (m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{al}} + m_w c_w)(T_0 - T_f)

Solving for the equilibrium temperature TfT_f yields: Tf=279.79 K(6.64∘C)T_f = 279.79\text{ K} \quad (6.64^\circ\text{C})


Part (b): Total Entropy Change for the Ice (ΔSice\Delta S_{\text{ice}})

Entropy is a state function. Even though the overall process is irreversible, the entropy change is evaluated by integrating along an equivalent reversible path consisting of two distinct stages:

  1. Isothermal phase change (melting at Tice=273.15 KT_{\text{ice}} = 273.15\text{ K}): ΔSmelt=QmeltTice=miceLfTice=0.0350 kg⋅3.33×105 J/kg273.15 K≈+42.67 J/K\Delta S_{\text{melt}} = \frac{Q_{\text{melt}}}{T_{\text{ice}}} = \frac{m_{\text{ice}} L_f}{T_{\text{ice}}} = \frac{0.0350\text{ kg} \cdot 3.33 \times 10^5\text{ J/kg}}{273.15\text{ K}} \approx +42.67\text{ J/K}
  2. Temperature increase of the melted water from TiceT_{\text{ice}} to TfT_f: ΔSwarm=∫TiceTfmicecw dTT=micecwln⁡(TfTice)\Delta S_{\text{warm}} = \int_{T_{\text{ice}}}^{T_f} \frac{m_{\text{ice}} c_w\, dT}{T} = m_{\text{ice}} c_w \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_{\text{ice}}}\right) ΔSwarm=(0.0350 kg)(4186 J/(kg⋅K))ln⁡(279.79273.15)≈+3.55 J/K\Delta S_{\text{warm}} = (0.0350\text{ kg})(4186\text{ J}/(\text{kg}\cdot\text{K})) \ln\left(\frac{279.79}{273.15}\right) \approx +3.55\text{ J/K}

Combining both contributions: ΔSice=ΔSmelt+ΔSwarm=+46.22 J/K\Delta S_{\text{ice}} = \Delta S_{\text{melt}} + \Delta S_{\text{warm}} = +46.22\text{ J/K}


Part (c): Total Entropy Change for the Calorimeter and Water (ΔScal+water\Delta S_{\text{cal+water}})

Both the aluminum cup and the initial water undergo a continuous temperature drop from T0=295.15 KT_0 = 295.15\text{ K} to Tf=279.79 KT_f = 279.79\text{ K}. Integrating dQ/TdQ/T over this temperature interval gives:

ΔScal+water=Cwarmln⁡(TfT0)\Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = C_{\text{warm}} \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_0}\right)

where CwarmC_{\text{warm}} is the combined heat capacity of the warm components. Because heat is removed and the temperature decreases (Tf<T0T_f < T_0), the logarithm is negative:

ΔScal+water=−44.59 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = -44.59\text{ J/K}

Common Pitfall: Entropy changes during temperature variations must be calculated using the natural logarithm ∫C dTT=Cln⁡(Tf/Ti)\int \frac{C\, dT}{T} = C \ln(T_f / T_i), not simply by dividing the heat transfer by an average temperature QTavg\frac{Q}{T_{\text{avg}}}.


Part (d): Net Entropy Generated (ΔStotal\Delta S_{\text{total}})

The calorimeter system is thermally insulated from the rest of the universe, so the total entropy change of the universe equals the net entropy change of the isolated calorimeter system:

ΔStotal=ΔSice+ΔScal+water\Delta S_{\text{total}} = \Delta S_{\text{ice}} + \Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} ΔStotal=+46.22 J/K+(−44.59 J/K)=+1.63 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = +46.22\text{ J/K} + (-44.59\text{ J/K}) = +1.63\text{ J/K}

Because heat flowed across a finite temperature difference, the process is inherently irreversible. In accordance with the Second Law of Thermodynamics, the total entropy change is strictly positive (ΔStotal>0\Delta S_{\text{total}} > 0).

Typical errors

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

01 The student omits the latent heat of fusion when setting up the energy conservation equation, treating ice as already liquid water at 273.15 K.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Incorrect
  1. Step 1

    micecw(Tf−Tice)=(mcalcal+mwcw)(T0−Tf)  ⟹  146.51(Tf−273.15)=945.2(295.15−Tf)  ⟹  Tf=292.20 Km_{\text{ice}} c_w (T_f - T_{\text{ice}}) = (m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{al}} + m_w c_w)(T_0 - T_f) \implies 146.51(T_f - 273.15) = 945.2(295.15 - T_f) \implies T_f = 292.20\text{ K}

    Correct

    miceLf+micecw(Tf−Tice)=(mcalcal+mwcw)(T0−Tf)  ⟹  Tf=279.79 Km_{\text{ice}} L_f + m_{\text{ice}} c_w (T_f - T_{\text{ice}}) = (m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{al}} + m_w c_w)(T_0 - T_f) \implies T_f = 279.79\text{ K}

    You omitted the heat required to melt the solid ice into liquid water (Qmelt=miceLf=11655 JQ_{\text{melt}} = m_{\text{ice}} L_f = 11655\text{ J}) from the heat gained side of your energy balance equation, treating the ice as if it were already liquid water at 273.15 K273.15\text{ K}.

  2. Step 2

    ΔSice=miceLfTice+micecwln⁡(TfTice)=11655273.15+146.51ln⁡(292.20273.15)=42.67+9.87=52.54 J/K\Delta S_{\text{ice}} = m_{\text{ice}} \frac{L_f}{T_{\text{ice}}} + m_{\text{ice}} c_w \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_{\text{ice}}}\right) = \frac{11655}{273.15} + 146.51 \ln\left(\frac{292.20}{273.15}\right) = 42.67 + 9.87 = 52.54\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔSice=miceLfTice+micecwln⁡(279.79 K273.15 K)=42.67 J/K+3.55 J/K=+46.22 J/K\Delta S_{\text{ice}} = \frac{m_{\text{ice}} L_f}{T_{\text{ice}}} + m_{\text{ice}} c_w \ln\left(\frac{279.79\text{ K}}{273.15\text{ K}}\right) = 42.67\text{ J/K} + 3.55\text{ J/K} = +46.22\text{ J/K}

    Your entropy change formula for the ice is completely correct, but your numerical result was affected by substituting the incorrect equilibrium temperature Tf=292.20 KT_f = 292.20\text{ K} instead of 279.79 K279.79\text{ K}.

  3. Step 3

    ΔScal+water=945.2ln⁡(TfT0)=945.2ln⁡(292.20295.15)=−9.50 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = 945.2 \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_0}\right) = 945.2 \ln\left(\frac{292.20}{295.15}\right) = -9.50\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔScal+water=(mcalcal+mwcw)ln⁡(TfT0)=945.2ln⁡(279.79 K295.15 K)=−44.59 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = (m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{al}} + m_w c_w) \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_0}\right) = 945.2 \ln\left(\frac{279.79\text{ K}}{295.15\text{ K}}\right) = -44.59\text{ J/K}

    Your expression using the natural logarithm of the temperature ratio is correct, but evaluating it with Tf=292.20 KT_f = 292.20\text{ K} yielded −9.50 J/K-9.50\text{ J/K} instead of −44.59 J/K-44.59\text{ J/K}.

  4. Step 4

    ΔStotal=ΔSice+ΔScal+water=52.54+(−9.50)=+43.04 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = \Delta S_{\text{ice}} + \Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = 52.54 + (-9.50) = +43.04\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔStotal=ΔSice+ΔScal+water=+46.22 J/K+(−44.59 J/K)=+1.63 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = \Delta S_{\text{ice}} + \Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = +46.22\text{ J/K} + (-44.59\text{ J/K}) = +1.63\text{ J/K}

    You correctly added the individual entropy changes, but the value reflects the earlier errors in TfT_f.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly identified the two-stage entropy formula for the ice involving isothermal melting and temperature increase.

You used the logarithmic temperature formula ∫dQT=Cln⁡(Tf/Ti)\int \frac{dQ}{T} = C \ln(T_f/T_i) rather than an erroneous linear average temperature approximation.

You correctly combined the individual subsystem entropy changes to state the net entropy generated.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Missing latent heat of fusion in energy balance

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You included the latent heat term mLfT\frac{m L_f}{T} when finding entropy in part (b), but omitted the corresponding energy term mLfm L_f from the First Law energy conservation equation in part (a), assuming only sensible heating took place.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Account for Phase Changes in First Law Balances
  • Before a solid at its melting point can increase in temperature as a liquid, it must absorb latent heat Qlatent=mLfQ_{\text{latent}} = m L_f at constant temperature.

  • Always list every physical stage of heat absorption: melting (mLfm L_f) plus warming (mcΔTm c \Delta T).

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Set up the complete heat balance: miceLf+micecw(Tf−Tice)=(mcalcal+mwcw)(T0−Tf)m_{\text{ice}} L_f + m_{\text{ice}} c_w (T_f - T_{\text{ice}}) = (m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{al}} + m_w c_w)(T_0 - T_f).

  2. Substitute the given constants: 0.0350(3.33×105)+146.51(Tf−273.15)=945.2(295.15−Tf)0.0350(3.33 \times 10^5) + 146.51(T_f - 273.15) = 945.2(295.15 - T_f).

  3. Simplify: 11655+146.51Tf−40019.2=278975.8−945.2Tf  ⟹  1091.71Tf=305340  ⟹  Tf=279.79 K11655 + 146.51 T_f - 40019.2 = 278975.8 - 945.2 T_f \implies 1091.71 T_f = 305340 \implies T_f = 279.79\text{ K}.

  4. Recalculate ΔSice=11655273.15+146.51ln⁡(279.79273.15)=42.67+3.55=+46.22 J/K\Delta S_{\text{ice}} = \frac{11655}{273.15} + 146.51 \ln\left(\frac{279.79}{273.15}\right) = 42.67 + 3.55 = +46.22\text{ J/K}.

  5. Recalculate ΔScal+water=945.2ln⁡(279.79295.15)=−44.59 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = 945.2 \ln\left(\frac{279.79}{295.15}\right) = -44.59\text{ J/K}.

  6. Find total entropy generation: ΔStotal=46.22+(−44.59)=+1.63 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = 46.22 + (-44.59) = +1.63\text{ J/K}.

Final answer

(a) Tf=279.79 KT_f = 279.79\text{ K}; (b) ΔSice=+46.22 J/K\Delta S_{\text{ice}} = +46.22\text{ J/K}; (c) ΔScal+water=−44.59 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = -44.59\text{ J/K}; (d) ΔStotal=+1.63 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = +1.63\text{ J/K}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Draw a temperature-versus-heat diagram (TT vs QQ) before writing conservation equations to visually confirm all latent plateaus.

  • Check that TfT_f is physically reasonable: melting 35 g35\text{ g} of ice requires over 11.6 kJ11.6\text{ kJ}, which should drop the warm water's temperature significantly more than 3 K3\text{ K}.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

02 The student forgets to include the entropy change associated with the phase transition of melting, calculating ΔS_ice solely from the temperature increase of liquid water.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Qmelt=0.0350×3.33×105=11655 J  ⟹  11655+146.51(Tf−273.15)=945.2(295.15−Tf)  ⟹  1091.71Tf=307340  ⟹  Tf=281.52 KQ_{\text{melt}} = 0.0350 \times 3.33 \times 10^5 = 11655\text{ J} \implies 11655 + 146.51(T_f - 273.15) = 945.2(295.15 - T_f) \implies 1091.71 T_f = 307340 \implies T_f = 281.52\text{ K}

  2. Step 2

    ΔSice=micecwln⁡(TfTice)  ⟹  ΔSice=0.0350×4186×ln⁡(281.52273.15)=146.51×0.03019=4.42 J/K\Delta S_{\text{ice}} = m_{\text{ice}} c_w \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_{\text{ice}}}\right) \implies \Delta S_{\text{ice}} = 0.0350 \times 4186 \times \ln\left(\frac{281.52}{273.15}\right) = 146.51 \times 0.03019 = 4.42\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔSice=ΔSmelt+ΔSwarm=miceLfTice+micecwln⁡(TfTice)≈42.67 J/K+3.55 J/K=+46.22 J/K\Delta S_{\text{ice}} = \Delta S_{\text{melt}} + \Delta S_{\text{warm}} = \frac{m_{\text{ice}} L_f}{T_{\text{ice}}} + m_{\text{ice}} c_w \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_{\text{ice}}}\right) \approx 42.67\text{ J/K} + 3.55\text{ J/K} = +46.22\text{ J/K}

    You only calculated the entropy change for warming the melted liquid water. You must also include the entropy gained during the isothermal phase change: ΔSmelt=QmeltTice=miceLfTice\Delta S_{\text{melt}} = \frac{Q_{\text{melt}}}{T_{\text{ice}}} = \frac{m_{\text{ice}} L_f}{T_{\text{ice}}}.

  3. Step 3

    ΔScal+water=945.2×ln⁡(281.52295.15)  ⟹  ΔScal+water=945.2×(−0.04728)=−44.69 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = 945.2 \times \ln\left(\frac{281.52}{295.15}\right) \implies \Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = 945.2 \times (-0.04728) = -44.69\text{ J/K}

  4. Step 4

    ΔStotal=ΔSice+ΔScal+water  ⟹  ΔStotal=4.42+(−44.69)=−40.27 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = \Delta S_{\text{ice}} + \Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} \implies \Delta S_{\text{total}} = 4.42 + (-44.69) = -40.27\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔStotal=ΔSice+ΔScal+water=+46.22 J/K+(−44.59 J/K)=+1.63 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = \Delta S_{\text{ice}} + \Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = +46.22\text{ J/K} + (-44.59\text{ J/K}) = +1.63\text{ J/K}

    Your formula summing the entropy changes is correct, but your negative result was caused by omitting the melting term in ΔSice\Delta S_{\text{ice}}. An isolated spontaneous process must always have ΔStotal>0\Delta S_{\text{total}} > 0.

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You correctly calculated the heat required to melt the ice and set up the First Law heat-balance equation.

You used the correct logarithmic formula ΔS=Cln⁡(TfTi)\Delta S = C \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right) for temperature-changing stages.

You correctly recognized that total entropy is the sum of the entropy changes of all interacting components.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Omission of Phase-Change Entropy

You accounted for latent heat in your energy balance in part (a), but forgot to calculate the corresponding entropy change QmeltTmelt\frac{Q_{\text{melt}}}{T_{\text{melt}}} in part (b).

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

Treating phase transitions as purely energetic transfers rather than structural entropy increases, forgetting that breaking a crystalline lattice at constant temperature contributes ΔS=mLT\Delta S = \frac{m L}{T}.

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Phase-Change Entropy Rule
  • During an isothermal phase transition at temperature TT, heat absorption or release always carries an entropy change ΔS=QT=±mLT\Delta S = \frac{Q}{T} = \pm\frac{m L}{T}.

  • Whenever a substance changes state, split its entropy calculation into two parts: latent heat transfer at constant temperature (mLT\frac{m L}{T}), plus sensible heating or cooling (mcln⁡(TfTi)m c \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right)).

Second Law Sanity Check
  • For any spontaneous, irreversible process occurring within an isolated system, the Second Law of Thermodynamics requires ΔStotal>0\Delta S_{\text{total}} > 0.

  • If your total entropy change for an isolated mixing or melting problem comes out negative, immediately check whether a positive latent heat entropy term was left out.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. Compute the entropy change during melting at constant Tice=273.15 KT_{\text{ice}} = 273.15\text{ K}: ΔSmelt=miceLfTice=0.0350×3.33×105273.15≈+42.67 J/K\Delta S_{\text{melt}} = \frac{m_{\text{ice}} L_f}{T_{\text{ice}}} = \frac{0.0350 \times 3.33 \times 10^5}{273.15} \approx +42.67\text{ J/K}.

  2. Add the entropy change for warming the liquid water: ΔSwarm=micecwln⁡(TfTice)≈+3.55 J/K\Delta S_{\text{warm}} = m_{\text{ice}} c_w \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_{\text{ice}}}\right) \approx +3.55\text{ J/K}.

  3. Combine both contributions for the ice: ΔSice=+42.67 J/K+3.55 J/K=+46.22 J/K\Delta S_{\text{ice}} = +42.67\text{ J/K} + 3.55\text{ J/K} = +46.22\text{ J/K}.

  4. Recompute the total entropy generated: ΔStotal=ΔSice+ΔScal+water=+46.22 J/K+(−44.59 J/K)=+1.63 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = \Delta S_{\text{ice}} + \Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = +46.22\text{ J/K} + (-44.59\text{ J/K}) = +1.63\text{ J/K}.

Final answer

(a) Tf=279.79 KT_f = 279.79\text{ K}; (b) ΔSice=+46.22 J/K\Delta S_{\text{ice}} = +46.22\text{ J/K}; (c) ΔScal+water=−44.59 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = -44.59\text{ J/K}; (d) ΔStotal=+1.63 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = +1.63\text{ J/K}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Review reversible paths for composite processes: always represent a melting-and-heating process as an isothermal stage followed by an isobaric heating stage.

  • Always perform a Second Law check on isolated systems: any negative ΔStotal\Delta S_{\text{total}} indicates a missing positive entropy term or inverted temperature limits.

OverviewACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

03 The student calculates entropy changes using ΔQ / T_avg with the arithmetic mean temperature instead of integrating to obtain logarithmic temperature ratios.

Sample Student Work

Reviewed by ACEpath Teacher
Step-by-Step Review
Walk Through It with Your Teacher
Partially correct
  1. Step 1

    Qmelt=0.0350×3.33×105=11655 J  ⟹  11655+146.51(Tf−273.15)=945.2(295.15−Tf)  ⟹  1091.71Tf=307340  ⟹  Tf=281.52 KQ_{\text{melt}} = 0.0350 \times 3.33 \times 10^5 = 11655\text{ J} \implies 11655 + 146.51(T_f - 273.15) = 945.2(295.15 - T_f) \implies 1091.71 T_f = 307340 \implies T_f = 281.52\text{ K}

  2. Step 2

    ΔSmelt=11655273.15=42.67 J/K  ⟹  Tavg_ice=273.15+281.522=277.34 K  ⟹  Qwarm=146.51(281.52−273.15)=1226.3 J  ⟹  ΔSwarm=1226.3277.34=4.42 J/K  ⟹  ΔSice=42.67+4.42=47.09 J/K\Delta S_{\text{melt}} = \frac{11655}{273.15} = 42.67\text{ J/K} \implies T_{\text{avg\_ice}} = \frac{273.15 + 281.52}{2} = 277.34\text{ K} \implies Q_{\text{warm}} = 146.51(281.52 - 273.15) = 1226.3\text{ J} \implies \Delta S_{\text{warm}} = \frac{1226.3}{277.34} = 4.42\text{ J/K} \implies \Delta S_{\text{ice}} = 42.67 + 4.42 = 47.09\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔSwarm=micecwln⁡(TfTice)=146.51ln⁡(281.52273.15)≈+4.42 J/K  ⟹  ΔSice=42.67+4.42=47.09 J/K\Delta S_{\text{warm}} = m_{\text{ice}} c_w \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_{\text{ice}}}\right) = 146.51 \ln\left(\frac{281.52}{273.15}\right) \approx +4.42\text{ J/K} \implies \Delta S_{\text{ice}} = 42.67 + 4.42 = 47.09\text{ J/K} (or +46.22 J/K+46.22\text{ J/K} with nominal TfT_f)

    While your phase change calculation ΔSmelt=Q/T\Delta S_{\text{melt}} = Q/T is correct because melting is isothermal, you used the arithmetic mean temperature ΔQ/Tavg\Delta Q / T_{\text{avg}} for warming. Entropy change during non-isothermal heating must be found by integrating dS=dQ/T=mc dT/TdS = dQ/T = m c\,dT/T, yielding ΔS=mcln⁡(Tf/Ti)\Delta S = m c \ln(T_f/T_i).

  3. Step 3

    Tavg_cal=295.15+281.522=288.34 K  ⟹  Qcool=−945.2(295.15−281.52)=−12883.1 J  ⟹  ΔScal+water=−12883.1288.34=−44.68 J/KT_{\text{avg\_cal}} = \frac{295.15 + 281.52}{2} = 288.34\text{ K} \implies Q_{\text{cool}} = -945.2(295.15 - 281.52) = -12883.1\text{ J} \implies \Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = \frac{-12883.1}{288.34} = -44.68\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔScal+water=(mcalcal+mwcw)ln⁡(TfT0)=945.2ln⁡(281.52295.15)≈−44.69 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = (m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{al}} + m_w c_w) \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_0}\right) = 945.2 \ln\left(\frac{281.52}{295.15}\right) \approx -44.69\text{ J/K}

    You repeated the same error by dividing heat loss by the average temperature TavgT_{\text{avg}}. The correct expression for the cooling of the calorimeter and water requires the natural logarithm: ΔS=Cln⁡(Tf/T0)\Delta S = C \ln(T_f/T_0).

  4. Step 4

    ΔStotal=ΔSice+ΔScal+water=47.09+(−44.68)=+2.41 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = \Delta S_{\text{ice}} + \Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = 47.09 + (-44.68) = +2.41\text{ J/K}

    Correct

    ΔStotal=ΔSice+ΔScal+water=+47.09 J/K+(−44.69 J/K)=+2.40 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = \Delta S_{\text{ice}} + \Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = +47.09\text{ J/K} + (-44.69\text{ J/K}) = +2.40\text{ J/K}

    Your setup adding the component entropy changes to find ΔStotal\Delta S_{\text{total}} is conceptually correct, but the numerical result is affected by the average-temperature approximation used in parts (b) and (c).

WHAT YOU DID WELL
Compliments from Your Teacher

You set up the heat exchange equation Qgained=QlostQ_{\text{gained}} = Q_{\text{lost}} accurately and solved for the equilibrium temperature TfT_f.

You correctly treated the isothermal melting of ice using ΔS=Q/T\Delta S = Q / T.

You recognized that the total entropy change of the universe is the sum of the entropy changes of all participating subsystems.

THE ERROR
Where Your ACEpath Teacher Spotted the Mistake
Arithmetic Mean Approximation for Non-Isothermal Entropy

none

WHY IT HAPPENED
ACEpath Teacher's Diagnosis

You treated entropy change during continuous heating and cooling as ΔS=Q/Tavg\Delta S = Q / T_{\text{avg}} rather than integrating dS=dQ/T=C dT/TdS = dQ / T = C\,dT / T, which produces logarithmic temperature ratios ΔS=Cln⁡(Tf/Ti)\Delta S = C \ln(T_f / T_i).

REASONING PATH
Your ACEpath teacher’s suggested approach
Isothermal vs. Non-Isothermal Entropy
  • For constant TT (phase changes): ΔS=Q/T\Delta S = Q/T. For changing TT: ΔS=∫TiTfC dTT=Cln⁡(TfTi)\Delta S = \int_{T_i}^{T_f} \frac{C\,dT}{T} = C \ln\left(\frac{T_f}{T_i}\right).

  • Whenever temperature varies continuously, never use an average temperature TavgT_{\text{avg}}; always integrate to find the natural logarithm of the absolute temperature ratio.

CORRECTED PATH
ACEpath Teacher's Demonstration
  1. For warming the melted ice from Tice=273.15 KT_{\text{ice}} = 273.15\text{ K} to Tf=281.52 KT_f = 281.52\text{ K}: ΔSwarm=micecwln⁡(Tf/Tice)=(146.51 J/K)ln⁡(281.52/273.15)≈+4.42 J/K\Delta S_{\text{warm}} = m_{\text{ice}} c_w \ln(T_f / T_{\text{ice}}) = (146.51\text{ J/K}) \ln(281.52 / 273.15) \approx +4.42\text{ J/K}.

  2. Total for ice: ΔSice=ΔSmelt+ΔSwarm=42.67 J/K+4.42 J/K=+47.09 J/K\Delta S_{\text{ice}} = \Delta S_{\text{melt}} + \Delta S_{\text{warm}} = 42.67\text{ J/K} + 4.42\text{ J/K} = +47.09\text{ J/K}.

  3. For cooling the calorimeter cup and water: ΔScal+water=(mcalcal+mwcw)ln⁡(Tf/T0)=(945.2 J/K)ln⁡(281.52/295.15)≈−44.69 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = (m_{\text{cal}} c_{\text{al}} + m_w c_w) \ln(T_f / T_0) = (945.2\text{ J/K}) \ln(281.52 / 295.15) \approx -44.69\text{ J/K}.

  4. Net entropy generated: ΔStotal=ΔSice+ΔScal+water=+47.09 J/K+(−44.69 J/K)=+2.40 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = \Delta S_{\text{ice}} + \Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = +47.09\text{ J/K} + (-44.69\text{ J/K}) = +2.40\text{ J/K}.

Final answer

(a) Tf=281.52 KT_f = 281.52\text{ K}; (b) ΔSice=+47.09 J/K\Delta S_{\text{ice}} = +47.09\text{ J/K}; (c) ΔScal+water=−44.69 J/K\Delta S_{\text{cal+water}} = -44.69\text{ J/K}; (d) ΔStotal=+2.40 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = +2.40\text{ J/K}

NEXT STEPS
Final Takeaways from Your Teacher
  • Memorize the fundamental integral definition of entropy: dS=dQrev/TdS = dQ_{\text{rev}}/T.

  • Practice identifying whether a thermal process is isothermal (constant TT, where Q/TQ/T applies) or non-isothermal (variable TT, requiring Cln⁡(Tf/Ti)C \ln(T_f/T_i)).

  • Verify that for any irreversible isolated process, ΔStotal>0\Delta S_{\text{total}} > 0 in accordance with the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

Lock it in

Similar question

01

A 0.050 kg0.050\text{ kg} ice cube at 0.0∘C0.0^\circ\text{C} (273.15 K273.15\text{ K}) is dropped into an insulated container holding 0.300 kg0.300\text{ kg} of water at 30.0∘C30.0^\circ\text{C} (303.15 K303.15\text{ K}). Given cw=4186 J/(kg⋅K)c_w = 4186\text{ J}/(\text{kg}\cdot\text{K}) and Lf=3.33×105 J/kgL_f = 3.33 \times 10^5\text{ J}/\text{kg}, find the final equilibrium temperature TfT_f in Kelvin.

Answer

Tf=287.67 KT_f = 287.67\text{ K} (14.52∘C14.52^\circ\text{C}). Key step: equate heat gained by ice to heat lost by water: miceLf+micecw(Tf−273.15)=mwcw(303.15−Tf)m_{\text{ice}} L_f + m_{\text{ice}} c_w (T_f - 273.15) = m_w c_w (303.15 - T_f), giving 16650+209.3(Tf−273.15)=1255.8(303.15−Tf)16650 + 209.3(T_f - 273.15) = 1255.8(303.15 - T_f).

02

For the system in the previous problem (0.050 kg0.050\text{ kg} ice at 273.15 K273.15\text{ K} added to 0.300 kg0.300\text{ kg} water at 303.15 K303.15\text{ K} reaching Tf=287.67 KT_f = 287.67\text{ K}), calculate the entropy change of the added ice during melting and warming, ΔSice\Delta S_{\text{ice}}.

Answer

ΔSice=+71.81 J/K\Delta S_{\text{ice}} = +71.81\text{ J}/\text{K}. Key steps: ΔSmelt=miceLfTice=16650 J273.15 K=60.96 J/K\Delta S_{\text{melt}} = \frac{m_{\text{ice}} L_f}{T_{\text{ice}}} = \frac{16650\text{ J}}{273.15\text{ K}} = 60.96\text{ J}/\text{K}; ΔSwarm=micecwln⁡(287.67273.15)=(209.3)ln⁡(1.05315)=10.84 J/K\Delta S_{\text{warm}} = m_{\text{ice}} c_w \ln\left(\frac{287.67}{273.15}\right) = (209.3) \ln(1.05315) = 10.84\text{ J}/\text{K}; sum = 60.96+10.84=71.81 J/K60.96 + 10.84 = 71.81\text{ J}/\text{K}.

03

A 0.020 kg0.020\text{ kg} block of ice at −10.0∘C-10.0^\circ\text{C} (263.15 K263.15\text{ K}) is placed into 0.150 kg0.150\text{ kg} of water at 20.0∘C20.0^\circ\text{C} (293.15 K293.15\text{ K}) in a well-insulated cup. Given cice=2090 J/(kg⋅K)c_{\text{ice}} = 2090\text{ J}/(\text{kg}\cdot\text{K}), cw=4186 J/(kg⋅K)c_w = 4186\text{ J}/(\text{kg}\cdot\text{K}), and Lf=3.33×105 J/kgL_f = 3.33 \times 10^5\text{ J}/\text{kg}, determine the net total entropy generated ΔStotal\Delta S_{\text{total}} once equilibrium is reached.

Answer

ΔStotal=+0.81 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = +0.81\text{ J}/\text{K}. Key steps: (1) Find TfT_f: micecice(273.15−263.15)+miceLf+micecw(Tf−273.15)=mwcw(293.15−Tf)  ⟹  418+6660+83.72(Tf−273.15)=627.9(293.15−Tf)  ⟹  Tf=280.95 Km_{\text{ice}} c_{\text{ice}}(273.15 - 263.15) + m_{\text{ice}} L_f + m_{\text{ice}} c_w(T_f - 273.15) = m_w c_w(293.15 - T_f) \implies 418 + 6660 + 83.72(T_f - 273.15) = 627.9(293.15 - T_f) \implies T_f = 280.95\text{ K}. (2) ΔSice=0.020(2090)ln⁡(273.15/263.15)+6660273.15+0.020(4186)ln⁡(280.95/273.15)=1.56+24.38+2.36=+28.30 J/K\Delta S_{\text{ice}} = 0.020(2090)\ln(273.15/263.15) + \frac{6660}{273.15} + 0.020(4186)\ln(280.95/273.15) = 1.56 + 24.38 + 2.36 = +28.30\text{ J}/\text{K}. (3) ΔSw=0.150(4186)ln⁡(280.95/293.15)=−27.49 J/K\Delta S_w = 0.150(4186)\ln(280.95/293.15) = -27.49\text{ J}/\text{K}. (4) ΔStotal=28.30−27.49=+0.81 J/K\Delta S_{\text{total}} = 28.30 - 27.49 = +0.81\text{ J}/\text{K}.

Loading workspace…